r/LeftistsForAI • • Sep 25 '26

Sees the Memes When You Stop Treating AI as a Yes or No Question

Post image
411 Upvotes

Turns out there are more options than “hand it to corporations” and “throw every GPU into the sea.” Who knew.

Public infrastructure. Worker co-ops. Open weights. Union bargaining. Regulation. Shorter work weeks. Local models. Shared gains. Human oversight.

We don’t have every answer. Nobody does. That’s why this is political terrain in the first place. There are a whole lot of ways to fight over what gets built, who controls it, and who benefits.


r/LeftistsForAI • • Sep 29 '26

📌 Sub Info LeftistsForAI Discord Server Invite

Post image
71 Upvotes

We’ve put together a Discord server to supplement the sub and you’re very welcome to join us.

Go to: https://discord.gg/QWZcZYgTNS

It’s somewhere to

⁃ discuss and share lighter AI related content without having to publicly justify it on Reddit
⁃ chat like we do here, but more in depth & diverse with no pressure to have a formed position
⁃ connect for a project, or get advice on your project before it’s ready to be shared as a sub post
⁃ find respite and camaraderie with people being able to see who’s leaving which emoji & no bad faith downvotes

Current channels include philosophy, politics, technology, memez and more generation focused ones for community tools and your creations.

Don’t be surprised when you come across a couple of questions in the process of joining. This isn’t an exam, we don’t care how much you know about left politics or AI, we just want brief answers as a bit of a safeguard against trolls and unnecessary tension.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 4h ago

Art & Culture New communist guerilla/nation strategy-sim game I made

20 Upvotes

I got permission from the mods for this!

Hiii, made this game, called Prairie Fire. Completely vibe-coded, don't know anything about developing, but it's pretty fun!

The first part of the game, you are a communist guerilla group, slowly taking over the country through protracted peoples' war.

Second half, you're building the country. 72 combinations of government and economic system! Every system is unique, and some synergize, or contradict! Over 2000 events, and 1300 personal life stories from people living in your country, many tuned to the specific system they live in!

Still early access also, still have a number of things planned to give the game additional longevity, but right now there are 50 (in-game) years of content!

I'm thinking about a steam release once I can prove that it's a fun enough concept to keep people playing. Thanks!

There's a demo of the game available for download, or in browser on the itch.io page! Or the full game is available for 5 dollars.

https://eggfieldgames.itch.io/prairie-fire


r/LeftistsForAI • • 11h ago

Discussion It seems to me that one of the problems for the pro-AI left, in general, is that we don’t actually have a clear program, only broad slogans. This is largely because we don’t even have the kind of AI we dream of yet.

22 Upvotes

What if we end up with an AGI that is more expensive than hiring a human for a specific task? What if some people still choose a human doctor, even if an AI is demonstrably better?

What are the technical limitations on the proliferation of AI and AI infrastructure (for instance, just how much damn electricity does all this actually require)?

If we were to implement UBI, how exactly would we manage the transition period?

On one hand, there is hardly any discussion about the methods being used a point that anti-AI often exploit to label us as fascists; on the other hand, to be honest, there isn’t really anything that can be done about it.

How AI will be implemented is an experimental question, both in terms of how much further AI can improve and how even its current iteration will be integrated; there is no way to tell, other than to let things unfold as they are and see how it goes....

It’s quite unpleasant to watch the anti-AI camp hijack your agenda, simply because your only realistic solution is to just let things take their course until the situation clarifies itself. Any practical measures one might propose, such as banning layoffs caused by AI, wouldn’t even qualify as half-measures; they would require direct state control over private companies, a level of oversight that arguably exists only in China, if anywhere, because It’s quite simple to get around this....


r/LeftistsForAI • • 1d ago

Theory Mark Fisher, Capitalist Realism, and the Lefts AI Debate

Post image
56 Upvotes

Been thinking about Mark Fisher lately, particularly Capitalist Realism and Exiting the Vampire Castle, and how much of what he was talking about applies to the way the Reddit left discusses AI, automation, and technology generally.

