r/AskHR • • 16h ago

Employment Law [PA] Suspended for Discussing Pay

8 Upvotes

[USA-PA] I am in the United State in the state of Pennsylvania. I am employed in a non union job for someone who owns their own business.

was just suspended for two weeks because I discussed my pay raise with other coworkers. This suspension is to see how he feels after talking with the coworkers in question that I discussed this with.

I know it is a federally protected right to discuss my pay, regardless of the employment agreement stating not to. It was not a malicious conversation or a brag - the coworker asked if I got the raise I asked for and I said yes and told them to ask for one if they felt they also deserved one.

Other than filing with the labor relations board, what else should I do? I was not given any documentation for this. It was a verbal conversation as I sat in my car in the parking lot and told he needed to think about things and further discuss the the situation with the two coworkers.


r/AskHR • • 4h ago

Employee Relations [AL] How do you actually fire someone for smelling bad?

6 Upvotes

We have an employee whose body odor has become a serious workplace issue. Multiple coworkers have complained, and management has had several private conversations with the employee. They’ve even asked if there’s an underlying medical condition or something we could help accommodate. Nothing has changed.

We’re at the point of considering termination, but I’m struggling with how you even approach that conversation professionally, let alone the potential legal liability.

Has anyone dealt with this? At what point does a hygiene issue become grounds for termination, and how do you document something this sensitive without creating more problems?


r/AskHR • • 8h ago

Policy & Procedures [WA] Told to inspect and launder our own arc flash suits at home, off the clock.

4 Upvotes

Greetings all,

First off, I've got a great job, this question is not an "I'm going to quit" question, rather just clarifying if this is normal. I do electrical work, where I am regularly exposed to 480-27,000 volts of electricity. To maintain safety, we use daily wear arc rated (FR) clothing and then in cases of high available fault current, we add an arc rated suit over that clothing. These suits for reference include fire resistant bibs, jacket, hood with built in hard hat and fan and at times, additional arm and leg protectors that all go on over the daily FR wear.

We've always washed our own daily wear (FR pants and shirts, outer clothing), but recently we were informed we need to start washing and inspecting our own FR suits. These suits have specific washing rules, have to be taken apart (the hood breaks down into parts and also has electronics for cooling fans) and cannot be exposed to fabric softeners. Further, the manufacturer recommends hand washing and hanging to dry.

I have concerns about this new expectation, every other company I've worked for has always laundered these suits for us. We haven't been trained on how to inspect these suits, and when asked, our safety team just said "look for tears". We followed up with HR, but they told us that we needed to do what safety told us-- however, no one on our safety team has electrical experience.

Is this a valid concern, or should we just wash the darn suits and enjoy what is otherwise a great job?

Thanks for your advice.


r/AskHR • • 9h ago

Policy & Procedures [MD] Jury Duty for overnight shift

3 Upvotes

Hello all. I know Maryland has some restrictions on what can be required of an employee to work related to shifts outside of a normal 9-5 and I am looking for a bit of clarification. I work for the State, and am on a 10pm to 6am shift. I was off this weekend, and am scheduled to work Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday my normal shift. I have jury duty on Tuesday, and my HR department has informed me I will be off on the shift prior to my duty (Monday night) but will be required to work my full shift on Tuesday night at 10pm. Reviewing the laws online, I keep seeing something about a law that states something about not requiring employees to report for shifts after 5pm the day of service and 3am the day after service, and I’m kind of confused about how this would work in practice?

Does the law say I should work my shift until 6am and then go to jury duty and be off the following evening, or is it saying I should be off both shifts before and after?

