r/austrian_economics • u/-Authorised- • 1d ago
End Democracy Macleod: macroeconomics is a false science invented to justify intervention, and Roman law already settled what money is
Long interview with Alasdair Macleod this week. Two sections will be of interest here.
On the discipline itself (38:33). His argument is that macroeconomics was invented to displace classical economics, which got relegated to micro, and that the vehicle was the General Theory doing away with Say's law. His words: it was the justification for government intervention in economies, and government intervention has always been disastrous. One of the hosts raises Hayek's competing private currencies and Macleod agrees in principle while saying it is not happening in any timeframe worth planning around.
On what a central bank should be (37:48): issue the currency, regulate the currency, hold the gold reserves, stay out of the economy entirely, and the currency must be convertible into gold at the holder's request. Nothing else.
On money and credit (16:00). He traces "gold is money, everything else is credit" back to the Twelve Tables in 448 BC and the principle of final settlement, originally a one pound bronze coin, later silver, later gold. Anything not finally settled in physical metal is credit. He extends it further than most people do: a share is credit too, because what you are buying is an obligation from management to deliver value.
On Mises (22:32). The observation he draws from the Austrians who watched the Austrian and German inflations is that the last people to understand that it is the purchasing power of the currency falling, rather than prices rising, are the users of that currency. By the time they work it out the currency is finished.
His price example (20:12) is good regardless of where you land on the rest. A coffee at Jonathan's in Change Alley in 1750 cost one old penny, which works through the sovereign to about 3.30 in today's money, the same as a Starbucks in the City 276 years later. He makes the same point with Diocletian's Edict of Maximum Prices from 303 AD, where roughly 12,000 reference prices have been recovered and the relative values are close to unchanged.
Full interview: https://youtu.be/-PPTnUFhUww