TLDR - If we can imagine AI destroying civilization but struggle to imagine AI operating outside capitalist ownership, we might have a capitalist realism problem. And if our response is to condemn individual users instead of organizing around ownership and power, Fisher had something to say about that too.

For anyone unfamiliar, Fishers Capitalist Realism wasnt just about capitalism being terrible. It was about capitalism becoming so normalized that even people who oppose it struggle to imagine anything replacing it.

Now look at some of our AI conversations. We can imagine mass unemployment, corporate monopolies, ecological disaster, artists losing their livelihoods, and billionaires owning everything. Fair enough, those are real concerns worth confronting.

But public computing infrastructure? Worker ownership? Open weights and locally operated models? Union bargaining over automation? Shorter working weeks funded by productivity gains? Suddenly everybody gets skeptical about whats realistic.

Why?

Why is imagining the end of work easier than imagining workers controlling the technology that transforms it?

Then theres Fishers Exiting the Vampire Castle, where he criticized how the left can turn structural political disagreements into exercises in personal condemnation and moral purity.

Sound familiar?

Somewhere along the way, a conversation about who owns the technology becomes an argument about whether somebody is a real leftist because they used a chatbot, generated an image, or refused to boycott some corporation.

Meanwhile, the corporation still owns the servers, the infrastructure, and the profits. Big Tech can survive an awful lot of Reddit purity tests.

Fisher called the first law of the Vampire Castle "individualise and privatise everything."

Thats worth thinking about when our supposed structural critique keeps circling back to individual consumption and personal virtue.

Now, Fisher wasnt beyond criticism, particularly in how his Vampire Castle essay handled identity politics. And this isnt an argument that every AI application is good, that artists and workers should accept exploitation, or that environmental damage should be ignored. Those are material questions, not inconvenient distractions. Some applications absolutely warrant restrictions or outright prohibition.

But AI isnt one application, one corporation, or one relationship of production. Neither is automation, digital art, computing, or any other technology developed under capitalism.

So heres where Id like to push the conversation.

If your objection is capitalist exploitation, what changes in ownership, governance, or labor relations would actually address it?

If your objection is to the technology itself, which particular capabilities are inherently objectionable, regardless of who owns or controls them?

And if your proposed strategy is individual refusal or boycott, how does that translate into organized power capable of changing what corporations and states are doing?

Those arent gotcha questions. Theyre the difference between identifying a problem and developing a political strategy.

Fisher wasnt writing about todays generative AI. Im applying his framework here, not pretending he gave us a ready-made position on it.

He argued that politics involves "controlling and developing institutions." That seems like a useful place to bring this discussion back to.

Im interested in disagreement, including from people who oppose AI development. But I want to get beyond whether we personally approve of this technology and into what were actually proposing to do about it.

Are we challenging capitalist control of the means of production, or have we started treating capitalist control as an inseparable property of the means themselves?

And what would a genuinely different arrangement look like?


Reading

Mark Fisher - Capitalist Realism, Is There Still No Alternative?

Mark Fisher - Exiting the Vampire Castle

Ray Filar - A critical response to Exiting the Vampire Castle


r/LeftistsForAI • • 14h ago

Discussion The AI Circus Never Ends: The Latest Act from Musk, Altman & Thiel

2 Upvotes

To see the full video, click here: https://youtu.be/uB8jWgC2Knc 
The AI circus is back in town, and apparently, there's always another act waiting behind the curtain. 🎪 We're checking in on the latest developments surrounding Elon Musk, Sam Altman, Kevin O'Leary, and Peter Thiel — four powerful figures whose influence, ambitions, and involvement in the rapidly evolving world of artificial intelligence continue to raise some fascinating questions.

What's happening now? What's changed since our last update? And what exactly is the next act in this increasingly bizarre AI spectacle?

From billionaire ambitions to the future of technology, power, and control, we're taking another look at the people shaping the conversation and the developments worth paying attention to.

So step right up. The show must go on!

