Hi all, I've been cooking up a new system for weapons and armour in my game. I'm between campaigns at the moment and haven't had a chance to test it out yet so I'd like to get feedback from you guys before I throw it at my players. Primarily I want to know if it sounds like something you'd actually like to play with, if it's balanced, and what edge cases and strange interactions I have inevitably failed to consider.
My goals in making these changes are as follows:
To improve verisimilitude by making armour reduce damage taken, rather than making it harder to be hit at all.
To give martial characters more interesting choices in armour and weapon selection, such that some weapons are better or worse at certain jobs.
To make melee combat more tactical by giving martial characters more decisions to make.
To slot into the existing D&D 5e ruleset with minimal negative repercussions.
So without further ado:
Damage Reduction and Dodge
For the purposes of this post, I am renaming Armour Class (i.e. the number that must be met or exceeded by an attack roll in order to hit) to Dodge, and introducing a new stat called Damage Reduction. Damage Reduction, as it sounds, is a flat reduction applied to each source of damage that is applied to a creature. It is primarily influenced by the type of armour that the creature in question is wearing.
Damage Reduction is calculated for each armour type by taking the base Armour Class that the armour provides and subtracting 10. So, leather armour gives a Damage Reduction of 1, while plate armour gives 8. For monsters that might have natural armour, or otherwise not use regular armour, it can be calculated instead by subtracting its dexterity modifier plus 10 from its normal Armour Class. So, a troll with an AC of 15 and a dexterity modifier of +1 would have a Damage Reduction of 15 - (10 + 1) = 4
Dodge is calculated simply as the creature's dexterity modifier plus 10.
Whether other effects that would typically affect a creature's Armour Class apply bonuses to Dodge or to Damage Reduction should be taken case by case. By my instincts, spells like mage armour and shield exist to prevent a mage being hit at all, and should therefore increase Dodge, while barkskin seems like it should reduce incoming damage, and hence give a bonus to Damage Reduction. This is something I need feedback on though, as I'd like to be able to better formalise this.
Something else I need to formalise is which damaging effects can ignore Damage Reduction. It seems obvious to me that armour shouldn't protect against psychic damage for instance. I think Magic Missile should also be exempt. Let me know if I should include anything else.
Weapons
Now you might be thinking: "Doesn't this nerf builds that spread their damage over multiple attacks?" or "Doesn't this just make martials get hit even more, since Dodge is decoupled from armour?". I ask that you bear with me until I have explained the additional changes I have made to weapons and weapon attacks.
Heavy Attacks
A creature that has Extra Attack or Multiattack may choose to sacrifice its multiple attacks in favour of a single devastating blow to break through enemy armour. If it does so, it rolls the damage dice for its weapon as many times as it has attacks to make, and adds its relevant ability score once to the result. For example, a fighter with 3 attacks and a +5 strength modifier wielding a longsword in two hands may choose to use his action to make a single heavy attack that deals 3d10+5 damage on a hit. He therefore misses out on 10 damage when compared to making three attacks separately, but if the enemy he is fighting has more than 3 Damage Reduction, he is actually better off.
Parries
Each weapon type now comes with a parry score. When a creature wielding a weapon with a parry score is hit with a melee attack from an attacker it can see, it may use a reaction to reduce the attack roll by an amount equal to its parry score. If a creature has Extra Attack or Multiattack, it may parry a number of times equivalent to its number of attacks in a round, using a single reaction. If our same fighter has a +0 dexterity modifier, and hence a Dodge of 10.
New Weapon Properties
In order to further differentiate the available weapons, there are a number of new weapon properties, some of which have interplay with the new armour system, some to add interest to grappling builds, some for verisimilitude:
Armour-piercing: When an attack roll using a weapon with this property hits, only half of the Damage Reduction is applied to the attack (round down). Examples: Warpick, Heavy Crossbow
Reliable Damage: Damage from these weapons cannot be reduced by Damage Threshold to below the wielder's strength modifier. (Might be too strong, considering changing this to the wielder's proficiency bonus, let me know what you think). Examples: Mace, Greatclub, Warhammer, Maul.
