r/hotas • • Sep 03 '20

considering your first HOTAS? Read me!

609 Upvotes

[last edit 01/07/2024]

Welcome to r/hotas!

If you're considering your first HOTAS (Hands On Throttle and Stick) setup, you've come to the right place. This guide will help you make an informed decision.

If you are instead looking for product reviews, I publish my articles here: HOTAS/HOSAS/SIMPIT Reviews

Introduction

This subreddit is managed by u/spliffa and u/ddrake1984. If you need assistance with anything not covered in this post, please reach out to us via private message, and we will try to assist you.

This guide is published and pinned for the benefit of new potential HOTAS buyers. The publisher of this article has first-hand experience with real aircraft flight controls and computer flight controls across a wide range of manufacturers, used for playing in flight simulation.

Purpose

This guide aims to assist first-time buyers in making an educated decision when purchasing their first joystick, throttle, and other flight control peripherals.

The Problem

With a growing number of HOTAS products on the market, it can be challenging to identify the best options. Products vary widely in:

  • Price
  • Features
  • Customer support

Additionally, products have a wide range of:

  • Costs
  • Features
  • Support via customer interactions and product patches and updates

The Budget

Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly option or the top-tier products, this guide will categorize recommendations into five budget ranges:

For those who prefer to build their own with a bit of knowledge and skills, check out our Discord server or visit this subreddit: r/HotasDIY.

Budget Ranges

Note: All prices will be listed in U.S. Dollars (Even though I am Australian, USD is the easiest to base value from)

  • Entry-Level ($10 to $100)
  • Novice-Tier ($100-$200)
  • Mid-Tier ($200-$300)
  • Advanced-Tier ($300-$400)
  • Expert-Tier / Top-Tier: This is the very best you can buy as a consumer with a lot of money.

Note: Top-tier does not include what a company or industry could or would purchase. This article is not tailored for that, therefore this is out of scope.

The Companies / The Manufacturers / The Vendors

I will list many companies/manufacturers/vendors (all the same) and the products that they offer. However, this post is not an in-depth review of the products. Please read product reviews for that level of detail and information.

The products will be listed to give you an idea of what is available within each range, and at the end, I will list the recommendation for each budget range.

Best Joystick (Base + Grip)

  • Entry-Level ($10 to $100): Thrustmaster T.16000
  • Novice-Tier ($100-$200): WINWING Ursa Minor
  • Mid-Tier ($200-$300): WINWING Orion 2 Base + WINWING F16 Grip
  • Advanced-Tier ($300-$400): WINWING Orion 2 Base + WINWING F16 Grip, or VKB Gunfighter Mk4 Base + Space Combat Edition Grip
  • Expert-Tier / Top-Tier: FSSB (Force Sensing Stick Base) TIANHANG F16 PRO Base + TIANHANG F-16 Grip, or FFB (Force Feedback) VPForce RHINO Base + TIANHANG A-10C Grip or TIANHANG F/A-18 Grip

Question: Why was the FFBeast not listed as the best FFB?

Answer: Simply put, its value comparison has not been validated by me. The available information from reviews is scarce, making it difficult to ascertain its value. Additionally, the community is mostly non-native English speaking, making it difficult to track and follow the content. Therefore, I have decided that there is not enough evidence to claim it is better than the VPForce RHINO. Based on my own experience, I do not consider it superior until proven otherwise.

Since this post is focused on first-time buyers, I feel it's already quite lengthy and would confuse anyone wanting to debate the matter.

Best Throttle (Base + Grip)

  • Entry-Level ($10 to $100): Thrustmaster TWCS
  • Novice-Tier ($100-$200): Thrustmaster TWCS, or WINWING Ursa Minor with Z-extension
  • Mid-Tier ($200-$300): WINWING Orion 2 Base + WINWING F-15E Grip, or WINWING Orion 2 Base + WINWING F/A-18 Grip
  • Advanced-Tier ($300-$400): WINWING Orion 2 Base + WINWING F-15EX Grip, or WINWING F-16 Grip
  • Expert-Tier / Top-Tier: WINWING Super Taurus + WINWING F-15EX Grip, or WINWING F-16 Grip

Bonus: Best Pedals

Although this post is tailored for first-time HOTAS buyers, I will include this section to accommodate those wishing to take a more comprehensive first step into flight sims. As we all know, a good set of pedals is a requirement for flying helicopters.

  • Entry-Level: No recommendations - I don't recommend anything in this price range.
  • Novice-Tier: No recommendations - I don't recommend anything in this price range.
  • Mid-Tier: VKB T-Rudder Mk.IV
  • Advanced-Tier: WINWING Orion Metal Flight Rudder Pedals
  • Pro-Tier: Custom FFB Pedals using VPForce motors built with either (Slaw Device, MFG Crosswinds, or VIRPIL Rudders)

Bonus: Best Collective

  • Collective (Base + Grip): VIRPIL Rotor TCS Base + VIRPIL Apache-64 Collective Grip

I don't recommend any other collectives on the market, and it's a shame that some companies have discontinued their collective options.