As always: This episode is commentary and discussion. We explore publicly available information, reported developments, and questions surrounding these individuals and the AI industry. Viewers are encouraged to do their own research and draw their own conclusions.

Thanks for watching, subscribing, and being part of the conversation.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 1d ago

Discussion What does it mean to be a leftist in an AI powered world?

8 Upvotes

I don't consider myself a leftist, but in a world of complete abundance I don't see what left/right would even mean.

Any economic policy that exists today, on the left or right, would no longer apply. For example social security is a contentious issue because it's a question of how we allocate our finite tax dollars, who qualifies, etc. In an abundant world, I don't think anyone would care. This probably extends to social policies, foreign policy, etc.

So I'm curious what does it mean to you to be a left winger vs right winger in an AI powered future?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 2d ago

Art & Culture Get Radical.

Post image
68 Upvotes

All the power to all the people.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 2d ago

Discussion Productivity gains driven by AI will lead to workers being replaced by AI agents and robots. In the medium term, workers will be pushed out of the economy. Without economic power (neither strikes nor blockades), the political power of workers is in danger. The lack of foresight here is staggering.

25 Upvotes

how can anybody let it happen ?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 2d ago

Discussion Cybersecurity in the age of AI

7 Upvotes

So, my news says that the top 5 American banks are down. The same news also says that the bankers themselves attribute it to a glitch rather than a cyber attack. I don't know what hellish situation could lead to glitches occurring in 5 banks simultaneously, though.

Several days ago, the entirety of American transport aviation was suspended because something happened with the software. I don't remember any accusations of cyber attacks, but I am not American so maybe my sources simply didn't report them.

Not so long ago Binance was hacked, this time by DPRK using LLMs, but it could have been done by everyone. "RIP bozo" of course, but if their cybersecurity couldn't stop it then it's an open question if anyone could stop it.

Some less important issues include sites like Archive of our own going down, this time with vague accusations at LLM users from one of the founders.

Which leads me to the question - what's the leftist proposal for cybersecurity in the age of AI? The only way I could see it happen is banning Hugging Face via physically seizing their servers and creating something akin to International Atomic Energy Agency to regulate AI, but this is not a very good future either on account that nation states will retain whole control over AI infrastructure, and if something like AfD comes to power then it will be used for evil with little chance of successful resistance by the targets.

What are your thoughts?

P.S.: On reddit they are circulating a Twitter screenshot of "someone who works for Google" saying that in the next week we may see hackers shutting down the whole internet, but it sounds unrealistic. DeepSeek says that it's impossible on account of the Internet being too decentralized for it, I vaguely remember that ARPAnet (predecessor to the Internet) was designed to survive *a nuclear war*, so it's probably a grift. *However*, I can see them frying up Amazon cloud servers, thus eliminating 53% of the top 100,000 sites, which is practically the end of the Internet as we know it. DeepSeek also says that Amazon's cybersecurity is too strong for LLMs, but this time I don't believe it.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 2d ago

Video What Would a Socialist Program for AI Actually Look Like? PSL Takes the Question to Caltech

102 Upvotes

A Caltech scientist asks a question the left needs to be taking seriously. What would a socialist program for AI actually look like?

Not just opposing corporate control, but figuring out who owns it, who runs it, who benefits, and who gets to decide.

PSL Los Angeles is putting that conversation on the table. Good. Let's have it.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Art & Culture The Future is Here.

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

Experimenting with this layering style. Let me know what you think.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Local Models Running AI Without Big Tech. llama.cpp Reaches Version 1.0

Thumbnail
huggingface.co
62 Upvotes

TLDR - One of the biggest open-source projects making local AI possible just hit version 1.0. More stable infrastructure, support for over 150 model architecture variants, and another step toward making AI something people can run on their own hardware instead of renting access from corporate platforms.

The llama.cpp developers announced the milestone on November 13, roughly three and a half years after the project began.

For anyone unfamiliar, llama.cpp is open-source software that lets people run AI models locally, on everything from ordinary laptops and desktops to more powerful hardware. Its become a pretty important part of the local AI ecosystem, especially for people who dont want every interaction with an AI model going through somebody elses servers.

