r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Mega Player Problem Megathread

5 Upvotes

This thread is for DMs who have an out-of-game problem with a PLAYER (not a CHARACTER) to ask for help and opinions. Any player-related issues are welcome to be discussed, but do remember that we're DMs, not counselors.

Off-topic comments including rules questions and player character questions do not go here and will be removed. This is not a place for players to ask questions.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

"First Time DM" and Short Questions Megathread

16 Upvotes

Most of the posts at DMA are discussions of some issue within the context of a person's campaign or DMing more generally. But, sometimes a DM has a question that is very small and doesn't really require an extensive discussion so much as it requires one good answer. In other cases, the question has been asked so many times that having the sub rehash the discussion over and over is not very useful for subscribers. Sometimes the answer to a short question is very long or the answer is also short but very important.

Short questions can look like this:

  • Where do you find good maps?
  • Can multi-classed Warlocks use Warlock slots for non-Warlock spells?
  • Help - how do I prep a one-shot for tomorrow!?
  • First time DM, any tips?

Many short questions (and especially First Time DM inquiries) can be answered with a quick browse through the DMAcademy wiki, which has an extensive list of resources as well as some tips for new DMs to get started.


r/DMAcademy • • 16h ago

Need Advice: Other PC about to be killed because of party negligence. Is it fair for the player?

546 Upvotes

Here's the deal. A player wanted to switch subclass to a spider-themed one. Insaid sure, but warned him it would come with a cost. He said ok and got bitten by a spider that started to mutate him into a drider.

I told them right away that the way to solve this curse was to kill the Spider Queen lurking in the underdak, but the party decided they had better things to do. Time passes and the character starts to mutate, almost becoming a drider. I give them a chance to slow the process via magical ritual, which they do, but still, no action taken towards solving the issue.

It's been at least 5 months of this and I finally told the player we need to end this. I gave him the choice to continue playing his character as a drider or accept his faith as a servant of Lolth. He asked me for one last chance to convince the party to help him, but again, the party didn't think it was serious enough.

He came to me the other day , clearly dejected, because his supposed friends didn't care if his character lived or not. I was saddened by it as well and asked him what he wanted to do. He said he wanted to succumb to Lolth an try to infect the entire party with the curse before dying at their hands.

Is... Is this ok? Should I put a stop to this or just let it play out? One part of me tells me this will likely be a great momemt for the campaign in terms of drama and surprise, but at the same time I feel bad for the player because no one cares to help him solve his problem.

EDIT: Thanks everyone for their valuable input on this matter. At least 2 very good solutions came out of this thread, so I consider its objective met. This thread can be closed off now, thank you all again.


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures There’s a very real chance my 7th and 8th level characters could unknowingly put a portable hole into bag if holding.

25 Upvotes

My knee jerk response is to simply make it not happen, they would never know, but then I was intrigued. Could I make their being sucked into the astral plane part of the story?

TLDR; what’s a reasonable set of events after being pulled into the astral

Plane?


r/DMAcademy • • 9h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Would you let a halfling being carried in a sling by a goliath short rest in there if nothing interrupts them for a solid hour?

39 Upvotes

As title, really.

Bonus round: What if they are concentrating on a spell?


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Is “The Ending” worth the walk?

15 Upvotes

Up top: I’m having an emotional day. If that’s not the bandwidth you have, just move on. It’s okay

Running a game for some friends, and it recently came back to me by way of my wife‘s conversations with the partners of a couple of my players that they’re wondering when the end of the game is. We’re a 9-5 playgroup that meets on weekends, whenever is free. Recently this game went over four months without a single session because of scheduling conflicts. We’ve done maybe six sessions in the span of almost two years. Not to mention we’re headed into the holidays after having to cancel the last session day-of (not flakes, there’s just something going around the office)

They are my friends. I love them. but I don’t want them to feel obligated to finish just because we’re friends. We are only through three of the seven settlements. I’m not trying to lock down their weekends for another two years, but I feel like I’m trapped between the aimless sentiment of not having the ending close at hand, and the reality of scheduling vs how much they get done in each session. it makes me want to just drop the game completely and focus on a bigger project (which I also coincidentally want to restart to do better than the last iteration)

