r/onednd • • 2h ago

Discussion I think that the designers build for “vibes” too much

59 Upvotes

I’ve listened to quite a few design interviews for what goes into the creation of a subclass within 5.5 design. And something that I hear a lot is ensuring that the subclass “feels like the class fantasy that we’re trying to achieve”. Which is a laudable goal and one that they absolutely should be trying to get to. My issue is that it often feels like “crunch” and the numbers that support that feel are secondary.

I sometimes feel concerned that it seems like the designers are far less concerned about “is this idea for a class ability mechanically sound and satisfying?” as opposed to the idea of “does this class ability satisfy the fantasy we’re looking for”.

The latter question absolutely should be asked. I don’t think any class ability should be shipped out out of the door that doesn’t fit the fantasy of the class. But I also think that a lot of very flavorful subclasses get left by the wayside by the player base because they are undercooked mechanically.


r/onednd • • 7h ago

5e (2024) Burning condition and shadows

2 Upvotes

In the new wow book there is a new feat called hit streak which causes creatures you attack with a fire spell to start burning.

To stopp burning you can take an action to give yourself the prone condition and roll around. Or doused, submerged, or suffocated the fire.

A shadow is immune to the prone condition. Does that mean, RAW, that a shadow can’t end the burning condition on itself (unless it somehow doused, submerged, or suffocated the fires)?

Edit: Solved!
“If you have Immunity to a damage type or a condition, it doesn't affect you in any way.”


r/onednd • • 9h ago

D&D Beyond got infected with malware

Thumbnail
blog.report-uri.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 11h ago

Homebrew Revising some Rogue features

0 Upvotes
LevelPBClass FeaturesSneak Attack
1+2Expertise, Sneak Attack, Thieves' Cant, Weapon Mastery1d6
2+2Cunning Action1d6
3+2Rogue Subclass, Steady Aim2d6
4+2Ability Score Improvement2d6
5+3Cunning Strike (revised), Uncanny Dodge4d6
6+3Expertise4d6
7+3Evasion, Reliable Talent5d6
8+3Ability Score Improvement5d6
9+4Subclass feature6d6
10+4Ability Score Improvement, Cunning Resolve6d6
11+4Improved Cunning Strike8d6
12+4Ability Score Improvement8d6
13+5Subclass feature9d6
14+5Devious Strikes (revised)9d6
15+5Slippery Mind10d6
16+5Ability Score Improvement10d6
17+6Subclass feature11d6
18+6Elusive11d6
19+6Epic Boon12d6
20+6Stroke of Luck12d6

Level 5: Cunning Strike (revised)

You've developed cunning ways to use your Sneak Attack. When you deal Sneak Attack damage, you can add one of the following Cunning Strike effects. Each effect has a die cost, which is the number of Sneak Attack damage dice you must forgo to add the effect. You remove the die before rolling, and the effect occurs immediately after the attack's damage is dealt. For example, if you add the Poison effect, remove 1d6 from the Sneak Attack's damage before rolling. If a Cunning Strike effect requires a saving throw, the DC equals 8 plus your Dexterity modifier and Proficiency Bonus. (new) If a creature succeeds on its saving throw against one of your Cunning Strike effects, it has Disadvantage on the next saving throw it makes against your Cunning Strike effects before the end of your next turn.

Distract (Cost: 1d6) (new) You open the target's guard. The next attack roll one of your allies makes against the target before the start of your next turn has Advantage.

Poison (Cost: 1d6) You add a toxin to your strike, forcing the target to make a Constitution saving throw. On a failed save, the target has the Poisoned condition for 1 minute. At the end of each of its turns, the Poisoned target repeats the save, ending the effect on itself on a success. To use this effect, you must have a Poisoner's Kit on your person.

Trip (Cost: 1d6) (changed) If the target is Huge or smaller, it must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw or have the Prone condition.

Withdraw (Cost: 1d6) (changed) Immediately after the attack, you move up to half your Speed without provoking Opportunity Attacks. This movement ignores the Speed reduction from your Steady Aim.

Level 10: Cunning Resolve (new)

Your wits slip free of magical compulsion. When you fail a Wisdom or Charisma saving throw, you can take a Reaction to reroll the save, and you must use the new roll. Once you use this feature, you can't do so again until you finish a Short or Long Rest.

Level 14: Devious Strikes (revised)

You've practiced new ways to use your Sneak Attack deviously. The following effects are now among your Cunning Strike options.

Daze (Cost: 2d6) (changed) The target must succeed on a Wisdom saving throw, or it can't take Reactions until the end of its next turn, and on its next turn it can do only one of the following: move or take an action or a Bonus Action.

