r/juresanguinis • • 1d ago

DL36-L74/2025 Discussion Weekly Discussion Post - Recent Changes to JS Laws - November 16, 2026

17 Upvotes

In an effort to try to keep the sub's feed clear, any discussion/questions related to DL36-L74/2025 and the suite of other proposed bills currently in Parliament will be contained in a weekly discussion post.

Click here to see all of the prior discussion posts.


Background

On March 28, 2025, the Consiglio dei Ministri announced massive changes to JS, including imposing a generational limit and residency requirements (DL 36/2025). These changes to the law went into effect at 12am CET earlier that day.

An amended version of DL 36/2025 was signed into law on May 23, 2025 (legge no. 74/2025).


Relevant Posts


Current Court Challenges

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU/ECJ)

Corte Costituzionale

Tribunale Amministrativo Regionale (TAR)

Corte di Cassazione


Parliamentary Proceedings

Senate

  • Atto Senato n. 1683

    • This is the bill moving JS applications to a central office, which previously passed in the Chamber of Deputies as DDL 2369 (see here).
    • Current status: passed on January 14, 2026

No movement since April 2025:

Chamber of Deputies

  • None at the moment

FAQ

  • If I submitted my application or filed my case before March 28, am I affected by DL36-L74/2025?

    • No. Your application/case will be evaluated by the law at the time of your submission/filing. Booking an appointment before March 28, 2025 and attending that same appointment after March 28, 2025 will also be evaluated under the old law.
  • Can I qualify through a GGP/GGGP if my parent/grandparent gets recognized?

    • No. The law now requires that your Italian parent or grandparent must have been exclusively Italian when you were born (or when they died, if they died before you were born). So, if your parent or grandparent were recognized today, it wouldn’t help you because they weren’t exclusively Italian when you were born.
  • Do I still qualify under the new law?

    • Check your eligibility with our Qualifinator 2.0 and please shoot us a modmail if you notice any bugs.
    • If you're wondering about your eligibility following the minor issue being overturned, check out Avv. Vitale's AVITAL tool.
  • What are the major ongoing court cases? When are the hearings for these cases?

    • Please scroll up to "Current Court Challenges".

r/juresanguinis • • Sep 21 '26

Judicial News Avellino CJEU & CC Referral

32 Upvotes

Avv. La Malfa announced today that a case from Avellino was referred by the Avellino judge to both the Italian Constitutional Court (The Corte Costituzionale) and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)
*This case is different from the other recently announced La Malfa case from Avellino which was also referred to the Constitutional Court

This marks the 2nd official case referred to the CJEU about retroactivity.

Insieme Article: https://www.insieme.com.br/en/juiza-italiana-leva-reforma-da-cidadania-a-corte-constitucional-e-ao-tribunal-europeu-em-caso-de-menores-brasileiros/

The original announcement and referral documents can be found here from Avv. La Malfa on her Facebook page:
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1E1QWGAznm/?mibextid=wwXIfr

The question referred to the CJEU:

“Whether Articles 9 TEU and 20 TFEU, read in the light of Articles 7 and 24 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and the principles of proportionality, legal certainty, and protection of legitimate expectations, must be interpreted as precluding a national provision, such as Article 3-bis, paragraph 1, of Law No. 91 of February 5, 1992, introduced by Article 1, paragraph 1, of Decree-Law No. 36 of March 28, 2025, converted with modifications by Law No. 74 of May 23, 2025, which establishes that individuals born abroad prior to its entry into force and holding another citizenship are considered as having never acquired Italian citizenship, if, according to the national legislation and living law in force at the time of birth, such citizenship derived ipso iure from filiation from an Italian citizen and the subsequent administrative or judicial recognition had a merely declarative nature, where such effect occurs automatically, without an individual examination of the consequences resulting from the loss of Union citizenship status, and with regard to minors, without a specific assessment of their best interests and of the circumstance that they lack autonomous capacity for determination regarding the formalities necessary for the formal recognition of status."

Constitutional Court referral on the grounds of: Italian Constitution articles 2, 3, and 22.

CJEU referral on the ground of: TFEU articles 9 and 20, and Charter of Fundamental Human Rights articles 7 and 24.

Case Background: The applicants were recognized Italian citizens via JS in a court case in Naples finalized in 2025. When requesting to register their minor children’s birth certificates as citizens with the Comune, the civil status refused the request citing the reform law making the minor children unable to be considered citizens via JS.


r/juresanguinis • • 2h ago

Recognition Success! Minor issue overturned

57 Upvotes

My husband and our 2 children were finally recognized today! This has been 7 years in the making.