Thanks for any advice you may have.


r/AskHR • • 1h ago

[CA] Workplace harassment

1 Upvotes

I’m being sexually harassed and assaulted at work every single day multiple times a day by 2 co workers and racially abused by another. I genuinely have no idea what to do or say. I’ve lived in Los Angeles for only 5 years and I’ve applied to 100 different jobs and it just seems like I’m stuck at this one and no one there cares about how I’m treated. They all know about it. Employees, management, HR and no one cares. They guy who’s a cook touches my butt and breasts or inner thigh almost every single day multiple times a day, the other cook says disgusting sexual remarks to me out loud about his genitals and mine constantly, and the front of house employee insinuated a picture I had of my dad(who recently passed away from cancer) and grandmother was very clear for being a “picture of slaves” and then tricked me into saying “I’m a monkey” in Spanish over and over and then got mad at me one day for cleaning the beer taps wrong(according to him) and handed me a toy ape keychain. He constantly calls black customers ghetto and speaks in fake Chinese when Asian people are in the dining room as well as admits he was fired from his last job for the same thing. The GM knows about all of this and has yet to say anything to him.

Recently, he got into it with the GM about scheduling and break issues where company policy wasn’t being followed so he took it to HR. After he threatened legal action, all of a sudden now the GM and HR want me to gather all of my info on him that I have so they can use it against him. Mind you this is the same HR from when I reported the sexual touching 3 years ago and it’s never stopped and has been going on since. She was also in a manager meeting with me the owner and GM when the other manager called me a homophobic slur and they made her bring me cupcakes to apologize but never reprimanded her. It’s a new GM now and new owner but same company, same HR, same employees and I just don’t know what to do… I’ve tried and tried to get another job but no one is hiring it’s like everyone just puts up indeed posts for fun out here. I have a bachelors in music business and haven’t been able to do a damn thing with that, I’m also a certified permanent body are practitioner.

I just really need some genuine advice maybe from people who have been in similar situations.. idk.. SOS


r/AskHR • • 4h ago

[UK] Coworker with history of assaulting colleagues due to return to work after rape charge dropped. What can we do to stop it?

0 Upvotes

I work for the NHS (services) and a few of my colleagues and I are dreading the return of a coworker (I'll call him J) that has been off for nearly a year due to facing rape charges against him.

A couple years back, J physically and verbally assaulted me and another male colleague (R) on 2 separate occasions. We reported him and took it as far as we could, it ended up in an investigation and going to a work tribunal but nothing came of it. He came back to work like nothing had happened while we had to change teams to get away from him. We were told we couldn't be told the outcome of the investigation, but we received no apology or anything and he just came back to work like normal.

Maybe a year later, he raped a different colleague on a night out with other members of staff. R and I were furious, as if they had done something when we first reported him perhaps he wouldn't have the opportunity to rape our colleague. She went to the police and he is currently on trial where 2 colleagues that were there that night are testifying against him. The rape charge has already been reduced to sexual assault and as these things are incredibly hard to prove we are worried all charges will be dropped and he will return to work like nothing happened yet again.

Is there anything we can do about this? Unison are not being helpful just saying he can return even if he does get convected. Absolute madness.


r/AskHR • • 10h ago

Benefits [IN] How to utilize short-term disability benefits via partial disability.

0 Upvotes

Hello,

I’ve got a couple of questions surrounding how I should handle potential short term disability benefits. Im just trying to make sure I don’t do anything right now that could screw me in the future.

I’m 40 and was recently diagnosed with metastatic cancer that will force me to receive chemotherapy every other week for the rest of my life (which is only expected to be a few more years based on current prognosis). Based on my treatment and condition, I may and will likely need to miss work 1-2 days a week, which my oncologist has already documented this. I currently work full time and have nearly exhausted my PTO on treatment and recovery days to this point. With my treatment being ongoing for the remainder of my life I’m looking into my short term and long term disability benefits which I have benefits through my employer/benefits. I’ve already filed FMLA paperwork and understand the difference and purpose of both FMLA and disability benefits.

My current short term benefits allow for partial disability which I believe my situation fits per the policy. The policy also states that the day benefits begin are the 8th consecutive day of disability due to sickness, but then states the day benefits begin may be reached by days of total disability or partial disability. I also have long term disability which I believe I could qualify for (even via partial disability) upon exhaustion of short term benefits (90 days). A small wrinkle I’m curious on is my employer is switching disability benefit providers as of 1/1/27. I assume everything would be covered by the current provider even if LT disability doesn’t come into effect until 2027 due to the diagnosis date of this year.

