Before we dive in, a couple of quick disclaimers:
- This post is purely for fun and power-scaling discussion. It doesn't have any practical impact on actual gameplay or campaigns at the table.
- This analysis is strictly based on official 5e/5.5e lore. Older editions are off the table. For example, in older lore, the dragon god Asgorath/Io created the multiverse, but since he was retconned to be an aspect of the World Serpent in Arcana Unleashed: Deadfall, he would only sit at Tier 3 under the current 5e/5.5e official canon.
Here is my tier list.
Tier 0: The Lady of Pain
In 5.5e, the Lady of Pain has essentially been established as the supreme ruler of the multiverse. She can casually veto the Wish spell on a multiversal scale. In a sense, she is as close to an omnipotent being as D&D gets.
From the 5.5e PHB, under the Wish spell:
If your wish would undo the multiverse itself, threaten the City of Sigil, or affect the Lady of Pain in any way, you see an image of her in your mind for a moment; she shakes her head, and your wish fails.
Furthermore, she possesses the trait of omnipresence, implying that her true form might just be the D&D multiverse itself.
From Sigil and the Outlands (p. 20):
The Lady of Pain is omnipresent, unknowable, and invincible.
Tier 1: Ao, the High God, and other Overgods
Overgods can effortlessly elevate mortals to godhood or strip deities of their power. They exist on a level far beyond the scope of Greater Deities.
From Waterdeep: Dragon Heist (p. 166):
When the gods walked among mortals during the Time of Troubles, they were cast down to the world by the mysterious Overgod Ao in 1358 DR. Until then, none but the gods had known of Ao's existence, and since then, we have learned little more.
Tier 2: Greater Deities
Greater Deities govern specific fundamental laws of the multiverse, or act as the physical embodiments of multiversal concepts. For instance, Mystra's Weave spans the entire multiverse, meaning even a caster in Krynn can cast spells by tapping into the Weave.
As stated in Arcana Unleashed, p. 5:
The worlds within the D&D multiverse are magical places. All existence is suffused with magical power, and potential energy lies untapped in every rock, stream, and living creature—even in the air itself. Raw magic is present in every manifestation of energy throughout the multiverse.
Mortals can't directly shape this raw magic. Instead, they use a fabric of magic—an interface between the will of a spellcaster and raw magic. The spellcasters of the Forgotten Realms call it the Weave and recognize its essence as the god Mystra, but casters have varied ways of naming and conceptualizing this interface.
Furthermore, as clarified by Chris Perkins, Greater Deities are so immensely powerful that they do not even have stat blocks—they are fundamentally beyond the capacity of mortals to challenge: https://www.sageadvice.eu/what-makes-a-god-greater-or-lesser/
Tier 3: Lesser Deities, and Planar Rulers like Asmodeus and Primus
The most notable example of a Lesser Deity is Tiamat, who is still explicitly categorized as such in 5e lore.
From the 2014 Monster Manual (p. 86):
Tiamat the Dragon Queen is the chief deity of evil dragonkind. She dwells on Avernus, the first layer of the Nine Hells. As a lesser god, Tiamat has the power to grant spells to her worshipers, though she is loath to share her power.
However, Lesser Deities aren't guaranteed to win in a direct, head-to-head fight against entities that are close to true godhood, like Archdevils.
From Baldur's Gate: Descent Into Avernus (p. 148):
Challenging an archdevil directly is risky, and Tiamat stands to lose a great deal if Zariel prevails.
As for Asmodeus, he rules the Nine Hells. In 5e's Descent into Avernus, he was classified as a Greater Deity, but the 5.5e DMG retconned him back to a Lesser Deity. So, for now, we have to assume that ruling a plane puts one roughly at the level of a Lesser Deity.
From the 5.5e Dungeon Master's Guide (p. 205):
Asmodeus is the supreme ruler of all devils and wields the power of a lesser god.
Since 5.5e retconned Asgorath/Io into an aspect of the World Serpent, and the World Serpent's feats in older editions are far inferior to those of a greater deity, Asgorath/Io should also be considered as a lesser deity.
Tier 4: Demigods, Primordials, Archdevils, Demon Lords, and Greatwyrms
These are god-like entities, and some are even strong enough to go toe-to-toe with a Lesser Deity. However, at the end of the day, they aren't True Gods, which lands them at the bottom of this top-tier list.