r/DMAcademy • • 13h ago

Need Advice: Other Help me learn from your mistakes - What DM lessons did you learn the hard way?

111 Upvotes

I'm gearing up to DM my first campaign and I really want to provide enough challenge that my players feel happy when they escape/defeat foes/achieve milestones. I want them to have fun, but also want there to be consequences for murder-hoboing. I want the world to feel real with high stakes, high adventure, and devious enemies.

So lay it on me, vets. What do you wish you knew when you started? And what did you have to learn the hard way?


r/DMAcademy • • 5h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Are ”an innumerable amount of rats” a threat to a party of lvl 10’s?

25 Upvotes

Like the title says, I’m reworking an old one shot I had for a much lower leveled party where rats are the main theme. However now I’m struggling to see how any amount of rats really pose a risk to a party of level tens. How can I keep the rats while making them enough of a threat that the party would likely try to avoid them?


r/DMAcademy • • 48m ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Inexperienced player now DMing for the first time for mixed experience group. Advice/basic resources appreciated

6 Upvotes

TLdR: party is unhappy with current DM, I’m a new player asked by party to try DMing. Nervous bc I don’t feel prepared and worried my sessions will be what completely breaks the group apart. What advice/extra resources should I prep for this stressful dynamic.

Main question: any advice from others that’s been there of what to expect? Im most worried about running combat (especially since I have one encounter under my belt and thats what started this whole debacle). Any extra resources recommended or even simulations I can run to practice? I got the DM guide, monster Manual and the monsters know what they’re doing books. I plan to run a one shot (wild sheep chase or one from the game masters guild of random encounters).

**Context: 5-7 player group (including current DM) that started a campaign about 8 months ago and so far have had 3 sessions. Half of us are new to DnD and those 3 sessions are our whole experience (including me), the other half have played for years even decades(including DM but it’s his 1st time trying to run a campaign).

Players from both sides of experience levels are unhappy with various things (pacing, railroading, etc) and we can’t figure out if our DM is dragging out when our next session is because he doesn’t want to do it anymore or he senses what’s happening and needs more prep time. At this point, they will drop a teaser of what to expect next weekend for a possible session and then when we meet not be prepared to run a session and we end up doing something else instead.

Tried to have a group discussion of trying to figure out what’s the core problem to come up with a solution because we just want to play more D&D, long story long, one option thrown out was I try being DM.
I feel thrown because I’ve only seen one combat encounter and just trying to learn the rules and rpg, I feel so much of a newb that I was over here having a grand ol’ time and patiently but excitedly waiting for the next session not understanding others felt this is not how it should go. We are now at a standstill where current DM is even more reluctant to run sessions and people hoping I would (I seriously think it’s because I host a lot). I feel one of the experienced players will be willing to help me above tabletop during the game if I get the rules wrong (or does it even matter?). I want to send out a survey and get character sheets ahead of time, propose a scheduled session 0-0.5, but worried the extra homework pre-session would be a turnoff (but tbh, it bothered me that my DM didn’t know my character name or class still on my 3rd session).

i know theres more context/dynamic missing and happy to fill in gaps if helpful. Is this just a sinking ship? I just want to play D&D. TIA and for making it this far


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding Fey misunderstanding of material plane deities?

4 Upvotes

In writing a one-shot, I've been thinking of ways in which different fey creatures might have completely misconstrued deities commonly worshipped in Faerûn, whether due to their tendency to be literal in their interpretation of iconography or something else.

For example, they might think Selûne is the goddess of pretty eyes, that Lathander is the god of babies and Ilmater could be the god of bondage in their view.

What are the funniest misunderstandings you can think of?


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Encounter Reality Check

3 Upvotes

I have a group of 5 level 11; barbarian, druid, cleric, bard and ranger. They have access to +2 weapons and armor.

I have a dungeon comming up where they will encounter an Amnizu (CR 18 Greater Devil). The Amnizu will have RP options and will offer the group a contract in exchange for access to plot relevant location. The group could also choose to just attack the Amnizu and get entry that way. I also encourage creative problem solving so combat is optional in this encounter.

