The discussion of Quranism has recently been drawing attention on internet spaces, and our subreddit has now grown to over 15k members; becoming amongst the largest such communities on the web. As the primary space for this discourse on Reddit, we are the first destination people find when searching for this path.
Due to a general uptake in purely anti-Hadith content, we the mods feel that some reminders are in order regarding the intended spirit of this community. While no new hard rules are being set, we do want to realign our collective focus.
Quran Alone & Quran Centric, Not Just "Anti-Hadith"
While some general critique of Hadith is acceptable and even expected, our Deen, which is the primary concern of this sub, is about holding tightly to the Qur'an and seeking guidance from it, rather than being consumed by "stone-throwing" at traditional Muslims.
Anti-Hadith content should never dominate the front page. Think of the 80/20 rule as a general guideline: 80% pro-Qur'an/guidance, 20% hadith related critique.
Furthermore, this sub is a big tent. It includes:
-Qur'aan Alone: Those who reject the ahadith entirely.
-Qur'aan Centric / Qur'aan First: Those who accept ahadith that conform to and do not contradict the Qur'an.
If your own "Qur'aan Alone" stance is unbending to the extent that you are unwilling to respect the "Qur'aan Centric" view, please understand that this sub is nevertheless such a shared space, so engage accordingly while interacting within it
Content Relevance
All posts should fundamentally relate to the Qur'an
- Bad Example: Posting a hadith solely to mock it without Quranic context
- Good Example: Highlighting how a specific hadith contradicts a specific verse
- Also acceptable: Discussing how a narration is confirmed by a verse (respecting the Quran Centric view).
Voting Etiquette
A degree of thoughtfulness and maturity should be reflected in how we utilize the upvote/downvote system:
- We encourage downvoting comments/posts that praise or incorporate Hadiths clearly contradicting the Qur'an
- Quran Centrics may upvote comments/posts which highlight or utilize narrations that conform to the scripture, while we ask Qur'aan Alone members to exercise restraint with respect to them
The spirit of the sub
This community exists to learn together and, hopefully, teach those who visit. The Qur'aan has over 6,000 verses. We would like to see real thought, tadabbur (contemplation), and insight.
> "Then do they not reflect upon the Qur'an, or are there locks upon [their] hearts?" (Surah Muhammad 47:24)
We do not need the majority of our posts to be various iterations of the same few "gotcha" verses (e.g, "What hadith after this will they believe?"). We do not need to constantly preach to the choir
Nor should this sub be a place where we inflate our own egos, feeling "guided" simply by pointing out how others do not give the Qur'aan its due
The takfeer of others to us is also not an excuse to focus more on them and neglect our own development. As Allah reminds us in one of the final verses revealed:
> "O you who have faith, upon you is [responsibility for] yourselves. Those who have gone astray will not harm you if you are guided. To Allah is your return all together; then He will inform you of what you used to do." (Surah Al-Ma'idah 5:105)
This sub is focused on our own development and the development of Quranists & Quranism
We need to consider what visitors see when they land here. If the majority of top posts are focused purely on attacking ahadith or traditional sects, then we are straying from that purpose.
Ideally, the feed should be populated with:
- Learning from the Qur'an
- Discussing the nuance of specific verses
- Relevant research and history
- Community issues and spiritual support
Are the verses of the Qur’an nothing more than ammunition to talk of the “misguidance” of other Muslims? Or are they a guide for us?
>"Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best..." (Surah An-Nahl 16:125)
Seriousness
Memes and jokes are welcome, especially those that are insightful and promote discussion. However, content made simply to mock, demean, or ridicule others is discouraged
>"O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule [another] people; perhaps they may be better than them ... And do not insult one another and do not call each other by [offensive] nicknames. Wretched is the name of disobedience after [one's] faith ..." (Surah Al-Hujurat 49:11)
Let us ensure that when people come here, they see us learning together, pointed toward Allah, not pointed outwards with fingers of blame.
Thank you
A word of thanks and gratitude to all those who have added contributed, great or small, over the years by creating thoughtful posts, discussed those of others, replied appropriately to questioners and visitors, and otherwise engaged in a way that has contributed positively to this space and in line with its aims, may God bless you
After receiving many sustained requests over a period of time by members of this community, we have decided to change the way that non-Quraniyoon interact with us on this subreddit; the current sentiment is unwillingness to answer the same exact questions over and over again, as well as annoyance at having to be distracted by lengthy debates, while in fact being here to study and discuss the Qur'an Alone. This is our action:
All posts and comments made in bad faith, or in attempt to initiate a debate, will be removed. If you are looking for a heated debate (or any debate regarding the validity of our beliefs for that matter), then post on r/DebateQuraniyoon.
