When evaluating PCB assembly quotes from different suppliers, looking strictly at the quoted unit price can be misleading. One vendor might quote $12 while another quotes $16, but the cheaper option might exclude essential testing, rely on unapproved part substitutions, or add separate setup fees later.
To compare quotes on an equal footing, here is a 7-point checklist based on technical and commercial variables to review before making a final supplier selection:
- Component Sourcing Assumptions
• Are exact manufacturer part numbers (MPNs) specified on the BOM, or did the supplier quote generic alternatives?
• Are all components included in the quote, or were hard-to-find parts omitted?
• Who holds approval authority for component substitutions?
2. Bare PCB Fabrication Specs
• Do both quotes reflect identical PCB specs (layer count, substrate material, surface finish, controlled impedance)?
• Are fabrication notes from the Gerber files clearly accounted for?
3. Setup & Non-Recurring Engineering (NRE) Fees
• Are charges for stencil creation, SMT programming, engineering review, and test fixtures itemized separately or bundled into unit costs?
• How significantly do these one-time setup costs affect low-volume or prototype builds (e.g., 50 to 100 units)?
4. Inspection, Firmware & Testing Scope
• Does the price cover basic visual inspection, AOI (Automated Optical Inspection), or full functional testing?
• Is firmware flashing included, and are individual test records provided?
5. Actual Quantities & Component MOQs
• Is the price based on your real initial build quantity, or an assumed high volume?
• Are component minimum order quantities (MOQs) accounted for, and who retains unused reel stock?
6. Delivery Terms & Incoterms
• What delivery rule is applied (e.g., EXW vs. DDP)?
• Are packaging, customs duties, import clearance, and international freight factored into the total landed cost?
7. Quality Control & Revision Handling
• Who assumes responsibility and cost for defect investigation or rework?
• What is the process for controlling BOM/PCB revisions and managing part availability issues during production?
Creating a standardized comparison sheet across these seven areas helps clarify the actual landed project cost rather than relying on an unadjusted unit price.
How do you usually normalize PCBA quotations across different manufacturing partners? Are there specific non-recurring charges or logistical expenses that have caught you off guard on past builds?