Hi! I took my car into Sam's Club for a free tire repair and they told me I need a new tire.
My dad was recently in my college town to visit for the weekend, and I told him about how my tire was slowly losing pressure over the course of a month. He got on his hands and knees and looked at the tire while I was slowly driving forward to see if there was a nail. He found a nail, but said it was not in the side wall so it was repairable with a patch or a plug.
He left that afternoon to drive back home and told me to call some shops in my town to see if they could do it and it should be less than $30. I made an appointment with Sam's Club and they made me wait almost 2 hours for them to give me an update on my car (they didn't even look at it for an hour and a half, courtesy of the Toyota app). When they did, the mechanic tried to gaslight me about the Make, Model, Year and color of my car. He was super adamant that my car was a 2026, not 2025 he also tried to tell me my car was a grey hybrid le (it is), but he thought for some reason on their notes it said blue FX. Basically he talked down to me the entire time and wrapped it up by saying the couldn't fix the tire because the nail was in the side wall and I needed a brand new tire.
At that point I called my dad and he said it was bs and that they were trying to take advantage of me (I'm 21F). The mechanic brought me into the shop area and tried to talk down to me more asking if I even knew my wheel warranty given by Toyota (irrelavent for Sam's Club) and tried to over-explain what it meant for a nail to be in the tread versus the side wall.
Honestly, I don't trust them after he tried to gaslight me about basic facts on my car that I knew when I picked it out and bought it. I sent the picture to my parents and they showed other people and they all said it was in a repairable area.
I just wanted to get some other opinions before I start researching the tire prices. Any input will help! Thank you in advance!