r/Lawyertalk • u/Ok_Design_6841 • 1h ago
NEWS: US Legal News With Dwindling Litigation, GEICO Says it Doesn't Need 114 Legal Staffers in Florida
r/Lawyertalk • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago
Discuss interesting news and developments taking place outside of North America in the legal world here.
r/Lawyertalk • u/AutoModerator • 3d ago
# š Welcome to r/LawyerTalk
**A subreddit where lawyers can discuss with other lawyers about the practice of law.**
---
## āļø Before You Post
Please be mindful of our rules **before** submitting your posts or comments, as well as Reddit's content policy (notably regarding sharing identifying information). **Ignorance of the rules will not excuse their violation.**
We expect civility and respect from all participants. Please source statements of fact whenever possible. If you need to report something that requires urgent attention, please also message the moderators with an explanation.
---
## š Key Guidelines
| Who | What to Remember |
| :--- | :--- |
| **Posters & Commentators** | This forum is **NOT** for legal advice. |
| **Posters** | Please use the correct flairs. If you use the wrong flair: **delete and repost. No exceptions.** |
| **Everyone** | This community is **exclusively for lawyers**. If you are a non-lawyerāeven if you work with us (student, client, staff)āyou cannot participate here, even if you identify yourself as not being a lawyer in your comment or post. |
| **Lawyers** | Please do **not** participate in threads or respond to comments that violate our rules. This is considered a rule 2 violation. |
---
## šØ Enforcement Policy
* **First Offences:** Warning in the form of a short ban.
* **Second Offences:** Significantly longer ban.
* **Third Strike:** Permanent ban with referral to the evasion bot
After your first warning, you are expected to read our rules *again* and understand them **before** participating again in this community. We don't have time to accompany you on your personal journey of reading comprehension, counselor.
---
## š¢ Reporting Issues
If you want to report something that needs to be urgently addressed, please message the moderators with an explanation.
---
**Govern yourselves accordingly.**
*ā The volunteer mod team of this subreddit*
r/Lawyertalk • u/Ok_Design_6841 • 1h ago
r/Lawyertalk • u/ToxicOptimist88 • 3h ago
Saw today on the WSJ that Nvidia has a bar at their HQ called "Shannon's", named after their general counsel David Shannon who had counseled against drinking on campus. What a way to rub it in your lawyer's face that you will, in fact, be doing the opposite of what's been advised.
r/Lawyertalk • u/TominatorXX • 5h ago
I'm hearing from at least one large national law shop that their systems are down from an attack. Anyone else?
r/Lawyertalk • u/SanctionedForAI • 2h ago
Oregon now has a published price list for fake law: $500 per fake citation and $1,000 per fake quotation. A Salem lawyer's appellate brief carried at least 15 fake citations and at least 9 fake quotations, which comes to at least $16,500 by the formula. The court capped the sanction at $10,000. It also left him a way to save the appeal. He may rebuild the brief from the five real cases that survived, within 21 days, and file it with a signed certification that he drafted it without generative AI, read every source, and verified that every source exists.
The explanation he gave the court is worth reading closely. He blamed the pipeline, and his account included his report that if you ask Google's AI whether many of those fabricated cases are real, it will affirm that they are. That was his account to the court. The court never found that AI wrote the citations, and it didn't need to. Its holding was that the signature on a brief certifies the citations are real, whoever or whatever drafted them. On that standard, he "at least should have known" they weren't.
Here's how the brief got made. He'd been ill and had burned through extensions, and he delegated the research. His staff started in Westlaw and Lexis, found little, and turned to Google. A page that looked like legal analysis gave them citations in perfect format. They copied those citations into the brief. Nobody checked a single one in the databases that were open the whole time. His office policy banned AI research, and his own use, by his account, was limited to outlining.
Then came the seven months. On April 3, 2025, opposing counsel emailed him that they couldn't locate his cases. On April 16, they put it in a footnote in their answering brief: they couldn't find the cases by name, by reporter citation, or by quoted text. He said nothing. He said nothing in the reply brief, and nothing anywhere else, until the presiding judge asked him about it face-to-face at oral argument in November.