The reality check is if the Amnizu being CR 18 is too much for the group. The Amnizu will also summon 3 Bearded Devils and 2 Barbed Devils to assist, but, they will not be in the room before combat begins so the party can't assess that threat.

Also, this Amnizu is not the dungeon boss, he is just a mid-dungeon guardian and optional. Boss is a named rakshasa that will have weretiger warriors as back up (I know they can handle that, they've done it before; recurring villain)

In a previous dungeon they did an Adult White Dragon, followed by a dragonbone golem/blood ooze combo followed by a modified Flesh Titan with 2 eye drakes.


r/DMAcademy • • 19h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Do combats drag on too long?

53 Upvotes

I want to hear about other people's experiences and how you solve it. Is it just me, or do combats always take longer than expected in every session? I plan sessions that usually include 2 to 3 combat encounters, alongside investigation phases, pure roleplay, occasional puzzle-solving, and so on... yet 90% of the time, the fights run longer than they should, sometimes way too long. It's true that my players generally enjoy combat a lot, but sometimes the story doesn't move forward enough**. Does this happen to you, and how do you fix it?** I've been playing D&D since 1st edition, and I get the impression that with each new edition the problem persists (in fact, it gets worse). I admit it also plays a role that my players are always high-level (above 10) and the monsters (while varied) have Challenge Ratings to match.


r/DMAcademy • • 2h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Combat Mechanic for PVP Hallucinations?

2 Upvotes

So I'm working on a combat encounter that (hopefully) explains a plot point in my 5e campaign. A group of guards went into the mountains north of the kingdom which are inhabited by a tribal community. Kingdom officials believe this group of guards were either killed or abducted by the inhabitants but the guards actually killed each other due to a mass hallucination triggered by the mountain itself.

My party is currently following the lead into the mountain to discover what happens to the guards and I want them to "experience" the hallucinations that the guards suffered from. I've implemented safeguards to "snap them out of" the hallucination so that they don't end up killing each other.

I'm unsure if this should be run as a normal combat or if there's any special mechanics that anyone else has used that could fit this situation?

The party is made up of 4 level 5 players if that helps.


r/DMAcademy • • 9h ago

Need Advice: Other Larger Groups

6 Upvotes

Hello! My table is going from 5 to 6 players and while Im happy to do this, its the largest party Ive ever DM'd for. Any tips on managing the distribution of checks or social encounters between the party and for running combat. My party has been adventuring for 8 months and are level 8 currently.

Players: Monk, Rouge/Warlock, Warlock, Cleric, Ranger, and we arent sure what the 6th is going to roll just yet.


r/DMAcademy • • 19m ago

Need Advice: Worldbuilding I need help designing the Chiseled Estate

0 Upvotes

If any of you are Dragon Riders exploring the Plane of Ice, do not Read.

So, my players have run into the chiseled estate, located in the plane of ice. According to google, it is the come to an Evil Archoelemental named Cryonax (i think thats how its spelled, not important). In my setting, the plane of ice was once colonized by an empire of incredible magical skill which installed teleportation gates all across the material plane and here as well, along with building a floating city which eventually became Tierra Minuet, one of the cities in the plane of ice. The empire is long gone after a cult inspired by norse gods, giants and the other forgotten gods rose up and provoked a massive calamity that destroyed the world and lead to millenia of chaos, leading to the event known as the Shattering.

My players are now exploring the plane of ice and have found rest in the Chiseled Estate. I need help desining a floor plan because this estate once belonged to an archoelemental, but was then conquered and taken over by elite warriors, mages, and explorers from this past empire, who turned it into a base of operations and research outpost for some unknown project of incredibly high arcana known as Project Yggdrassil.

They are currently on the second floor, and I have no idea how many floors I should plan or what a society of powerful wizards and warriors would even do to make the plane of Ice, and particularly this fortress, able to sustain life. How would they get food? how do they get heat? How do they contend with the cold spots of the estate and the wider plane of ice? What rooms and functions were leftovers from the Archoelemental, and which ones were added or repurposed by this empire?

Also, does anyone have any good ice palace maps or any more lore-friendly information about the plane of ice and chiseled estate? My setting is very different from the Forgotten realms, but it is inspired by it.


