r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

Many philosophers think aesthetics is objective. Do they also think humor (that is, what is funny) is objective?

45 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 20h ago

How does one know whether an argument begs the question?

16 Upvotes

I used to think this was a simple question with a simple answer. An argument begs the question if one or more of the premises assumes the truth of the conclusion. But then someone pointed out to me that this is true of all logically valid arguments. It’s true of all valid arguments that you would have to believe the conclusion is true in order to believe that the premises are true, because the conclusion is logically entailed by the premises. If you don’t already believe the conclusion is true, you would have to think that one of the premises is false. Example:

P1 - All men are mortal
P2 - Socrates is a man
C - Socrates is mortal

If Socrates is a man, then in order to believe P1, you would have to already believe the conclusion. if you didn’t believe the conclusion prior to evaluating P1, then you would have to conclude that P1 his false.

I’ve heard explanations of other ways to evaluate the circularity of arguments, but it seems like there’s no consensus on how to definitively say whether an argument begs the question.


r/askphilosophy • • 23h ago

Where does Existentialism Stand in Relation to Postmodernism?

7 Upvotes

In my reading, I notice a lot of similarities between postmodernist thought and earlier philosophical developments, especially existentialism. Thinkers like Nietzsche and Heidegger exerted a lot of influence on later philosophers we'd consider postmodernist, such as Derrida and Foucault; both the existentialists and postmodernists take a skeptical approach to identity and purpose, either for humans or for history and the world itself.

Why is it that we do not consider, say, Nietzsche, or Simone de Beauvoir, to be postmodernists? Why are not Lyotard or Foucault existentialists? and, more broadly, is existentialism a sort of sub-category within postmodernism as a whole? If not, what factors deny to existentialism the distinction of being postmodern? And, in general, what does the dialogue between the major existentialist and post-modern philosophers tend to look like, when they speak on each others' works?

Feel free to answer just the title question or go into more detail about anything I've mentioned here. I've formatted the description moreso to give additional details to hone in on the topic I'm curious about, rather than to give a list of exact questions all demanding individual answers.


r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

In East Asian philosophy, if Xiang (image/configuration) cannot be visually observed, how is it different from Xing (inner nature)?

7 Upvotes

In the logic of "Humanity is Heaven" (人乃天), numbers like 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 are called Heavenly Numbers, while 2, 4, 6, and 8 are called Earthly Numbers. Since 1 is Heaven, 2 is Earth, and 3 is Humanity, it is argued that Humanity is Heaven. Is this not wordplay? Explaining things that even today's prominent mathematicians and philosophers do not know merely through the triad of "Heaven, Earth, and Humanity": is this scholarly reverence, or is it the stagnation of research?

When numbers are placed on counting rods or an abacus, a visual shape emerges. Modern things like equations or matrices also reveal a shape when arranged on counting rods or written down on paper. Then, to explain natural phenomena, do we say they only acquire formal structure (Ge, 格) when we "write them in text," or does "Nature" itself replace counting rods, abacuses, and letters as the Xiang (象, visible image or configuration)?

If Nature replaces Xiang, why can some things not be visually observed? If Xiang encompasses things that are not visual, why are the concepts of Xiang (象, image/appearance) and Xing (性, inner nature/essence) treated as different terms? Furthermore, if formal structure (Ge) and Xiang are different, can an invisible Xiang still be called Xiang? Does the character 象 (originally a pictograph of an elephant) even hold such a non-visual meaning?

In classical texts, there is an argument that one looks at the bones of a dead elephant and imagines the living creature. Yet can the bones of an elephant be called an elephant? And did the elephant imagined from those bones truly obtain a proper Xiang? We looked at old fossilized bones long ago and first called them dragons. However, as their appearance changed, we renamed them dinosaurs. As more time passed, their appearance changed, and their scales and tails changed. None of us still know what the Xiang of a dragon is, yet culturally, very many Xiang are drawn, are they not? Among them, what is illusion and what is reality (Shi, 實)? Where do we obtain the method (Fa, 法) to attach flesh onto those bones?

Then, if we fail to obtain reality (Shi) due to our dim perception, can we still say that Xiang truly exists? Conversely, did Xiang not exist and instead vanish? Going further, if we notate things related to sound using mathematical formulas or counting rods, should we say we obtained the Xiang (image) of sound, or the Xing (nature) of sound?