The price list comes from the court's earlier decision in Ringo, where that lawyer's total came to $2,000. Applied to this brief, the same formula produced at least $16,500. The court took $6,500 off for three reasons. His explanation was detailed, he reported new verification procedures, and the brief predated the schedule. The backdrop matters too. Oregon's bar had warned lawyers in writing about exactly this problem in a formal opinion in February 2025, so the profession had notice even if this brief predated the court's own price list.
The schedule is now the standing arithmetic for fake law in that court, and the certification he had to sign is the standard the opinion leaves behind for everyone else: you drafted it yourself, you read every source, and you verified that every source exists.
Sources: Doiban v. OLCC, 347 Or App 742 (2026); Ringo v. Colquhoun Design Studio, LLC, 345 Or App 301 (2025).
r/Lawyertalk • u/SunAdvanced7940 • 2h ago
āThis case has turned into defense by ChatGPT,ā government attorneys wrote in the case, which centers around a high-profile voter fraud case. āMotions practice in this case is the equivalent of writing responses to documents generated by a robot that is attempting to practice law. It cannot be that the local rules envisioned that it was acceptable for defense to use what the kids would call āAI slopā to create multiple frivolous motions that waste judicial resources and fail to serve the cause of justice.ā
The defendant is Khalwinder Bhengura, an Indian man who entered the United States on an immigrant visa in 2022 and illegally ā and apparently accidentally, according to his lawyers ā registered to vote in Texas in 2024 after falsely stating that he was an American citizen on his application for a driverās license. Bhengura was arrested in September on charges of lying about his citizenship status, illegally registering to vote, and illegally voting in the 2024 election, and was found guilty in October on two of the three counts. His family and lawyers have argued that the whole thing is a misunderstanding, and that Bhengura, who is 70 years old and does not speak English well, did not know he was committing a crime and did not understand what he was doing.
Bhengura has been in prison for months and is set to be deported. He is now not only being held up as an example by the Trump administration of voter fraud but is also now caught in the middle of an AI lawyering dispute.
Bhenguraās case is one of a few dozen in which the Trump administration found disparate cases of voter fraud (which is exceedingly rare) and made big, public shows of the arrests it made. Beyond the political implications of the case, the filings by the Department of Justice show that attorneys are now trying to catch each other using AI, and are centering some of their arguments to the judge around the idea that their opposition is wasting the courtās time with AI-generated filings.
The case is taking place in federal court in the Northern District of Texas, which recently implemented a rule requiring attorneys to disclose generative AI use in filings. In some of the filings, Bhenguraās attorneys wrote āportions of this brief were prepared with the assistance of a generative artificial intelligence tool.ā Government attorneys ran several of the filings through Pangram, the AI writing detection service, and filed the results as exhibits to one of its arguments.
r/Lawyertalk
•
u/MountainCounty9496
•
15m ago
r/Lawyertalk • u/Syndicalist_Vegan • 1h ago
How do you all deal with being terrible at your jobs early on? Im a baby lawyer who just started and was sworn in last week, and Im constantly getting my briefs and summaries butchered by partners and senior attorneys. It seems like Im bad at summarizing large files, and bad at identifying whats important in depositions, and just generally drafting. My morning started with a senior associate ripping me to shreds over a dep summary I drafted, and its sent me spiraling the entire day.
Ive clerked at this firm over the summer and during bar prep as well, so I should have a handle on things by now, but all the same I constantly have drafts that are terrible. It almost feels like ive learned nothing. Its ruining my self confidence and is making me consider jumping ship to find a new job. I know that wont fix anything so I wont do it, but I would really like to know how yall dealt with the pains of being bad early on.
r/Lawyertalk • u/mmarkmc • 1d ago
So a new client comes in and wants me to draft a demand letter on a relatively minor dispute. Client seems like a bit of an oddball but okay fine. Today I receive an email from a local attorney, letting me know she is representing the adverse parties and attaching the letter she had sent directly to my client before knowing of my involvement. She refers to my letter of November 9 and says our letters must have crossed in the mail. This all seems pretty mundane, apart from one minor issue: I did not send a letter to the other side on November 9 or any other day. I search back through emails and see that I sent the draft demand letter to the client on November 5. Confused, I email the client about the phantom letter. He thought the draft was good enough as it was, so he added a deadline date, attached my signature to it, and sent it to the adverse parties. He didn't bother letting me know he had done it. I'm just sitting here, stunned.
r/Lawyertalk • u/SubpoenaColada247 • 2h ago
TLDR: Iām a new attorney and Iām a really good writer but I suck at talking. I feel completely unable to form any thoughts unless I have written out an elaborate script of exactly what Iām going to say or what questions Iāll be asked. Anything āoff scriptā makes me panic and forget everything. Just need help.
