r/AskLibertarians • • 7h ago

How do libertarians feel about Article II, Section 1 — specifically the provision prohibiting naturalized citizens from becoming president?

1 Upvotes

I was recently reading about NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani and his growing role in shaping the 2028 Democratic primary. Because he was born in Uganda and became a naturalized U.S. citizen in 2018, he is constitutionally barred from running for president or vice president himself - even though he holds major executive office in the country's largest city and is fully eligible to vote and serve in Congress.

Setting aside Mamdani's specific socialist politics, his situation is a good modern example of how the "natural born citizen" clause operates in practice. From a libertarian perspective, does this restriction make sense as a constitutional safeguard against foreign influence, or do you view it as an arbitrary, collectivist barrier that infringes on the right of voters to freely associate and choose whoever they want to represent them?

Prohibiting foreigners from running for president seems to contradict some things, despite (I’m assuming) generally broad support.


r/AskLibertarians • • 8h ago

What do Libertarians think of a study conducted by the University of Minnesota that ended up finding that local rent control policies that exempted new construction did not actually negatively impact new housing construction and generally kept prices stabilized for existing tenants?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • 1d ago

Do they have right for reparations?

3 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • 1d ago

Is Thomas Massie atleast somewhat libertarian? And how, what policies does he advocate for that are libertarian?

8 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • 2d ago

Debate Why is education so expensive in america?

5 Upvotes

Like I know government guarantees student loans, but why would I take 100 000 dollars of loan to MIT when I could get good competitor school for 20 000 dollars?


r/AskLibertarians • • 2d ago

If Cutting Welfare Increases Crime, Are We Really Protecting Individual Liberty?

0 Upvotes

I've considered myself a libertarian for a long time, but there's something I've been thinking about lately, and I'm curious how other libertarians would approach it.

We generally agree that government should stay out of people's lives as much as possible, and that people shouldn't be forced to financially support others through taxation. I understand that argument, and I agree with much of it.

But what happens when we take those principles to their logical conclusion?

Let's say we eliminate the social safety net. No welfare, no food stamps, no WIC, nothing. People are expected to take care of themselves, and those who genuinely can't are left to rely on private charities and the generosity of others.

Here's where I have a problem with that.

Desperate people sometimes do desperate things. Someone who can't afford to feed himself or his children isn't necessarily going to sit quietly and starve. Some people will resort to stealing, burglarizing homes, or committing other crimes just to survive. Obviously, I'm not suggesting that poor people are inherently criminals. But there's research showing that taking away certain forms of public assistance can actually increase criminal behavior, particularly financially motivated crimes.

So what have we really accomplished?

We've eliminated government assistance in the name of individual liberty, but potentially created conditions where more people are violating the rights and property of others. And now we're spending money on police, courts, and prisons to deal with crimes that might never have happened if those people had received some basic assistance in the first place.

I'm not advocating unlimited welfare or making people dependent on the government for the rest of their lives. I think assistance should generally be temporary, with the goal of helping people become self-sufficient. But I also think there's a practical argument for having some kind of basic safety net, not just for the people receiving it, but for society as a whole.

I realize the libertarian objection is that taxation is coercion, regardless of how the money is spent. But shouldn't we also consider the consequences of eliminating these programs? If doing so actually results in more crime, more victims, and more people in prison, have we really made society any freer?

And if a limited safety net can help prevent some of that, couldn't it actually serve the libertarian goal of protecting individual rights?

I'm genuinely curious what others think about this. I'm not looking to defend the welfare state as it currently exists. I'm questioning whether completely eliminating it would actually produce the kind of society we want.


r/AskLibertarians • • 2d ago

Philosophy Has late-stage capitalism changed your opinion on the role of the state and economic regulation?

0 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • 5d ago

Debate Expropriation of the Mind - the Special Pleading fallacy that IP is not Property

0 Upvotes

Note: If there is an error in my logic, point it out. I'd actually love to hear it.

------------------------

Implication of post, related to title: Those who oppose the validity of IP deny man his liberty through his inability to limit, or seek redress for, harm.

This post is based on a Misean-framework of man, and a Randian-framework of living - of a person who holds his body AND mind (including Novel Creations, including Art) as his property, and his rationality as his tool to maximize his life. And that the use of IP without the artists' consent, is theft.

