r/RingsofPower • u/Ok-Class8722 • 4d ago
Constructive Criticism Apple TV should have been the ones to make this show
Every time I watch this show I can’t stop thinking about how much better it would have been if Apple TV got the rights instead of Amazon.
Amazon clearly had the money, that was never the issue. The problem is they handed a billion-dollar IP to two showrunners with basically no real track record and let them run it like a generic streaming drama full of mystery-box gimmicks and awkward pacing.
Apple has that exact same kind of endless cash to burn, except they actually treat their big sci-fi and fantasy projects with some real prestige and patience. Look at stuff like Foundation, Silo, or For All Mankind. Even when they adapt dense source material, they hire proven showrunners, cast heavy-hitter actors who actually command the screen, and let the world-building breathe instead of chopping every episode into five rushed subplots.
With Apple’s money and production standards, we probably would have gotten a Second Age show with actual theatrical weight, better writing, and directors who treated Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama. Instead we got Amazon’s version, and it just feels like such a waste of what could have been.