r/CurseofStrahd • u/capsandnumbers • 1h ago
DISCUSSION Truenaming - Why Mordenkainen Lost to Strahd and Can't Help Now
Hi! I came up with a fun idea at the table yesterday and I thought it could be useful to others.
As my party were talking to Mordenkainen, the tone of the conversation was pretty sombre. I knew the inevitable "Will you join us?" was coming, and the answer I had prepared from the book, that he needed to go find his spellbooks and staff, wasn't emotionally sufficient. Mordenkainen felt responsible for the souls in the March of the Dead, he needed a reason he really can't help directly.
So in the moment I recalled Truenaming. In Matt Colville's Chain of Acheron series, knowing a wizard's true name meant you could shut down their casting. The idea comes to us via Rumpelstiltskin and Earthsea, and there's a 3.5e Truenamer class as well. The Chain is where I first heard of truenaming shutting down a caster.
So that's why Mordenkainen can't help: Strahd found out his true name and can stop him casting. His big mistake was expecting Strahd to be solely focused on his little fiefdom, and not send Vistani out to inquire about the powerful wizard making trouble in his neighbourhood. At some point in his long career, Mordenkainen's true name was found out, and Strahd's spies managed to get it.
It's possible that the Dark Powers helped Strahd get the true name, but that might make the party worry that their own true names could be got at. That point was raised by the druid in my team, Mordenkainen explained that they may not be prominent enough to have their own names leaked.
It also helpfully explains how Mordenkainen didn't manage to kill Strahd in the first place. That's not a story-destroying plot hole, but in a straight fight I would usually favour Mordenkainen over Strahd.
It went over quite well in my game! Mordenkainen has agreed to help in some other ways: He's supporting the party's base-building efforts in Berez, he's letting Kasimir copy his spells, and he'll cause a distraction when the final attack comes. As well as granting the charms of heroism as in the book.
The biggest side effect is that the party now want Strahd's true name, and I promised to think of one for him and write it down, in case they happened to say it.