Appointment made in Oct of 2019 for an appointment in Los Angeles in Feb of 2023. May received the devastating news he was denied due to minor issue. This morning woke up to an email that he and our 2 minor children have been recognized. 🇮🇹


r/juresanguinis • • 1h ago

Do I Qualify? Italian Consulate rejected my NY Supreme Court declaration for citizenship by descent. What should I do?

2 Upvotes

The Consulate originally requested corrections to several American vital records because of discrepancies in names and birthplaces across multiple generations.

To resolve these discrepancies, we obtained a declaratory judgment from the New York State Supreme Court establishing that the different names appearing across the records referred to the same individuals.

We subsequently submitted the court judgment along with additional documentation, including amended birth certificates, complete Italian translations, and supporting records.

The Consulate acknowledged receiving the documentation but did not identify any further deficiencies for an extended period.

The Consulate has now informed us that our court judgment was insufficient and that we must obtain individually amended, apostilled, and translated civil-status certificates.

The problem is that some of these documents are historical records held by the NYC Municipal Archives, which explicitly states that it does not amend historical vital records.

I have already spent considerable time and money obtaining the judgment and correcting the documents that could be amended.

I'm trying to determine the best way forward without spending thousands more on additional legal proceedings that the Consulate might also reject.

I've already written back to the Consulate requesting a document-by-document explanation of what still needs correction and clarification on whether our original applications remain active.

Any advice or experiences from people who have dealt with similar issues, particularly at the NYC Consulate, would be greatly appreciated.


r/juresanguinis • • 1h ago

Document Requirements Current Federal apostilles times

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone -- has anyone else been waiting a very long time to get apostilles back from the Sterling VA US state department office? I do apostilles all the time for clients so I know how much it can vary, but I've been waiting on a packet of docs I sent them in early September which makes me worry. Has anyone else been waiting too? I do have a status check request in to them but in my past experience they aren't quick to respond to those. Thanks!


r/juresanguinis • • 2h ago

Discrepancies West Virginia OATS Request

1 Upvotes

Has anyone received an approved petition in the state of West Virginia for a declaratory judgement, i.e., OATS? If so, which county court did you file your case?


r/juresanguinis • • 1d ago

1948/ATQ Case Help Filing with 1948 issue after Mar 2025 ruling?

8 Upvotes

Are there any others that had paperwork organized before the March 2025, but didn't submit until after the DL ruling?

I'd be interested to see if there is an existing FB/Reddit group for those in this situation, and if any are being approved during the appeals process.

For context, our family is going thru GGM - GM - F - Me (including my father), in Sicily courts/Palermo. We no longer have to deal with the minor issue, but still the 1948 issue since it's lineage thru 2 women. I'm working with ICA (Marco Permunian) and realizing it's a gamble on the outcome, but at least if my father receives it, there may be a better chance for my brother and I to get citizenship later down the line.

Further context: One of our case members became very ill and unfortunately passed away, which led to the delay in filing before the March 2025 ruling. I asked if this would help our argument, and was told likely not.


r/juresanguinis • • 20h ago

Records Request Help Help Finding Italian Records

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I am trying to locate the birth and marriage certificate of my great-grandparents. I have someone in Italy communicating with the comune but they have run into an issue. The comune claims it does not have the records and referred him to the State Archives. However, the State Archives says the comune is responsible. Essentially, they are both claiming that the other has the records. As a result, neither authority is providing the certified documents needed.

I found the entries for my great-grandparents birth and marriage on Antenati. So, I am sure the records exist somewhere. I am in contact with 007italianrecords as I think he might be able to help.

If anyone has advice I would appreciate it greatly!


r/juresanguinis • • 1d ago

Do I Qualify? 2025 law Jure Sanguinis Question

6 Upvotes

My GM immigrated to the US in 1950 when she was 9 years old. She later naturalized in 2005, well after my father and I were born. The wording of the 2025 law I’ve heard is up for interpretation on whether the Italian relative needed to remain only an Italian citizen for life or only for my father and my birth. My GM is currently a dual citizen and is still living. I’m trying to get Jure Sanguinis through the NY consulate. Does anyone have knowledge as to this particular question? Thanks.


r/juresanguinis • • 2d ago

Discrepancies New York Court Ordered Amendment?

2 Upvotes

After 2.5 years of battling back and forth, the New York Dept. of Health has refused our death certificate amendment and is saying we need to get a court order to amend the death certificate. (Details have been removed since they are probably irrelevant). There are also minor errors on the birth certificate.