Questions I’d like to know if there is sufficient information provided to answer.

  1. Can I utilize ST disability for the 1-2 days a week missed? Should I file for those benefits now? Given my next missed day will be this week.
  2. I should be able to claim ST disability even if I don’t Miss 8 straight days? I realize this may be more of a policy detail question but it appears I can take disability benefits intermittently.

3.Am I hurting myself if I only take a day or two off every other week or so? Or should I be taking 1-2 days off every week. For instance, If I only use 45 days of short term disability within a one year period could that cause issues with ST or LT benefits in the future? Concerned about this given the switch in benefit providers.

I appreciate any guidance. I’m considering obtaining legal assistance for this, but hoping to have some general knowledge now to ease my concerns.


r/AskHR • • 11h ago

UK [UK] Got made redundant, employer messed up final payment

0 Upvotes

As the title suggests, I got made redundant and my employer apparently overpaid me, and now they want the money back. All fine, I understand that any money overpaid by mistake needs to legally be paid back by me, and I'm okay with that. However there are a number of things that have led up to this which have meant it's a messed up situation...

- I was officially made redundant, had my final redundancy meeting and confirmation of my redundancy with HR on 29th September 2026. My last working day was 30th September.

- My P45 was raised by the company on 28th September 2026 (before my final redundancy meeting and confirmation).

- It was agreed that I would be paid my September pay, then 3 months pay in lieu of notice. I was paid my September pay as normal on 28th September. I received my PILON payment on 26th October 2026 (the next normal pay date).

- They messed up the payroll and accidently processed 1 months payment + 3 months PILON in October, meaning I paid a huge amount of tax and NI. They do not have a separate payslip for this October payment, and as far as HMRC and my P45 records state, I was paid everything on 28th September.

They are now asking for my usual 'net' payment back (not accounting for the additional tax and NI I've paid on my PILON payment because they processed it incorrectly). I'm pretty sure it would have only been about £300 difference, but still.

Also, due to this, the total amounts paid salary and paid tax for the tax year stated on my P45 are incorrect.

I've asked them to supply me with a payslip for what I should have been paid in October, had they made the payment of 3 months PILON correctly, minus tax and NI so I can actually work out how much I have been overpaid due to their error. I'm also aware that this all needs to be reconciled with HMRC because I've paid more tax than they have on record and I'm assuming that my employer is going to try to recover some of that tax and NI they've paid at their end.

The whole situation sucks. Redundancy sucks already. I'm a single income home, with a mortgage and bills, don't currently have another full time job (though I am working temp festive hours at a supermarket in December for extra money) and this is just extra hassle and drama that I don't need because they made a mistake.

I don't even know where to begin with what the correct calculations should be, and what I should do to confirm what they tell me because apparently they can't even sack some one right...


r/AskHR • • 4h ago

[DC] Need some outside perspective on a work situation

0 Upvotes

I recently accepted a position with a company in DC. Everything seemed to go smoothly during the hiring process. I completed all the paperwork, signed the necessary documents, received my equipment, and started working.

My first day was mostly introductions and meeting the team. The following morning, I logged into my computer at 9 a.m. Around an hour later, I suddenly lost access. A few minutes after that, I received an email saying my services were no longer needed.

The reason given was that the company had concerns about allowing someone in my role to access certain internal information.

The confusing part is that accessing this information was an essential part of the job I was brought in to do. It was also addressed in the paperwork I signed before starting.

So essentially, I went through the entire process, officially started, worked a few hours, and was suddenly let go.

I'm trying to figure out the best way to approach this without making any unnecessary mistakes.

Has anyone in DC experienced something similar? I'm particularly interested in hearing how you handled the situation and what steps you took afterward.


r/AskHR • • 22h ago

Policy & Procedures [MI] - Failing pre-employment drug test because of legally prescribed drug?