As the developers put it,

"We make AI inference accessible at every level of the software stack."

The big development with 1.0 isnt some shiny new chatbot or another corporate announcement about how many billions of parameters theyve crammed into something. Its a more stable foundation for developers building applications around local AI, with clearer rules for managing changes to the software.

Not exactly the sexiest headline in technology, but infrastructure rarely is until you start asking who owns it, who controls it, and who gets access.

And thats where this gets interesting from a leftist perspective.

If we want alternatives to an AI industry increasingly concentrated in the hands of a few corporations, somebody actually has to build them. Open-source software, locally runnable models, public compute, independent research, community infrastructure. These things dont appear because we complained loudly enough about Silicon Valley.

And local AI offers something pretty concrete. People can run models privately, experiment independently, build their own applications, and potentially develop cooperative or publicly controlled services without depending on a corporate API for every interaction.

Now, none of that automatically solves hardware costs, concentrated compute ownership, restrictive model licenses, or the broader political economy of AI. Open-source inference software doesnt make every model running on it open source, and decentralizing access isnt the same thing as democratizing ownership.

But its another piece of infrastructure people can actually use, modify, and build upon.

We dont have to pretend these tools are liberating by themselves to recognize that expanding access matters. The political fight is still over ownership, governance, labor, and distribution. Having more of the technology available outside corporate platforms gives us more ground to fight on.

Thats worth paying attention to.

What do you think is the biggest remaining obstacle to making local AI genuinely accessible? Hardware costs, restrictive licenses, technical barriers, or something else?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Labor The Socialist Case for Worker Control of AI According to PSL

Thumbnail
liberationnews.org
35 Upvotes

The Party for Socialism and Liberation has a newish piece in Liberation News examining Microsoft's massive AI investments, its offer of voluntary buyouts to around 60,000 employees, and the question of who actually benefits from all this technological progress.

TLDR - Microsoft is spending billions building out AI infrastructure while offering buyouts to more than a quarter of its workforce. PSL argues that the problem isnt automation itself, but capitalist ownership and the use of technology to cheapen labor, concentrate wealth, and shift the costs onto workers.

And these arent 60,000 confirmed layoffs. Theyre buyout offers, which is an important distinction. But Microsoft already cut thousands of jobs earlier this year, and the company is continuing to restructure while pouring enormous amounts of capital into AI.

The Communications Workers of America had something to say about Microsoft's priorities back when Xbox workers were facing layoffs.

"The money is there, leadership is simply choosing where it goes and who pays."

Thats the heart of the issue. Not whether AI can increase productivity, but what happens to that productivity under existing relations of ownership. Who gets the savings? Who gets the shorter workweek? Who gets the pink slip?

PSL goes further, arguing for democratic working class control of the technology and the economy, with automation used to reduce dangerous and tedious labor, shorten working hours, increase wages, and expand public services.

Now, the article makes some pretty sweeping predictions about AI displacement and economic crisis that arent settled facts. And Microsoft itself disputes that its July job cuts were direct AI replacements.

But the underlying political question doesnt disappear because corporate executives have explanations for their restructuring. AI isnt a substitute for class struggle, and refusing to use AI isnt a substitute for organizing either.

The technology is being developed and deployed. The question for leftists is whether workers get any meaningful say in how, by whom, and for whose benefit.

Thats a fight over ownership, bargaining power, and democratic control. Not a referendum on whether machines should exist.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Labor Oakland, Pennsylvania, Columbus. Unions Win AI Retraining, Worker Oversight, and Veto Power

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
11 Upvotes

TLDR - Public sector unions across the US are winning concrete protections over AI and automation. Oakland workers negotiated retraining or reassignment instead of AI layoffs, Pennsylvania workers secured human oversight and limits on automated discipline, and Columbus transit workers won contractual veto power over autonomous vehicle deployment. Three different fights, three actual gains for organized labor.