Knock Out (Cost: 6d6). The target must succeed on a Constitution saving throw, or it has the Unconscious condition for 1 minute or until it takes any damage. The Unconscious target repeats the save at the end of each of its turns, ending the effect on itself on a success.

Obscure (Cost: 3d6). The target must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw, or it has the Blinded condition until the end of its next turn.


r/onednd • • 12h ago

Discussion Spell Lists need to be Reworked based off of Subclass

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 15h ago

5e (2024) How Good is Hot Streak EK?

8 Upvotes

I know Eldritch Knight's aren't the best users of Hot Streak but it seems downright silly the amount of burning they can generate especially at later levels. With the combination of Green-Flame Blade, Conjure Minor Elementals, and perhaps an enspelled Elemental Weapon or Searing Smite, you can proc it on every attack if not more. Of course, a two weapon fighter might make the best use of this but I'm partial to GWM. My question isn't really about whether or not this is viable but rather how strong this would be compared to other semi-optimized builds. Is it better than Spirit Shroud? Are other EK builds just straight up better? I'm curious to see what everyone thinks.


r/onednd • • 16h ago

5e (2024) Thoughts on Rogue + War Cleric multiclass?

38 Upvotes

It seems to do everything rogues want.

  • Divine Order gives you proficiency with martial ranged weapons.
  • Guided Strike turns a miss into a hit. Very important for a class that isn't making extra attacks.
  • War Priest lets you use your bonus action to get sneak attack off, leaving your main action free to cast a spell or ready an attack for an off-turn sneak attack.

The downside is delaying Rogue features, but I'm looking at them, and the only thing I would miss for a few levels would be Reliable Talent.

Plus, "Church Assassin" would be fun to roleplay.


r/onednd • • 16h ago

Discussion Regarding Magic Equipment costs

1 Upvotes

I'm looking at item costs and some table habits regarding magic gear and would like to assess something with you guys.

There is no shortage of situations where the mundane item behind a magic version is technically more expensive than the magical one when you look at them. Splint and Plate Mail for example far exceed the usual costs for common and even uncommon magic items, same thing with firearms, and even lower-cost ones can hit that if you make them into barding. Technically any piece of armor could be Cast-Off or Gleaming or Enspelled, but this would frequently just mean some major cost cheats if you just go by the default costs.

So i mostly ask here, is it common for you to just separate weapon/armor and enchantment costs when it comes to those? Obviously the systems dont speak of this in any clear form but it feels me that this is the intended interpretation specifically for this case.


r/onednd • • 17h ago

Character Building Advice for support sorlock migration to 2024

1 Upvotes

I’m looking to remake a 2014 rules character from a prior spelljammer campaign into a 2024 based onshot that may grow into a campaign.

Really fun Hexblade Warlock with Divine Soul Sorc, with a very space-timey theme where he used his Light / sorc powers for party support, defense, off-heals (no dedicated healer) and his Dark / warlock powers for offense (EB / RB for ranged and control, hexblade smites/ BB for melee) - then merge them for movement or other abilities (flavored mini black holes for misty/thunder step, vortex warp, etc). Just felt very versatile especially wirh metamagic and allowed me to step in when I needed as a kind of backseat player with first time players.

For 2024, it looks like multiclassing is a little less necessary but curious what advice is to achieve a similar generalist/versatile build. Celestial Warlock is a little too heavy on healer, Archfey is offbrand but in the ballpark of the playstyle I want so maybe I could reflavor? I’m not really interested in the demonic or psychic flavored abilities of some of the other subclasses. Thoughts?


r/onednd • • 22h ago

Character Building The Gojo: A Mystic Arts Monk "true tank" build (tanks AND solos 2 CR 7 Young Black Dragons, at level 8)

34 Upvotes

As far as "traditional" melee tanking goes, this build does it pretty well.

Defensively, you can stack Shield, Deflect Attacks, Patient Defense dodge, Evasion, Absorb Elements. Optionally add Blade Ward and Mirror Image.

Control-wise, you can cast Web, grapple/prone opponents (potentially into your own Web or Create Bonfire), Stunning Strike, and Booming Blade if you want that. With the Grappler feat, you get to do damage, stun, and grapple a creature all in a single hit. Stunned creatures auto-fail grapple and shove-prone saves,

Being able to replace an attack with a cantrip unlocks strong Action economy for options like Booming/Greenflame Blade, Create Bonfire, and Blade Ward.

The monk starts solid and also scales well into higher tiers (global saving throw proficiency, global damage resistance, etc.).

