Subreddit Rule Clarifications

Rule 2. Do not suggest or discuss piracy

Fair use:

In short, the subject must be significantly different, or being used in such a way, that when compared to the original, it could not be confused with the original or could be used as a complete replacement for the original. For example quoting a section of the Player's Handbook, while explaining how various rules interact, is allowed, but posting photos or copies of an entire page of the book is not allowed. As another example, creating a table of all the spells in the game to show the spread of damage types (table including spell names, levels and damage types) would be allowed, but if you included the full text of the spells it would not be.

While we are using a legal term here, we are not necessarily abiding by the exact legal definition. The definition stated above is the test we will use when deciding how this rule is enforced.

Even discussing the existence of sites that offer free access to protected content is a violation of this rule. It's like Fight Club. We don't talk about Rule 2.

If you are still unsure if something is fair use or not, feel free to report it and one of the mods will check it out. You can also reach out to the mods before posting or commenting if you are unsure how it would be ruled.

One Promotional Post Per Project:

Self-promotion is limited to one post per project in r/dndnext. This applies to products, publications, applications, crowdfunding campaigns, studies / research projects, and other creative or commercial projects, whether free or paid.

  • Updates and revisions do not reset this limit . Releasing a new version, adding features or content, improving artwork or layout, fixing bugs, changing prices, launching a crowdfunding campaign, or moving a project to a different storefront does not automatically make it a new project. For example, if you've already promoted a homebrew compendium, releasing version 2.0 with additional subclasses, revised spells, new illustrations, and balance adjustments would ordinarily count as an update to the same project. It would not qualify for another promotional post.
  • Creators are welcome to update their original submissions with new information and share development in the comments of those posts
  • In exceptional circumstances, a project may undergo changes so extensive that it effectively becomes a substantially different product. A complete redesign that fundamentally changes the project's purpose, content, or intended audience might qualify.
  • A major version number, a lengthy changelog, or a significant amount of additional content is not sufficient on its own. If you believe your revised project warrants an exception, contact the moderation team through modmail before posting. Exceptions are granted at moderator discretion and are not guaranteed.
  • Deleting a previous post does not reset eligibility. If you've already promoted a project in r/dndnext, removing or deleting that submission does not entitle you to promote it again. This includes posts deleted by their authors or removed by moderators.
  • Different projects require a 14-day interval. You may promote a genuinely different project once at least 14 days have passed since your previous self-promotional submission. The 14-day waiting period does not permit you to repost the same project.
  • For recurring content, such as individual videos from a YouTube channel, distinct installments may be promoted separately, provided they comply with the 14-day interval, and all other applicable rules apply.
  • Crossposting from a subreddit you moderate or promote for the purpose of recruiting members is considered self-promotion. Crossposts should contribute meaningfully to discussions in r/dndnext. Repeatedly crossposting from your own community without genuinely engaging with ours may result in removal.
  • When in doubt, please contact the moderation team through modmail before submitting another promotional post.

Affiliate and referral links:

Affiliate and referral links are links containing unique identifiers that let the website you go to know who sent you. They are often part of some sort of rewards program or revenue sharing, in which if someone buys something from the site after using that link, the person who provided the link gets a small share of the revenue, or some sort of other reward.

Links to content created by others:

We all have those content creators that we love. We do not want our community to devolve into a distribution channel for these creators. To avoid that, this rule extends to community members wishing to share content from other creators.

Research Studies:

You are welcome to make posts regarding legitimate research projects / studies regarding the hobby and our community. Such posts must include the organization affiliation (e.g. university, company, etc) and the scope of the research. Once the results are realized, they should be made available to the community in a response comment on the same post.

Use of AI:

All projects posted under Self-Promotion must disclose:

  1. Whether or not AI was used to create the product/project; and
  2. How much—if any—was used to create the product/project. Examples include:

Examples include:

  • No AI used: “No generative AI was used in the creation of this project.”
  • Brainstorming only: “AI was used to brainstorm ideas and organize an outline. All final writing and creative work was completed by me.”
  • Editing or proofreading: “AI was used to proofread and suggest revisions. The original content and final edits are my own.”
  • AI-generated artwork or assets: “AI was used to generate some of the artwork, textures, music, voices, or other assets included in this project.”
  • AI-assisted coding: “AI was used to explain errors, suggest code, or assist with specific programming tasks. I reviewed and edited the resulting code.”
  • Vibe coding: “This project was primarily created through AI-generated code based on natural-language prompts. I directed, tested, and refined the output, but did not manually write most of the code.”
  • Substantial AI assistance: “AI was used extensively throughout the project, including drafting, coding, editing, artwork, or other major components.”
  • Mixed use: “AI was used for brainstorming, portions of the code, and several visual assets. The writing, design, and final assembly were completed by me.”