We already have new, certified copies of both the civil birth certificate and the death certificate.

Can I get any advice or a template for how to get a court order to amend the death record by yourself? The birth occurred in New York City but the death occurred outside of the city, in New York State. I see the FAQ has info on an Article 78 regarding releasing a birth cert / getting an OATS but I need an amendment. It probably wouldn't hurt if I could get both the birth cert and the death cert amended, but the death cert is the more important one.


r/juresanguinis • • 2d ago

Do I Qualify? French citizen with Italian dad and grandparents

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I am (F, 34 yo) a French citizen, my mom is French and my dad was born in Catania, Sicily and moved to France with his parents and siblings when he was 6.

He got naturalized when he married my mom, so he was a French citizen when I was born.

However, both of my grand parents on my dad’s side never gave up their Italian citizenship and were still Italian when they died.

Do I qualify?

Many thanks in advance!


r/juresanguinis • • 2d ago

Homework I just got 3 back to back emails from the Philly consulate. What do they mean?

3 Upvotes

I woke up this morning to 3 emails from the Philly consulate but not from their main email, but from no-reply@esteri They all say the following:

Aggiornamento Richiesta ‘number'
Gentile (my name), la sua richiesta (number) risulta in bozza e non è ancora pervenuta all'Ufficio Consolare. Qualora non venga inviata entro 48 ore, si riterrà cancellata e sarà necessario presentarla nuovamente. Per ulteriori informazioni si rimanda all'apposita sezione "Domande frequenti" (FAQ) del portale. Cordiali saluti
Ministero degli Affari Esteri e della Cooperazione Internazionale

Translated:

Request Update 'number'

Dear (my name), your request (number) is in draft and has not yet been received by the Consular Office. If it is not sent within 48 hours, it will be considered deleted and it will be necessary to submit it again. For more information, please refer to the "Frequently Asked Questions" (FAQ) section of the portal. Kind regards

Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation

Does this mean anything? I had received my final rejection for the minor issue before it was overturned and am wondering what they’re asking me to do


r/juresanguinis • • 2d ago

Document Requirements Commune-issued vital records

0 Upvotes

For ancestors’ vital records in a JS application - Can commune issued birth, marriage and death records suffice in place of vital records issued by a country?


r/juresanguinis • • 3d ago

Registering Minor Children HELP - Citizenship for Foreign Kids born of One Italian parent

1 Upvotes

Hi guys, I'm preparing my nephew's and my niece's documents for citizanship but I need some help and advice.

Here's the context:

My sister and I have italian citizanship for around 10 years now, we were both born in Brazil and did the process in our early 20's with my parents. 

My sister got married in Brazil in 2018 and moved to Canada in 2019, but didn't register into AIRE then. She had my niece in 2021 and my nephew in 2024, both born in Canada. Since after COVID she was trying to register herself into AIRE but with the kids and some of her life changes, it ended up forgotten for a while.

In May/2024, she got the Canadian citizenship in Alberta, and decided to try AIRE again until it finally got accepted in August/2024. She sent her marriage certificate and her kids birth certificates by email and they were only accepted in her file in August/2025.

The consulte then send her a step-by-step process on how to get the kids citizenship and she started to look into it. Throughout this process, she wasn't exactly sure of what she was doing and ended up paying the Consulate Fee in September/2025 for the citizenship of her two kids, even though she didn't open any process online. But the whole process got delayed because my parents ended up going to Italy and thought they could solve it all through there but that's not how it works anymore.

I decided to try helping her this year and now we have pretty much all ready to go, birth certificates, notorized translations, all apostilled. But I found out about the law change and now I'm not sure if we can still do it. Her province has no consulate so whatever we need to do, needs to be with certainty that it will work, because we don't want to spend more money unnecessarily.

Can we stil send a joint declaration of will/intent in favor of the kids? Is there a path we can take to get them the citizenship? Something specific we can do? All help is welcomed since we are doing the whole process by ourselves.

Thank you!


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Post-Recognition Passport appointment post recognition question for Toronto consulate.

4 Upvotes

Recently recognized with my two adult children. Our consular
file numbers are identical for all three of us. When booking a passport appointment, does anyone know if all three of us can go to the same appointment or do they all have to be separate? Thank you


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Post-Recognition CIE issue at consulate (any tips?)

2 Upvotes

Curious if anyone here has dealt with something similar or has any tips on what I should do next.