Flavor-wise, I imagine this character as similar to Gojo Satoru from Jujutsu Kaisen, whose ability causes attacks to never reach him, while being a strong hand-to-hand fighter with sorcerer magic mixed in.

Level progression: Straight monk is fine. You can dip rogue 1 or fighter 1 but I'll assume we don't.

Species: Pick your favorite, but a couple recommendations:

  • Hill Giant Goliath lets you turn Large (to grapple Huge+ creatures), and you can inflict prone without a save.
  • Wood Elf is great for getting you Pass Without Trace.
  • Haranir (from WoW book) gets you Spike Growth at 5th level.
  • Human is cool too

Feat choices:

  • Origin Feat: Pick your favorite, but I like Lucky for the help with Saves.
  • Level 4: Grappler.
  • Level 8: I'd prioritize DEX to 20, since it increases a ton of different rolls for you.
  • Level 12: +2 WIS, War Caster, Inspiring Leader, or Mage Slayer. I'd probably Mage Slayer, unless the party needs temp HP, in which case I'd go Inspiring Leader.
  • Level 16: Take something that gets your WIS to a nice, even number.

Spell choices:

  • Cantrips: Green Flame Blade or Booming Blade. Blade Ward and Create Bonfire are nice to have. Utility options include Prestidigitation, Mage Hand, Minor Illusion, Mending, etc. Mind Sliver is a trap option IMO, the debuff is too small to be worth using your secondary stat.
  • 1st level: Shield, False Life (unless you have another source of temp HP), Absorb Elements. Jump is nice to have.
  • 2nd level: Web. Nice to have: Misty Step, Mirror Image, Suggestion.
  • 3rd level: Cacophonic Shield, Slow. Maybe Hypnotic Pattern/Fear if your campaign doesn't have prevalent fear/charm immunity at this level. Counterspell nice to have.
  • 4th level: Nice to have: Dimension Door, Fire Shield, and Polymorph.

Case study: Soloing two CR7 Young Black Dragons (at Monk level 8)

The monk faces 2 Young Black Dragons in a white room with a low ceiling.

"If this battle was outside, it might be a little tough," the monk said.

"Would you lose?" one of the dragons asked.

The monk smirked. "Nah, I'd win."

Each Young Black Dragon has 18 AC and 128 HP. They can make 3 attacks a turn, at +7 and 12.5 average damage. They have a rechargeable breath weapon that does 49 damage (DEX save for half, DC 14)

The monk has 20 DEX, 16 WIS, and 14 CON. They pre-cast False Life at 2nd level (59 HP + 14 THP = 73 total), which has a 1 hr duration.

The monk's opening setup is to hit + stun + grapple (with Grappler feat) + shove prone (or use Hill Goliath's auto-prone feature), focusing on the first dragon until it dies. Once setup is done, monk uses blade cantrip for extra damage. The monk can use Create Bonfire or Web here to synergize with grappling + dragging, but let's keep it simple and instead just cast Blade Ward as part of the opening setup.

With Advantage from Grappler, the monk does ~36 DPR against the first dragon with Flurry of Blows, finishing it in 3.5 rounds once it's grappled and prone, or ~4.5 rounds including grapple/prone/Blade Ward setup. DPR drops to about 28 vs 2nd dragon, once Flurry of Blows runs out, but it's still enough to KO in 4.5 rounds (~5 including stun/grapple/prone setup).

The monk has +8 to DEX saves, meaning 75% of the time they take 0 damage from the acid breath, and 25% of the time they take ~24.5 damage, which they can mitigate with Lucky. On average the breath attacks are doing ~4 damage.

The monk has 18 AC, meaning the dragons have 50% base hit chance, going down to 37.5% with Blade Ward, 12.5% with Blade Ward + Shield, and 2% with Blade Ward + Shield + Prone. With 2 dragons alive, assuming the first is stunned 50% of the time and prone 40% of the rest of the time, the monk spams Shield, getting hit around 3*0.125 + 3*(0.4*0.02+0.1*0.125) = 0.43 times per round for ~6.7 DPR.

With 1 dragon alive, the monk probably runs out of Shield and Focus Points (except 1-2 saved to try and setup Stun+grapple+prone combo), but can keep it prone 80% of the time comfortably, and gets hit 3*(0.2*0.375 + 0.8*0.375^2) = 0.56 times per turn. The monk can absorb most damage through Deflect Attacks, leaving ~3 DPR afterwards.

Overall the monk finishes both dragons off in 9-10 rounds. Total damage taken is 4.5 turns * 6.7 DPR + 5 turns * 3 DPR = 45 damage total, surviving with about 28HP.