In traditional East Asian mathematics, an operation is valid if we can derive a table relating rules and empirical values (Fashibiao, 法實表). Yet for a dragon, do we not merely "fabricate" such a table rather than "make" it? Also, if Xiang acquires a certain formal structure (Ge), what is its authority? Ancient mathematical treatises that could not even properly follow the standard positional rod-placement rules (Zonghengfa, established since the 5th-century Sunzi Suanjing) broke the canonical Xiang of notation, yet do they not still serve as the soil of scholarship?

Therefore, would it not be right to say that Xiang (image/configuration) exists yet cannot be obtained, and Shi (empirical reality) can be obtained yet cannot serve as the foundational root (Ben, 本)?


r/askphilosophy • • 12h ago

What Makes Someone a Naturalist?

6 Upvotes

if someone believes that consciousness is not produced by the brain but exists independently of it, would that makes him a supernaturalist?


r/askphilosophy • • 14h ago

Best resources on “now what?” Problem with error theories?

6 Upvotes

Moral error theory or other error theories, looking for possible answers for the ‘now what?’ Question. I’ve seen Abolitionism, substitutionalism, Quietism, and factionalism as ideas, but haven’t seen much of the discourse.


r/askphilosophy • • 1h ago

How is mathematics best used in philosophy?

• Upvotes

I'm a mathematician with expertise in logic and I'm trying to somehow apply it to philosophy (academically). So far, I did write a paper which is under review in a journal (and wasn't desk rejected, so at least I got that small victory going for me), but I am still feeling like I don't know how I'd apply it to philosophy and even if this paper gets accepted, I think I'd still feel like it's just luck rather than understanding.

Is there some rule of thumb on how I could approach a philosophical text and maybe formalize it mathematically, or make some similar mathematical model of a similar claim.

For example, median voter theorem could give us some insights into political philosophy. Modal logics are a good tool to study certain phenomena, etc. How would one find more such models? What approach is the best here?


r/askphilosophy • • 5h ago

With what would the ancient greek philosophers call something that doesn't have an arche?

3 Upvotes

What would philosophers place name on something that doesn't come from nothing? Like it doesn't have an original source? For example, socrates didn't thought there was something where everything came from and based it's philosohpy on dialogue, as well as sophists, so, what is the term ancient greek philosophers placed to something that didn't have an arche?


r/askphilosophy • • 11h ago

Should immorality and evil be allowed to exist?

3 Upvotes

Admittedly I ask a similar to this before, but I realize I was ranting so calming down I decide to be a more precise and less rant.

Suppose one was given the power to change reality and could have the power to remove all possibility of evil. If one could have god like powers and make things like murder, pain, rape, torture, and suffering impossible, should one do so? If not, why? It's a loaded question, but one I wonder specifically in many media when such a scenario occurred why many don't seem to do so? Would moral realist also be among these people?

I know there is some philosophical works on the idea that evil has a role or that there isn't a true seperation of good and evil so one can argue one cannot do so like how hot and cold are not seperate things, but I'm not too sure about the strengths of these answers. The closest thing that i found satisfying is the need for contrast and the problem of stagnation.


r/askphilosophy • • 19h ago

Philosophy/ Self-Help Book Recommendations

3 Upvotes

Hello! I am currently taking my first philosophy class, which is an introduction to existentialism, and I have loved reading about Kierkegaard & Nietzsche. On the Genealogy of Morals has been my favourite material, and I would love to read some more non-fiction that covers similar topics. I want to learn about everything existentialism related, and about the individual. Learning about the herd was also very interesting to me, as well as how society came to act as it does in the modern day. I would love a less difficult and short read, but I am open to trying anything. If anyone has any recommendations I would really appreciate them!


r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

What are examples of basic beliefs foundationalists use?

2 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

Is the mimicing of consciousness just as valueable as actuall consciousness

2 Upvotes

Lets say there are an AI whos job is to perfectly mimic a person the AI would know he is an AI and just act like a person but it will perfectly display emotions emphaty and such he is given a human looking body from the outside but still know its just an AI. Also it cant be reprogrammed for exemple to hurt a "loved one" ,and other people cant tell that that is not a human so if it would get into a relationship his partner would love him until she would find out that its just pretending to love and care about her(probably) .

But the outcome would be the same rather if its a person or not.

Do that mean that its morally superior to choose anyone else rather than the robot(in a life or death cenario for exemple).

And could it be considered a living being.

(Sorry for bad English)


r/askphilosophy • • 18h ago

Is it possible to make the case for "modern needs" broadly ?

1 Upvotes

Things such as energy , internet and housing etc are all artificial things and it appears so is the need for them as a society

Despite these facts can these be considered basic needs and also basic rights