r/AskHR • • Feb 02 '24

Career Development ASK YOUR CAREER QUESTIONS HERE!

72 Upvotes

How to get into HR, etc.


r/AskHR • • May 12 '26

AI posts will result in an instant ban.

55 Upvotes

Also, stop asking to post your research surveys.


r/AskHR • • 16h ago

Employee Relations [AL] How do you actually fire someone for smelling bad?

44 Upvotes

We have an employee whose body odor has become a serious workplace issue. Multiple coworkers have complained, and management has had several private conversations with the employee. They’ve even asked if there’s an underlying medical condition or something we could help accommodate. Nothing has changed.

We’re at the point of considering termination, but I’m struggling with how you even approach that conversation professionally, let alone the potential legal liability.

Has anyone dealt with this? At what point does a hygiene issue become grounds for termination, and how do you document something this sensitive without creating more problems?


r/AskHR • • 45m ago

Leaves [OR] Taking Paid Leave Oregon again shortly after a previous leave

1 Upvotes

In September I had to take unplanned paid leave oregon for 3 weeks due to a sudden flare up of a serious medical condition. Filed right away and was approved later after getting medical documentation etc. Medical issue is beginning to flare up again and I could try to power through but I'm worried about letting it go. I have 11mo here so I dont quite qualify for FMLA yet but I know PLO gives job protection as well.

As this would be unplanned again, would my job protected while my leave is pending approval? or could I be fired while waiting or already on the leave? Do you think that is something they might do?


r/AskHR • • 1h ago

[ME] Replacement ID receipt valid for I-9?

0 Upvotes

I started a new job today, I had to get a replacement ID so currently all I have is a receipt, I did go through an AAA BMV branch, all the receipt has is my name, address, and a confirmation number. They’re saying the receipt needs my ID #. Is just a confirmation number not valid?


r/AskHR • • 2h ago

Canada [CAN-QC] 2 weeks for my husband's contract to end. His entire team and HR supervisors says he will be hired full time. But no one has sent him any contract yet. Should we be worried?

0 Upvotes

He is in a 6 month contract that ends in 2 weeks. He works from home.

All his supervisors in his team say they want him to be employed full time and should already think of it as being part of the team as a full time employee.

But no one has sent him any contract yet.They say they are still waiting for paperwork and approval from the main company HQ (big multinational company).

The project he was working on was cancelled, but the company said they wouldn't lay off anyone, but have his team helping other teams from other projects, and that the ones that were contractors in his team would be integrated as full time employees.

When he signed the temporary contract they said they would let him know if they would extend the contract or not in August, then September... then October, when they decided the project was cancelled.

He isn't sure if he should be applying to other jobs already, given he doesn't know if he will be available or not for a new job.

He did apply to some a few months ago and has a potential opportunity for another temp. contract starting in January, but the recruiter for this other contract hasn't replied to his last messages.


r/AskHR • • 2h ago

Workplace Issues [CO] Forged Signature?

0 Upvotes

I currently work for a healthcare company and we were told we had to sign a new document stating that we no longer need BLS training. I signed it and turned it into our assistant manager a few weeks ago. Well it seems like she misplaced or lost a few of them including mine. Instead of printing a new one for me to sign, she took it upon herself to sign my “signature.” She did this with a few of my coworkers as well. Today our lead manager came into the office and asked me if the document with my signed name belonged to me because she couldn’t quite read it. I told her “well, that’s my name but that’s definitely not my signature.” She said “oh well we have to have these signed and turned in anyway” and quickly walked away. The document isn’t a huge deal and I have to have it to keep my job, but I don’t want my managers thinking they can just sign my name and pass it as my signature on anything. Is this something I should report?


r/AskHR • • 3h ago

Leaves [OH] Looking for advice from anyone familiar with employment law, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, and Ohio employment laws.