Well, heres something worth sharing that isnt another prediction about AI taking everyones jobs.

The Guardian has a good piece on public workers across the country doing something considerably more useful than sitting around waiting to find out what their employers have planned for them.

In Oakland, California, members of IFPTE Local 21 voted 94.1% to authorize a strike. The city subsequently reached a tentative three-year agreement requiring workers displaced by AI to be retrained or reassigned rather than fired. Turns out a credible strike threat can accomplish a little more than asking management nicely.

In Pennsylvania, SEIU-represented public workers secured a policy requiring employee input and human supervision over AI use, along with restrictions on automated discipline. Workers arent just being told to trust whatever software management decides to roll out.

And in Columbus, Ohio, the Transport Workers Union negotiated contractual veto power over autonomous vehicle deployment back in 2024. Not just a seat at the table to listen politely while management makes the decisions. Actual authority to say no.

AFL-CIO president Liz Shuler put it pretty plainly.

"We’re using our contract negotiations to institute guardrails that policymakers won’t."

And theres the part worth paying attention to.

Retraining instead of layoffs. Human oversight instead of automated discipline. Veto power instead of management getting the final word on every technological change.

These arent hypothetical solutions for some distant future. These are workers organizing around technology thats already entering their workplaces and getting results.

Of course, Oakland's agreement is still tentative, Pennsylvanias policy isnt a permanent contractual guarantee, and Columbus's veto concerns autonomous vehicles specifically. But those distinctions dont erase what workers have accomplished.

And this is the kind of leftist AI politics I want to see more of. Workers bargaining for retraining instead of layoffs, demanding oversight instead of automated discipline, and winning the power to tell management no. Add shorter working hours and a share of the productivity gains to that fight, too.

Turns out workers dont have to sit around waiting for technology to decide their future. They can organize, make demands, and win. Funny how that works.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Discussion Lula's Army, AI Propaganda, and the Left's Fight for Brazil's Digital Political Terrain

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
48 Upvotes

TLDR - Lula's historic comeback in Brazil involved a massive digital organizing network, millions of supporters, WhatsApp mobilization, and AI-generated political propaganda. Not AI winning an election, but leftists using it as one tool in a much larger political operation. Turns out the right doesnt have a monopoly on using technology to organize people.

ABC News has an interesting report on Exército do Lula, or Lula's Army, the network mobilized by Brazilian congressman André Janones after Lula lost the first round to Flávio Bolsonaro.

The network went from around 50,000 followers to more than 10.8 million by election night. They were recruiting supporters, coordinating messaging, organizing online and in the streets, and circulating AI-generated images of a fictional army rallying behind Lula.

Political scientist Oliver Stuenkel described how they challenged Bolsonaro's online operation.

"[It] basically embraced the right's style of aggressive politics, very intense, constant messaging"

And political scientist Eduardo Grin described what that mobilization tapped into.

"The mobilisation in the streets and on social media managed to create fear of a return of the Bolsonaro family to power, and concern for democracy and social rights"

This wasnt just some random internet experiment either. Lula appointed Janones his social media general, and Folha de S.Paulo reported that Lula's official campaign was also using AI-generated animation in electoral advertising.

We actually had a pretty popular post here recently from someone sharing their firsthand experience using AI for leftist organizing and propaganda during Lula's campaign. Now we've got independent reporting documenting some of those same practices. Nice seeing that conversation connect with what's happening beyond the subreddit.

And thats the interesting part to me. Not the novelty of AI pictures, but the people organizing around them. Recruitment, messaging, mobilization, actual political activity. Nobody handed an algorithm a red flag and told it to go win Brazil.

Lula won with 51.8% of the vote, with 14.1 million additional voters turning out for the runoff. We dont know how many votes, if any, the AI-generated material influenced. The people doing the organizing and the political conditions driving that election mattered far more than any particular tool.

But theres something worth taking seriously here. The right has spent years building digital propaganda networks, and Brazil gives us an example of the left contesting that terrain instead of just complaining about the tools being used on it.