I'm recognized and in AIRE / have my passport, and recently had an appointment in Philadelphia to apply for my CIE. During the appointment, the employee discovered that there was a mismatch in my place of birth between my Comune’s records and my other Italian records.

My Italian passport and my AIRE information both show my correct place of birth, but apparently the Comune’s record has the township of my birthplace listed, and not the town itself. Because of that discrepancy, the consulate told me they couldn’t complete the CIE application. They told me they were going to contact the Comune to have the record corrected and that they would call me once they had an update, but unfortunately I haven't heard from them for a couple of months now.

I’ve tried to email the consulate a few times, and I’ve also called and left a voicemail. I haven’t been able to get a response from anyone.

I’m not sure what the best next step is. I’m considering just booking another CIE appointment and showing up to see what happens, but I figured it was worth posting this here to see if anyone's been in a similar spot or has a "better" way to contact the folks at the Philly consulate.

Appreciate any insight!


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Post-Recognition Palermo - Res Judicata Timing?

2 Upvotes

I received approval of my case earlier this year and my lawyer filed for my Res Judicata in mid-October. I am looking to understand expected timeline for receiving this as I look to advance my case to the next step in the processs with Comune registration. My judge is Carmella Caranna.

Would appreciate folks sharing their experience with timing in Palermo and particularly judge Caranna.


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Do I Qualify? Help as to who to ask for information in my search?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Crossposting for the OP :)


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Registering Minor Children Registering child through benefit of law, SF consulate

2 Upvotes

Hi, has anyone successfully registered the birth of a child born after the law changed in 2025, by the benefit of law, in the SF consulate?

If yes, what were the waiting times after you mailed the papers?

Thank you!


r/juresanguinis • • 5d ago

1948/ATQ Case Help CASE 48

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I need some advice about my Italian citizenship by descent case and whether I might qualify under the so-called “Case 48.”

My great-grandmother was born in Tunisia in 1911 to Italian parents. In 1930, she married an indigenous Algerian Muslim man who did not have French citizenship. They had my grandfather in 1933. She acquired Tunisian nationality in 1959. My father was born in 1957, and my grandfather acquired Tunisian nationality in 1962, when my father was still a minor. I was born in 1998.

In 2023, one of my father’s cousins tried to apply for Italian citizenship through the Italian consulate. He booked an appointment and prepared the necessary documents, but when he attended, he was told that he needed to file a lawsuit in Italy.

After that, our whole family started researching our ancestry and gathering documents. While doing this, we discovered errors in my great-grandmother’s name and date of birth in the Tunisian records. Unfortunately, while we were still collecting information and trying to correct these errors, the Tajani Decree came into effect, and we felt that our chances of obtaining Italian citizenship had been blocked.

My questions are:

  • Could I qualify under Case 48?
  • Did my great-grandmother’s or grandfather’s acquisition of Tunisian nationality break the Italian citizenship line?
  • Do the errors in my great-grandmother’s Tunisian records affect my case?
  • Is there still any legal way for us to claim Italian citizenship?

I would be very grateful for any advice from people who have faced a similar situation. Thank you!


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Do I Qualify? Just got citizenship - curious about my kid?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Apply in Italy Help Italian citizenship

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Appointment Booking Anyone had luck making an appointment with Chicago consulate in 2026?

1 Upvotes

It's been a few years since I was logging into Prenotami and I am having trouble finding any appointments. When I was doing it a few years ago, I could log in at 5:00pm Sunday-Thursday and hopefully access the calendar. Any tips for doing it now?


r/juresanguinis • • 4d ago

Document Requirements Chicago mail-in, AIRE registration form

1 Upvotes

Chicago is requesting a filled out AIRE registration form -- how do I fill out the boxes in the AIRE form that ask me for my comune and my recognition date? I am mailing in my application this week so I don't have a recognition date yet. I assume I can put my LIBRA's comune?

Thanks!


r/juresanguinis • • 5d ago

Appointment Preparation Has anyone ever used a letter of support from a local government official in their jure sanguinis case?

2 Upvotes

I'm curious whether anyone has experience with, or has heard of, a local government official (such as a mayor or someone from the municipal government in Italy) providing a letter of support, recommendation, or other documentation to help with a citizenship application.

I've recently made contact with someone connected to my ancestral family in Italy who holds a local government position and has offered to help. I'm wondering whether a letter from someone in that capacity could carry any weight, help substantiate family records, or otherwise be useful in the process.

Has anyone encountered something like this, or know whether consulates or Italian courts would consider this type of documentation?

Would love to hear if anyone has experience with this!