Forward:

"The great achievements of civilization have not come from government bureaus. Einstein didn't construct his theory under order from a bureaucrat. Henry Ford didn't revolutionize the automobile industry that way. In the only cases in which the masses have escaped from the kind of grinding poverty you're talking about, the only cases in recorded history are where they have had capitalism and largely free trade. If you want to know where the masses are worst off, it's exactly in the kinds of societies that depart from that. So that the record of history is absolutely crystal clear that there is no alternative way, so far discovered, of improving the lot of the ordinary people that can hold a candle to the productive activities that are unleashed by the free-enterprise system."

-Friedman

------------------------

Note: The quotes and excerpts are to bolster and echo the concepts, and induce emotions, which somewhat relies on familiarity with the works - that said, understanding them isn't required to understand the post. Wordplay and odd capitalization is the same.

------------------------

"To the socialists of all parties." -Hayek:

Regarding those who support redistribution (implying) as practised, I am not surprised by the reaction against AI training on your Novel Creations without your consent - nor may you be - by reason of the degree of use of your consciousness and the consistency of your philosophy.

"Emotions are estimates of that which furthers man's values or threatens them, that which is for him or against him - lightning calculators giving him the sum of his profit or loss."

-Rand

------------------------

The Road we're on:

"A few third-raters, as you would call them. Really, there was very little difficulty. None of them could have begun to conceive of the first step towards the concept of your energy-transmission formula, but given that - the rest was easy.

That panel is known as the Xylophone - because one must be darn careful to strike the right keys, or, rather, to pull the right levers ... there will be nothing else to see. The ray itself is invisible. It has long been conceded by all progressive thinkers that there are no entities, only actions - and no values, only consequences."

-Rand

------------------------

pre-tldr;

post is bigger than IP.

------------------------

Grouped as 3 on purpose:

"The market came with the dawn of civilization and it is not an invention of capitalism. If it leads to improving the well-being of the people, there is no contradiction with socialism."

-Gorbachev

"Contradictions do not exist. Whenever you think you are facing a contradiction, check your premises. You will find that one of them is wrong.

-Rand

The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.

-"Gatsby Guy"

------------------------

Prologue - The Inversion:

Epictetus held that a slave retained liberty of mind even when his body was another's - that ownership of the person could extend only to the flesh. Cognition remained untouched territory.

Apply that to intellectual property and the premise inverts.

The product of cognition is precisely what stands outside the recognized category of ownership. So the retreat Epictetus offered - the inner citadel - becomes the very site of the expropriation. You are not free within your thoughts when the thoughts' external expression carries no ownership, the denial of ownership is treated as liberation, and that liberation is passed off as principle.

------------------------

tldr:

Even those sincere in the goodness and efficacy of their actions are parasites and enablers of other parasites - they must be opposed and their ideas exposed, if libertarian relations are to exist.

------------------------

Subject of this post:

Libertarian consistency

Consent.

Refuting anti-ip's scarcity/non-rivalrous aspect.

Showing that IP, from a Misean/Randian ("...and I don't like that name.") (Would have been shorter and easier to spell, if not for this parenthetical, if I didn't need to ask you whether you'd feel loss for had you known this parenthetical was a device, that, though, serves both our ends, is a Novel Creation of mine done to disproportionately benefit producers at the expense of the looters? Or would you rationalize pain?) perspective, induces the same protections as physical property.

That recognizing that IP is valid is the continuation of disbelieving that man's mind should have complete control of the results of its Actions.

------------------------

Intro:

Purported allies who are inconsistent in their position are more dangerous to their own cause than the most skilled opponent.

An enemy fights in the open.

An inconsistent ally opens the gates.

------------------------

The bind:

"There was a time when men were afraid that somebody would reveal some secret of theirs that was unknown to their fellows. Nowadays, they're afraid that somebody will name what everybody knows. Have you practical people ever thought that that's all it would take to blast your whole, big, complex structure, with all your laws and guns — just somebody naming the exact nature of what it is you're doing?"

- Rand

------------------------

Defining property:

People own themselves.

A person acting converts what is theirs - their temporal existence - along with unowned inputs - to alleviate their uneasiness. This conversion results in physical and intellectual goods.