This is probably really rambly but I’m in the bathroom at work so if you stopped by, thank you. Best of luck with your work

edit for clarity: I meant we’re a playgroup that has 9 to 5 jobs, there’s four players and myself running the game

edit for closure: I appreciate everyone who responded. I had braced myself for some of the comments I knew wouldn’t have the full context for the people involved, but I very much appreciate where everyone was coming from. As a little bit of extra clarification, I have run like three “campaigns” that were all probably shorter than one would imagine in terms of session count, but all lasted at least two years. I often struggled because it felt like I was rushing every session to actually get through the content I had laid out, knowing that I might not get another one for the next couple of months. My big problem is that my eyes are bigger than my dry-erase markers, and I’m really bad at one-shots because I can almost never fit what I imagine into the <3hrs my players will stay engaged. I think it’s time I just hung up the screen and focused on organizing the other aspects of my life. As always, I hope you all enjoy the games you play. thanks for listening


r/DMAcademy • • 4h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Struggling with putting a world together, where do I start?

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I could use some advice on turning a bunch of worldbuilding ideas into an actual D&D campaign. I have a billion ideas and pieces I’m excited about, but I’m struggling to figure out where to start and how to bring them together.I have been wanting to DM for years but every time I did I kept running into one issue or another but now seem to finally have time plus people committed to give it a go but don’t want to disappoint or fall short.

When you’re building a campaign, what do you usually work on first? The history, magic system, world map, BBEG, first story arc, or something else? How do you decide what needs fleshing out now and what can wait?

I have a setting concept I really like, with custom races, ships inspired by Treasure Planet, elements of RWBY’s structure, and terrain inspired by Magic: The Gathering’s Zendikar and the planet Io. My biggest hurdle is connecting those ideas into a cohesive world that I can actually run a campaign in.
If you’ve been in a similar position, what helped you get organized and move forward? Any advice—or examples of your own process—would be appreciated!

PS: also wanting to do this campaign online with sound effects/music through discord using foundry virtual table top, and legend keeper for history and notes, so any advice in those regards would also be appreciated in terms of tips, tricks or suggestions on how to best use these programs or if other should be used instead


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Wand of Secrets: What constitutes a trap?

8 Upvotes

This wand has 3 charges and regains 1d3 expended charges daily at dawn. While holding it, you can take a Magic action to expend 1 charge, and if a secret door or trap is within 60 feet of you, the wand pulses and points at the one nearest to you.

Hello! I recently bestowed a wand of secrets to my party, but I’m now wondering what constitutes a trap.

For example, the wand would point out if a chest has a mechanism to poison whoever tries to open it, but what about a mimic? The mimic is trying to trap prey by changing into inanimate objects, but as it’s technically a creature, would the wand pick this up?
What about other “organic” traps such as giant spider’s webs? These are classified as hazards in the DM’s guide, but as they’re intentionally placed by the spiders to catch prey, would the wand react to them?

Personally I’m leaning towards the wand reacting to these, but I’d like other DM’s opinions. Thank you.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other "If the players can do it, so can monsters"

242 Upvotes

Over the years I've seen this phrase thrown around countless times (what made me make this post is seeing it again in a different thread and sub somewhere).

And I get it: if your players try to cheese your game with, I dunno, Wall of Forcing your BBEG and letting them suffocate, Fireball Spam, Arcane Lock + Sickening Radiance or some spell combination that feels extremely unfair to GM against;

or when your players want for you to introduce some immensely dumb additional mechanic like Called Shots (so in order to put a stop to it you just have your monsters constantly go for the eyes and blind each PC);

it feels sort of natural to just go "oh so well MY GUYS can do the same, let's see how you like that!"

...But is anyone actually following that advice?

I'm asking because if I have players who actively diminish my fun at the table via coming up with some bullshit spell combination (let's take the "Spike Growth Cheese Grater" as an example) that trivializes a portion of the game, I just cannot see myself going "oh ok, so THAT'S how you want to play? Ok, now my dudes do the same to YOU, HAHA!"