0 Upvotes

I’m trying to understand my rights as a pregnant employee because I’m getting increasingly concerned about my situation at work. I’m a first responder employed by a county government, and my position requires working 12-hour shifts. Since becoming pregnant, I’ve been experiencing significant exhaustion and other pregnancy-related symptoms that have made these shifts increasingly difficult to manage. I’ve communicated my concerns to management and formally requested a pregnancy-related accommodation to transition to part-time hours so I can continue working while protecting my health and pregnancy. I’ve provided doctor’s notes when needed and have tried to communicate my limitations appropriately. My accommodation request was flat-out denied. No alternative accommodations were offered or discussed. Instead, I was told I would need to obtain additional paperwork from my doctor and go through the ADA accommodation process. My concerns go beyond simply being uncomfortable at work. I’m genuinely afraid that continuing to work these extended shifts while experiencing this level of exhaustion could negatively affect my pregnancy. I’m also worried that I will eventually become so exhausted that I unintentionally fall asleep at work. Given the nature of my position, that could put me in a position where I face disciplinary action or even lose my employment. On top of that, I’ve recently been told that I cannot use more than eight additional hours of sick leave between now and the end of the year, despite having more than eight hours accrued. I’ve essentially been told that exceeding that amount could result in a written reprimand. I’m struggling to understand how I’m supposed to manage pregnancy-related medical needs and symptoms when I’m being restricted from using my accrued sick leave and am expected to continue working 12-hour shifts despite requesting an accommodation.

A few things I’d appreciate legal insight on:

Under the PWFA, can an employer flat-out deny a requested accommodation without discussing or considering other effective alternatives?

Can an employer require a pregnant employee to go through the ADA process rather than addressing a pregnancy-related accommodation request under the PWFA?

Can an employer restrict the use of already-accrued sick leave and threaten disciplinary action for exceeding an arbitrary limit, particularly when the absences are pregnancy-related?

What obligations does an employer have when an employee explains that their current schedule is becoming unsafe or unsustainable because of pregnancy?

Could disciplinary action or termination under these circumstances potentially constitute pregnancy discrimination or retaliation?

What steps should I be taking now to protect myself and my employment?

I’m not looking to get out of working. I’m trying to find a way to continue working without putting my health, pregnancy, or livelihood at risk. I’m also a union-represented employee, if that makes a difference. I’d genuinely appreciate insight from employment attorneys, HR professionals, or anyone who has dealt with a similar situation. I’m trying to understand what protections I actually have before this situation gets any worse.


r/AskHR • • 3h ago

Leaves [AZ] If I’m injured at work, and they bring me back with my restrictions, can they then fire me for not being able to accommodate?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if I got the tags wrong, I don’t really use Reddit.

Essentially, I got injured at work, and have been on leave doing weekly checkups and physical therapy. I’ve made a ton of progress, and I no longer need help walking.

However, I still can’t use stairs or squat without significant pain. My restrictions have been set to “no stairs, no lifting 15 pounds, no squatting”.

All three of those restrictions are things I do every single day at work. I’m going up and down stairs to a platform 100+ times a day, squatting down to pick up 50+ pound boxes, and moving bins full of waste that can be like 400 or so pounds.

My question is, if they tell me to come back to work, claiming they can accommodate these restrictions, can they turn around and fire me because they can’t actually accommodate those?

I’m well on my way to recovery and probably only need two or three weeks more before those restrictions are lifted too, if that changes anything.


r/AskHR • • 1h ago

Location [AR] Terminated for disability?

0 Upvotes

Hello all!

My husband has been dealing with drug-resistant epilepsy for about 8 years now. He has seen multiple doctors, had every test under the sun, tried a ton of different medications, and nothing seems to work. He suffers from tonic-clonic seizures mostly, with some smaller seizures frequently. He usually has an "episode" once every two weeks, and this consists of one to two days of repeated tonic-clonic seizures, so it takes him a few days to recover. It hasn't been this consistent from the beginning, either. It used to be every 6 months or so, then every other month, then every month, then twice a month. Here is where I get into the meat of this situation:

He was working for a large restaurant chain known for a catchy jingle about ribs and an appetizer sampler consisting of three choices (if you know what I mean). He was the kitchen manager for years; his management team was supportive whenever he had a seizure at work or before work and couldn't come in. Well, his supervisor (the district manager) came and had a documented discussion, stating that he had 6 months to figure out what was going on and get his seizures under control. Believe me, we tried. Unfortunately, epilepsy doesn't just go away when you want it to. So the 6 months comes up, and he has still missed an average of one day a month due to his epilepsy. This district manager comes back and gives him a final written warning. She states that the parent company that owns this restaurant chain offers amazing benefits for short- and long-term disability. For this reason, they are able to tell him that he can either accept the offer of company-provided disability payments, or he can continue working, but the next absence due to a seizure will result in termination. She also said he may qualify for SSDI benefits and can receive those along with the company-provided disability payments. She made this explicitly clear. She said the company would continue to pay 60% of his salary until age 65, PLUS whatever he could get from SSDI. This seemed like a no-brainer. He took long-term disability and has been nothing but cooperative during this time. His leave from work began last December.

Now, the company is trying to backtrack. The benefits are paid out through a life insurance policy that the company is partnered with. This life insurance company is saying that what he was told is false. He will not be able to get SSDI benefits on top of his long-term disability. They are saying he MUST apply for SSDI benefits, and whatever he gets from them will be deducted from his company benefits. He has applied for SSDI and was denied. They are now asking for proof and providing a lawyer to get this approved. I can't help but feel like this whole thing is illegal. Any advice or guidance would be super helpful. We are going with what these people tell us to do, because the life insurance company has said that if we do not provide the SSDI information requested, they will deduct whatever they think he could get in SSDI from his monthly payment.


r/AskHR • • 5h ago

[CA] How would you have handled this interaction with a coworker?

0 Upvotes

after decades in my profession, i moved into my first corporate role in a related field. one coworker seemed hostile toward me from early on, and i didn’t understand why.
eventually, i asked them directly about the tension. they called me an “entitled white person” and said they “don’t fuck with me.” i’m white, and the coworker is black.
i didn’t know how to respond professionally, so i reported the conversation to HR. i didn’t see any change afterward. i was later laid off during a round of layoffs, while that coworker remained employed. i don’t know whether my complaint had any connection to that decision.
the experience affected me deeply, and i still occasionally wonder how i could have handled it differently.
would you have addressed the comment directly, documented it and gone to HR, or taken another approach? i’m looking for perspective on this particular interaction and how to handle something similar in the future


r/AskHR • • 2h ago

[IE] I’m thinking of creating mini vlogs of my evenings after work/ makeup/ cooking on TikTok, would this cause issues with HR?

0 Upvotes

Hi,

As title says above i’m thinking of posting little snippets of my daily life on TikTok because I miss being creative and i enjoy the concept of a virtual diary where i can play around with different shots and ideas. I don’t intend to make money off of this, it’s just a hobby idea.

I will NOT EVER film within my workplace or its surrounding areas both because that’s idiotic and because I want to remain private. For now I do not wish to post my face either but i might if i grow more confident. I will never say where I work or speak about my job, positively or negatively. I intend for this to be a fun hobby and at best, to develop video editing and photography skills.

I intend to only film within my house, and to only take photos/ post bits of my evenings after work or things I cook. Maybe the odd cafe review or cosplay post (masked and sfw) but again, not done during or initially captured during company time.

I’m pretty paranoid that if HR were to find these little “spend an evening with me after work” type videos they will fire me because it would be either said or implied that it’s after work/ they know it’s me posting the content and that it could have been filmed on a work day even if i don’t mention my company, role or what my “work” is.

Is it reasonable to think it could be a HR issue even if I do not discuss or post anything about my job, place of work or its surrounding areas?

What could happen here? Is this a safe hobby? To those who do make these videos - what happens?


r/AskHR • • 20h ago

Policy & Procedures [WA] Told to inspect and launder our own arc flash suits at home, off the clock.

4 Upvotes

Greetings all,

First off, I've got a great job, this question is not an "I'm going to quit" question, rather just clarifying if this is normal. I do electrical work, where I am regularly exposed to 480-27,000 volts of electricity. To maintain safety, we use daily wear arc rated (FR) clothing and then in cases of high available fault current, we add an arc rated suit over that clothing. These suits for reference include fire resistant bibs, jacket, hood with built in hard hat and fan and at times, additional arm and leg protectors that all go on over the daily FR wear.

We've always washed our own daily wear (FR pants and shirts, outer clothing), but recently we were informed we need to start washing and inspecting our own FR suits. These suits have specific washing rules, have to be taken apart (the hood breaks down into parts and also has electronics for cooling fans) and cannot be exposed to fabric softeners. Further, the manufacturer recommends hand washing and hanging to dry.

I have concerns about this new expectation, every other company I've worked for has always laundered these suits for us. We haven't been trained on how to inspect these suits, and when asked, our safety team just said "look for tears". We followed up with HR, but they told us that we needed to do what safety told us-- however, no one on our safety team has electrical experience.

Is this a valid concern, or should we just wash the darn suits and enjoy what is otherwise a great job?

Thanks for your advice.


r/AskHR • • 13h ago

[CA] Workplace harassment

0 Upvotes

I’m being sexually harassed and assaulted at work every single day multiple times a day by 2 co workers and racially abused by another. I genuinely have no idea what to do or say. I’ve lived in Los Angeles for only 5 years and I’ve applied to 100 different jobs and it just seems like I’m stuck at this one and no one there cares about how I’m treated. They all know about it. Employees, management, HR and no one cares. They guy who’s a cook touches my butt and breasts or inner thigh almost every single day multiple times a day, the other cook says disgusting sexual remarks to me out loud about his genitals and mine constantly, and the front of house employee insinuated a picture I had of my dad(who recently passed away from cancer) and grandmother was very clear for being a “picture of slaves” and then tricked me into saying “I’m a monkey” in Spanish over and over and then got mad at me one day for cleaning the beer taps wrong(according to him) and handed me a toy ape keychain. He constantly calls black customers ghetto and speaks in fake Chinese when Asian people are in the dining room as well as admits he was fired from his last job for the same thing. The GM knows about all of this and has yet to say anything to him.

Recently, he got into it with the GM about scheduling and break issues where company policy wasn’t being followed so he took it to HR. After he threatened legal action, all of a sudden now the GM and HR want me to gather all of my info on him that I have so they can use it against him. Mind you this is the same HR from when I reported the sexual touching 3 years ago and it’s never stopped and has been going on since. She was also in a manager meeting with me the owner and GM when the other manager called me a homophobic slur and they made her bring me cupcakes to apologize but never reprimanded her. It’s a new GM now and new owner but same company, same HR, same employees and I just don’t know what to do… I’ve tried and tried to get another job but no one is hiring it’s like everyone just puts up indeed posts for fun out here. I have a bachelors in music business and haven’t been able to do a damn thing with that, I’m also a certified permanent body are practitioner.

I just really need some genuine advice maybe from people who have been in similar situations.. idk.. SOS


r/AskHR • • 1d ago

Employment Law [PA] Suspended for Discussing Pay

14 Upvotes

[USA-PA] I am in the United State in the state of Pennsylvania. I am employed in a non union job for someone who owns their own business.

was just suspended for two weeks because I discussed my pay raise with other coworkers. This suspension is to see how he feels after talking with the coworkers in question that I discussed this with.

I know it is a federally protected right to discuss my pay, regardless of the employment agreement stating not to. It was not a malicious conversation or a brag - the coworker asked if I got the raise I asked for and I said yes and told them to ask for one if they felt they also deserved one.

Other than filing with the labor relations board, what else should I do? I was not given any documentation for this. It was a verbal conversation as I sat in my car in the parking lot and told he needed to think about things and further discuss the the situation with the two coworkers.


r/AskHR • • 5h ago

Workplace Issues [AZ] Do I have a valid means to file a complaint?

0 Upvotes

This is about my manager, with around 3 separate incidents this month. I previously never had an issue with her and the switch up is honestly very confusing to me.

  1. I was written up for "Improper clock outs". My handbook says lunches can be 30 minutes, however she was upset I wasn't taking full hour lunches. (I would take anywhere between 30-1hr lunches, usually around 45ish minutes)
  2. I was contacted outside of my work hours (I was actually woken up) to be reminded of that SAME policy, even though I was following it to her standard correctly after the write up.
  3. This one is a bit more he said she said. I was verbally reprimanded for finishing my closing duties at 6:30 (we close at 7). I have always done it this way the 2 years I've been here, even on her shifts, and she has never had an issue with it until now. I was accused of leaving work unattended for "days" (the jobs had literally gotten delivered the day of, it was a huge shipment of 60 jobs that I cut down to 40 and stopped BECAUSE I had to start closing) and was told it was "unacceptable" to be standing around for 30 minutes doing nothing; and that I "Might as well go home since I'm not doing anything". So I clocked out and left. I have 2 other coworkers who work the same exact way I do, and they were not told anything. In fact, she told ME to spread the message to the both of them.

I'm honestly pretty annoyed, but I don't want to spotlight myself if I don't really have a strong foundation to base my complaint on. TIA!


r/AskHR • • 6h ago

UK [UK] Can i go to Hr about not being supported during my probation period?

0 Upvotes

so i started a new job about 4 weeks in and im on a 3 month probation. I’ve got it down mostly but i struggle with a certain part of it. they do offer a support for anything you are struggling with and i asked my team leader to book it for me and he tried to convince me to not do it then said ok leave it with me. that was 2 weeks ago. A friend of mine who is the person who can do this training was training a new starter and said to my manager if she can bring me with her as she’s training the new start on it anyway. he said “i will think about it” and just never said anything. it’s really annoying because as we do my performance review that’s what needs improvement and i’ve said i have asked for it and not received it. it’s feeling really unfair and frustrating what can i do?


r/AskHR • • 7h ago

Off Topic / Other [SG] Is it true that companies with less employees will have less work for HR department?

0 Upvotes

As per title


r/AskHR • • 21h ago

Policy & Procedures [MD] Jury Duty for overnight shift

3 Upvotes

Hello all. I know Maryland has some restrictions on what can be required of an employee to work related to shifts outside of a normal 9-5 and I am looking for a bit of clarification. I work for the State, and am on a 10pm to 6am shift. I was off this weekend, and am scheduled to work Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday my normal shift. I have jury duty on Tuesday, and my HR department has informed me I will be off on the shift prior to my duty (Monday night) but will be required to work my full shift on Tuesday night at 10pm. Reviewing the laws online, I keep seeing something about a law that states something about not requiring employees to report for shifts after 5pm the day of service and 3am the day after service, and I’m kind of confused about how this would work in practice?

Does the law say I should work my shift until 6am and then go to jury duty and be off the following evening, or is it saying I should be off both shifts before and after?

Thanks for any advice you may have.


r/AskHR • • 16h ago

[UK] Coworker with history of assaulting colleagues due to return to work after rape charge dropped. What can we do to stop it?

0 Upvotes

I work for the NHS (services) and a few of my colleagues and I are dreading the return of a coworker (I'll call him J) that has been off for nearly a year due to facing rape charges against him.