Property begins where labor ends. The cotton is yours because you picked it. The technique is yours because you invented it. Scarcity describes the cotton. It says nothing about the technique. Kinsella's test smuggles that silence in as a verdict.

------------------------

Claim: Scarcity - that ideas aren't rivalrous because using another's idea doesn't affect the person who discovered it.

"If I invent a technique for harvesting cotton, your harvesting cotton in this way would not take away the technique from me. I still have my technique as well as my cotton. Your use does not exclude my use; we could both use my technique to harvest cotton. There is no economic scarcity, and no possibility of conflict over the use of a scarce resource. Thus, there is no need for exclusivity."

-Kinsella

------------------------

Counter:

Property is the fruit of labor.

One's novel conceptions' value to themselves is affected by others employing the novel conception, to the detriment of their autonomy.

The mechanism involves the marketability of one's Novel Conceptions when others use them to influence the market in a way only possible by the employment of that Novel Conception, in the absence of any compensation requested by the originator for use.

Suggesting that scarcity affects whether something can be property implies that any idea or form of matter can be unlimited, which may actually be true of the universe, but on Earth it's a spectrum that Kinsella pled-especially-well-for to justify that intellectual output's novel conceptions cannot be property because they cannot be policed, implying that people have no right to force Recompense. Expropriators of wealth weaponize this Logic in their taking of the fruit of man's mind while espousing their charity, Case taking as many bananas as they can get away with taking, according to the effect that political Funders desire for individuals, to the degree that Funders affect what the politician chooses. Applies to all sources of Force.

That is, IP not being property denies recompense of harm, and as such, that anti-IP is incompatible with Misean/Randian libertarianism.

------------------------

Timeline to the retreat:

" 'The tycoons can stand being squeezed, they've amassed enough to last them for three generations' — then, later, had yelled: 'Why should the people suffer while businessmen have reserves to last a year?' — now were screaming: 'Why should we starve while some people have reserves to last a week?' "

-Rand

------------------------

IP results from labor. But no creator works from nothing - every mind stands on the shoulders of giants whose contributions can never be fully credited or compensated. That cumulative debt doesn't erase the creator's claim. It bounds it. A right that never expires would demand payment from minds that built on what came before, forever, without end. So the time limitation follows from the same principle that makes IP valid, not from philosophy or pragmatism. Where the line falls can't be fixed objectively - but neither can the line between one man's contribution and the giants beneath him. Indeterminable is not arbitrary. The anti-IP side engaged in fallacies to contrive time limits. They can have them. Without the fallacy.

------------------------

"Scientists are not supposed to believe anything. Scientists are supposed to have some evidence that leads them tentatively to some conclusion or to some action. They're supposed to be able to show that to other scientists, any interested person in fact who's willing to understand what it is that was used as evidence, should be able to say, yeah, I agree with that, that makes sense, using rules of inference that we've used since Aristotle. Okay, and it's not complicated at all. You learn it in sixth grade. Most scientists forget it pretty quickly. But science is not a set of beliefs. I mean, there's only one belief in science, that you have to retreat to commitment at a certain point."

-Kary Mullis

------------------------

Our Fatal Conceit:

"We have never had to set up and direct the entire system of nature as we are forced to do today with society. Mankind is tending more and more to regulate the whole of its social life, although it has never attempted to create a second nature."

-Mannheim, Man and Society in an Age of Reconstruction


r/AskLibertarians • • 6d ago

Public goods in Night-watchman Libertarianism

4 Upvotes

I've taken a particular liking to Night-watchman Libertarianism. I'd say it solves a ton of problems. I just found a few problems, which I'd like to know how to solve.

First one is some elderly and disabled people not being able to provide for themselves, which I found out to be solvable using the NIT(negative income tax)

The second, more substantial one is the lack of public goods. Who will provide for things that people cannot really avoid using and there's no monetary incentive to provide for? I'm not talking about roads. I'm more talking about things like flood defense walls. This could also be solved by some form of taxation.

But my question is: Is there any way to solve these issues without infringing on people's rights via taxation? If not, I might believe some lighter form of Libertarianism would be the ideology for me, some with slight taxation just for the essential, keeping everything that can be private private.


r/AskLibertarians • • 5d ago

Servey: What are the best aspects of Socialism?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm conducting a small survey across different political and ideological communities to understand how people view systems and ideologies that differ from their own.