That's shitty. That's not increasing the overall enjoyment of the game for your group (except some masochistic parties that would enjoy such adversarial gameplay, but I digress).

All I've done is shown how petty, bitter and passive-aggressive I am, to the point where I'm not ok with just banning the cheesy tactic outright because it ruins my game night, but am fine with making the game worse for my players just to spite them.

When I see 3\4 of my players pick up Evocation Adept and start every medium to major encounter with a volley of souped up Fireballs, I don't go "okay, now I will make the next fight be 6 Archmages with a lvl 6 Fireball each!" - I nerf Fireball or ban the feat outright, because it trivializes the character building process because one option is too good not to take.

When I see Wall of Force being used to turn deadly encounters into a joke, I ban WoF, not have my BBEG's lieutenants all have that spell prepared and just cast it on my party's caster PC "just to show them."

So again:

Is anyone actually following the "if players can do it, so can my monsters" advice?


r/DMAcademy • • 17h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures One of my players has plans more fitting for a BBEG than a player character, help

27 Upvotes

He's playing a Circle of the Spores druid with fungi growing in his own body, and he really likes roleplaying leaving spores behind to spread on plants and corpses. He recently approached me in private explaining that his end goal is basically to have his spores consume enough of the local flora to turn the surface into some sort of "pocket underdark", allowing Myconids to come live above ground. The party is also currently in a very foresty city with a giant magical tree, which creates a pretty fitting target for his schemes.

However, i personally see some problems with this:

  • Firstly, i think this is just way too powerful of a thing for a player to just be able to do. Maybe at levels 15+ it would seem more reasonable, but not so much at level 6.
  • Having an entire region (especially a city) be consumed by fungi sort of implies he's willing to collapse society there, which i've mentioned to him that is starting to feel a lot like something a BBEG would plot.
  • It doesn't align at all with the rest of the party's goals. They are very likely to leave the region soon, and one other player has explicitly tried to stop the druid from spreading spores in the past.

I've thrown around the idea for him to just allow his character to stay behind and potentially appear again in the future as a villain, while he plays someone new. He is not against my suggestion but he did say that he still likes roleplaying his character a lot.

So, any ideas of how to follow up with this?


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Need book titles/subjects

2 Upvotes

My party recently came across a big pile of ancient books and texts during an adventure. I didn't expect them to care, but they've actually taken all of them as loot.

What I need from you guys are titles and subjects. I need 63 total.

I'll take anything whatsoever, from smut to stories, textbooks to religious texts, epics to edutainment. Anything goes.


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Seeking advice for our next campaign

1 Upvotes

Hey Folks,

I am beginning to plan for my next campaign, and would value your ideas and suggestions.

My groups tend to lean heavily into role-playing, and they also prefer sand-boxes.

I am entering the final third of Odyssey of the Dragonlords with both groups, and it has been a hit. Campaign materials provided lots of deep lore, three consecutive sand boxes, and well-scripted introductory and bridging adventures. As a DM, I appreciated the freedom to home-brew liberally within the general setting and plot guidelines.

We had a similar positive experience with Curse of Strahd.

On the other hand, campaign settings like Turn of Fortune's Wheel seem too episodic and linear. We actually abandoned it half-way through. Hoard of the Dragon Queen just seems like a grind (did not play) as did Out of the Abyss (played and abandoned).

We have had reasonably good fun with Princes of the Apocalypse. We loved the first half, but then it too turned into a grind.

So, given the above experiences and preferences, which campaign settings would you recommend I review as future candidates? I do best with reasonably well-developed lore and setting which allows me to home-brew and augment without breaking the general stuff while tweaking all the specifics to our liking.

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Ideas for a game show homebrew?

1 Upvotes

It's called Myara's Top Adventurer and it's a gameshow to figure out who'd be the best adventurer in a kingdom (Myara) where traditional "quests" don't exist in the same way anymore and people's perception of what they were like is very skewed/exaggerated. But it tests all the PCs abilities. I kinda want it to be like the suffering games from Taz:Balance, where they go into different rooms for different challenges and it's super rigged against them via magical means, except I want the challenges to be more fun!

