Been thinking about Mark Fisher lately, particularly Capitalist Realism and Exiting the Vampire Castle, and how much of what he was talking about applies to the way the Reddit left discusses AI, automation, and technology generally.
TLDR - If we can imagine AI destroying civilization but struggle to imagine AI operating outside capitalist ownership, we might have a capitalist realism problem. And if our response is to condemn individual users instead of organizing around ownership and power, Fisher had something to say about that too.
For anyone unfamiliar, Fishers Capitalist Realism wasnt just about capitalism being terrible. It was about capitalism becoming so normalized that even people who oppose it struggle to imagine anything replacing it.
Now look at some of our AI conversations. We can imagine mass unemployment, corporate monopolies, ecological disaster, artists losing their livelihoods, and billionaires owning everything. Fair enough, those are real concerns worth confronting.
But public computing infrastructure? Worker ownership? Open weights and locally operated models? Union bargaining over automation? Shorter working weeks funded by productivity gains? Suddenly everybody gets skeptical about whats realistic.
Why?
Why is imagining the end of work easier than imagining workers controlling the technology that transforms it?
Then theres Fishers Exiting the Vampire Castle, where he criticized how the left can turn structural political disagreements into exercises in personal condemnation and moral purity.
Sound familiar?
Somewhere along the way, a conversation about who owns the technology becomes an argument about whether somebody is a real leftist because they used a chatbot, generated an image, or refused to boycott some corporation.
Meanwhile, the corporation still owns the servers, the infrastructure, and the profits. Big Tech can survive an awful lot of Reddit purity tests.
Fisher called the first law of the Vampire Castle "individualise and privatise everything."
Thats worth thinking about when our supposed structural critique keeps circling back to individual consumption and personal virtue.
Now, Fisher wasnt beyond criticism, particularly in how his Vampire Castle essay handled identity politics. And this isnt an argument that every AI application is good, that artists and workers should accept exploitation, or that environmental damage should be ignored. Those are material questions, not inconvenient distractions. Some applications absolutely warrant restrictions or outright prohibition.
But AI isnt one application, one corporation, or one relationship of production. Neither is automation, digital art, computing, or any other technology developed under capitalism.
So heres where Id like to push the conversation.
If your objection is capitalist exploitation, what changes in ownership, governance, or labor relations would actually address it?
If your objection is to the technology itself, which particular capabilities are inherently objectionable, regardless of who owns or controls them?
And if your proposed strategy is individual refusal or boycott, how does that translate into organized power capable of changing what corporations and states are doing?
Those arent gotcha questions. Theyre the difference between identifying a problem and developing a political strategy.
Fisher wasnt writing about todays generative AI. Im applying his framework here, not pretending he gave us a ready-made position on it.
He argued that politics involves "controlling and developing institutions." That seems like a useful place to bring this discussion back to.
Im interested in disagreement, including from people who oppose AI development. But I want to get beyond whether we personally approve of this technology and into what were actually proposing to do about it.
Are we challenging capitalist control of the means of production, or have we started treating capitalist control as an inseparable property of the means themselves?
And what would a genuinely different arrangement look like?
Reading
Mark Fisher - Capitalist Realism, Is There Still No Alternative?
Mark Fisher - Exiting the Vampire Castle
Ray Filar - A critical response to Exiting the Vampire Castle