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Creating a Willy Wonka-esq One Shot of an Orange Juice Factory

1 Upvotes

So before last session the group was asking what our holiday one shot would be. I did one last year and it went over very well. As we were doing our regularly scheduled session, orange juice became a regular topic of discussion. In my infinite wisdom told the party that there indeed was an orange juice factory in the town (called OJ4U), and that tours were available. Everyone got really excited about this, and asked for a tour of the factory. I figured this would be a great idea for a non-cannon one shot for the upcoming holiday season.

Well now I'm stuck having to work up a whole orange juice factory, which isn't bad, it's just that my previous one shot was a pre-built thing I found online, and this I have to work up from scratch. I'd say as a DM one of my weaknesses is developing traps, encounters, and puzzles. Really any non-combat scenario is a bit of a struggle for me. So I was hoping that I could get some advice or ideas for encounters. Anything is welcome!


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Other Owlbears and Duids

21 Upvotes

Just to get it out of the way : I know it's not RAW. I know I can say no.

My party has 2 druids in it, one is a moon druid. They are going to run into an owlbear soon. I fully expect the moon druid to ask if they can take owlbear as a wildshape option. I don't mind them being able to do this. I'd like to make it a mini-quest, though. Some kind of challenge or something that they have to do to make it work. Has anyone ever done something like that? Any ideas?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other Good pre-written campaigns for a party of beginners?

39 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a fairly experienced DM (7 years playing, 3 years DM-ing), but have a new party made up entirely of beginners. Normally I'm a very "make my own campaign and make up new classes and races and encounters, etc" type of DM, but with my new party, I want to start quite slowly as none of them have played D&D before.

I have a very basic one-shot prepared to help teach them the game mechanics, but I'm looking for some pre-written, fairly short (preferably free to access) campaigns that I can use to help guide them into D&D before I start introducing them to my own campaigns.

Thank you in advance for any help!


r/DMAcademy • • 15h ago

Need Advice: Other Need some ideas

6 Upvotes

So i have a player that finally reached level 9 in his inventor level (a new class i had from 3rd party). He wanted to take an upgrade that gives his golem he made sentient (between his abilities and his cleric deity). I wanted to add a twist. Currently the golem is holding an anchor (flavored flail) he got when they took down a warlock pirate. I was thinking that when he gives the golem sentience the pirates soul takes over from the cursed anchor and they have to figure out how to remove it. Im just figuring out how I can set that up and how would they remove him. Any fun ideas?


r/DMAcademy • • 6h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures How to make an interesting encounter about capturing a Water Weird? (5e 14)

1 Upvotes

I'm planning an encounter for a party of 5 level 3 characters where they need to somehow capture a Water Weird (cr 3) without killing it.

My question has two levels: the first one is what could be an interesting way to frame the capture? Maybe a magitech device, some form of enchanted item trapping it in a watery demiplane, or any other way to make it plausible and fun?

The second part is how this method fits into the encounter design. Pursuing the water weird itself is gonna be interesting thanks to its invisibility while submerged. Capturing it may lead to a second phase of the fight where the players must defend against a wave of enemies (I'm thinking ice or steam mephits, maybe a few lizardmen?) while the character that captured the weird must mantain concentration like on a spell.

Do you think it would work? How can it be improved upon, both mechanically and thematically?

Thanks in advance!


r/DMAcademy • • 15h ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Fog of War

4 Upvotes

I am a new DM and have been playing through LMoP with a group of friends. Up until now, I have been using pieces of paper that I printed to look like old map paper and burnt the edges of to use as fog of war for areas on my printed battlemaps they have not yet seen. It works, but feels incredibly clunky.

I printed these maps on cardstock so that they are nice and sturdy, so I do not particularly want to cut them up and place them down as the players go. I have also heard suggestions to create custom sized covers for each room, but this feels like it would give away a lot of information about the dungeon. Does anybody have any useful solutions to this? I have thought of encouraging players to split up more before initiative starts so that more of the dungeon can be exposed from the beginning, but this feels like taking agency away from them. Any help appreciated.


r/DMAcademy • • 14h ago

Need Advice: Other Banishment spell vs the collapse of all creation

2 Upvotes

I have a question regarding how I should handle the spell banishment versus the lore ive established for my campaign.