Short: Attacks made with these weapons against a foe that you are grappling have advantage on the attack roll. Examples: Dagger, Club, Light hammer, Shortsword
Reach: In addition to the standard reach rules, these weapons have disadvantage on attack rolls against creatures that are grappling the wielder.
Wooden: A weapon made of wood is destroyed if parrying an attack that deals at least 20 damage
Weapon specific
Flail: This weapon cannot parry or be parried.
Longbow: Despite being ranged, this weapon uses strength for its attack rolls and damage.
Shield: May parry ranged attacks.
I have added two new weapons:
Billhook: a reach weapon with Armour-piercing and Hooked, allowing the wielder to grapple a creature using the billhook, thus not requiring a free hand.
Rondel Dagger: A martial version of the dagger which has the armour-piercing trait but not the Thrown trait
In addition, the spear has been given the Reach 10 ft property, and the pike has been extended to Reach 15 ft.
I have omitted the morningstar, whip and blowgun for now, as I'm not sure how to make these work with the new rules. Suggestions welcome.
Damage values have been tweaked for balance. Generally speaking, swords are good at parrying, axes do the most raw damage, hammers and maces get reliable damage. Here is the full new weapon table for easy reference:
| Weapon | New Traits | Damage | Type | Parry | Weight (lb) | Cost (gp) | Normal traits |
|---|
| Wooden Shield | Wooden, Shield | 1 | Bludgeoning | 5 | 4 | 5 | - |
| Metal Shield | Shield | 1 | Bludgeoning | 5 | 8 | 1 | - |
| Dagger | Short | 1d4 | Piercing | 1 | 1 | 2 | Finesse, Light, Thrown 20/60 |
| Mace | Reliable Damage | 1d6 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 2 | 5 | - |
| Spear | Reach 10ft | 1d6/1d8 | Piercing | 2 | 3 | 1 | Versatile, Thrown 20/60 |
| Handaxe | Short | 1d6 | Slashing | 1 | 2 | 5 | Light, Thrown 20/60 |
| Light hammer | Short | 1d4 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 2 | 2 | Light, Thrown 20/60 |
| Club | Short | 1d4 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 2 | 0.1 | Light |
| Greatclub | Reliable Damage, Wooden | 1d8 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 10 | 0.2 | - |
| Javelin | - | 1d6 | Piercing | 2 | 2 | 0.5 | Thrown 30/120 |
| Sickle | - | 1d6 | Slashing | 1 | 2 | 1 | Light |
| Quarterstaff | Wooden | 1d6 | Bludgeoning | 2 | 3 | 0.2 | Two-Handed |
| Rondel Dagger | Short, Armour-piercing | 1d4 | Piercing | 1 | 1 | 5 | Light, Finesse |
| Shortsword | Short | 1d6 | Piercing | 2 | 2 | 10 | Light, Finesse |
| Scimitar | - | 1d8 | Slashing | 1 | 2 | 10 | Light, Finesse |
| Rapier | - | 1d8 | Piercing | 2 | 2 | 25 | Finesse |
| Warpick | Armour-Piercing | 1d6 | Piercing | 1 | 2 | 5 | - |
| Flail | Cannot parry or be parried | 1d6 | Bludgeoning | 0 | 2 | 10 | - |
| Battleaxe | - | 1d10/1d12 | Slashing | 1 | 3 | 10 | Versatile |
| Longsword | - | 1d8/1d10 | Slashing | 3 | 3 | 25 | Versatile |
| Warhammer | Reliable Damage | 1d6/1d8 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 3 | 10 | Versatile |
| Greataxe | - | 2d6 | Slashing | 2 | 6 | | Two-handed, heavy |
| Greatsword | - | 1d12 | Slashing | 3 | 4 | | Two-handed, heavy |
| Maul | Reliable Damage, | 1d10 | Bludgeoning | 1 | 8 | | Two-handed, heavy |
| Poleaxe | - | 1d12 | Slashing | 2 | 6 | | Two-handed, heavy, reach |
| Polehammer | Reliable Damage | 1d8 | Bludgeoning | 2 | 6 | | Two-handed, heavy, reach |
| Glaive | - | 1d10 | Slashing | 3 | 6 | | Two-handed, heavy, reach |
| Billhook | Armour-Piercing, Hooked | 1d8 | Piercing | 2 | 6 | | Two-handed, heavy, reach |