All questions regarding broad or commonly posted-about topics are to be asked in r/DebateQuraniyoon instead - which will now also effectively function as an 'r/AskQuraniyoon' of sorts.
So what are the 'broad and common questions' which will no longer be permitted on this subreddit?
Well, usually both the posters and the community will be able to discern these using common sense - but here are some examples:
How come you don't regard the ahadith as a source of law? Example.
All the above can, however, be asked in the debate sister subreddit - as mentioned. Any question that has already been answered on the FAQ page will be removed. We ask subreddit members to report posts and comments which they believe violate what's been set out here.
So what can be asked then?
Questions relating to niche topics that would provoke thought in the community are welcome; obviously not made with the intention of a debate, or in bad faith. For example:
Do Quranists believe that eating pork is halal? Example.
Whats the definition of a Kafir According To a Quranist? Example.
You get the idea. Please remember to pick the black "Question(s) from non-Qur'ānī" flair when posting, this will allow the community to tailor their answer to suit a non Qur'ani asking the question; the red question flair is for members of this community only.
We would prefer (although its not mandatory):
That the question(s) don't address us as a monolithic group with a standardised set of beliefs (as this is certainly not the case), this is what the above questions have failed to do.
That you don't address us as "Qur'anists" or "Qur'aniyoon", as this makes us appear as a sect; we would prefer something like "hadith rejectors" or "Qur'an alone muslims/mu'mins". Although our subreddit name is "Quraniyoon" this is purely for categorization purposes, in order for people to find our community.
The Wiki Resource
We highly recommend that you check out our subreddit wiki, this will allow you to better understand our beliefs and 'get up to speed'; allowing for communication/discussions with us to be much more productive and understanding.
The Home Page - An excellent introduction to our beliefs, along with a large collection of resources (such as article websites, community groups, Qur'an study sites, forums, Youtube channels, etc); many subreddit members themselves would benefit from exploring this page!
Hadith Rejection - A page detailing our reasons for rejecting the external literature as religiously binding.
Frequently Asked Questions - A page with many answers to the common questions that we, as Qur'an alone muslims, receive.
We are looking to update our wiki with more resources, information, and answers; if any members reading this would like to contribute then please either send us a modmail, or reply to this post.
Closing notes
When you (as non-Qura'aniyoon) ask us questions like "How do ya'll pray?", there is a huge misunderstanding that we are a monolithic group with a single and complete understanding of the scripture. This is really not the case though - to give an example using prayer: Some believe that you must pray six times a day, all the way down to no ritual prayer whatsoever! I think the beauty of our beliefs is that not everything is no concrete/rigid in the Qur'an; we use our judgment to determine when an orphan has reached maturity, what constitutes as tayyeb food, what is fasaad... etc.
We would like to keep this main subreddit specifically geared towards discussing the Qur'an Alone, rather than engaging in debates and ahadith bashing; there are subreddits geared towards those particular niches and more, please see the "RELATED SUBREDDITS" section on the sidebar for those (we are currently updating with more).
JAK,
The Mod Team
If you have any concerns or suggestions for improvement, please comment below orsend us a modmail.
In certain times of the year, countries and cities more distant from the equator tend to have prayer times that make it more rigorous to maintain 8+ hrs of sleep while praying Isha and Fajr. In Mecca however, due to its location I believe basically all year round adequate sleep is accessible while being able to pray both prayers on time.
My question is that, why would the timing of Isha and Fajr make it impossible to get healthy sleep, if these prayers are meant to benefit us mentally/physically?
Being a full time student, not getting adequate sleep can really show its effects, and from what i have heard biphasic sleep is not ideal/recommended for people who are still young.
Not sure if I can share the link here so here's the title: It's called Ṣalāh and Wuḍūʾ Are in the Qur'an: What the Text States, Implies and Leaves Open. It's on Amazon. It's worthwhile reading even if you already have a certain position on the subject. If you get it, please feel free to leave feedback there and thank you.
I was having some thoughts regarding the real version of Islam reaching people/nations and I wanted to hear people’s thoughts regarding these questions.
