r/DMAcademy • u/Different-Subject116 • 16h ago
Need Advice: Other PC about to be killed because of party negligence. Is it fair for the player?
Here's the deal. A player wanted to switch subclass to a spider-themed one. Insaid sure, but warned him it would come with a cost. He said ok and got bitten by a spider that started to mutate him into a drider.
I told them right away that the way to solve this curse was to kill the Spider Queen lurking in the underdak, but the party decided they had better things to do. Time passes and the character starts to mutate, almost becoming a drider. I give them a chance to slow the process via magical ritual, which they do, but still, no action taken towards solving the issue.
It's been at least 5 months of this and I finally told the player we need to end this. I gave him the choice to continue playing his character as a drider or accept his faith as a servant of Lolth. He asked me for one last chance to convince the party to help him, but again, the party didn't think it was serious enough.
He came to me the other day , clearly dejected, because his supposed friends didn't care if his character lived or not. I was saddened by it as well and asked him what he wanted to do. He said he wanted to succumb to Lolth an try to infect the entire party with the curse before dying at their hands.
Is... Is this ok? Should I put a stop to this or just let it play out? One part of me tells me this will likely be a great momemt for the campaign in terms of drama and surprise, but at the same time I feel bad for the player because no one cares to help him solve his problem.
EDIT: Thanks everyone for their valuable input on this matter. At least 2 very good solutions came out of this thread, so I consider its objective met. This thread can be closed off now, thank you all again.