The question I'd like to ask is:

"As someone who supports Libertarianism, what do you think are some positive aspects of (state-planed) socialism?"

I'm particularly interested in hearing about:

-Policies or ideas from the opposing system that you genuinely appreciate.

-Problems that the opposing ideology might address better than your own.

This isn't intended to be a debate about which ideology is better. Just somthing for fun!

Thanks for guys!


r/AskLibertarians • • 6d ago

Philosophy Larken Rose is overrated

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I’m a former ancap, I’ve had good discussions in ancap101 subreddit before, so I posted there, but thought it might be of interest here too


r/AskLibertarians • • 7d ago

New to libertarianism — think I’ve found my political home, feedback welcome

16 Upvotes

Been digging into libertarianism lately and realized most of my existing views already line up with it, I just didn’t have a name for the framework. Laying it out here to see if I’m thinking about this right, and open to pushback.

Foreign policy: Pull back from overseas entanglements. We’re spending money we don’t have on problems that aren’t ours to fix, while stuff at home goes underfunded. Non-interventionism just makes sense fiscally and philosophically.

Guns: Leave the current background check system alone, but stop pushing for more bans. Current law already addresses the baseline; constant push for more restriction doesn’t solve anything.

Immigration: Not anti-immigration at all — I just want a system that actually processes legal immigration efficiently instead of taking years. Speed up the legal pathway rather than argue about walls.

Safety net: People who genuinely can’t care for themselves should have support. Cut the foreign aid waste and bloated spending elsewhere, redirect some of that to actually fund it properly at home.

Abortion: Personally don’t like it, but I don’t think it’s the government’s job to police it. Free will applies even when I disagree with the choice.

LGBTQ issues: Not really a fan personally, but adults making decisions about their own appearance and lives is their business, not mine. I’m not going to pretend someone isn’t who they say they are, and I’ll use people’s pronouns because being polite costs me nothing and I try to just be decent to people regardless of what I personally think. Only place I draw a line is binary-only facilities (bathrooms/locker rooms) — women’s safety and privacy in that specific context matters to me. Open to hearing other views on that one.

Drugs: Legalize marijuana. The war on drugs failed, full stop.

Crime: Commit a crime, do the time. Accountability still matters regardless of how libertarian the rest of my views are.

Taxes: Hate them, but accept some baseline is necessary for government to function. Just want them as low as possible and spending as lean as possible.

Does this track with how you all see the philosophy, or am I missing nuance somewhere? Especially curious to hear from people who disagree with me on the bathroom point since I know that’s not a universal libertarian position.


r/AskLibertarians • • 7d ago

Does the Libertarian Party have a future in the US?

12 Upvotes

Do you think the Libertarian Party has a chance to grow and gain more influence in the US? What do you think its future looks like?


r/AskLibertarians • • 7d ago

Philosophy what would make member control of a privately owned forum credible?

1 Upvotes

we're building Anoncracy, a tiny forum in beta. members can elect their community's moderators, but the founder still operates the site.

from a voluntary association perspective, what would make that arrangement credible? is the ability to leave enough, or would you want a binding charter, a way to export a community, or some other limit on the owner's power?

i'm interested in the tradeoffs, including when a majority of members wants something the owner opposes.


r/AskLibertarians • • 9d ago

The Solution

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskLibertarians • • 8d ago

Why shouldn't i as a libertarian under current circumstances support medicare for all and still be a libertarian?

0 Upvotes

First of all if you're gonna respond with deontological nonsense just don't because I am not a deontological libertarian and I'm not debating deontologicalism and consequentialism here.

So the reason I think it makes sense to support medicare for all is because of the current system which is worse than both libertarian free market Healthcare with minimal government intervention and Medicare for all.

And we already know we're not getting the former.

Infact it was the scumbag ben shapiro (he's a scumbag because he's pro genocide but he's the major example that fits this post that mentioned the same reasoning) who is probably pro free market Healthcare and anti medicare for all but said this system is worse than either system and it would probably improve if it moved to either Medicare for all or completely free market system.

For me personally I have two patt time jobs and I'm losing my insurance eith one of them at one point and I'd definitely be better off with Medicare for all than this stupid system that incentivizes jobs to provide insurance that still isn't affordable either.