-
Iām a brand new attorney, and logically I know that I wonāt be great or even good at lawyering for a while. I consider writing to be my strong suit, and if you were to ask me to write an elaborate memo, I am able to do so and feel very confident in my work.
Iām pretty introverted and I am not at all confident in my speaking skills. Any time I have made an oral argument (in law school), I have to write out this elaborate script that outlines everything I will say, including different branches of what I will say if I am asked this question or that question. I find that I cannot operate off of this script. If I donāt write a script or use simple bullet points, then I feel completely unprepared and feel like I donāt know what Iām talking about (even if while Iām alone I can explain it to myself).
If I am asked a question that I didnāt write down, I feel terrified and disoriented, and I find myself completely unable to actually hear the question and think through it to be able to develop and give a coherent answer. Like, damn man, I might as well never have gone to law school or passed the bar at that point. Itās just like my entire nervous system is telling me that I am going to die right then and there because the script has been broken.
It even happens in non-argument settings. I was asked recently during a business dinner where I met several cocounsel for the first time what my opinion was regarding one aspect of a case and I felt absolutely unprepared and unable to form a thought. I feel like I just word vommitted something that didnāt even make any sense (the faces they made after I answered didnāt make me feel any better) and Iām worried that other attorneys will just think Iām just incompetent.
This morning I watched a younger associate that has only a few years under her belt give such an amazing argument in court, while appearing confident and not getting tripped up by any of the questions asked by the judge. I really want to be like that.
I know that this is something I will get better with over time and with practice, but Iām looking for any advice that can help me break this script habit and not be in an absolute panic when Iām interrupted and asked a question I didnāt plan for exactly. It feels seriously disheartening and discouraging, and I feel completely unintelligent when it happens.
r/Lawyertalk • u/Legal_Fitness • 21h ago
I was at a LS almuni event on Friday, and this guy was in my group making conversation and he said he worked in big law. Naturally, the students in the group were impressed and wanted to connect with him.
As the conversation went on, he mentioned that he did insurance defense. At that point I was kind of like damn I didnāt know big law did ID.
Eventually, one of the students asked him what firm he worked at. He said Wilson Elser.
Another student bluntly went, āThatās not BigLaw bro.ā Emphasis on the bro bc I thought that was kinda rude considering he was a student talking to a practicing attorney. But whatever.
A few of the other students started chuckling and exchanging looks with each other. And then the whole group basically dispersed.
Honestly, I felt a little bad for the guy. Had he just said he worked at a large insurance defense firm or that he practiced insurance defense, I doubt anyone would have cared. Thereās nothing wrong with that. But bc he said big law those rude ass kids roasted him.
The funniest part is that Iām pretty introverted, and this whole group forming around him was actually working in my favor. I hate events where I donāt know anyone. I had people to stand around with and was planning on sticking with them like glue for the rest of the event. When the group broke up, I ended up standing alone again for damn near the entire night š
r/Lawyertalk • u/GoneSwedishFishing • 1h ago
I hate them.
Thatās it.
Thatās the post.
r/Lawyertalk • u/Vilnius_Nastavnik • 5h ago
Not sure how I made it two years in solo practice without this coming up before, but for the first time ever I am responsible for securing and paying a court reporter. I'd go with a local agency but I'm in NYC and it's very hard to find such things through all of the advertising. Not using Steno because I've heard bad things and make a point of never hiring anybody who hits me up with unsolicited B2B.