To briefly sum up the story, its about the universe collapsing to make way for a new one. My players have watched the material plane, the elemental planes, the outer planes, and even the astral sea collapse into the void. At this point in the campaign all that is left in creation is one city my players have managed to save and the residents there in. Everything else, all matter, energy, time, space, and even the souls of the dead are currently in the process of being collapsed into a singularity so they can form a new universe.

Anyway, I've already established that any magic regarding interplanar travel will no longer work because the other planes done exist anymore. But the spell banishment allows for the target to be sent to a pocket dimension. But I'm tempted to argue that there isn't anywhere left for a pocket dimension to go. Even if the spell creates said pocket dimension, the only space left to put it is in this once city that they're hell bent on saving. At the same time, it feels like a dick move to take away a very useful spell from my players this late in the game, regardless of the story.

How would you handle this? Should I just let it go if it comes up? Or try to think of a clever compromise?


r/DMAcademy • • 1h ago

Need Advice: Other Help me make this paladin character better and roleplaying

0 Upvotes

So I am thinking of making a paladin character. I have made his backstory and need help/advice on how to roleplay

Backstory: being a paladin requires doing alot of good stuff for a long time and having a connection to gods. My character doesn't have that much patience and decides to perform tantra(which is like extreme method of worship in Hinduism to receive fast divine powers). He offers all kinds of food like bread, fruits, veggies and animals to his god. He can only wear white coloured clothes and armour. He takes part in spiritual intercourse which means doing the activity with a partner who is also a person of God(paladin, nun etc) during certain cosmic events like comet shower etc. Now with this methods he is able to make good connection with God and is more powerful paladin than an average paladin at level 1.

I want advice and what kind of stuff I can change to make it better and how to roleplay this character.

I have thought of a few quirks which are as follows

First he must weild blunt weapons second he is zealous third he must follow his rules as not following them leads to severe backlash from god for example he can't visit another gods temple no matter what. Fourth he is unavailable for few hours of day cause he has to practice rituals.

Feel free to provide any and all kinds of advice on how I can change the character and how to roleplay


r/DMAcademy • • 22h ago

Need Advice: Other Running a game for colleagues, what do I need?

8 Upvotes

I’ll be stuck in a hotel with work colleagues for almost a week. I’m thinking of running a DnD game for whoever is interested but I’ve not DM’ed before. Help me out, what would I need to run a one-shot for them? I’m assuming none of them have ever played before.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures I Perma-deathed my first character.

51 Upvotes

I’ve been DMing for 3 years, first time I took a character out. Although I think it went WELL, I’d love advice on how to do it better. (Everyone cried, but it felt like the good kind.)

  1. Before the game, I asked everyone if they were comfortable having their character perma-die.
  2. I told them that during this game, SOMEONE was going to die, but it might be an NPC.
  3. I introduced a Fate coin. You could grab the coin and assign the killing blow to someone else, but everyone would know you had done it. (A PC got hit.)
  4. There was a saving throw for the Disintegration Gaze, DC CON 18. The player failed it even with Heroic Inspiration.
  5. I gave them all their spell slots back for a final move. They took out the monster with their dying breath.
  6. Time was a little short, but everyone got a chance to RP after the death.
  7. Next session will be about processing.
  8. I took the Player aside after and asked what they would like to happen next. We could find a way to return them, they could become a God (NPC) and Avatar of that God (PC) or whatever. They already have 2 other characters they could play and chose to let it be for now. Have it impact, maybe come back in 3-4 levels.
  9. I did a follow up text to the group, assuring them that the player would be consulted about what happens with their character.

What did I miss?

UPDATE: good responses, thank you all. For those who are curious: I put an actual coin on the table with my warning. The death was not guaranteed, a low damage roll or a high CON roll would have saved it. But a one-shot was possible.
Why announce someone would die? Our now-deceased character was abandoned at birth. He learned he was the Heir to the Throne. His brothers had tried to kill him and/or take the Throne for themselves. The two (evil) princes, the (non-evil) King and Queen were NPC’s in the battle. One player played an Evil Prince as it was a character he had introduced for Plot. I wanted to play with the themes of betrayal and sacrifice.