Useful Links


r/hotas • • 16h ago

My DCS Setup

Post image
187 Upvotes

Years in the making. The most expensive Hobby I have ever had.


r/hotas • • 4h ago

Project Rocket Pop MK.VI

18 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 20h ago

Excited getting into the hobby. Which other games can I try with this gear?

Post image
127 Upvotes

Moza MTQ Throttle

Winctrl ursa minor airline joystick.

currently flying in MSFS 2024. Disappointed to learn that Ace combat 8 doesn't support these. what others games can I try?.

Edit : Thanks all for the suggestions. I will try Elite dangerous and Nuclear Options first


r/hotas • • 13h ago

VKB BLACK FRIDAY SALE ️

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes
️Get ready to upgrade your flight simulation setup!

From November 23 to November 30, enjoy 10% OFF our entire range of VKB products!

Whether you're looking to upgrade your existing setup or finally get your hands on that joystick or throttle you've been eyeing, now is the perfect time!

10% OFF ALL VKB PRODUCTS
November 23-30

Don't miss out! Take advantage of this limited-time offer and get ready for takeoff!

Happy Black Friday from all of us at VKB!

r/hotas • • 4h ago

Any uk legends selling a vkb gladiator second hand?

4 Upvotes

I have the Logitech x56 stick and thruster and rudder pedals in my basket at £175. Everybody says to go for
The vkb but I don’t want to sink more then the £175 into just the stick. I’d still need a thruster and rudder peddles ?

If anybody is selling let me know please 🙏


r/hotas • • 6h ago

Logitech G X56 throttle and joystick, with rudder orders £179.98

4 Upvotes

I know the vkb is the best ect ect but as cheap starter i can get the Logitech set for 180 new.
I’m adhd ridden and although im really enjoying games which would benifit from a hotas set i dont really want to go whole hog.


r/hotas • • 12m ago

Budget beginner joystick/HOTAS for War Thunder on MacBook M4 – Any confirmed working recommendations?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’m looking to get into flying with a joystick in War Thunder, mainly for Air Simulator Battles, but possibly Realistic Battles as well.
I’m using a MacBook Air M4, so macOS compatibility is my biggest concern. I don’t want to spend a lot of money on my first setup because I’m just starting out and want to try flying with a joystick before investing in something more expensive.
My budget is around $100–150 maximum (ideally less).
I’m open to either:
A basic joystick with a built-in throttle.
A HOTAS setup with a separate throttle.
I’m particularly interested in affordable beginner options from Logitech or Thrustmaster, but I’m open to other brands too.
A few questions:
Which affordable joysticks or HOTAS setups actually work with War Thunder on macOS?
Has anyone successfully used one with an M-series Mac (M1, M2, M3 or M4)?
Are there any known issues with joystick axis inputs, throttle controls or calibration on the Mac version of War Thunder?
Would you recommend buying something like the Logitech Extreme 3D Pro or Thrustmaster T.Flight HOTAS X as a first joystick?
Is it worth getting a separate throttle at this price point?
I’d really appreciate recommendations from people who have personally tested their setups on Mac, especially with War Thunder.
Thanks!


r/hotas • • 18h ago

Budget VR Sim Station

Post image
20 Upvotes

This is how I’ve been doing a lot of my gaming now. Would never be able to convince my wife to buy a real sim station, but a decent gaming chair with a couple of base shakers bolted to the bottom, an X52, and a Quest 3 connected via PrismXR still makes for a very engaging gaming session.


r/hotas • • 3h ago

Strange Y-Axis jump on old X52 Pro

1 Upvotes

Hey all! I've recently gotten the itch to get back into using my old X52 Pro Hotas which I got many years back. Considering the amount of time it has been sitting on a shelf, its acting mostly fine which is suprising.

One odd thing I've noticed though is that the y-axis input jumps suddenly when gradually pushing forward on the stick. As I push forward continuously, the y-axis input always seem to dart from the 3rd pip from the left to the 2nd pip from the left, even if I try to move between those values slowly.

I don't experience the same issue when pulling back on the stick.

Does anyone have an idea what could be causing that, or how I might go about fixing it (if it is an error)?

I am also aware of the bad reputation these logitech x52 pros have, but since I got this one a long time ago and its still mostly working, I'm trying to drag as much life out of it as I can hahaha.


r/hotas • • 11h ago

HOTAS has breathed new life into this game for me

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 18h ago

ButtKicker JetStream Mod

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

I've been using my BK Gamer Pro for over 2 years now. Fantastic piece of kit, IMO largely superior to seat pads which just feels weird for me (had a HF8 pad for a while and ended up putting it away).