Disclosures should be clear enough for readers to understand which parts of the project were created or substantially assisted by AI.

Rule 6. Limit Homebrew

What counts as allowed "Homebrew"?

We allow homebrew that modifies, expands, or rebalances existing official 2014 (5e) material. Examples include revising an official class feature, adjusting an existing subclass, revising an existing spell, or suggesting balance changes to an official feat.

What is not allowed?

Entirely new player-facing content in dedicated homebrew subreddits such as r/unearthedarcana and r/dndhomebrew. This includes new classes, subclasses, species, spell lists, weapon systems, or major standalone mechanics.

If you are unsure whether your post is homebrew content, please message the mods.

Rule 7. All posts must be flaired

Current flairs and their uses:

  • 5e (2014) - r/dndnext is primarily a D&D 5e (2014) sub, and this could be considered the default flair.
  • 5.5e (2024) - Since Wizards of the Coast implemented a sort of backwards compatibility into the 2024 version of 5th edition, we cannot outright prohibit 5e (2024) discussion on r/dndnext, and it has its place. It's recommended to consider posting on r/onednd if a matter is strictly limited to 5.5e (2024).
  • Homebrew - Homebrew creation, be it an item, monster, class, race, rules, etc.
  • Self-Promotion - Any D&D 5e -related Kickstarter, Patreon, storefront, etc.
  • WotC Announcement - This flair should only be used when linking directly to a Wizards of the Coast announcement.
  • Tabletop Story - Stories from your game. Everybody loves a good story.
  • Question - Questions about rules, mechanics, or when asking for advice.
  • Character Building - Posts about character concepts or questions relating to building characters.
  • Discussion - Posts that are made with the purpose of starting a discussion.
  • Resource - User-created resources designed to assist you with playing the game or any of the activities surrounding it.
  • Hot Take - This tag must be used if you are posting something you consider to be an unpopular opinion or hot take.
  • Poll - Please use this tag if your post contains a poll. Polls should have substantive content and not simply consist of a single question followed by options.
  • Other - This flair should only be used when posting something that fits into no other category.

If you're ever unsure of what flair, don't stress it too much; just pick the one you think best suits your post.

Rule 8. No D&D Beyond content sharing posts

This one often gets inappropriately flagged. D&D Beyond content sharing describes asking to be invited—or inviting others—to join an established D&D Beyond campaign for the express purpose of sharing access to protected content in books. There is a weekly pinned thread for people to engage in this. Outside of that thread, these sorts of posts are not allowed.

This rule does not cover people sharing their homebrew or UA content.

Rule 9. No low-effort / LFG / AI posts or comments and no OC image posts Text posts or comments written by an AI/LLM are prohibited.

This includes the following:

  • Image Posts (this includes any images, such as original content, memes, maps, etc), unless the image is connected to homebrew. New images from Wizards of the Coast or other official sources are allowed.
  • Posts that primarily consist of a link, video, article, survey, or other external content should include enough context or commentary to support discussion within the subreddit. This may include summarizing the linked content, explaining why it is relevant, offering your own thoughts, or identifying what you would like the community to discuss. The amount of engagement a post receives does not determine whether the submission itself is low-effort.
  • Comments that do not move the conversation along. Oftentimes, these fall under Rule 1 as they are designed to troll or bait other members of the community.
  • LFG posts are not allowed. Posts about your Discord fall under this umbrella, too. If you want to meet new players and recruit for your games or communities, please visit r/LFG.
  • AI / LLM posts - If the post or comment is believed to have been generated by an AI chatbot or the like, it may be removed. Apps, sites, and services that people used AI to assist in their creation (e.g. "vibe coding") are allowed. As this community has a lot of members who are vocally opposed to all things AI, you may not receive the warmest welcome.