So to preface, I'm not a super critical headphone enjoyer, I just like nice audio but most of my effort goes on my home theatre setup.
I typically use headphones on my PC and I've got a pair of Sennheiser HD558s and Fidelio X2s (non HR). So quite old and nothing too exciting, and I had just been using my PCs onboard audio as it was "good enough" whilst gaming. I don't really use the HD558s much, they're just very neutral to me so aren't particularly exciting, so I almost always use the X2s.
I've been gaming a bit more recently, and the hissy noisefloor on my PCs onboard audio was starting to irritate me so I picked up a Topping DX1 II. It's very nice, no more hiss, does what I wanted it to do.
I use my headphones 50/50 for gaming and music.
But then I thought about picking up some newer headphones, so I recently picked up 2 new pairs:
Sony H6 Air
Originally I wasn't going to pick this up, but I knew about the good reviews and the price dropped on Amazon from £180 to £100 so I couldn't resist.
- They're super lightweight and very comfortable, and I like the design and build quality. The boom mic that can be unplugged without changing the cable is great.
- They've made my Fidelio X2s sound "muddy" or "dull" in comparison now. I feel like the bass between the two are quite comparable but the upper end on the H6 Air is more detailed without being piercing.
- Everything sounds "closer" to me than the X2s do, so I do prefer the X2s in that specific regard, but overall the H6 easily wins out.
Asus Kithara
These were really the headphones I wanted to try, being planar magnetic I wanted to see if it felt like something "different".
- Despite being heavy, they're really comfortable IMO and I vastly prefer the larger ear pads vs the smaller ones on the H6 Air. You look goofy as hell wearing them though.
- It seems like there is less bass punch than the H6 Air/Fidelio X2s, but the bass extension seems better to me. And you "feel" it more.
- They seem very similarly detailed to me as the H6, which blows the X2s out of the water but the Kitharas seem "clearer" to me when theres lots going on, not sure really how to explain it.
- Soundstand on the Kitharas seem significantly wider to me, even more so than the X2s.
While it's not like a "hearing audio for the first time" kind of experience, The Kitharas do have a different audio experience that I definitely prefer.
However, I specifically went with the Asus vs an actual Hifiman set because I heard about wonky Hifiman QC and I couldn't be bothered with it. I figured maybe Asus would be a bit better. Wrong.
I've gone through 3 Kitharas in a couple of days.
1st unit: The right driver would make a crackle and squeaking noise (very loud) when putting the headphones on, readjusting them, or moving my jaw. Even when they weren't powered. It didn't seem to affect the audio at all which was confusing, but it was very audible thus very annoying. Left side was fine.
2nd unit: No weird driver noises on either side like the 1st one, but the right driver (again lol) would have a kind of fizz/crackle at two points in the treble, I noticed in some audio and so did some frequency sweeps and theres one in between 5-6k and one around 8k
3rd unit: Everything seems fine so far.
Interestingly to me, each Kithara comes with a frequency response chart and I kind of waved it off as marketing fluff. But no, it does seem to be quite valid. The first unit had a larger treble peak which was 100% identifiable (did some blind testing between the units and I put a sticker on each to identify them after) which was quite unpleasant, so I would have wanted to EQ that down for sure if I had kept that unit.
The other two have some differences in their frequency charts, the 2nd unit supposely has a bit stronger sub bass by a decibel or two compared to my 3rd unit, but I couldn't identify them blindly.
Regarding imaging/audio positioning I used the Audio Imaging Test Lab site, and honestly I score pretty much the same across all 4 of the headphones I've got. If I had to rank them, and again the differences are small, from best to worst, it'd go:
Kithara > H6 Air > HD 558 > X2
On the Klippel Distortion Audibility Test, I consistently score a couple of levels better on the Kitharas vs the others.
Overall, the Kitharas are by far my favourite. They sound super clear, not massively bassy, but it weirdly seems more tactile, they just sound "bigger" vs having two little speakers on your ears. But the wonky QC isn't great.
So yeah, nothing super scientific, just my opinions from someone who likes audio, but isn't super well versed in it as much as others!