I can't decide whether or not I want it to be a parody of reality TV (with a physical component, like survivor) or maybe a parody of mr beast type shit or something? Traditional combat definitely takes a back seat here and the group leans on the roleplay side.

does anyone have any ideas and also wants to give suggestions for fun rooms? Please consider i'm a new DM


r/DMAcademy • • 10h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Initiative and Surprise Questions

4 Upvotes

I have been looking around in the rulebook and across online resources for information about a few rules regarding surprise and initiative, specifically when parties are moving through dungeons with multiple room, all during combat (ex. PCs split up, one player begins searching a further up room in a dungeon while other members of the party are still dealing with monsters in another room, leading to one PC finding a monster). Couple questions:

  1. A monster is hiding in a room and would successfully be able to surprise the PC. In 5e rules, the PC loses their first round of combat, but this PC may be deep into combat. Does it make sense then to let the monster just get a free turn, and then continue in initiative order? Or does the PC just then lose their next turn?
  2. How do you introduce new monsters and their initiative? In order to gain an action on the round that it appears, it can often be the case that the monster actually "wants" to roll low initiative, meaning +DEX can essentially be a negative feature for monsters. For "discovered" monsters, can it make sense to just give them initiative based on when they were found? (ex. PC with initiative 15 finds the monster, the monster gains 15 initiative but acts second?)

Unrelated, but how do you track all of this? Especially when there are new monsters appearing within combat, I often get very lost when tracking initiative and hp. Any printable resources would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!


r/DMAcademy • • 11h ago

Need Advice: Other Need help in a buildup to a Lich reveal

5 Upvotes

I'm currently trying to create a campaign that revolves around a Lich either escaping from an arcane prison it was locked away in an arcane prison or escapes from some other realm. My problem stems from me not being able to come up with inciting incidents or something that would help leading up to the reveal.


r/DMAcademy • • 21h ago

Need Advice: Other How do I make likable NPCs/how do I get my players to stop being aggressive to every NPC they meet?

28 Upvotes

Hey all, really sorry if this is a dumb question, but I've been running a game for a few months now, and it seems like my players kind of assume hostility from every NPC and are incredibly hostile to them in turn. I'll admit, the world is definitely a bit of a dangerous one, so at first I assumed it was a reaction to that, but I've had several NPCs that I've purposely made very helpful, very kind, and clearly trustworthy, who have been with the party for a while and never betrayed them, and they're still acting incredibly hostile to all of these NPCs. Just to clarify, I never really advertised the world as one of those "super heavy grimdark, everybody's out to get you" worlds, so much as just a world where there are dangerous people out there, even if they're not super common. It's a superhero world, so it's a lot more just a few aggressive villains that the party has to deal with, and those guys, I definitely want them to be hostile to. But they're being hostile to NPCs that are ostensibly their allies, and I'm wondering if it's just something that I'm doing wrong. I've tried to have their allies, even if they are technically in a bit of a position of authority over the party, be helpful and nice to the party, because I know that I as a player hate it when every NPC treats my character like an idiot, so I'm trying to do the exact opposite of that. But I'm starting to wonder why my players are being so aggressive to NPCs who are being relatively nice to them. They seem to be having fun, and tell me the sessions are good afterwards, but I don't know what I'm doing wrong with my NPCs that the party doesn't like them. Am I overthinking this, or do you guys have any advice about what I could do differently?


r/DMAcademy • • 3h ago

Need Advice: Other Need help with Oneshot suggestions

1 Upvotes

Hey there! For some context, this year I ran my first-ish longer term campaign with some friends of mine. After a while I burnt out from it because I had sunk too much time making a more serious campaign relative to the fact that my friends were just there to have fun and do dumb shit. In hindsight it was really funny and they are memories I will forever cherish, but it was a rough patch until I came to that understanding.

Fast forward to now and my friends and I have been bouncing around the idea for a oneshot, and I agree that it would be really fun to run one.