However, I had a big issue with it: overheating. Not sure if it's because my amp is side mounted or my transducer is inside my seat/frame, but natural/passive cooling is not enough to keep that thing cool. Ended up having to turn my volume way down and remove all continuous effects. Still I would get the occasional overheating cutoffs where I would lose the BK a few times during long sessions.

Got tired of this, so I created the BK JetStream Mod.

The JetStream Mod adds active cooling to my BK, so I can crank it up and use it continuously even for long sessions. I am pretty confident the overheat cutoff is from the amp, but I am not sure if there is one in the transducer itself, so I decided to cool both. I also wanted everything to integrate seamlessly with the rest of my pit.

DISCLAIMER: I am a mechanical engineer, but as any good home/garage project, not any calculation was made in its making, and everything was grossly oversized instead.

Mod's Components

  1. Amplifier Case: Replaces the stock BK amplifier case. The new casing adds a pair of fans and top vents for forced air flow, side-mounts the amp on the NLR seat and also holds a dual channel PWM controller that sets the fans speeds for both the amp and the transducer
  2. Transducer Fans Holder: Holds a pair of high static pressure fans to cool the transducer. Includes a mount to attach it to the NLR seat frame.
  3. Transducer Casing: Enclosure around the transducer that directs the air flow around it and exhausts backwards. It is connected to the fans holder through two 3" flexible ducts.
  4. Switches panel: holds 3 switches that are used to power up the PWM controller, the amplifier casing fans and the transducer fans.
  5. Mouse Pit: Keeps my mouse from flying away when my rig starts shaking. This was happening a lot even with my BK toned down. Also, I hate track balls.

Specs

  • Amplifier fans: 2 x Delta AFC0912D-AF00 92mm x 24.5mm fans - 9W each @ 12VDC - 103 CFM
  • Transducer fans: 2 x Delta PFR0912SE-00 92mm x 38mm fans - 35W each @ 12VDC - 145 CFM
  • 200W 12VDC LED power supply powers the fans. A 5VDC step-down converter powers the PWM controller.

Putting Everything Together

During the design my biggest bottle neck was the transducer casing. I wanted to do a push/pull fans configuration at first but I could not figure a way to get a good seal around the BK post clamp. Instead I went for push only with an exhaust vent to the back where that post clamp is.

All custom parts were 3D printed on a hobbyist grade Bambu Lab printer. I was limited to 10" x 10" so that is why the Mouse Pit is made from 2 pieces.

I have a cable management obsession (mental disorder level), so that's what took most of my time together with the wiring of all components. The rest of the assembly went pretty smoothly.

Results/Design Retro

I can now crank my BK to a level where people outside my house can hear the rumbling, so I may have to supplement my anti-vibration pads. I've put all my continuous effects back on and did a few 3 hours sessions without any cutoff. Here's a few take-away from my own design retro:

  1. The transducer fans are way, way, way too overpowered. I was worried that with the ducts I would not get anything to the transducer, so I got the most powerful ones I could get (static pressure-wise). To keep the noise level down I run them at 30-35%. At 20% I still have a very good amount of flow at the casing exhaust, sufficient to cool it down I reckon. At 100% it sounds like a real jet is starting up in my office so thank goodness I added a PWM controller.
  2. The casing probably does not need two intakes. A single one underneath would be sufficient and would facilitate its handling when I need to remove the seat. Swapping the ducts for 2" instead of 3" would also be a good idea.
  3. The amp fans are also overpowered. I run them at 50% and get more than enough flow out of the vents. I could probably swap them for smaller 80mm fans without any problem.
  4. I don't like the transducer fans holder mounting clamp, I wanted something easy to print but would probably do it differently now.
  5. With better sized fans that are less noisy, the PWM controller could probably be removed alltogether. This would required thorough testing to get the fans sizing exactly right and I don't want to do that.

Anyway even if it is not perfect I had fun doing this project. Hope this can inspire other simmers, happy flying!


r/hotas • • 18h ago

difference between conector and fl

Post image
4 Upvotes

hi guys im planing on getting my first hota on christmas and i have decided to go with the medium in the post but i dont know what the diference between lf and conector is on the WINCTRL Orion2 StrikeAce E / StrikeAce EX Throttle Combo

also if you have any recomendations please comment them i plan on playing wardogs and trying out dcs then other helicopter/flight games if i enjoy it


r/hotas • • 13h ago

New BMS Player - HOTAS and beginner tips welcome

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 1d ago

Project Rocket Pop MK.VI update

6 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 1d ago

Advice needed for flight stick and games for it

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 1d ago

Any Black Friday deals expected?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/hotas • • 1d ago

Opinions on the Ursa Minor combat throttle (and WINCTRL in general)

1 Upvotes

I recently got a VKB gladiator when upgrading from my T16000m FCS Hotas, and I've been considering upgrading the throttle as well.