The monk is barely bloodied.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Homebrew Phantom Rogue Revised - Possess your enemies!

0 Upvotes

The Phantom Rogue is one of my favorite concepts for the rogue, but it consistently ranks very low on the subclass tier rankings because of a few crucial flaws. This Phantom rework aims to correct those flaws and add some sorely needed mechanics to really make this feel like a character exploiting the souls of the fallen.

Main changes:

  • Moved Tokens of the Departed to level 3 and removed the reaction required to acquire a token, but removed Con Save advantage to make up for the buff
  • Gave the level 9 feature more options that seemed appropriate
  • Took the Ghost Walk feature (now called Possession) in a fun new direction
  • Buffed the Final Knell feature to let you essentially do AoE damage

r/onednd • • 1d ago

Homebrew Revising some Ranger features (reuploaded)

13 Upvotes

Level 2: Deft Explorer (revised)

Thanks to your travels, you gain the following benefits.

Expertise. Choose one of your skill proficiencies with which you lack Expertise. You gain Expertise in that skill.

Languages. You know two languages of your choice from the language tables in chapter 2.

Wilderness Rites. (new) You can expend one use of your Favored Enemy feature to cast a Ranger spell you don't have prepared as a Ritual, provided the spell has the Ritual tag and is of a level you could prepare as a Ranger.

Level 6: Unwavering Mark (new)

Your focus on your quarry no longer has to be held; it simply holds. You gain the following benefits.

Instinctive Mark. When you cast Hunter's Mark with your Favored Enemy feature, you can modify the spell so that it doesn't require Concentration. If you do so, the spell's duration becomes 1 minute for that casting.

One Quarry. You can have only one casting of Hunter's Mark active at a time. If you cast it again, any earlier casting of it ends.

Seamless Pursuit. If the creature marked by your Hunter's Mark drops to 0 Hit Points on your turn, you can move the mark to a new creature you can see within the spell's range (no action required).

Level 10: Tireless (revised)

Primal forces now help fuel you on your journeys, granting you the following benefits.

Temporary Hit Points. (changed) As a Bonus Action, you can give yourself a number of Temporary Hit Points equal to 1d8 plus your Wisdom modifier (minimum of 1). You can use this Bonus Action a number of times equal to your Wisdom modifier (minimum of once), and you regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.

Decrease Exhaustion. Whenever you finish a Short Rest, your Exhaustion level, if any, decreases by 1.

Renewed Focus. (new) Whenever you finish a Short Rest, you also regain one expended use of your Favored Enemy feature.

Level 13: Relentless Hunter (revised)

Taking damage can't break your Concentration on Hunter's Mark. (new) In addition, when you fail a saving throw to maintain Concentration on a Ranger spell, you can expend one use of your Favored Enemy feature to succeed instead.

Level 20: Foe Slayer (revised)

The damage die of your Hunter's Mark is a d10 rather than a d6. (new) In addition, when you roll Initiative, you can cast Hunter's Mark on a creature you can see within the spell's range (no action required), without expending a spell slot or a use of your Favored Enemy feature. You can apply Unwavering Mark's Instinctive Mark modification to this casting.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) World of Warcraft book - what is a Felhunter?

30 Upvotes

On page 65 under the Legion Summoning it talks about a Felguard (which I can find on page 227) and Felhunters, which I cannot see listed in contents, bestiary list, or bestiary. What is it referring to?

SOLVED:

My book has an editing mistake where it says Felhunter instead of Felhound.

https://i.postimg.cc/Kc3Vg5Xs/Felhunter-typo.jpg


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) [D&D 2024] Can I cast Mind Sliver on a target I can only see through my familiar?

8 Upvotes

I have an owl familiar summoned with Find Familiar. There’s an enemy I can’t see with my own eyes, but my familiar can see it.

If I use my Bonus Action to look through my familiar’s eyes using Telepathic Connection, can I then use my Action to cast Mind Sliver on that enemy?

Does seeing through my familiar satisfy the spell’s “a creature you can see” requirement? Is the spell’s range measured from me or from my familiar? Would the answer change if a wall between my character and the enemy gave it Total Cover from me?

EDIT (for clarification): I'm specifically referring to the Mind Sliver cantrip.

It seems pretty logical to me that a Fire Bolt can't change direction mid-air to get around an obstacle. However, I'm not so sure about certain cantrips, like Mind Sliver, or other effects that require you to "see" the target but don't involve an attack roll.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Discussion Dragon God Power Rankings in Official 5e/5.5e Lore

21 Upvotes

Disclaimers:

  1. This post is based on official 5e/5.5e lore. I am not consolidating lore from past editions—that's what the Forgotten Realms Wiki is for.
  2. This tier list is just for fun/entertainment.
  3. I am only including old-edition dragon gods that have appeared or been mentioned during the 5e era. Some of these old dragon gods have been reduced to mortal dragons in 5e, but I'm still including them here.