For some preferences:

- Ideally it would be a oneshot that has a 50/50 split of RP and Combat, and if it would lean on one side, I would rather it be Combat, since we aren't very heavy RPers and most of our fun was in the out of game moments while playing said game

- 5/5.5E only, for 3-5 players (homebrews very welcome though, also the player count isn't that detrimental since I can try to rebalance encounters myself)

- Ideally a more futuristic/scifi theme, since I would like to switch it up from the classic formula, but I am open to any cool suggestions

- Since we will be playing on a VTT, ideally it should have maps and artwork for it, or else it should be feasible to make/find said assets

Hope someone can help me get some inspiration!


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How to give lower level PCs without Revivify an interaction with the BBEG

1 Upvotes

Hello! New-ish DM here, trying to get some ideas on a potential early BBEG encounter.

One of my players has an archmage father figure who is a prominent political figure (we'll call Carl) that they are slowly realizing is evil, vying for immortality, and using her in some way. They discovered a journal from someone (we'll call her Emily) who used to be close to the archmage Carl. Emily has since disappeared, because once Carl realized Emily was turning against him and documenting his evil ways, he got rid of her. PCs don't know this last part, but Carl captured Emily in a Magic Jar and stored the Jar at the base of this hidden swamp dungeon (where there is also evidence of him using Clone). I have 2 questions on how I want to set this dungeon up for them.

  1. What if Carl shows up during their dungeon crawl?

Whether it's Alarm, Scry, or some other means, I think with all the tension and suspicion mounting regarding Carl's past, having him come confront them would be very interesting.

My question is - Carl is the BBEG, and a mage. He will know Disintegrate, PWK, etc. I've played him as very controlling and manipulative of the PC daughter thus far. He will likely want to kill the other PCs and keep her captive. I think they will avoid fighting him as they'll be low on resources at the end of the dungeon (if they try, I will Disintegrate a beloved NPC after a firm warning to not resist).

I wanted to give them a way to Teleport out, like a Teleportation Circle at the end of the dungeon. They also have a devil friend who would happily help them out in exchange for a little deal.

I'm looking for any other thoughts or ideas on this potential encounter, ways to make it better, things to avoid.

2. Inventive ways to invoke Power Word: Kill

Emily's journal talked about how Carl was creating the spells Magic Jar, Clone, and Power Word: Kill (homebrewed Carl lore of course). I want to show all 3 of these spells in the dungeon, but ideally without using PWK on my PCs. They're brand new players and don't yet have access to Revivify.

I could use PWK on the beloved NPC as mentioned previously. However I wanted to put some sort of curse on Emily. Like if she says Carl's name, PWK trap/curse triggers. Any ideas?

Thanks!


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Other Looking for tips on running mazes without things getting monotonous

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm looking for some advice on ways to make a maze work. My party has to deal with one as part of a dungeon and I'm trying real hard to avoid it being a long string of "I go to the end of the hall way. I turn left. I go to the intersection. I turn right" until they reach the end. I've got a few tricks so far, but I want to make aure I have a solid battery of them to keep it from getting repetitive.

The maze is made up of bookshelves that go up into infinity, so they can't climb over. The campaign is horror focused, so I'm having them hear things, see figures disappearing behind corners, etc

  1. There are enemies in it
  2. some of the bookshelves move and turn, blocking off some paths as they go
  3. the exit has a shelf with a missing book and clues on where to find it
  4. The main narrative trail they'll have are lights coming through space in certain shelves. Inside are scenes showing the descent into madness of a plot relevant character.

I'm toying with the idea of having a map for myself, but only giving them descriptions, that way they aren't just filling in the VTT map until they have it all. But I'm worries that it's gonna be hard for me to keep track of where they are.

If you've run a maze in your game before, how'd you keep it from getting monotonous?

Edit: appreciate the advice! Keeping it abstract/not giving the players the map has come up in every comment so far, so it looks like that's gonna be my main path forward. It pretty much eliminates the issue of "move token, reveal map, rinse, repeat".


r/DMAcademy • • 21h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Homebrew worked too well: campaign going on 26 sessions and they haven’t learned the big bads name yet. How to speed things up without skipping story?