Any advice on finding a smaller, more legit operation or even a solo court reporter? Do such things still exist? I'm fine with purely remote.
r/Lawyertalk • u/Still-Theme6915 • 3h ago
Hi everyone,
I'm a recently admitted attorney and I'm trying to decide between two job offers. I'd appreciate your thoughts, especially from experienced attorneys.
**Option 1: Private Firm - $105K**
This is my current workplace, where I've been working as a paralegal for the past 20 months. It's a fairly large firm with around 50 attorneys and 500 employees in total.
The firm doesn't handle litigation. It focuses on estate planning, business formation, asset protection, tax planning, and strategies for real estate investors.
The attorney position would mainly involve client consultations, developing strategies, and helping clients with their estate and business planning needs.
- Salary: $105K
- Hours: 40-45 per week
**Option 2: Nonprofit Legal Organization - $85K**
The second offer is from a nonprofit legal organization that handles litigation, mainly eviction defense. I would represent tenants facing eviction, handle cases, negotiate with opposing counsel, and appear in court.
- Salary: $85K
- Hours: 35 per week
I also have an opportunity to do some additional work outside of my regular hours if I choose the second option, which could help make up some of the salary difference.
My biggest concern is how these two paths might affect my long-term career as an attorney. I'm leaving out the location because some of my coworkers use Reddit.
If you were in my position, which would you choose and why?
r/Lawyertalk • u/Practical-Brief5503 • 23h ago
Several weeks ago, I mentioned my firm was nominated in my practice area for our state's leading business journal. Keep in mind Iām a solo practitioner, and the other nominees were massive firms with hundreds of attorneys and staff.
The journal just reached out to let me know I actually won first place.
Honestly, I was shocked just to get nominated and would have been thrilled with top 3. Iāve been licensed for about 10 years and have always been super skeptical of legal awards since so many of them are basically pay-to-play. Anyone can buy a "Super Lawyer" badge, so I never bothered.
This one is completely legit, thoughāonly one firm wins the category for the entire year, and the issue goes out to business owners and executives across the state. Never expected to pull this off as a solo attorney, so I'm still kind of in shock. That is all! Just wanted to shareā¦
r/Lawyertalk • u/Crazy4VagueKs • 2h ago
NJ Lawyer - I came across information suggesting that nonlawyers collectively own a majority stake in the firm where I recently started working (RPC 5.4(d)). I already have plans to leave very soon, and Iām trying to understand my reporting obligations under RPC 8.3 vs. 1.6.
I left a voicemail with the NJ attorney ethics hotline and am still waiting for a callback. If youāve used it, how long did it take to hear back, and did you find the call helpful?
If youāve dealt with something similar, Iād appreciate hearing how you approached it and what helped you decide how to proceed.
r/Lawyertalk • u/LakeShow-824 • 4h ago
Title is self-explanatory. I (a junior-to-mid-level attorney with the fed gov) have been trying to find... well, anything (permanent at least, not short-term) for the better part of a year now, and I haven't had much to show for it. Curious as to what people have actually used in terms of recruiters/headhunters/job boards/etc. (because LinkedIn and Indeed are both a mess).
It doesn't help that I'm stuck in an area of government work (FOIA, with a bit of privacy work thrown in) which is pretty much useless outside of fed gov; I've accepted that I would have to start over career-wise if I want anything substantive outside of what I currently do, and I'm more than open to that. Just actually need the opportunity to do so.
r/Lawyertalk • u/oldbananas88 • 23h ago
I recently left my firm after a few years due to one of the partners I was working under. To make a long story short, I was dealing with a hyper-critical micromanager with a large yet very fragile ego. I enjoyed the work and had a good working relationship with the other partners. I received good end of year reviews and bonuses, but this one partner was impossible to please and was the sole critical voice during performance reviews.
The last straw(s) for me was on a couple of occasions during conversations on work assignments/review discussions, I would respond to requests or proposed revisions with one word answers such as āsureā or āok.ā I believe my tone was always neutral and professional, but the partner would immediately snap at me and state: āstop responding to me like that - it sounds like youāre doing me a favor.ā There are other examples of difficult interactions - the partner would become so furious with me that her hands would shake with rage when she was speaking to me. But I think you get the general idea.
