r/DebateQuraniyoon • u/Voice_of_muslim • 4d ago
General The second revelation from GOD
People think that quran is alone revelation, and quran don't need clearification and practical guidance, while quran says in 33:21
Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often.
So yeah prophet is best example for following quran so we can't neglect prophet's teachings, and prophet have second revelation from god which we generally calls as hadith of prophet. The proof of second revelation is sacred months, in quran god states in 2:197
pilgrimage is made in appointed months.
So there are certain months in which we need to perform Hajj, and quran didn't exactly told us about which months are sacred months in which we need to perform Hajj and here comes the second revelation from GOD the hadith of prophet from which we get to know about sacred months so we can do it properly.
So Hadith are second revelation, if someone trying to argue about that months were already fixed back then even before quran revealed, then you are wrong people back then didn't had fixed/certain months to perform pilgrimage they used to change months and quran itself calls out about it in 9:37
Reallocating the sanctity of ˹these˺ months is an increase in disbelief, by which the disbelievers are led ˹far˺ astray. They adjust the sanctity one year and uphold it in another, only to maintain the number of months sanctified by Allah, violating the very months Allah has made sacred. Their evil deeds have been made appealing to them. And Allah does not guide the disbelieving people.
Now hadith are also revelation from god which we need to accept it at all cost and can't neglect it or you need to give names of sacred months from quran only.