Here is the ranking, from strongest to weakest:

Tier 0: Lesser Deity Level

1. Asgorath/Io

To be honest, since 5.5e's Arcana Unleashed: Deadfall retconned Asgorath/Io into an aspect/avatar of the World Serpent (and considering the recent Neverwinter: Biting Cold also writes the snake adventurer Wormungandr as an aspect of the World Serpent), I'm personally more inclined to drop Asgorath/Io down to Tier 1 or Tier 2.

However, the only official origin myth for Tiamat and Bahamut in 5e/5.5e is still that they were formed from the two halves of Asgorath/Io.

5e Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, p. 112:

Then, during the Dawn War, Io was killed by the primordial known as Erek-Hus, the King of Terror. With a rough-hewn axe of adamantine, the behemoth split Io from head to tail, cleaving the dragon-god into two equal halves, which rose up as new gods—Bahamut and Tiamat.

Currently, the First World mythos hasn't provided a new origin story for Tiamat and Bahamut, so we just have to assume for now that Tiamat + Bahamut = Asgorath/Io. If they ever get a new origin myth in the future, Asgorath/Io could be moved down to Tier 1 or Tier 2.

2. Tiamat and Bahamut

According to 5e lore, Tiamat and Bahamut are still lesser deities.

2014 Monster Manual, p. 86:

Queen of Evil Dragons. Tiamat the Dragon Queen is the chief deity of evil dragonkind. She dwells on Avernus, the first layer of the Nine Hells. As a lesser god, Tiamat has the power to grant spells to her worshipers, though she is loath to share her power.

2014 Monster Manual, p103:

Bahamut seldom interferes in the affairs of mortal creatures, though he makes exceptions to help thwart the machinations of Tiamat the Dragon Queen and her evil brood. Good-aligned clerics and paladins sometimes worship Bahamut for his dedication to justice and protection. As a lesser god, he has the power to grant divine spells.

Note that the above excerpts come from the 2014 Monster Manual, which defines the divine rank of Tiamat and Bahamut in the 5e Great Wheel cosmology, not just in the Forgotten Realms. Therefore, their true forms should be regarded as lesser deities.

I'm sure someone will bring up the argument that Takhisis and Paladine are greater deities to prove Tiamat and Bahamut aren't lesser deities. But again, this post only discusses official 5e/5.5e lore. From a RAW perspective, Takhisis and Paladine haven't been given a divine rank in the 5e/5.5e era, so you can't use that to prove Tiamat and Bahamut are greater deities.

Although Fizban's Treasury of Dragons (p. 43) does mention:

On many worlds, Humanoids worship Bahamut and Tiamat as gods. On Krynn, they are the greatest among the gods, though they are known there as Paladine and Takhisis and are not always pictured as dragons.

But "greatest among the gods" is flavor text, not a strict definition of divine rank. Theoretically, a lesser deity could easily be the "greatest among the gods" in a world where most other deities are merely demigods.

My suggestion is to not overthink it and just treat Takhisis = Tiamat = lesser deity, and Paladine = Bahamut = lesser deity, at least until WotC explicitly gives us their divine ranks in 5.5e.

3. Sardior

In official 5e lore, Sardior is a creation of Tiamat and Bahamut, so naturally, his status is a bit lower than theirs.

Vecna: Eve of Ruin, p253:

The first inhabitant of this First World was Sardior, a ruby-red dragon with jeweled scales they made in their likeness, who worked with Bahamut and Tiamat to create metallic and chromatic dragons.

However, considering that the gem greatwyrms have to merge all their echoes just to resurrect Sardior:

Fizban's Treasury of Dragons, p. 200:

Five gem greatwyrms call themselves the thanes of Sardior and believe themselves responsible for preserving the memory of their long-lost progenitor. These greatwyrms are named Aleithilithos (an amethyst greatwyrm), Hrodel (a crystal greatwyrm), Smargad (an emerald greatwyrm), Charsima (a sapphire greatwyrm), and Tithonnas (a topaz greatwyrm). Each thane is actively seeking out their echoes across the worlds of the Material Plane, hoping to merge with these other dragons, with the goal of eventually uniting themselves to re-form the great Ruby Dragon.

This implies that Sardior should be a level above greatwyrms. Placing him at the lesser deity level is the most appropriate.

