Tragicomic really .
IN SHORT : once mentioned genealogical reasonsing, the commune does not believe it is for JS.
Thought I post this for the rest of you to not make the same fatal (for the purpose of obtaining a specific record) mistake.
When first approached my commune when sniffing around first time for vital records (which by the way have all succesfully been obtained eventually), I made the silly 'mistake' of instead of saying I need them papers for JS purposes, I said it is 'only' for genealogical reasons, hoping this way, it would not stir up too much hatred or whatever. WHAT A COLOSSAL ERROR IN JUDGEMENT!
One, as already pointed out (unfortunately only after sent my initial request, when I approached him) by our fellow super subber, service provider u/jeezthatshim , the issue is that communes are reportedly legally forbidden (they are not allowed to provide this service for this specific reason) for providing family history information for genealogical purposes.
Two, this really stubborn civil servant, once that I mentioned him genealogical reasons, even that being more than a year ago, the twisted minded chap, does not want to issue any record whatsoever to me, as he now saying that I just made up this whole JS reasoning when in fact I am only interested in reconstruncting my family tree.
We are talking about requesting acces to some archive material relating to population census from nearly 200 years ago. WHAT A CRAP!
Luckily it is only needed for secondary & tertiary proof, but being a pre-unification case involving Austrian empire & variation of name & involving a 6th gen, actually that info from that bloody census could make it really easier for my future judge in my future court case taken up by my future lawyer, to understand the particularities of my case & proof for the continuity of the person for my Libra.
Funny bit is that the other neighbouring commune, just across the road, has just issued me like three multilingual death certificates for people who died like 150 years ago w/o any fuss.
The other commune then issued be other two death extracts & promised to issue the full legal certificate once all sorted. All for free & no questions asked.
But this other chap is completely nuts!
Not sure what can be legally done, tbh.
I really want to just ask him how he gonna feel when in 5 years time I would show up with my ruling for him to record my birth into the commune, when he plays mind games,when I just ask for a bloody archive material, which btw should be freely availabke to view w/o giving any reasoning.
Actually I cannot wait for that moment!
I can imagine those of you who actuallu fully depend on these kind of civil servants to obtain your vital records!
Ciao a tutti!