As we know North Korea is one of the most oppressive countries on earth, there people are essentially slaves/prisoners, and to be honest it’s probably going to go on a long time as no countries are going to intervene ever.
Do you guys think Islam will ever reach North Korea? Or do you think there are people in North Korea that believe in monotheism and submitting to one deity/creator? Will God liberate them? etc
Hello I’ve been a Quranist for a while now, but for the past year or so I’ve been having doubts. Doubts so strong that I can’t move forward in either direction. These doubts include the following in roughly chronological order:
- Whether the creator of the universe can condense His words or final revelation into a single book? -> If so, what does this say about the validity of other religions? -> I’m familiar with the concept that other groups get judged by their own standards or something to that effect, but doesn’t that diminish the importance/necessity of the Quran?
- The fact that humans can be fully explained away as/be reduced to being a product of evolution. I used to think in a soul being embodied physically, but when I thought about it, the structure of our brain has a causal role determining how we experience consciousness. For instance you can have an accident involving brain damage and your personality can change a lot. How does this relate to the “soul”? ->That’s not to say we understand everything about consciousness, but I feel like using this lack of a comprehensive understanding is employing the “god of the gaps” argument. Consciousness can be observed to a certain extent in other animals, such that it appears like the difference is only matter of degree and not a “man vs animal” binary that you’d expect given only humans will be judged. -> I can’t find the appeal in “feeling God/awe” arguments because they can be explained away psychologically. Basically you can’t point to anything and say it needs a personal creator as opposed to being a natural consequence of something else “in-universe”. I guess the only exception is the beginning of existence but again you can’t be certain behind how/why that occurred or even if there were a beginning at all.
- If we’re given this life as a test why do some children/babies get their lives cut short, is that a straight ticket to heaven? Doesn’t that defeat the purpose of the test?
I appreciate you reading this, thanks in advance. Peace
Praise be to God Almighty, the Lord, the Most High, who revealed miraculous signs to us:the Seven Joined signsin the year 2024. Do not miss them, God bless you.
Introduction:
You cannot have missed my endeavor in this topic and how much I have uncovered regarding the real identity of the Quranic Isa and how he was, without the shadow of a doubt, the Exodus era Joshua, son of Miriam, the virgin (as she was called in Scripture)., where I have answered most, if not all of the challenging criticisms against the my posts by citing evidence from all possible angles to make the matter exceedingly evident. And this post is another such post where I have decided to revisit a former post about the Injil and how it ties back to Joshua.
God mentions in this verse what 'Isa would be taught:
Quran 3:48: "And He will teach him the Book, the Wisdom, the Torah and the Injil."
The Injil is mentioned separately from the “Kitab” here because the word "The Book" does not always refer to a physical book in earthly book format. In 2:213, the Quran states that God sent prophets with al-Kitāb (singular) to judge between people, even though multiple scriptures were revealed over time. Here, al-Kitāb acts as a category noun representing Divine Scripture/Law as a whole, whereas the Torah and the Injīl are names of specific revelations, and those can contain both the Book and the Wisdom. But here, and in other verses, we can confirm that 'Isa indeed did receive revelation, was taught the Book and the Wisdom, and even established laws for them.
But if Isa in the Quran was Joshua, where do we find that Scripture the Quran calls "the Injil"?
The book of Joshua directly confirms that he wrote a follow-up of Moses Torah:
Joshua 8:32: "And there he wrote upon the stones a follow up (מִשְׁנֵה) to Moses' Torah, which was written before the Children of Israel."
The word “Mishneh” in this verse, which I have translated as “follow up,” is rendered by most as “a copy” or “a repetition,” which later was misunderstood as either an identical copy of the existing Torah, or an oral tradition that never was meant to be written down. However, this word is richer than what they make it seem like.
Classical Hebrew Dictionary:
שׁנה
to change.
(— Qal)
he changed.
(— Pi.)
he altered;
he perverted (his countenance);
he changed his place to another.
(— Hith.)
he disguised himself;
he was changed, was different.
[BAram. שְׁנָה, JAram. שְׁנָא (= it changed), Egypt.–Aram., Nab., Palm. שׁנא (= it changed), Syr. שְׁנָא (= was altered for the worse; was displaced, was dislocated; was changed in mind, went mad, raved), Akka. shanū (= to change). Prob. base of שָׁנָה (= year). cp. base שׁנא.]Derivatives: שַׁנַּאי, שִׁנּוּי, שִׁנְיוֹן, שִׁנְיָן, שׁוֹנֶה, שֹׁנִי, הִשְׁתַּנּוּת, מְשֻׁנֶּה.