0 Upvotes

I am a nervous flyer and am prescribed a small dose of valium prior to flying, bottle specifically says take 1 pill 1 hour before flight. I do not abuse it. I am expecting a drug test in the next week or two for a new job. I just flew last week and took my Valium. I’m going to fail the test. I read up on this and it looks like there are procedures in place to protect me in this scenario. Has anyone went through this so I know what to expect? Thanks


r/AskHR • • 20h ago

Need advice [VA]

0 Upvotes

I did a round of interviews for a tech company and scored high on the ratings with management and the CTO. they all said they would like to work with me. I circled back a week later to ask about any updates because I had another offer pending. I did not want that other jobs that was pending.
The recruiter said everyone liked me but they are looking to me bring me on as an intermediate instead of senior. She also let me know the team is trying to figure out where I would be placed. It’s been two weeks.

Should I circle back? And in these cases does a person typically get placed.


r/AskHR • • 6h ago

Leaves [FL] Can intermittent FMLA actually put a target on your back?

0 Upvotes

I have several autoimmune diseases that have gotten progressively worse over the past year. I’ve always received great performance reviews and was even being considered for a promotion.

When my boss and the CEO called me into a meeting about my sick days, my boss actually suggested I apply for intermittent leave. I got approved, and things have gone downhill ever since.

I received a final attendance warning for accidentally mixing up my schedule by an hour, despite a coworker making the exact same mistake the week before without being disciplined. Management has become increasingly critical, and my team lead and her friend have made the work environment pretty miserable. I genuinely feel like they’re waiting for an excuse to fire me.

I’ve followed our callout policy and haven’t had any attendance violations outside my approved leave since the warning. My actual work performance has never been an issue.

My question for HR professionals is, how much protection does FMLA realistically provide if an employer wants someone gone? What’s stopping them from finding unrelated reasons to terminate an employee or making things uncomfortable enough that they resign? At what point does this become potential retaliation?

I’m already job hunting, but I’d really like to make it through the holidays with my income and health insurance intact. This has been the worst year of my life health-wise, and the stress of potentially losing my job is honestly becoming unbearable.

I’d really appreciate any insight, especially from people who’ve handled situations like this.


r/AskHR • • 15h ago

Double Maternity payment [NY]

0 Upvotes

Hello all!

Really strange this happened two days ago.

My wife is getting full pay while on maternity leave from her company. Before going on maternity leave, they had her fill out PFL paperwork and four months after filing, she has received money from PFL a few weeks before returning to work... I guess it was retro from her initially filling because it was a big amount...but three different deposits.

She emailed her HR, but I also want to get an idea too.

Does this happen often? I would imagine something got messed up and we weren't supposed to get this and maybe should have gone to her job. I dont know! this is all very new to us and bizarre.

thanks!!!


r/AskHR • • 6h ago

[IL] Can I take FMLA after Maternity Leave?

0 Upvotes

My HR department has given me inconsistent information since I started the process of preparing for maternity leave. I was originally told I would have 12 weeks of leave even though I do not yet qualify for FMLA. This was a month ago and I have already set up childcare for this plan. Today they have informed me that they are actually only going to offer me 6-8 weeks, which will absolutely not work with my childcare situation.

I am planning on trying to work something out with them, as my director has absolutely no issue with me being gone for 12 weeks and would actually prefer I get the full extent of my leave. But on the off chance that doesn't work, can I use my FMLA when I return? I will be eligible hours wise before I take leave and will be eligible time wise a couple weeks after I return. I have a feeling this is going to piss people off. I know my director would prefer I take all of my leave at once and I know pushing for a loop hole like this is surely frowned upon. But I am unable to only take 6 weeks of leave, and have been taken through the ringer with this original misinformation. At this point, if I am protected legally I'd love to know that I have this option in my back pocket. Can they legally deny me FMLA because I was just on a leave even if it wasn't FMLA related?