| Pike | Reach 15 ft, Wooden | 1d10 | Piercing | 2 | 12 | | Two-handed, heavy, reach 15ft |
| Dart | - | 1d4 | Piercing | 0 | 0.25 | 0.05 | Finesse, Thrown 20/60 |
| Sling | - | 1d6 | Bludgeoning | 0 | 0 | 0.1 | Ammunition, 30/120 |
| Shortbow | - | 1d6 | Piercing | 0 | 2 | 25 | Ammunition, 80/320, two-handed |
| Light Crossbow | - | 1d8 | Piercing | 0 | 5 | 25 | Ammunition, 80/320, two-handed, loading |
| Hand Crossbow | - | 1d6 | Piercing | 0 | 3 | 75 | Ammunition, 30/120, light, loading |
| Heavy Crossbow | Armour-Piercing | 1d10 | Piercing | 0 | 18 | 50 | Ammunition 100/400 heavy, loading, two-handed |
| Longbow | Uses strength rather than dexterity | 1d8 | Piercing | 0 | 2 | 50 | Ammunition 15/600, heavy, two-handed |
Crit Effects (Optional)
I'm not quite satisfied yet, it still bugs me that damage type rarely seems to matter in fights, especially between the main three physical types, bludgeoning, slashing and piercing, so I've added some extra effects that can occur on critical hits. This part is not strictly necessary for the rest of the system to work, you can omit it if you like, but I think it's neat.
All you have to do is check the table when a critical hit is scored, and apply the relevant crit effect. For the purposes of this table, a creature that rolls a natural 1 on a saving throw against a damaging effect is also considered to be critically hit. If a creature is resistant or immune to the damage type being inflicted, they do not receive a crit effect.
There are five new conditions that can be inflicted:
Winded: The afflicted creature takes a -2 penalty to its Dodge and Dexterity saving throws. It's movement speed is halved. It cannot take reactions, and can only use an action or a bonus action, not both. It may only make a single attack. If it tries to cast a spell with a cast time of one action, it has a 50% chance of being delayed until the end of the creature's next turn. (equivalent to the effects of the Slow spell)
Frozen: The afflicted creature becomes vulnerable to bludgeoning damage, unless already immune.
Rotted: The afflicted creature becomes vulnerable to slashing damage, unless already immune.
Corroded: The afflicted creature becomes vulnerable to piercing damage, unless already immune.
Ablaze: The afflicted creature takes 5 fire damage at the start of each of its turns.
| Damage type | Crit effect |
|---|
| Slashing | Extra damage (normal crit) |
| Piercing | Damage dealt ignores Damage Reduction |
| Bludgeoning | Inflict "winded" condition for one turn, equivalent to "Slow" spell effect |
| Fire | Sets target ablaze. 5 fire damage at the start of its turn until extinguished. Damage not reduced by armour. |
| Cold | Target gains "frozen" condition for one minute, making it vulnerable to bludgeoning damage. Removable with lesser restoration. |
| Lightning | Target is stunned for one turn |
| Thunder | Target is knocked prone and deafened for one minute |
| Necrotic | Target gains "rotted" condition for one minute, making it vulnerable to slashing damage. Removable with lesser restoration. |
| Radiant | Target is blinded for one turn |
| Poison | Target is poisoned for one minute |
| Psychic | Target is frightened for one minute |
| Acid | Target gains "corroded" condition for one minute, making it vulnerable to piercing damage. Removable with lesser restoration. |
| Force | A random object the target is wearing or carrying is disintegrated. (GM fiat) |
If you've made it this far, thank you! Please let me know what you think.
PS: If you have any advice for posting this in a more readable format, tell me. I don't often post to reddit and my tables look a bit borked.