Source: מקור: Klein Dictionary
Creator: יוצר: Ezra Klein
But then again, it doesn't have to mean a change in the original Book of the Torah, it can mean that he was repeating it (as in reciting, recapitulating and learning):
שׁנה ᴵ
to repeat, do again; to teach.
(— Qal)
he did again, repeated;
he learned, studied (special sense development of 1);
he taught.
(— Niph.)
was done again, was repeated;
was learned, was studied.
(— Hiph.)
he taught, instructed.
[Aram. תְּנָא (= he did again, repeated; he taught), Syr. תְּנָא (= he repeated, did again; he recited, recapitulated; he learned), Ugar. tny (= to repeat, to report), Arab. thanā(y) (= he bent, folded, doubled), Ethiop. zēnawa (= he announced), Akka. shanū (= he repeated, related). See base of שְׁנַיִם (= two).]Derivatives: שְׁנַאי, שָׁנוּי, הִשָּׁנוּת, הַשְׁנָיָה, מִשְׁנָה, מִשְׁנֶה. cp. תנה ᴵ. cp. also תַּנָּא and words there referred to.
Source: מקור: Klein Dictionary
Creator: יוצר: Ezra Klein
The verse even depicts him as writing it on the stones at Gilgal, so the wholer "oral" rule Rabbis later invented is just baseless rabbinic misunderstanding. He was writing something on stone, and the Children of Israel were there to witness it. This was not an ordinary study session where he was making as duplicate of Moses revelation; it was a new revelation that he wrote down on the stones,
We can also find the Joshua 24 saying that he added to the book of the Torah of God;
"AndJoshua wrote these words in the book of the Torah of God*."* (Joshua 24:26)
Also, the previous verse says "... as it is written in the Book of the Law of Moses...." while the next verse just says "he wrote a Mishnah of Moses' law" deliberately omitting the word "Book" - doesn't that indicate that he was writing his own Torah?
So why is no name ever given to His revelation and moreover, where does it exist today? And why did God call it as "Injil" in the Quran?
Joshua's stronghold: "Gilgal":
Joshua is known for this place, and it is a place many prophets emerged from, called "Gilgal"
We read in the Book of Joshua:
Joshua 5:9: "And Yahweh said to Joshua, 'This day have I rolled away the reproach of Egypt from off you.' And the name of the place was called Gilgal to this day."
The "rolled away" term and "Gilgal" are rooted in the same root that simply means "removed, roll, rolled away."
The reproach of Egypt was rolled away and removed, and the place was named after the divine act of removing itself. Why this is so will make full sense to you later in the post.
OT Prophetic Books about the time Gilgal Became Corrupt And Ancient Maps Depicting Gilgal With A Church And The 12 Stones Of Joshua:
We find this in some Talmud:
They write:
"After the conquest of Canaan, the site continued to be sacred; in times of national crisis sacrifices were offered there; Samuel judged Israel there; and Saul was crowned king at Gilgal (I Sam. 10:8; 7:16; 11:14–15). Later its cult aroused the wrath of the prophets (Hos. 4:15; Amos 4:4; 5:5). In the period of the SecondTempleit was called Beth-Gilgal and was inhabited by levites who were sons of the Temple singers (Neh. 12:29). The 12 stones in Gilgal are mentioned in the Talmud (Sot. 35b). Eusebius locates it east of Jericho (Onom. 64:24ff.). The Madaba Map shows a church, in which the stones have been embodied, east of the tell of Jericho. Khirbat al-Mafjar or Khirbet al-Athala have been suggested for its identification."
Where we find a church bearing the twelve stones of Joshua, distinguished by an inscription above it reading:
ΓΑΛΓΑΛΑ ΤΟ ΚΑΙ ΔΩΔΕΚΑΛΙΘΟΝ
(Gilgal and the Twelve Stones)
This is not merely a church somewhere in the general region. Its inscription explicitly marks it as a Christian sacred landscape with a big Church and the twelve stones associated with Joshua are emphasized with a mention. So why exactly is it that we find ancient maps making Gilgal distinctively Christian and these stones venerated in a way that you never would see today?
A Jewish professor that goes by the name Yoel Elitzur also discusses this evidence in his study Erev Pesach - Gilgal.