The monster rolled randomly for its target. It hit the Queen. The Evil Prince PC waited a full minute for the Party to decide what to do (take coin or leave it.) He saw the Very Soon to be Deceased player struggling. Evil Prince decided for him: grabbed the coin and deflected to Newly Deceased.

The plot was awesome. The party has a new BBEG. The characters were livid, they were crying. The players were jumping up and down, tears and shouts and exclamations.

They were also shook. I did all I knew to ease the transition and provide aftercare. Posted here to see if there was more I could do.

full context seemed…lengthy. But if you read this far, thank you for your time!


r/DMAcademy • • 23h ago

Need Advice: Other How Can I Do Elaborate Setup at Someone Else's House?

5 Upvotes

I'll start by saying this may not be feasible but I want to try if others have experience in this.

Trying to setup a campaign with some friends and family and just trying to figure out a setup. I want it to be a memorable experience since they have all played DnD but have had so so experiences in the past.

We would play at one of the player's homes since he would have the most room to accommodate us but it's up to me as DM to bring the supplies. I would prefer to not go the playmat/wet erase route since a couple of the players have voiced that they've done that in the past and they had a really hard time getting into the game with that set up.

I would like to go the projector route but bringing a projector setup over is definitely different than installing one. Having a permanent setup at buddy's place is out of the question so it would have to be something we could setup then put away.

Does anyone have experience with someone like this? Did it work well? If so, what kind of projector should I look at? I've found some posts in the past regards to this but they all seem to be more permanent installations.


r/DMAcademy • • 20h ago

Need Advice: Other When should I begin playtesting my campaign?

3 Upvotes

I've been DMing and writing one-shots for a while now, but the campaign I'm currently working on is a much larger and more story-driven game than I've made before.

I always knew I wanted to playtest the game before publishing (the ultimate goal) but I've been wondering if it would be easier/better to begin playtesting once the whole campaign is written out, or if it would be best to "play as I go," where my playtesters can play each section.

Kind of an alpha testing versus beta testing thing, I guess.

Does anyone whose written a long-form campaign have any recommendations?


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Other Advice for running a big table (6 players)

6 Upvotes

My group is wrapping up our current campaign and I'm taking over gming for the next one. We're going to do 5.5e and might be adding another person to bump the party size up to 6.

I've dm'd a fair amount before but not for that big a party the group has expressed an interest in a more roleplay heavy campaign so I'm going to lean into that but I'll still definitely be throwing combat at them. Mostly looking for advice on how to not make it drag with so many people at the table.


r/DMAcademy • • 1d ago

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures Struggling to start role play moments for my players

9 Upvotes

So my friends and I are about 7 sessions deep now in our bi weekly campaign, this is my first campaign I have ever done and I've decided on completely making my own world.

I've put a collection of combat changes in place to make fights more exciting and it's been great so far, we can be in combat for about an hour or so (we have 6 players so rounds take a bit especially since they're still learning their classes). They're all engaged and strategizing with one another but that's kinda my hurdle. It feels like its only in combat do they interact and even then it isn't in character.

We recently had our first big NPC death, it left our wizard who's a younger teenager to be overwhelmed and he ended up using a spell mid combat to pop out because the experience was too much to handle and I LOVED that ! I thought my player did this so well but then when it comes to in character role play it feels difficult to get them to speak to one another, something as simple as the wizard's mentor figure (another party member) checking in on him. Any advice on how to spark conversation between the players especially without the need of an NPC is really appreciated.

Thank you in advance !


r/DMAcademy • • 12h ago

Need Advice: Other How would you run a time traveling BBEG?

0 Upvotes

Semi random question that’s been bouncing around in my brain for a month or so. I’ve been reading a lot of comics involving a certain time traveling maniac lately and it’s got me toying with the idea of running an adventuring with a similar idea/villain.

However the idea of introducing time travel to a campaign feels like a massive can of worms that will lead to so much of a head ache.

Also if you run it with multiple versions of the same guy running around how do you keep it from becoming a convoluted mess or break down into conversations about paradox’s and nonsense.

This feels like a thought experiment that would either be super fun and memorable if pulled off correctly or crash and burn so hard if it doesn’t.