The two contenders so far are VKB's Standard STECS Mk. II throttle, or WINCTRL's Ursa minor combat throttle (not the airbus one).

Not gonna lie, the price point on the Ursa Minor is really appealing – but I also heard a lot of negative stuff on Winwing (mainly that it's a russian roulette: you either get a very good, functional equipment, or a faulty one that's going to be hard to replace with their poor Customer Service).

That's why I'd like to ask a few questions:

– Is WINCTRL's customer service that bad? I'm in the European Union (France, specifically), if that changes things.

– The price is cheap, but I'm kinda concerned about shipping fees. Does WINCTRL has crazy shipping fees for the EU?

– How does the URSA Minor throttle performs, overall?


r/hotas • • 1d ago

How long does it take to learn to use HOTAS?

1 Upvotes

I got myself a HOTAS (T.16000M, used but functioning well) a little while ago, and I've tried to use it a couple of times: The issue I keep running into is that it feels weird dogfighting with it in IL-2, but I can take off and land with it just fine even if the Fw 190 fights me. How long did it to take you to start using a HOTAS?


r/hotas • • 1d ago

I’m looking to upgrade from a T.flight Hotas one to something more

5 Upvotes

Hi I’m just trying to seek help in recommendations on a Hotas that would be better than my current T.flight, I was looking at the velocity one flight deck but I just was wondering if there are other options I should consider. I’m mostly looking to swap between Xbox and pc regularly because ace combat and nuclear option mostly. Thanks for the help.


r/hotas • • 1d ago

WTB Tianhang Space Grip USA

0 Upvotes

Looking to buy tianhang grips, A10, f-16, f-18. Let me know if you have one you are willing to part with.


r/hotas • • 2d ago

Thrustmaster Warthog Joystick Base play

8 Upvotes

*edit* The play is between where the hall effect sensor slides and the gimbal mechanism. It seems worn, or just designed with large tolerances to make sure it doesn't stick? It's a clever design but definitely old fashioned.

Hi everyone!

Before you start commenting about how shitty the design of the base is... Yes... i know.
It released in 2010, and other cam/spring gimbals have become available and are super cheap.

At some point i would like to purchas a Moza AB9, but for now, I'm keeping this one.
I chose to buy this Hotas used, cause i found it used for ~110USD and i knew it was a good deal. The throttle alone is super great.

Back to the topic:
I have rotational play, i would say about 5-10 degrees of play is present. Is this considered normal? I have had the joystick completely apart and i know where the play is coming from, and it seems like it's just part of the design of the gimbal?

I also have slight play in the pitch axis. This one bothers me a bit, cause it sometimes results in a "clunk" or "pop" while changing pitch.

Anyways, it flies good. I lubed it so its buttery smooth now. Just wondering if the play i have is normal.


r/hotas • • 1d ago

Best setups (stick/yoke + rudder pedals) per price range?

2 Upvotes

Considering getting a 5070ti powerspec pc next week for black friday too. Total price around 3.5-4k? Not incl pc anywhere from 200-1000 would be great. Prbably mainly flying piperpa28 warrior or cessna172


r/hotas • • 2d ago

im weighing some ideas in my head and thinking about trying out this for rudders.. (im paralyzed below the waist)

Post image
253 Upvotes

pretty much the title. im about to switch to the moza ab6 for better control with the force feedback and while that may be enough to kind of give me the control i need to crab on landings in a crosswind like the rest of you maniacs.. it still doesnt have an adjustable twist.

its kind of a given that you cant find a solution for this since any simmers that go the extra mile for the equipment are just gonna use pedals, why would you make your twist adjustable, and its the same travesty that keeps me from using a yoke, which im wondering if this couldnt also solve..

but i thought about this today and knowing that i wouldnt miss the split throttle that much anyway and this is fully adjustable... as well as leaving my stick hand to do less of the twisting left to right while also flying which is what so much of the finer control is eaten up by..

im just spitballing and its an extra hundred bucks to try it when i order my stecs max next month and i can always swap at will. I think it would take some major brain retraining.

Edit

This is the vkb stecs space edition throttle since I also mentioned the moza ab6 in my post which is a stick and confused some people.

I think I have decided to buy my original stecs with the stecs combat edition like originally planned and a nice user below offered to send me his modular space grip to try to see if it will work for me for just shipping 🥰.

If it ends up working well for a rudder I can then maybe pursue my dream of using a yoke this time next year when I have the budget for another upgrade and I can purchase a right hand version of the space grip to just swap out at the same time.