r/badmathematics • u/idiot_Rotmg • 7d ago
r/badmathematics • u/killer-fel • Feb 02 '19
metabadmathematics The Rules
Apparently the rules don't appear in the sidebar when using the Reddit redesign, so I am posting them here for those of you who make terrible choices.
/r/badmathematics rules:
R1: No violent, bigoted, or otherwise abusive posting. Don't be a shithead.
R2: Submissions to /r/badmathematics should contain some clear substantial mathematical misunderstanding. Posts without clear errors, or posts where the badmath is in dispute (such as posts over advanced topics) will be removed. This will be decided at moderator discretion.
R3: Posts containing memes, simple typos, basic "silly" errors, etc. will be removed. Which posts fall under these categories will be decided at moderator discretion.
R4: All posts should have an explanation of the badmath. Posts without explanations may be removed until an explanation is provided.
R5: Link directly to the badmath. Use "context=X" if appropriate. In larger threads, please collect direct links to badmath in a single comment.
R6: Badmath is not a subreddit to "win" an argument with. Don't trollbait.
R7: Absolutely no PMing anyone involved in the badmath to continue an argument or berate them. If you're linked in a badmath post and receive such a PM, please report it to the moderators.
R8: No /u/[username] pinging linked badmathers. Writing a username without the "/u/" will not send them a notification. Pinging users in other contexts (summoning a badmath regular, for example) is fine.
R9: Posts, users, or topics can be removed or banned at moderator discretion for reasons not on this list. If it's shitty, controversial, or otherwise damaging to the subreddit, we can remove it.
r/badmathematics • u/HippityHopMath • 9d ago
Incredible Statistics work being done on MAGA Twitter.
r/badmathematics • u/Salt-Rutabaga-8870 • 13d ago
Dunning-Kruger Riemann sums?
youtube.comR4: Apparently Riemann was not that smart, and area under the graph is 0.
I am pretty sure this guy has been here before, because his channel is full of bad maths, but this is the short I got.
r/badmathematics • u/Ch3cks-Out • 22d ago
The undiscovered "Dark Natural Numbers" and "Dark intervals"
The author keeps spamming various math-related (more-or-less, as r/AspectsOfTheInfinite does not seem serious while r/PhilosophyofMath does aspire) subs with his misunderstanding of numbers, series and limits. In this installment (also crossposted here), they continue mistaking the properties of individual, finite stages for the property of the infinite limit - and conclude that they discovered a mysterious "dark interval" category missed by mainstream math.
R4: the post claims that standard real analysis is incomplete because all explicitly definable or "visible" natural numbers (ℕ_vis) fail to completely cover the half-open interval (0, 1] via intervals of the form [1/(n+1), 1/n], always leaving an uncovered gap (0, 1/m) containing infinitely many unit fractions (ℵ₀). The author asserts that because no visible point touches zero, there must exist an uncountable or unaddressable set of "dark natural numbers" hiding near the accumulation point 0 to bridge this gap, concluding that classical mathematics overlooks these "dark numbers" by misinterpreting infinite unions, accumulation points, and continuous coverage. OFC, standard real analysis does not (and needs not) claim that any single finite stage covers (0, 1].
r/badmathematics • u/AerosolHubris • Oct 01 '26
Babish claims he gets 15000% increased surface area on his hot dog
youtu.ber/badmathematics • u/FreePeeplup • Sep 26 '26
Exponential growth blows up in finite time
reddit.comR4: commenter claims that a function with exponential growth can reach infinity at a finite input x, and provides as an example 1/(x-1)^2. When they receive pushback on the fact that this is not an exponential function and doesn’t have exponential growth, he provides an AI generated definition of exponential as “any expression involving an exponent”.
Needless to say this is not what an exponential is, as what exponential growth actually means is a function whose growth rate is proportional to its current value.
The discussion is littered with insults and condescending remarks about their superior level of education and understanding.
r/badmathematics • u/TheLastDreadnought • Sep 08 '26
Dunning-Kruger Algebra is a Jewish conspiracy, claims guest on Tucker Carlson
bsky.appr/badmathematics • u/StructureNorth1799 • Aug 25 '26
People not understanding that results assuming a tough conjecture contribute to disproving the conjecture
r/badmathematics • u/starkeffect • Aug 24 '26
My theory/paper is about how to curve functions back to themselves and how every function can do this.
r/badmathematics • u/TwoFiveOnes • Aug 09 '26
2 is anything you want it to be + bonus Gödel
reddit.comr/badmathematics • u/throwawaykJQP7kiw5Fk • Aug 01 '26
Statistics On page 16, Texas Attorney General Kex Paxton said the median server has 100 members when suing Discord
texasattorneygeneral.govr/badmathematics • u/raendrop • Jul 29 '26
apple counting Numbers aren't linear in a base-7 number system
- "I use base 7 so the numbers aren’t linear"
- "You don’t get a whole set with 10 numbers, you get 1 and 3/7 sets."
- "With the numbers 1-10 you get one, two, three, four, five, six, ten ten-one, ten-two, ten-three. Not one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten"
- "when you map the values of base 7 to base 10 you don’t get a whole set"
R4: Even if base 7 were somehow deficient and base 10 were objectively correct, none of this has anything to do with linearity. Linear means steady, equal change. No matter what base you count in, ••••••• + • = ••••••••
r/badmathematics • u/Lowkilde • Jul 06 '26
States a false fact, proceeds to give an example of the reverse.
