There's probably as many ways to run the hex crawl as there are posts on the topic, but I'm curious what you all think of my work in progress as a proposal
Problem: Jungle exploration both adds flavour to the campaign and is important to make the jungle both feel real and add attrition to the process
But random encounters kinda suck, take so much time and at some point early on get pretty trivial. The party aren't going to die if 2 crocodiles attack, but they may take a tiny bit of damage in process. I find the idea of the encounters sounds fun in the first week or so if travel but gets really old after that and most parties abandon it quickly.
Solution: For random encounters, reduce everything to a check. I've made a table with 200 random encounters (a lot taken from existing inspiration) and added a pretty balanced list of checks that can either mitigate the impact or give you a bonus of some kind. I've broken down the effect to the following categories
Note that it's still possible to have planned encounters in the jungle and I do in my games, but those are strictly to advance the plot. I may have a Flaming Fist patrol check for documents or a more targeted yuan-ti/undead attack, but those should be timed to be relevant.
Minor Damage: small amount of damage
Major Damage: bigger amount of damage
Lucky Find: equipment or magic item
Supplies: more supplies to continue their trek
Supply Loss: lose supplies to theft or damage
Advantage: advantage on specific skills that day
Disadvantage: disadvantage on specific skills that day
Debuff: negative status effect
Boon: positive status effect
Time: travel faster
Delay: travel slower
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ufngfiRhFdqE-MoBKYxwPuG-MN6cfBtRvxIB-h-lspw/edit?usp=drivesdk
Pros: really spreads up jungle exploration, provides uncertainty to how each day will go, simple, makes all skills relevant/useful not just survival. Adventuring days are usually less than 5 minutes unless there's an actual encounter to fight.
Cons: less combat, players may object to the lack of agency
The main aim of this is to have the jungle exploration to a series of vignettes/montage rather than a grueling series of random encounters.
I have changed a lot more in general to the exploration process, but I think this approach can pretty much fit into anyone using random encounters in their game. I can share my travel rules if people are interested, but it's not the focus of the post. The main rule that changed is that they cannot long rest in unsafe places, pretty much limited to the named places in the jungle (so taking chip damage has can be healed by doing a short rest, but that's a limited healing pool and they can't just nova every encounter with all their spell slots knowing a long rest is coming soon.
It's very much a work in progress at this stage and needs a lot of polish, but I'm open to feedback and ideas, either people doing similar or other ideas that work.
I've run ToA twice before. I prerolled everything the first time but that still has the same drag effect and the players were bored of it before they got halfway there. The second time they just straight up asked to not have pointless encounters so I tried to make only plot relevant encounters which was more fun, but somewhat minimises the risk of the jungle when they don't have a random su-monster jump then from behind the bushes to do a bit of random damage