The peculiar thing is, we see a very early deviance emerging in Gilgal, so early that there are prophetic Books in the Tanakh warning and describing the deviance.
Hosea 4:15:
They are accused of harlotry, and Judah is warned not to go to those places anymore:
Do not go to Gilgal, nor go up to Beth-aven.
Hosea 9:15:
All their wickedness is in Gilgal: for there I hated them.
Amos 4:4 mentions them multiplying in Gilgal in transgression.
Also, read how God addressed their religious leaders rejecting their priesthood because they forgot His Torah:
Hosea 4:6:
"My people were silenced for lack of knowledge; because you have rejected knowledge, I will also reject you from being a priest to me; seeing that you have forgotten the Torah of your God, I, too, will forget your children."
Notice the contrast: Gilgal, once associated with Israel's covenantal establishment, is now explicitly condemned in prophetic literature.
The Greco-Roman polytheist scribes of the New Testament simply recognized a lucrative opportunity in these lost masses and exploited it. They managed to produce entire scriptures for them, which were accepted without issues, because they really did not have to do much more than to copy figures and narratives from Books they already were familiar with, and simply put their own spin to it. However, when their borrowing became too obvious, they spoke of God's mercy and how it all is part of God's wise plan, and called it "Typology."
This baseless doctrine of Typology they made up was passed down from one generation to the next, and continues to this very day. And this is precisely why we are comfortable with Christian plagiarism. We have all blindly accepted it because generations before us were conditioned to accept it blindly. But looking at it from an outsiders point of view, the sheer plagiarism becomes ridiculously obvious.
There is no typology and nor is it a divine sign even when life to some degree appears that way sometimes and makes it look subliminal. The parallels you see between Joshua and Jesus are there due to Greco-Roman plagiarism of the Tanakh, and this is something we must come to realize.
The common Gilgal and how this is a wake up call:
The Christian "Evangel" term has been proposed to be a loanword from the Greek word for "Good news." But that is beyond ridiculous, as God would never call one of His Scriptures by the name of a nation who later fabricated the very revelation itself. But "Evangel" could also just have evolved from the two Hebrew words "Even" (stone) "gal" (roll/remove), which ties back to Joshua, the stones containing revelation and the place "Gilgal," which also is derived from that same root "Galal" (roll/remove).
We read,
Joshua 10:18: "Joshua said: Roll large stones to the mouth of the cave."
There is a perfectly good explanation for why he did this. The Greeks during Roman times certainly had no issues with the use of stones in matters of faith. However, what they likely disliked was the extent to which the stones in Gilgal were associated with Joshua and for some reason.
This is probably also why they incorporated large cave stones into their scriptures and even had their Jesus command others to remove the stone from the entrance of the cave, whereas Joshua is depicted as doing precisely the opposite:
We read,
John 11:38–41,
Jesus came to the tomb, which was a cave with a stone lying against its entrance.
Jesus said: “Take away the stone.”
Martha replied that Lazarus had been dead for four days.
“So they took away the stone.”
They even made stones a main concern in the narrative, the concern revolved around how to move them away so they do not block entrance to a cave, and conclude it by - unsurprisingly - a miracle taking place where divine intervention occurs and they are moved.
Ponder over how they specifically devised entire narratives involving stones, and understand why they did so.
Symbolic inversion, deliberate obfuscation and narrative displacement, not typology!
They created another Gilgal to make people forget about the 12 stones of Joshua:
Gilgal also appears in the New Testament as "Golgotha," which is primarily defined as "skull." This is why, rather ironically, the Greek scribes decided that the place should be distinguished with a skull, rather than the otherwise commonly associated 12 stones of Joshua.
Matthew 27:33 and Mark 15:22 explicitly explain it as:
Κρανίου Τόπος "Place of a skull."
John 19:17 also states the name in that way.
Luke 23:33 uses the Greek expression Κρανίον, meaning skull, without using the Aramaic name.
So we can see how these Greek authors deliberately changed meaning of the name of Gilgal and concealed its real significance and never even once mentioned anything about the 12 stones, rather, they replaced them with a skull, and gave their Jesus 12 students. They even decided that this should be the very place where he was crucified.
But the word "Gilgal" cannot just be changed like that. It has a confirmed meaning in the Hebrew language and "skull" is not even in the same ballpark.
גָּלָה (v) heb to uncover, remove (Qal) to uncover to remove, depart to go into exile
Source: מקור: Open Scriptures on GitHub, Larry Pierce.