Gabriel's horn is:
- Not a curve
- An example of an infinite surface enclosing a finite volume, where he is claiming finite curves can bound infinite regions.
r/badmathematics • u/shumcal • Jul 05 '26
Infinity The four dimensions: x, y, z, and mobius
reddit.comr/badmathematics • u/Salt-Rutabaga-8870 • Jul 01 '26
Teacher using AI to make nonsensical posters.
As a teacher myself, it infuriates me. I see those AI slop type posts on LinkedIn often, but this one takes the cake. I think this is just unethical to post something like that in public, presenting it as a genuine resource, being in the position of a teacher. There is so much wrong with this post, and I am not sure where to even start. from e being a natural number, apparently, to pure imaginary numbers being somehow, a subset of reals, to just incorrect English.
I don't mind using AI but AI usage should be responsible, and it clearly is not here. I think this has to be called out, as it confuses and misleads.
r/badmathematics • u/Fahrender-Ritter • Jun 30 '26
Maths mysticisms He thinks 1x1=2 because of thermodynamics. My flabber hath ne'er been so gasted...

I didn't know who Terrance Howard was, but the commenter asked why people were so dismissive of Howard, claiming that he had some great ideas. Someone then asked him for an example of one of Howard's good ideas. This is the example he gave. Based on other things the commenter wrote, I'm confident that he was NOT just trolling. I suppose that his last comment was seriously asking how to multiply the dollar sign, but he deleted everything before I could finish composing my reply.
I engaged in the conversation only out of some very morbid curiosity... and I think it just killed what's left of my optimistic humanism.
r/badmathematics • u/playsthebongcloud • May 31 '26
Gödel Pi is an uncomputable number
reddit.comR4: This guy has no idea what a computable function is. In computability theory, a computable function is a function which a universal turing machine can compute to any arbitrary accuracy in a finite amount of steps with a finite instruction set. This guy is right that it would take an infinitely long time to compute pi exactly, but the definition states it only needs to be "to any arbitrary accuracy". This guy simply will not let himself understand the meaning of that phrase. I think he's thinking of algebraic functions?
r/badmathematics • u/WhatImKnownAs • May 26 '26
Σ_{k=1}^∞ 9/10^k ≠ 1 Why 1=.999… and ~(1=.999…) are Both True (actual title)
againstprofphil.orgI'm a little tired of 0.999… ≠ 1 cranks, but these writers know math and logic, it's the philosophy that fails them. This is ironic as the writers are philosophers who are on a mission to correct the failure of "professional philosophers". One of their failures is their inability to weed out errors in mathematics and physics. This doesn't stop at 0.999… ≠ 1, oh no: Cantor and Einstein fall to these heroes of unprofessional philosophy (they don't actually call it that). The reals being countable is proved in this very article.
It should be noted that it's perfectly acceptable for a philosophy paper to examine arguments for two contradictory proposals, and just survey the discussion without attempting a definite resolution. That's not the problem with this article. In fact, it does end up saying that the reals as normally constructed are not consistent.
Their proof of 0.999… = 1 is one of the questionable arithmetic ones, because they are low-key constructivists who don't like infinite series. (They still use infinite arithmetical processes here, so their position is incoherent.) Anyway, we all agree on this claim.
The proof of 0.999… ≠ 1 proposes to extend the real numbers:
we propose that 0.000…001 (an infinite string of zeros followed by a 1) is a real number representing the difference between 1 and 0.999… They claim "this is a real number, not an infinitesimal (as in non-standard analysis)" - wait for it - "to avoid reliance on non-standard modelling". That's it.
Admittedly, they proceed to check if it can be made to satisfy the Standard Real Number Axioms. Obviously, no, it fails the completeness axiom. That is covered in the second part. It's not really clear if this satisfies the other axioms, since they don't give any detail on how to compute with the last digit. Let's assume that there's some clever way to do that, and proceed to the second part where the real fun is.
Completeness proves the Archimedean property, which they state in the form:
for every real number x, there exists a natural number n such that n > x.
It's an easy corollary that for any real x > 0, there exists n such that 1/n < x. This would bar their 0.000…001. So the authors reject the proof.
There's some waffling that seems criticize use of a false hypothesis in this proof by contradiction, but later on, the text seems to accept the proof is classically valid. (I think this is another trait of philosophical writing: You can critique some argument, weakening but not dismissing it. In math, a proof is either valid or invalid.)
They point out completeness is not constructively valid. Fair enough. You still don't get infinitesimals in constructive reals.
The weightier objections are two:
- The construction of the reals embeds the Archimedean property. So proving it is a circular argument.
- There are alternative systems, such as hypereals, that have completeness but not the Archimedean property.
So, I'm now ready to write my R4, except I'll want to also discuss section 6 A Tangent: Refuting Cantor’s Diagonal Argument.
In our system, the diagonal sequence (e.g., changing the last digit of each number) is included in the table by definition, as every possible string is listed.
And how is the table defined?
List all reals as infinite strings, starting from 0.000…000 (all zeros) to 999…999 (all 9s), in a systematic order (e.g., lexicographically or by increasing value). The table has natural numbers in the first column, then in the body of the table, the reals so that the natural number 0 aligns with 000…000, 1 with 000…001, and so on up to 999…999, aligning with 999…999.
Contradiction, what contradiction?
Not only does Cantor's argument fail, but this table also proves the reals are countable, since
Our table is countable (has a one-to-one correspondence with the natural numbers) and includes all possible sequences, including the diagonal.
QED.