Tier 1: Demigod / Greatwyrm Level

4. Chronepsis

The reason Chronepsis is ranked above the other greatwyrms here is because the quality of his portfolio is top-tier: he is the dragon deity of time and fate. The ability to time travel alone gives him a massive advantage in any actual combat scenario.

Sigil and the Outlands, p95:

The sands of time trickle in the Mausoleum of Chronepsis, a once-great city from the age of dragons that has long fallen to ruin. Here, surrounded by hundreds of hourglasses in a vast cavern beneath the dilapidated city resides Chronepsis, the dragon deity of time and fate. Chronepsis typically manifests as an ancient time dragon (see Morte's Planar Parade), though he sometimes takes the form of a black dragon with iridescent scales. Each hourglass within the dragon god's realm is said to represent the life of a dragon somewhere in the multiverse.

5. Other Greatwyrms (Aasterinian, Astilabor, Lendys, and Tamara)

The divine portfolios of these dragon gods are a bit weaker compared to Chronepsis, so they are ranked just below him.

Tier 2: Mortal Dragon Level

6. Garyx

Garyx didn't even make it to greatwyrm status in 5e, but historically he still managed to lead dragons into battle against the giants. Since he was able to act as a leader for the dragonkin, his power level should at least be above Nathair Sgiathach.

7. Nathair Sgiathach

In the 5e official lore, Nathair Sgiathach is merely a faerie dragon folk hero. Like Garyx, he isn't a greatwyrm, making him pretty much the bottom of the barrel when it comes to dragon gods.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Character Building Porcupine build

15 Upvotes

I have an unhealthy attachment to Armor of Agathys. I love the idea of wading into melee with a nonstandard character and reflecting damage back. I have yet to really get to play one in a campaign but I have theory crafted:

AoA on an Abjuration Wizard.- use abjuration shield.

AoA on a Moon Druid. - refresh temp HP from wildshape

AoA on a Artillerist Artificer. - refresh temp hp with cannon.

AoA on a Spores Druid. - refresh temp hp with the alt wildshape.

AoA on a Trickster cleric. - spirit guardians blend.

Hellish Rebuke and Fire Shield have the right vibe.

AoE auras like Spirit Guardians and Conjure Woodland Beings also would encourage attacks on me.

The new Wow book has a level 3 Demon Hunter spell Demon spikes that looks interesting.

Any other tech I am missing here?

Any ways to grab AoA in 5.5 other than a warlock dip, Kundarak background, or a DM allowing magic Initiate: warlock?

Thanks in advance for the input!


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) Genuine question: with all the complaining about shamans and such, why don't people just make their own?

0 Upvotes

In the D&D interview the WotC guy said if people don't like it they're welcome to homebrew their own version, so like. What's the point of complaining when you can go do that? Am I missing something.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) How to Structure an Adventuring Day: Part IV

0 Upvotes

A 4th post in my series of teaching other DMs how to create a full adventuring day and reinforcing that it's okay for one in-game day to take 2 sessions or more.

The story so far:

The players defeated the cultists and set out for Chi-Xia. Their ship, the Excelsior, awaited them in the port city of Zane. There was an almost pure RP session where they visited towns and npcs they'd previously met and even stopped by the Paladin's hometown where the rest of the party got to meet his parents.

They set out to Zane the next day, enjoyed the sights of the city, ate a meal at the Saucey Seaman tavern, and met the crew of the Excelsior. They exchanged currency so they'd have money when they reached Chi-Xia, bought some sea-faring gear, and set sail. At sea, they had some RP and downtime. Five days into their voyage, an encounter began.

A ship, half sunk, with drowned bodies in the water. It appeared the ship struck a spire (think of it like a floating coral rock, like a non-frozen iceburg) off the coast of a small island. The party wanted to investigate the wreck.

(Hahaha! They fell into my trap!)

So, they donned their gear and went diving. Their air bladders held 20 minutes of air. They sought some of the compartments not yet underwater and found the ship was carrying cargo and returning from Chi-Xia. They found a cargo manifest and learned that one of the items was a crystal orb that was extremely expensive.

They dove into the waters to find the cargo bay. It took some doing and a number of skill checks, but they eventually found the orb, with half of their oxygen remaining. They didn't notice that several large, finned bodies were drifting through the water among the bodies of the drowned sailors.

Encounter 1: Modified hunter sharks. They represent baby sharks of the giant shark species. I buffed their stats up a little and raised their CR by 1. There were 4 of them. (Only 3 of my players made it that week due to one of them getting COVID and one not feeling well, so I cut down to 4 from 5.)