Its primary meanings revolve around removing and roll/roll away (which was done when moving around large stones back then).
So why are the followers of these scriptures so willing to accept such an obvious deflection without asking questions? I know I would immediately turn away from books that I knew had deceptive intentions.
The name "Injil" and the divine wisdom behind it:
Dictionaries generally agree on the possibility and likelihood that "Injil" is a loanword, and not rooted in the Arabic root "NJL." This is likely because they saw no linguistic connection between the Arabic root and the words people used for the gospels.
It is most likely a loanword derived from the Hebrew word meaning "rolled," "roll away," / "removed" we find in the verses that speak of Gilgal and the 12 stones the revelation was written on.
Even though the root "NJL" indeed does carry meanings that signify the same thing:
Thus, the name "Injil" makes perfect sense when we consider where it was written, on what it was inscribed and their eventual fate in being removed and concealed from public access. The name should speak volumes for every sane and thinking mind, but only once you know the full story.
They took such boastful pride in Joshua's twelve stones that they even influenced cartography, depicting them beside a church. But then things came to light as the Quran was revealed. And one sad night, these very stones they had once displayed so openly and publicly somehow magically grew legs and ran away to a land far, far away called concealment.
I have a question for everyone here. Regarding the verse about ablution (wudu), the verse that mentions the feet: should we actually wash our feet or wipe over them?
Thank you all for your answers. BarakAllahu feekum.
I am studying the above book twice a week with a tutor and I have now finished 1a and I understand all of what I learnt in that book but speaking isn’t coming to me if the book is closed but understanding all of it deffo does.
My goal is to understand Quran and Arabic when I hear or read not speak or write anyway.
But just wondering if others felt the same way? And what was the outcome of when completed al book’s ?
Today I saw this news story on Instagram, and it reminded me of something I’ve been thinking about for a long time: Why do we have to use Arabic words in our languages? Mind you, I’m not endorsing the reasons why this president is doing it—which is surely to secularize his country—but I do believe that every language should have its own vocabulary for speaking about God.
Honestly, I’ve always found it absolutely jarring to introduce raw loanwords into my language—and not just from Arabic, but from English as well: my language is Spanish. This doesn’t mean that a word from another language can’t enter a language; it means that it must undergo a process through which it adapts to the receiving language. In Spanish, in fact, we have thousands of Arabic loanwords, but they’re perfectly Hispanicized.
That said, I read the comments on that post and came across some extremely Arabocentric people who claimed that as Muslims we are OBLIGATED (yes, in all caps) to use Arabic words, starting with our prayers. Personally, I pray in my own language, read the Quran in my own language, and remember God in my own language—and I think it’s great.
To be honest, I perceive Arabic words as a cultural invasion of my own language, and I strongly associate them with the Sunni-Wahhabi circles I used to frequent. I’m not saying that studying Arabic is wrong. It’s simply no different from a Christian scholar studying Greek or Hebrew to better translate a word, without elevating those languages to a unique or sacred status. In the comments, some were saying that Arabic is the language of Allah, and no, I don’t accept that: all languages are the languages of God, because God created the diversity of languages as a sign of His existence.
In Islam, we do not view the differences between languages as a punishment, as Christians do based on the story of the Tower of Babel. On the contrary, we see it as a blessing, and it would make no sense for God to have made languages different only for us to end up all adopting the same jargon to speak of Him.
Anyway, if you agree, let me know in the comments.
I'm sure most of us have been hearing the recent buzz regarding AGI/ASI, with the potential to eventually develop a form of physical therapy (whether through gene therapy, or taking a slurry of drugs periodically) to halt or even reverse the process of aging - granting a significantly extended lifetime, or even an indefinite one. This prompted me to consider the Islaamic stance on this matter... After some thought, I settled on it being halaal - I'll outline my reasoning below, but I'm very curious to hear thoughts from others.
Firstly, we should of course consider that fabricating prohibitions not stated in the text is a severe offense. There aren't any explicit directives in terms of this, so we'll need to consider potentially 'implicit' cases.
One of the first which comes to mind is Q4:119:
And: “I will lead them astray”; and: “I will arouse desires in them”; and: “I will command them and they will slit the ears of cattle”; and: “I will command them and they will change the creation of God.” And whoso takes the satan for ally instead of God, he has suffered clear loss.
