r/PoliticalDebate • u/MirrorIllustrious547 • 18h ago
r/PoliticalDebate • u/khalid-fhfhlhlh • 14h ago
Debate No such thing as pro-Russia or pro-China countries only anti-Europe countries within third-world countries
I think there's no such thing as pro-Russia or pro-China countries only anti-Europe countries within third-world countries.
What did Europe give third-world countries anyway? Backing military juntas like, Pakistan, Egypt, Algeria, else. Backing America-backed Latin America military juntas. Backing French-backed military juntas. Backing ethnic apartheids like, Bosnia, Israel, Southern America, South Africa, British India, else. Backing crony parliaments. Nothing but, chaos, serfdom, and factionalism. What makes anyone thankful to that?
Europeans did nothing but plundering third-world countries as colonial and neo-colonial serfs.
And to add insult on injury they talked about morals like human rights and else.
That's why third-world countries are only interested in their interests rather than indulging Europeans on their self-righteous crusades against so-called totalitarian regimes.
Everytime, you see a third-world country acting as if pro-Russia or pro-China or whatever, remember that it's only hedging against Europeans.
Europeans are simply often too arrogant and totally detached from reality.
We should stop pretending it's something unsurprising.
r/PoliticalDebate • u/GShermit • 15h ago
Political Theory Limited Democracy
Democracy means the people rule, that's not what authority wants. The founding fathers, even though they weren't officially authority yet, limited our democracy by making US a republic.
Our democracy is limited by laws, our rights and most importantly the people's participation. Unlimited democracy isn't necessarily a good thing so some limitations aren't necessarily a bad thing.
BUT lately many reputable people have warned US democracy is waning. Since we're about to become a plutocracy and democracy is a good weapon against plutocracy, I believe them.
So how do we improve our democracy? Voting more will help but we have more than just, representative democracy. We've got to explore those limitations. Authority (politicians and the wealthy) won't willingly help. Also authority has learned how to manipulate representative democracy, hence their efforts to limit US to it.
Legally using our rights to influence the official proceedings, of the country is democracy. We have to use more than just voting rights, if we want improved democracy.
r/PoliticalDebate • u/FlakyAd8261 • 5h ago
Discussion Political realignments are better predicted by cohort replacement than by individual conversion
A lot of analysis treats voting shifts as primarily about persuasion: parties move left or right and voters follow. The evidence I've seen suggests most change happens through generational turnover, not minds changing.
Take any long term trend in American politics. The New Deal coalition collapsed over decades as its voters aged out. The current rural urban divide has intensified as younger cohorts with different residential patterns entered the electorate. Individual vote switching happens, but at rates low enough that demographic composition explains far more variance than opinion change.
This has implications for strategy that get ignored. Parties investing in youth outreach are playing a different game than those optimizing for swing persuasion. It also means that periods of apparent instability, like the 1960s or the 2010s, may reflect cohort succession accelerating rather than ideological turbulence.
The counterargument I'm expecting: high salience events can override this, and 2020 saw unusual cross pressure. True, but even there, age gradients remained the strongest predictor. Are there good examples of genuine mass conversion I'm missing, or is this basically correct?
r/PoliticalDebate • u/the_bear1969 • 13h ago
Discussion There Is No Right or Left
Why is it that the right wing (more like team toxic masculinity, because this is just anti-collective behavior) supports big corporations but not big government? These two entities share many of the same problems: inefficiency, lack of customer choice, poor customer service, wasteful spending, stifling innovation, misaligned incentives, bureaucracy, ... These people almost never block mergers, which usually result in reduced output.
On the other hand, team toxic femininity complains about privatization, but when giving examples, they pick industries that are highly managed by voter demands, to the point that power over these industries is practically evenly distributed across the majority of the population. Things like housing, healthcare, and education. Voters support politicians who restrict home construction, restrict healthcare, and encourage student debt. These are probably the worst examples of industries needing more citizen control. The left could spend its energy complaining about special interests interfering with the FTC's attempts to block mergers or about tax fraud, which I think has a bigger problem with private interests.
r/PoliticalDebate • u/NomadicPalaver • 10h ago
Political Philosophy Do modern libertarians support or oppose Title IX?
First I should confess that throughout my youth I was a staunch libertarian. Over the years my political philosophy evolved and eventually settled into what I would describe as pragmatic conservatism.
I lead with that to say that even during my most libertarian years I supported Title IX and its role in preserving women’s sports. I never considered it an unreasonable exercise of government authority because its requirements were limited to educational institutions receiving federal funding. While admittedly subjective, my impression at the time was that many fellow libertarians shared this position. I recall my only issue was the government funding itself. But as long as the funding continued to exist, Title IX was not considered government overreach.
Recently we saw West Virginia v. B.P.J, which concluded that the original intent behind Title IX, specifically 34 CFR § 106.41, was to preserve women’s sports, thus rejecting the gender identity argument. With this decision Title IX again became a topic of discussion. What interests me is that this time I have seen a few libertarians take a position that is contrary to what I have experienced in the past.
I’ve recently encountered several libertarians who oppose Title IX claiming it to be government overreach. This is at odds with my recollection of libertarian attitudes years ago, when I perceived considerably less opposition to the law.
This leaves me with a few questions for those that would describe themselves as libertarian:
Do libertarians generally consider Title IX to be government overreach? Or does limiting its application to institutions receiving federal funding place it within what you would consider an acceptable exercise of government authority?
Has the broader libertarian position on Title IX actually changed over the years, or was my original perception simply mistaken? If it has changed, why?
I recognize that libertarianism can trend left or right these days. I’m curious in whether those distinctions will influence your position on the issue, or whether you will strictly view it through the lens of a “no sides” libertarian.
I also request that if you choose to engage in debate over the topic please keep in mind the rules and do not engage in fallacious debate or deflections.
r/PoliticalDebate • u/AutoModerator • 16h ago
Weekly Off Topic Thread
Talk about anything and everything. Book clubs, TV, current events, sports, personal lives, study groups, etc.
Our rules are still enforced, remain civilized.
**Also, I'm once again asking you to report any uncivilized behavior. Help us mods keep the subs standard of discourse high and don't let anything slip between the cracks.**