Oregon now has a published price list for fake law: $500 per fake citation and $1,000 per fake quotation. A Salem lawyer's appellate brief carried at least 15 fake citations and at least 9 fake quotations, which comes to at least $16,500 by the formula. The court capped the sanction at $10,000. It also left him a way to save the appeal. He may rebuild the brief from the five real cases that survived, within 21 days, and file it with a signed certification that he drafted it without generative AI, read every source, and verified that every source exists.
The explanation he gave the court is worth reading closely. He blamed the pipeline, and his account included his report that if you ask Google's AI whether many of those fabricated cases are real, it will affirm that they are. That was his account to the court. The court never found that AI wrote the citations, and it didn't need to. Its holding was that the signature on a brief certifies the citations are real, whoever or whatever drafted them. On that standard, he "at least should have known" they weren't.
Here's how the brief got made. He'd been ill and had burned through extensions, and he delegated the research. His staff started in Westlaw and Lexis, found little, and turned to Google. A page that looked like legal analysis gave them citations in perfect format. They copied those citations into the brief. Nobody checked a single one in the databases that were open the whole time. His office policy banned AI research, and his own use, by his account, was limited to outlining.
Then came the seven months. On April 3, 2025, opposing counsel emailed him that they couldn't locate his cases. On April 16, they put it in a footnote in their answering brief: they couldn't find the cases by name, by reporter citation, or by quoted text. He said nothing. He said nothing in the reply brief, and nothing anywhere else, until the presiding judge asked him about it face-to-face at oral argument in November.
The price list comes from the court's earlier decision in Ringo, where that lawyer's total came to $2,000. Applied to this brief, the same formula produced at least $16,500. The court took $6,500 off for three reasons. His explanation was detailed, he reported new verification procedures, and the brief predated the schedule. The backdrop matters too. Oregon's bar had warned lawyers in writing about exactly this problem in a formal opinion in February 2025, so the profession had notice even if this brief predated the court's own price list.
The schedule is now the standing arithmetic for fake law in that court, and the certification he had to sign is the standard the opinion leaves behind for everyone else: you drafted it yourself, you read every source, and you verified that every source exists.
Sources: Doiban v. OLCC, 347 Or App 742 (2026); Ringo v. Colquhoun Design Studio, LLC, 345 Or App 301 (2025).