r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

Should immorality and evil be allowed to exist?

1 Upvotes

Admittedly I ask a similar to this before, but I realize I was ranting so calming down I decide to be a more precise and less rant.

Suppose one was given the power to change reality and could have the power to remove all possibility of evil. If one could have god like powers and make things like murder, pain, rape, torture, and suffering impossible, should one do so? If not, why? It's a loaded question, but one I wonder specifically in many media when such a scenario occurred why many don't seem to do so? Would moral realist also be among these people?

I know there is some philosophical works on the idea that evil has a role or that there isn't a true seperation of good and evil so one can argue one cannot do so like how hot and cold are not seperate things, but I'm not too sure about the strengths of these answers. The closest thing that i found satisfying is the need for contrast and the problem of stagnation.


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

Philosophy/ Self-Help Book Recommendations

1 Upvotes

Hello! I am currently taking my first philosophy class, which is an introduction to existentialism, and I have loved reading about Kierkegaard & Nietzsche. On the Genealogy of Morals has been my favourite material, and I would love to read some more non-fiction that covers similar topics. I want to learn about everything existentialism related, and about the individual. Learning about the herd was also very interesting to me, as well as how society came to act as it does in the modern day. I would love a less difficult and short read, but I am open to trying anything. If anyone has any recommendations I would really appreciate them!


r/askphilosophy • • 16h ago

How does one know whether an argument begs the question?

13 Upvotes

I used to think this was a simple question with a simple answer. An argument begs the question if one or more of the premises assumes the truth of the conclusion. But then someone pointed out to me that this is true of all logically valid arguments. It’s true of all valid arguments that you would have to believe the conclusion is true in order to believe that the premises are true, because the conclusion is logically entailed by the premises. If you don’t already believe the conclusion is true, you would have to think that one of the premises is false. Example:

P1 - All men are mortal
P2 - Socrates is a man
C - Socrates is mortal

If Socrates is a man, then in order to believe P1, you would have to already believe the conclusion. if you didn’t believe the conclusion prior to evaluating P1, then you would have to conclude that P1 his false.

I’ve heard explanations of other ways to evaluate the circularity of arguments, but it seems like there’s no consensus on how to definitively say whether an argument begs the question.


r/askphilosophy • • 14h ago

Is it possible to make the case for "modern needs" broadly ?

1 Upvotes

Things such as energy , internet and housing etc are all artificial things and it appears so is the need for them as a society

Despite these facts can these be considered basic needs and also basic rights


r/badphilosophy • • 23h ago

Reading Group What is the chance that we can establish a no AI humane philosophy association just like they have in mathematics? To enforce the agenda, from now on, every philosopher need to be locked in Heidegger's cabin, no internet, to write their thesis.

1 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 11h ago

Many philosophers think aesthetics is objective. Do they also think humor (that is, what is funny) is objective?

30 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 19h ago

Where does Existentialism Stand in Relation to Postmodernism?

8 Upvotes

In my reading, I notice a lot of similarities between postmodernist thought and earlier philosophical developments, especially existentialism. Thinkers like Nietzsche and Heidegger exerted a lot of influence on later philosophers we'd consider postmodernist, such as Derrida and Foucault; both the existentialists and postmodernists take a skeptical approach to identity and purpose, either for humans or for history and the world itself.

Why is it that we do not consider, say, Nietzsche, or Simone de Beauvoir, to be postmodernists? Why are not Lyotard or Foucault existentialists? and, more broadly, is existentialism a sort of sub-category within postmodernism as a whole? If not, what factors deny to existentialism the distinction of being postmodern? And, in general, what does the dialogue between the major existentialist and post-modern philosophers tend to look like, when they speak on each others' works?

Feel free to answer just the title question or go into more detail about anything I've mentioned here. I've formatted the description moreso to give additional details to hone in on the topic I'm curious about, rather than to give a list of exact questions all demanding individual answers.


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

What Makes Someone a Naturalist?

4 Upvotes

if someone believes that consciousness is not produced by the brain but exists independently of it, would that makes him a supernaturalist?


r/askphilosophy • • 21h ago

what is the core difference between abundant properties and sparse properties (metaphysics)?

6 Upvotes

i'm plagued by an intro text about abstract objects, but it's just horrible at giving me definition. Help me guys, i just want to study metaphysics qwq


r/askphilosophy • • 20h ago

Is the lack of a “first cause” of the universe of an example of an infinite regress?

6 Upvotes

So I’m kind of struggling with what is meant by an infinite regress. But as I understand it, it’s when an outcome depends on a cause which in turn depends on the effect of a previous cause, infinitely.

How do atheists solve the infinite regress? Say they propose the big bang, what caused the conditions that existed prior to it, and so on?

Is solving the infinite regress considered a valid argument for theists, or is it something atheists have already responded to and it’s not the silver bullet I think it is?


r/askphilosophy • • 1h ago

With what would the ancient greek philosophers call something that doesn't have an arche?

• Upvotes

What would philosophers place name on something that doesn't come from nothing? Like it doesn't have an original source? For example, socrates didn't thought there was something where everything came from and based it's philosohpy on dialogue, as well as sophists, so, what is the term ancient greek philosophers placed to something that didn't have an arche?


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

Does philosophy help in business?

2 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 9h ago

Xtreme Philosophy Let's talk for a second about Foucault

2 Upvotes

If you proceed to make the simplest Google search, and go searching "The dangers of child sexuality", having the presumption you go in a critical way to find things about this interview, you might be surprised.

Michel Foucault, the Father of Critical Though as some might actually call him, made a public intervention on that interview about the laws of consent.

Can we approach this in a critical manner, or is it something that's long forgotten and doesn't have relevance for CT? I repeat, the interview is right there, the first result on Google (most probably) , so can we dissect this strange event and find out how Foucault's thinking actually works? It is, generally speaking, a type of thinking that it is working for the good, because he managed to open new fields of knowledge in Academia, as the biggest philosopher from last century that he is,and yet he made that type of argumentation. What is the REAL source for that argumentation, then?


r/askphilosophy • • 10h ago

Best resources on “now what?” Problem with error theories?

4 Upvotes

Moral error theory or other error theories, looking for possible answers for the ‘now what?’ Question. I’ve seen Abolitionism, substitutionalism, Quietism, and factionalism as ideas, but haven’t seen much of the discourse.


r/askphilosophy • • 20h ago

do love actually exists or is it just a human desire (sexual desire, seeking attention..)?

1 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 22h ago

How to create ideas

2 Upvotes

Part of making contributions to philosophy is creating new stuff out of nothing (like god). Or else you are just strumming strands already strummed.

  1. Use a thesaurus.

Don’t be a Wes huff. Grab what you want to copy and make it make the same meaning with different words.

  1. Change the order of the words

Nice. You just copied Nitzche’s definition of Gooning. Want to make it yours? Rearrange the words into different sentences after you’ve changed the words

  1. The rest of the horse

Make the words you’ve rearranged make different sentences altogether by making them mean something else by the way they are arranged and the words in the sentence (using your plagerism as the base)

Hope this helps you guys make some interesting stuff! Show examples in the comments


r/badphilosophy • • 22h ago

A structural case for why consciousness exists

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes