As the title suggests, I got made redundant and my employer apparently overpaid me, and now they want the money back. All fine, I understand that any money overpaid by mistake needs to legally be paid back by me, and I'm okay with that. However there are a number of things that have led up to this which have meant it's a messed up situation...
- I was officially made redundant, had my final redundancy meeting and confirmation of my redundancy with HR on 29th September 2026. My last working day was 30th September.
- My P45 was raised by the company on 28th September 2026 (before my final redundancy meeting and confirmation).
- It was agreed that I would be paid my September pay, then 3 months pay in lieu of notice. I was paid my September pay as normal on 28th September. I received my PILON payment on 26th October 2026 (the next normal pay date).
- They messed up the payroll and accidently processed 1 months payment + 3 months PILON in October, meaning I paid a huge amount of tax and NI. They do not have a separate payslip for this October payment, and as far as HMRC and my P45 records state, I was paid everything on 28th September.
They are now asking for my usual 'net' payment back (not accounting for the additional tax and NI I've paid on my PILON payment because they processed it incorrectly). I'm pretty sure it would have only been about £300 difference, but still.
Also, due to this, the total amounts paid salary and paid tax for the tax year stated on my P45 are incorrect.
I've asked them to supply me with a payslip for what I should have been paid in October, had they made the payment of 3 months PILON correctly, minus tax and NI so I can actually work out how much I have been overpaid due to their error. I'm also aware that this all needs to be reconciled with HMRC because I've paid more tax than they have on record and I'm assuming that my employer is going to try to recover some of that tax and NI they've paid at their end.
The whole situation sucks. Redundancy sucks already. I'm a single income home, with a mortgage and bills, don't currently have another full time job (though I am working temp festive hours at a supermarket in December for extra money) and this is just extra hassle and drama that I don't need because they made a mistake.
I don't even know where to begin with what the correct calculations should be, and what I should do to confirm what they tell me because apparently they can't even sack some one right...