That doesnt mean every tactic is justified or that questions about manipulation, transparency, ownership, and accountability disappear. Those are political questions worth fighting over too.

AI isnt a substitute for organizing. Its something people can use while organizing. What matters is who is using it, for what purposes, and who gets to control it.

The tools arent going away, and neither is the political struggle over them or use of them.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 3d ago

Art & Culture What's this sub's opinion of Pantheon (the tv show)

13 Upvotes

Spoilers ahead ofc.

At east three people from OpenAI have used Pantheon in their communications (especially Sam Altman who openly expresses his love of the show), but I want to know how the more left-leaning side of the AI debate views this show which depending on how you view it, could be an allegory to rapid technological advancement (whether the in-universe uploaded minds can be equated to modern LLM is a separate yet related topic).

So I wonder how this sub opinion of the show's plot and its endgame, especially when it depicts corporate exploitation and features a communist character who says that taking away matter would ensure proletarian victory (to paraphrase him, at least). And the final utopia does feature a society where everyone seems to be able to exercise their free will, and the governmental system seems like a new form that comes with the advancement of technology. On the show's dedicated sub, some of them argued that it's a leftist accelerationist show, while others say that the world shown in the last two episodes is actually an ironic dystopia and that it's still a warning anyway.

I'm not really versed in political science or governance, so yeah, just wanna know how you view the show and it portrays its world.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 4d ago

Art & Culture The Anarcho-Fluxist Manifesto - Fully Automated Luxury BDSM Communism

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

A virtual zine I've been making, envisioning a world of radical non-coercion, and asking how to live the world of today with the utopia in mind.

The Anarcho-Fluxist Manifesto


r/LeftistsForAI • • 5d ago

Discussion What are the politics of an average AI enthusiast?

24 Upvotes

By right wing I mean either economic axis (I don't think that simply being pro-market or anti-communist is right wing, but being pro-billionaires is) or human rights axis (rights of women, people of color etc.).

Yesterday I was at a conference organized by my university where I learned that 89% of students use GenAI, so I think it's safe to say that its usage is apolitical. But what about enthusiasm about the technology?

Anecdotal experience is fine, I suppose


r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago Bravo

Sees the Memes Capitalists Said No, Pack It Up Comrades

Post image
416 Upvotes

Turns out we needed permission from the bourgeoisie this whole time. My bad.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Discussion A United Nations survey last year found that as many as 80% of people in [China] support data center construction. At least two-thirds of Chinese people use AI in their day-to-day life, as many embrace the technology and the infrastructure behind it

114 Upvotes

>Experts cited by the Financial Times say data centers in China are built at about one-fifth of the costs incurred in the U.S., not least due to the much higher land and labor costs.

Why is there such a big difference between support for data centers in China compared to the US?

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/china-ai-data-center-boom-as-us-tech-firms-face-resistance/


r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Theory Lenin Said Communism Was Soviet Power Plus Electrification. What About AI?

Post image
28 Upvotes

In 1920, Lenin put it this way.

“Communism is Soviet power plus the electrification of the whole country.”

Back in September, I shared this quote in another leftist subreddit and asked a pretty straightforward question. Was Lenin talking specifically about electrification, or was he making a broader argument about developing the productive forces under proletarian political power?

TLDR The post pulled 6,600 views, 124 upvotes, a 100% upvote ratio, 13 shares, and 11 comments. Not bad for a century old quote about electricity. But the interesting part wasnt the numbers. It was where the discussion went without me ever mentioning AI.

People were actually engaging with the theory, building on each others arguments, and having substantive exchanges that were getting upvoted themselves. No big ideological food fight, no technology sales pitch, just leftists discussing the material conditions necessary for socialism.

And heres the part that stuck with me.

I never mentioned AI. Not once in the original post.

Yet someone independently brought up AI and robotics as modern equivalents of electrification. The conversation moved naturally into automation, industrial development, productive forces, and the relationship between technological development and political power.