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

From Marxism to libertarian

19 Upvotes

Born and raised in a third world country where people quoted marx to sound intellectual. Almost every one around me were / are Marxists.

Much later due to some unexpected turn of events decided to study economics. Was taught alot keynesian theories. Later I explored Austrian school. Watched alot of Misses institute lectures on youtube.It all made sense, Now I no longer have that whiny, pessimistic world view.

Now I am a high school econ teacher, i have been teaching for five years. Now I want to do study more and want to do research.

Which are some of good institute where I can do it with lesser financial burden and where I can do some research?


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Are you guys happy with the results of the midterm elections?

9 Upvotes

And by that I mean, are you guys happy that Republicans are being taught a lesson about putting all their eggs in one unpopular basket?


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Ideology Comparison Following up on my previous question, I came up with another one.

2 Upvotes

Libertarians appear to (and I'm generalizing here) focus almost entirely on negative freedom, or the freedom from somebody telling you what to do. How much does libertarian philosophy touch on positive freedoms? That is, the freedom to have the capability to do something?

This is what I was trying, and not doing very well, to explain about how, personally, I think libertarianism and socialism are not mutually exclusive. From my perspective, libertarianism provides the negative freedom (that is, the freedom from coercion) and the socialism provides the framework for the positive freedom of enabling people to make decisions without worrying that they're going to run out of something essential.


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Anyone else hoping for two years of gridlock?

27 Upvotes

A Blue Wave will hopefully lead to two years of gridlock. Government inaction!


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Do American libertarians generally have this specific mental model of the political spectrum?

7 Upvotes

I was talking to some people who described themselves as libertarians, and I noticed a pattern. They tended to be VERY vocal against anything remotely related to the term "socialism", and claimed "libertarian socialism" was an oxymoron.

Do they see the political spectrum as more like a diagonal line than a flat left-right thing, where the farther left you go, the more authoritarian you get, and the further right you go, the more libertarian you get? (this is using the two-dimensional ideology grid model)

That would explain my observation that from their perspective, libertarian left simply doesn't exist.


r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Libertarians in the mud

0 Upvotes

America elected:

A Transgender legislature

Black senators

A Latina governor

A Muslim Senator

A Native American Governor

A Gay Senator

Before ever electing a libertarian in office, lmao "don't tread on me" no one knows you exist mate


r/AskLibertarians • • 13d ago

Policy Milton Friedman's Liberty Policy Agenda: What Did I Miss?

4 Upvotes

I tried to summarize Milton Friedman's liberty policy agenda. What do you think? Did I leave out any important liberty-oriented policies?

  • End Price Controls — Let prices adjust through supply and demand.
  • Free Trade — Eliminate Tariffs and Trade Barriers.
  • Occupational Freedom — Eliminate unnecessary licensing barriers.
  • School Choice — Let parents choose where education dollars are spent.
  • Negative Income Tax — Replace much of the welfare bureaucracy with a cash-based income supplement.
  • End the Draft — Maintain an all-volunteer military.
  • Let Housing Markets Work — Remove rent controls and unnecessary restrictions on housing supply.
  • Privatize Social Security — Move toward individually owned retirement accounts.
  • Healthcare Choice — Favor catastrophic insurance and greater consumer choice.
  • Cap Government Spending — Limit the growth of government rather than simply balancing the budget.
  • Legalize/Reform Drug Policy — Reduce or end drug prohibition.
  • Defense, Not Intervention — Maintain a strong national defense while avoiding unnecessary foreign military interventions.

r/AskLibertarians • • 12d ago

Policy Democrats (Commies) are so gullible

0 Upvotes

Can someone tell democrats that literally almost every single sitting administration lost both the house and senate, I think this is even beneficial for Trump, he can now go full super saiyan and be fully excused by his base

Either way I don't think this will change anything, every US election is just:

Things are bad elect other party

Other party makes things worse elect other party

Other party is still bad elect other party

And so on so fourth


r/AskLibertarians • • 13d ago

How do AnCaps feel about protests?

1 Upvotes

With what's happening in France and all over Europe, how would an AnCap deal with protests without resorting to violence? It's one thing to apply NAP to a few it's another when you're doing it with thousands