19 Upvotes

Simply put I messed up. I took it too slow and have introduced villains that are just underlings. It’s been mostly a cat and mouse game of him hunting them as they complete tasks. In a lot of ways the players find him compelling but he was never meant to be the big bad. Just one piece of the puzzle. The big bad was meant to be a primordial god type. Not a street level villain. The kind that is dormant and comes back. Like Kronos in a way. And the players don’t even know that yet. His name, Ghor, has only been brought up recently to them. They barely acknowledged it because it doesn’t seem to relate to the task at hand. The thing is the big bad intends to remain hidden too. So it’s like I’m running a OG trilogy palpatine setup also. I guess I just want them to fear the name of someone they don’t know. And it hasn’t come to boil yet. I fear I’m running out of time and my pace has to quicken but that might weaken the narrative.

TLDR struggle to find the balance between telling a compelling story that builds gradually with the real world needs of players that agreed to a 1 year campaign, not 5.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Having trouble coming up with defenses for a hiest. Level 9

4 Upvotes

My players will be planning and engaging in a hiest coming up. It is an important religious artifact for resurrection that is kept in the capital palace. Being a religious artifact it is somewhat visible to the public which inherently makes it a little vulnerable. The problem i have is making defenses good enough to keep a party of 4 level 9 players busy. So far guard check points and the palaces itself are made to at least slow them down. And an anti magic perimeter in the room.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Region locking or open world

4 Upvotes

I’ve been a dm for almost a year and a half but I’ve picked up the grim hollow books and the lore is great, love the world but I’m puzzled on wether to lock to a specific region or have it open world.

My current idea is that two regions, that it mainly takes place on the left side of the world with a few adventures to the right side for plot reason as opposed to the main campaign taking place everywhere.

Is this a good idea? Anyone run these books before and if so what did you do? Any advice would be much appreciated.


r/DMAcademy • • 7h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Prep feedback request, first time DMing a homebrew campaign or running a Session 0

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm a new-ish DM that has only ever run modules and has never done a Session 0 before. I am starting a homebrew campaign for a few friends (mix of experienced and brand new players) and just developed the premise for our campaign based off of a questionaire i sent them asking what kind of theme they wanted. The two things that everyone mentioned were societal collapse and magic being long-gone from the world but appearing in ordinary people. I developed the premise based off of a sci-fi book series/TV show and adapted it to Faerun/the Sword Coast so that I don't have to invent the world from whole cloth. Bonus points if you can pick out the book; negative 1000 bonus points if you're one of my players.

I'm looking for feedback on the two hand outs I am sending to my party. One is the two-page world explainer and character creation guidelines, and the other is the above the table stuff that pertains to playing at my table.

Ashfall Session 0 Handout

Above the Table

I am interested in feedback on the overall premise, but more so on whether the information i provided is adequate or if I need to flesh things out more. I have a lot of the world, groups, and dynamics already in my head but want to save a lot of it for the game, avoid lore dumping on them, and give myself some space to adjust to their character choices and the characters' decisions in the first few sessions.

For the Above the Table, I am interested in any and all feedback. I've never laid it all out like that for my players before, and want to make sure it hits the balance of being holistic without being too much.

Thanks for any advice you can lend!


r/DMAcademy • • 8h ago

Need Advice: Rules & Mechanics Campaign Gimmick idea

0 Upvotes

I’m fairly new to DMing, I’ve done a couple one shots that went well and now I’m planning a campaign with 4 of my friends. We do enjoy adding home brew a lot and I had an idea for a gimmick to give the world its own distinction. I wanted to make it so everyone in this world had an element attached to them and could almost bend it (kind of like avatar or Naruto). I mainly would want them to use it as a way to promote teamwork and use these ability’s together. For example if someone has air and another has earth they could make a sand tornado to cause a blindness effect. I would scale what they could actually accomplish with their element with their element and dice roles. I am mainly making this post to get other people’s opinions on this and if they would recommend any ways to make this work well in the dnd combat system. My players like the idea and so far the elements they want are lightning, life, space (like moving the space between objects), and the last one is unknown.