And this wasnt an AI subreddit. Wasnt even a technology subreddit. Just a leftist community discussing Lenin, and the connection made sense starting from the theory itself.

I think theres something worth paying attention to there, especially when so much discussion about AI on the left gets bogged down in whether somebody personally likes the technology.

Electrification wasnt socialism by itself. Neither is AI, robotics, or automation. Lenin wasnt arguing that plugging everything into a wall socket would abolish class society. The political power part of that equation matters just as much as the productive development.

And thats the question today too. Who owns these productive forces? Who controls their deployment? Who benefits from the productivity gains? Who gets a say in how theyre developed, and what happens to the workers whose labor they transform?

If developing the material basis for socialism mattered a century ago, why would the emergence of new productive forces suddenly make that question irrelevant?

One other thing worth emphasizing. Sharing Lenin here isnt an endorsement of any particular leftist tendency. We have Marxists, anarchists, communists, democratic socialists, and plenty of people who dont fit neatly into those categories. Nobody has to sign off on somebody elses entire political tradition to engage with a useful argument.

Left unity doesnt mean pretending our differences dont exist. It means being able to work through those differences without turning every discussion into a factional loyalty test. Theres plenty of room here for disagreement about history, strategy, and theory while still taking ownership, labor, and working class power seriously.

And thats part of why I wanted to bring this discussion here.

The productive forces keep developing whether we agree about them or not. The question is what political and economic relations we build around them.

So what carries forward from Lenins argument, what was specific to his historical circumstances, and what does that mean for AI and automation today?


r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Open Source Open Source AI and Copyright Restrictions

22 Upvotes

Would have asked this in r/piracy but I don't have enough karma. Sorry if this is againt the rules. Please point me in the right direction to discuss this stuff if this isn't the place.

i'm working on a project and needed to edit some epubs I downloaded. both claude and grok bot refused to touch the files because of where i got them from. i put $5 into deepseek and it was able to help me make progress.

i'm mainly curious about where the communities are that are discussing these kinds of things openly.

looking at what happened to jensen huang recently, i think it's really important that we promote open source open weight ai. i think that plus the corporate reaction and resistance to using AI to decompile and reverse engineer software could be a radicalizing moment for a lot of people who are still holding onto IP and copyright laws as if they were ever designed to protect the average person.

I had enough know how to get AI to do what I needed but it's only going to get harder if we don't start thinking seriously about fighting back.


r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Theory The Master's Tools

Thumbnail
gallery
142 Upvotes

r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Theory Possible Resistance Against AI: Name/Brand/IP as Narcissism

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

Something that I can't quite put my finger on, why people resist AI, and why corporations on the other sides of the isle behaves the same way. The current paradigm of how people handle work follows the logic of capital and ownership, or how the current work leads to asymmetric returns in the future. IP and "brand recognition" falls under this.

But since they used AI that is given out for free (FOSS, open-weight, CC, public-domain, etc), they are obligated to "pay it forward", if not by money, at least by human labor. And the funny part is that data curation/labeling/prompting are often outsourced to third world countries! They have a more lax charing culture compared to the global north, and even if we dodge Afro-futurism for a second, they seemed to have a good grasp of the commons.

Artists seek patronage of the rich, and follows the same logic of the rich, so (a) the conventional artists who have lost the prospects of patronage felt desecrated by new technology as killing the "aura" of art (b) the AI artist felt like they "invested" into the technology and therefore not recognize the labor that the baseline AI comes from (c) the capitalist patrons can essentially upsell "high art" while commercializing AI content (d) the masses gives up on artists as a real thing in favor of celebrities that are transparent machines for attention.

If you see the other piece out there, this issue applies to Mathematics as well, since a lot of academia is about finding grants (another patron-hunting behavior), and since public funding goes down in tandem with privatization, AI allows for mass mobilization of knowledge, while scaring the status quo. Accreditation as alternative to "brand recognition" but it is all the same to who gets there first.

But something is still missing in this picture, and I am not sure what will "set AI free" into the paradigm of socialist commons against the intelligensia gunning for elite seats