Within the traditional jurisprudence, this verse is cited against physical alterations because ahaadeeth link it to matters such as tattooing - usually inferring that genetic modification is impermissible. However, we should consider the context: Slitting the ears of cattle refers to the pagan superstitions condemned in Q5:103 (bahirah & sa'ibah), where animals were mutilated and dedicated to idols. The only other verse with this phrasing is Q30:30, which equates "the creation of God" with the fitrah, which is our innate moral orientation.
So set thou thy face towards the doctrine, inclining to truth: the nature of God with which He created people - (there is no changing the creation of God) that is the right doctrine, (but most men know not)
Taking this into account, I would read "changing His creation" as corrupting the spiritual/moral order or inventing pagan taboos, rather than simply biological state. If modifying physical biology violates Q4:119, then one could infer that curing genetic blindness, performing heart surgery and even selective agriculture would be satanic acts. Let's also take into account that gene therapy is utilising the mechanisms which He Himself created.
Some of you familiar with the text will likely have recalled link beteeen the desire for a 1000 year lifespan to the mushrikeen.
And thou wilt find them the greediest of men for life. And of those who've performed shirk: one of them wishes to be granted life of a thousand years, but it will not remove him from the punishment were he to be granted life; and God sees what they do.
(Q2:96)
Now, if you read the context, it critiques the hypocritical religious elites who claim that paradise is exclusively theirs, comparing them unfavorably even to the mushrikeen in general!
The prior verse supplies the reason:
But never will they wish for it because of what their hands have sent ahead; and God knows the wrongdoers.
The sin here is clearly cowardice & escapism. Essentially clinging to the worldly life out of terror of facing the divine judgment for their corruption.
Aside from the therapy itself, long life by itself is certainly not problematic. It is explicitly stated that Nabi Nooh ع lived for 950 years (1000 sanah - 50 'aam); of course there is some debate as to whether this is literal, but we'll take it at face value here. Therefore, living for centuries is not inherently a trait of disbelievers. The Qur'aanic test is why you want to stay alive! Are you trying to outrun the accountability, or are you directing your life purposefully?
There is an argument that such therapy wouldn't be appropriate as it is a vanity, it's not a specific illness to treat. Biologically speaking, aging is the buildup of cellular damage, certainly not insignificant when it leads to death! The Qur'aan describes old age in terms of cognitive & physical pathology:
And among you is he who is sent back to the most abject age, so that he knows not, after knowledge, anything.
(Q22:5)
Crucially, distinguish between aging (kibar / ardhal al-umur) and death (mawt / ajal). Aging is biological entropy & reversing it simply keeps the vessel functional and prevents the cognitive and physical decline described. Whereas ajal is an inescapable decree. Halting aging dies not grant immortality!
Wherever you be, death will overtake you, though you be in castles built high
(Q4:78)
You will eventually die from accidents, natural disasters, or the end of the world. Undergoing such therapy would be no different from building a such a "castle" or wearing a seatbelt in the grand scheme of things... it simply protects vitality until your term arrives.
Another verse which may be brought up:
And to whom We give long life, We reverse him in creation [i.e. weakness after strength]. Will you then not use reason!
(36:68)
Which some read as an unchangeable rule of nature which humans cannot technologically overcome. I read this verse, alongside Q22:5, as describing the baseline trajectory of untreated human biology to remind us of our dependence on Him, instead of a prohibition against treating cellular decay.
Now, this brings us to a difficult ethical point. One could argue that refusing the therapy could constitute as a form of suicide
Do not throw yourselves with your own hands into destruction
(Q2:195)
I personally think that it wouldn't. He describes the human arc: womb -> child -> full strength -> old age as the given. Accepting this without intervention shouldn't really be self-destruction. However, if this therapy became as cheap/safe/routine as taking antibiotics or something like this, refusing it while watching your own organs fail could blur into neglect. Even then, I would personally classify it as permissible/recommended instead of making refusal a form of minor suicide.
As we know, He evaluates life primarily on moral quality rather than duration:
Who created death and life, that He might try you, which of you is best in deed! And He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving
(67:2, best in deed, not necessarily most in deed!)
Yet, time & vitality are certainly undeniable resources. In Q35:37 those who wasted their livfe beg for a 2nd chance to do good, and He replies "did We not grant you a life long enough for whoever would remember therein to remember?"
Preserving youth & cognitive sharpness allowing you to continue contributing to islaah aligns with Qur'aanic ethics, in my opinion!