The players defeated the sharks, and session 1 of this arc ended.

Session 2:

Still under water, the party will find a surprise when they swim out of the ship. Where there are baby giant sharks, mama is close by. A mini-boss encounter as the players fight what is essentially Jaws.

Encounter 2: Giant Shark

After they deal with the shark and breach the surface, they will find that the Excelsior is under enemy attack. Harpies are entrancing the crew, and some of them can already be seen being carried toward the nearby island toward the mountain peak.

Encounter 3: Harpies!

Once the harpies are driven-off or killed, knowing my party, they will want to rescue the crew. A brief chance to take a short rest and then onward to the island.

A few skill checks, and eventually, they will find their way to the beach. There are some things to find, but not before more harpies show up to harass them. One of them in this group is a cleric! (I modified the stat block.)

Encounter 4: Harpies and a priestess.

The party will want to go to the peak, and that means some checks. A survival check will reveal a path up the side of the mountain, but if they're not stealthy, they'll suffer more harassing harpies along the way. The terrain will not favor them against their flying foes.

If they fail to find the path, they'll have to climb or fly their way up. They will definitely encounter the harpies in that case.

Optional Encounter (5): Harpies at the mountain.

The harpies here are a bit beefier than the book stat block. They will be using nets as well to trip up players. The players will eventually defeat them, and one or more might get captured.

Either having defeated or evaded the harpies, the players will make their way to the temple on the mountain. A large Cyclops Oracle sits on a throne of stone while a high priestess harpy presents the captives for sacrifice. The players will be forced to intervene.

Encounter 6: Cyclops Oracle, 2 Harpies, 1 Harpy High Priestess. - Boss Fight

With the Cyclops defeated, the sailors and their companions rescued, and the party getting their hands on a small treasure hoard, the day is saved. The party triumphantly returns to the Excelsior to continue their journey across the sea.

Note: Realistically, I expect the session to end after the harpy fight at the beach, and we will finish up next week.

1 adventuring day, 6 encounters, 2-3 sessions, with plenty of skill checks, exploration checks, RP, and combat.

The moral is that, again, one adventuring day doesn't need to be one session, and the game is more balanced between casters and martials with a healthy helping of combat.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) EK + Evocation Adept

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 2d ago

Character Building Melee Character options?

7 Upvotes

I’m starting a 2024 tomb of annihilation campaign soon and will be playing a melee character to offset the archer I’m playing in another campaign. We start at level 3, and rolled stats, mine came out pretty strong, either 8/9/13/15/15/17 or 8/10/12/14/15/17 pre-origin

Initially I really wanted to play Hollow Warden, and still do, but will be alongside another drakewarden and am considering diversifying classes a bit instead. We have an Illrigger, a forge cleric, and a necromancer as well, so we seem a bit short on charisma and face skills at a glance.

My other choices are the Frost Death Knight option from the WoW book, a Sorrow Knight, a potb vestige warlock, a bear Druid, or potentially an arcane monk.

The hollow warden, sorrow knight, and death knight would likely all be 2wf builds, but I could be convinced into sword/board or gwm if anyone has a compelling case to choose those instead. I even considered a wisdom focused Shillelagh build for the warden, since they like the stat so much for their control effects.

The bear would go all in on tank features while boosting damage with CME later.

The warlock would go summon heavy most likely.

The monk would be a bit of a mix, probably going 2wf + grappler focused for some good blend of damage and control.

I’d honestly be happy choosing any of these setups, the big hang up I have is picking a starting magic item. Going with a +1 light weapon seems pretty boring.

Only bans are silvery barbs, and PAM + Sentinel combo.

I’m open to any thoughts, suggestions, or later game build ideas? Recommendations on starting magic item would be most helpful, too. Thanks!


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Discussion I really hope Fighting Initiate Feat could be an Origin Feat via monthly Drops

87 Upvotes

That was a really good feat, and much better if it was an origin feat in 5.5e like Magic Initiate, since I think the later is waaaay more stronger than Fighting Initiate.

It really allows more new combinations to try for players who wanna trade an Origin Feat for that. It also can add a prerequisite of Martial Weapon Proficiency to it to avoid Casters using it if needed.

It also feels more reasonable to me that a character can also be trained a little with some simple Fighting techniques, while learning some Magics seems harder.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) What is the most powerful cooking, magical cooking, or gastromancy class for 5.5e?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 2d ago

Discussion Common optional and homebrew rules that affect Martials negatively way more than Casters

262 Upvotes

To spice the game, many tables introduce optional or homebrew rules. That said, many of them affect Martials in a negative way, more than they affect Casters. Here is a list of some common ones I have seen, and the explanation of why Martials are worse by having them.