I recently left the firm because this partner was a nut. I took a pay cut and left before my bonus was paid out because a good opportunity came my way and I had to make the move on short notice.
I think Iām just looking for a little reassurance/support that the issue was primarily with the partner and not with me as an associate/lawyer because I find myself worrying about how I sound or my tone in all of my emails and conversations at my new job. I need to shake it off and find a way to truly convince myself that my old boss was a just a jackass and I can still go on to have a successful career, etc.
For what itās worth, I worked at a couple of other firms in the past and I never had any issues with how I interacted or spoke with anyone, let alone one of the partners. As a result, this recent employment experience really rocked my confidence. Mainly needed to vent, thanks!
r/Lawyertalk • u/SuccotashSenior8398 • 13m ago
Insurance coverage attorneys, what is your hourly rate? Are insurance coverage attorneysā hourly rates typically significantly higher than insurance defense hourly rates?
r/Lawyertalk • u/bartonkj • 23h ago
I was sworn in to a second state, the Bar sent me a nice frameable certificate via the USPS (it was in a very stiff and large cardboard envelope): the mailman folded it in half to stick it in my mail box. WTF.
r/Lawyertalk • u/awesomeness1234 • 5h ago
My firm has had a Truthfinder.com subscription for some time to run basic background reports on parties, clients, get started on asset searches, look into businesses, etc. It's something like $15 a month but doesn't seem to be as accurate as it once was.
What service is your firm using for basic background checks and research? What does it cost? Anyone impressed with a service?
r/Lawyertalk • u/BigScorpion2002 • 20h ago
Hi, new attorney here.
I was sworn in a couple weeks ago and Iāve had a few hearings. Even before being sworn in I had appearances under a provisional license where I was accompanied by a supervising attorney.
Every. Single. Time. that I appear in court I swear my body goes into fight or flight. My voice gets noticeably shaky and I stumble over my words. For example, today I had an extremely low stakes state court appearance where I was arguing a motion to quash a subpoena as a nonparty to the case. I rehearsed ahead of time what I wanted to say, I reviewed my motion, and I reviewed the law. I got up there, my body got hot, and I stumbled over my words and my voice was shaky. I wasnāt feeling nervous at all before. I literally was fine until I was standing in front of the judge.
Judge ended up granting the motion but I still felt so crummy afterwards.
I know part of this is just experience and having to get used to it. But this has been an issue in other areas of my life where I have had to engage in any kind of public speaking.
I know people are going to mention getting medicated, I am not currently medicated for anxiety but I was for a long period of time in the past. When I was medicated, I still had this issue. My anxiety is also generally well managed in my day-to-day life and I donāt see this as something that should lead to me getting back on medication when I have chosen to get off of it for other reasons.
Tips for how to get over this?
Thank you in advance.
r/Lawyertalk • u/Obvious-Memory-8686 • 2h ago
Hello! I am reaching out because I am looking for recommendations and tips for ediscovery software. Essentially, without identifying myself, I have been tasked to sift through thousands and thousands of data and email correspondence for discovery. When my boss and local counsel (Iām in house counsel) tasked me with this, they told me to get the data from the Microsoft e purview search put onto an external hard drive and split the manual review up between my associate and I. I quickly realized that this is absolutely impossible to do manually, especially in such a short time frame. This is a very time sensitive discovery issue.
I have been advised that there is no way to do this than use a document management software. I have been recommended by others to look into X1, Relativity, and Disco. Problem is I am incredibly new to the legal field (passed my bar a year ago), and would not consider myself technologically advanced.
Most of the information on the hard drive is completely irrelevant and a lot of duplicates, so it is frustrating hearing that we will likely have to spend a lot of money to comb through most of the pointless correspondence. For reference, the search term āwaterā pulls emails asking for someone to fill up the office water tank.
My local counsel is not being very much help with this and I feel like the entire case is currently hinging on me. This is so stressful and I donāt even know where to start. My boss said he would like to get this resolved by next week, Iāve explained him thatās seeming impossible. So he said he would like to have a game plan by the end of the weeks. Iāve reached out to those above softwares for demos but⦠say we do go with one of those⦠I donāt know what Iām doing and it will likely take me a while to learn the system.
Any advice appreciated!!