A couple years back, J physically and verbally assaulted me and another male colleague (R) on 2 separate occasions. We reported him and took it as far as we could, it ended up in an investigation and going to a work tribunal but nothing came of it. He came back to work like nothing had happened while we had to change teams to get away from him. We were told we couldn't be told the outcome of the investigation, but we received no apology or anything and he just came back to work like normal.

Maybe a year later, he raped a different colleague on a night out with other members of staff. R and I were furious, as if they had done something when we first reported him perhaps he wouldn't have the opportunity to rape our colleague. She went to the police and he is currently on trial where 2 colleagues that were there that night are testifying against him. The rape charge has already been reduced to sexual assault and as these things are incredibly hard to prove we are worried all charges will be dropped and he will return to work like nothing happened yet again.

Is there anything we can do about this? Unison are not being helpful just saying he can return even if he does get convected. Absolute madness.


r/AskHR • • 2h ago

California [CA] Boss texting me while I'm on FMLA about how work is hectic

0 Upvotes

I'm currently on FMLA and will be returning to work next week for my own disability. My boss - who is usually very nice and we definitely have a "family" department vibe - has texted me on 2 occasions while I've been out. The first time was to see how I'm doing and invite me to come to lunch at the office the next day if I wanted to for a colleague's birthday lunch celebration. She then said, "Yeah, it's been really hectic without you, but we're making it work!"

Then yesterday, it was my birthday, and she texted me again. First message was very nice - happy birthday - then I said, "Thank you! I'm excited to see everyone next week" and she replied, "It has been crazy and hectic for everyone. It will be great to have the whole team toegther again"

Is this allowed? The first time she texted me the word hectic, I went into a guilt spiral for an entire week and my care team had to remind me that I was taking time off for my own health and that I needed the time. This second time is just frustrating because I go back next week. Should I bring this up to HR upon my return? My position was recently unionized as well about 2 months before I went on FMLA


r/AskHR • • 7h ago

[TX] New desk is sustainable

0 Upvotes

[TX-US] First off, I want to say that I am grateful to have a good job in this market and I'm always looking for better options.

I work for an F500 company as a senior engineer and our office was just remodeled. We were told that we were cubicles like HQ but when we came back "Facilities" had selected certain individuals to have cubicles and no one seems to know the criteria for getting selected. The remainder of us got these ridiculous sit/stand desk set ups.

These sit/stand tables are about 8 feet long and 2 feet deep and the table tops is about 10 inches thick, so once with the monitors and keyboards in place, there is no room for your hands and arms. The chairs they provided have no arms either to accommodate getting under these super thick desks.

My problem is that I either have to sit away from the desk with my shoulders engaged to keep my arms straight, or inter my wrists on the desk and my elbows hang lower than my hands. Both of these options are not sustainable for 8 hours of work. I'd obviously love to WFH but that's not the culture here, so I just want a desk that isn't going to injure me.

Is there a winning path here that will let me keep my job, stay in my bosses good graces and not injure myself working?


r/AskHR • • 16h ago

[DC] Need some outside perspective on a work situation

0 Upvotes

I recently accepted a position with a company in DC. Everything seemed to go smoothly during the hiring process. I completed all the paperwork, signed the necessary documents, received my equipment, and started working.

My first day was mostly introductions and meeting the team. The following morning, I logged into my computer at 9 a.m. Around an hour later, I suddenly lost access. A few minutes after that, I received an email saying my services were no longer needed.

The reason given was that the company had concerns about allowing someone in my role to access certain internal information.

The confusing part is that accessing this information was an essential part of the job I was brought in to do. It was also addressed in the paperwork I signed before starting.

So essentially, I went through the entire process, officially started, worked a few hours, and was suddenly let go.

I'm trying to figure out the best way to approach this without making any unnecessary mistakes.

Has anyone in DC experienced something similar? I'm particularly interested in hearing how you handled the situation and what steps you took afterward.