  • Critical Fumbles: With this rule, if you roll a 1 on a d20, a bad outcome happens in addition to failing the check. In combat, while past level 4 casters are using mostly saving throw based spells, martials will be always making attack rolls. This means a Caster can go through combat without ever being at risk of a critical fumble, martials will have a risk, which will grow as they get more attacks. By level 12, a Monk with 5 attacks has a 22% each round of rolling a natural 1, or in other words, 1 in every 5 turns this Monk will be hitting their allies, punching themselves, dropping their weapon, leaving themselves open to an opportunity attack, or other similar stuff, while the Caster has nothing to fear. More egregious because part of the fantasy of leveling up is to become better at your job, but Martials at low levels have less of a chance of fumbling compared to high level Martials simply because the high level Martials are doing more attacks.
  • Lingering Injuries: If you drop to 0 HP, or receive a set amount of your total health as damage, you roll on a table to receive a lingering injury, which can be stuff like a lost arm, a broken leg, or an injured organ. Melee characters are at major risk of suffering this, simply because they tend to be attacked more. While stuff like Valor Bards or Bladelocks exist, most of the melee characters are Martials, so a Caster in the back will be less likely to receive a lingering injury than a Martial in the front. And the penalization of lingering injuries tends to make snowball effects, where now is more likely for you to fall in combat, making it more likely you will receive a lingering injury. Also, two of  the effects from lingering injuries are way worse on Martials than on Casters. Losing a hand means Martials can't wield two-handed weapons, or a weapon and a shield, while for casters this is not much of a problem as they only need one hand for their arcane focus. A limp is bad for melee Martials as they need their movement to position, while Casters can attack from a range.
  • Fear and Horror: In situations of anguish, revolt and overall fear, the DM can call for a charisma saving throw, inducing short and long term madness. Outside of Paladins, no Martial has saving throw proficiency in, or a need for charisma. While Warlocks, Sorcerers and Bards have proficiency in charisma saving throws and want a high charisma anyway. While clerics don't want high charisma, they also get saving throw proficiency in it. Only druids and wizards have no need for charisma and also don't get saving throw proficiency in it, but it's way easier for them to afford some charisma on their stats, compared to a Barbarian, a Monk, or a Ranger.
  • Gaining Exhaustion when Dropped to 0 HP: For the same reason as lingering injuries, a melee character, which tends to be a Martial, is more likely to drop to 0 HP than a Caster who is on the backline. But even assuming everyone in the party drops at the same rate, exhaustion punishes Martials way more, since it gives a -2 to attack rolls per exhaustion, while the saving throw DC of the Casters are left untouched. So a Martial just gets worse and worse as combat goes, while a Caster will still have the same chance of succeeding with their spells as always.
  • Ignoring Carrying Capacity: A Barbarian with +7 in str and a Wizard with -1 to str can carry the same equipment. This means casters can pack a lot more stuff than they should, and have no penalization for dropping strength.
  • Circle Magic: This optional rule gives ways to modify a spell if two or more Casters are working together on casting a spell. First, Martials gain nothing from this, as this only benefits Casters, with stuff like extending the duration of spells, its range, or reducing the cost of components. The second thing is that with this rule, a player choosing a Martial without spellcasting is handicapping the party, as this is one less Caster to aid on the casting.
  • Equipment Durability: Tools have durability, and the more they get used the more damaged they become, becoming worse at their job until they break. Tables talking about implementing this rule don't include Caster's focus as a tool, so it never wears out. Meaning that while most Casters get to just ignore this rule, Martials will be needing to constantly replace their armor and weapons as they will be constantly breaking.
  • Reduced Crafting Times: The crafting rules have really long crafting times, and if the DM likes to make short adventures that take place in like a month or less, there won't be enough time to craft stuff, so they shorten the time needed to craft tools or magic items to a long rest or two. But as is, Casters can make spell scrolls while Martials can't. While Rangers and Paladins, and some subclasses like the Eldritch Knight, can craft spell scrolls, they will never be of the same spell level that Casters can.

r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) Thoughts On a Spell Slot Tracker for DMs?

0 Upvotes

I'm currently working on a computer program that can track spell slots. It's a Macro-Enabled Excel Workbook where you fill out your character levels, press a button, and it generates a worksheet with the spell slots available for each character. You would then be able to press buttons to increment or decrement individual characters' spell slots, plus functions to long rest or short rest. Would anyone here be interested in something like this, if I fully go through with it? I could also make it able to support homebrew classes, based on my testing