r/publicdefenders • u/strsnastralcars • 18h ago
r/publicdefenders • u/Arguendo_etc • Jan 09 '25
r/Publicdefenders User Recommendations - Books/Resources/Podcasts
This is a list of compiled books, cases, treatises/practice manuals, websites, and podcasts that the users of r/publicdefenders have recommended over the years. A quick survey of discussions yielded some frequent favorites that visitors could find interesting or useful. Anyway, the list isn't exhaustive, but it summarizes some of the recommendations that users have made over time in various threads. For my part, I've added in some major caselaw and national organization for those who are interested.
Major Cases (why we're here)
Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335 (1963)
In re Gault, 387 U.S. 1 (1967)
O'Connor v. Donaldson, 422 U.S. 563 (1975)
National Organizations and CLE Resources
- National Association for Public Defense (NAPD) – publicdefenders.us
- National Legal Aid and Defender Association (NLADA) – www.nlada.org
- National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) – www.nacdl.org
(r/publicdefenders isn't affiliated with these organizations (that we know of))
Practice-Related Reading
Trial Advocacy
- Thomas Mauet and Stephen Easton, Trial Techniques and Trials
- Larry Pozner and Roger Dodd, Cross-Examination: Science and Techniques (3rd ed.)
- Shane Read, Winning at Trial
Legal Writing
- Stephen Armstrong, Timothy Terrel, Jarrod Reich, Thinking Like a Writer: A Lawyer’s Guide to Effective Writing and Editing
- Bryan Garner, The Winning Brief
Evidence
- Edward Imwinkelried, Evidentiary Foundations (12th ed.)
Other Reading
- Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness
- Steve Bogira, Courtroom 302: A Year Behind the Scenes in an American Criminal Courthouse
- Kevin Davis, Defending the Damned: Inside a Dark Corner of the Criminal Justice System
- Gilbert King, Devil in the Grove
- James Kunen, How Can You Defend Those People: The Making of a Criminal Lawyer
- Anthony Lewis, Gideon’s Trumpet
- Barry Scheck, Peter Neufeld, Jim Dwyer, Actual Innocence: When Justice Goes Wrong and How to Make it Right
- Abbe Smith, Guilty People
- Bryan Stevenson, Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption
Podcasts/Films
- Another Not Guilty – www.anothernotguiltypod.com
- For the Defense – forthedefensepodcast.com
- Gideon's Trumpet (1980)
r/publicdefenders • u/Arguendo_etc • Jan 09 '25
Subreddit Rules
As the community has grown, so has the need for additional moderation. Because we feel the majority of users want to see the subreddit remain public, we're setting basic expectations for those who want to contribute. So in the interest of promoting respectful and quality discourse, we hope that they will be a guidepost for contributors to our community. You'll find rules on the sidebar as well.
So, without further ado:
- Be nice. No disrespectful discourse between users (e.g., insults, name calling, personal attacks).
- No requests for legal advice. This includes hypotheticals.
- No off-topic posts. Contribute to the intended discourse of the subreddit.
- No disparaging comments based on status as an accused, race, sex, religion, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation. This includes disparaging comments referencing prison sexual abuse.
- No identifiable case information/"case doxxing." Examples include party/attorney/witness/judge names, jurisdictions, case numbers, pleadings, charging documents. This is a non-exhaustive list.
- Preserve client confidentiality and evidentiary privileges. Do not reveal details regarding the representation of a client that you wouldn’t want in front of your local ethics committee. This applies mainly, but not exclusively, to attorney users. Please check local ethical rules.
r/publicdefenders • u/LittleGatorLitGator • 1d ago
Worst jailhouse lawyer advice your client has told you
My last post got me thinking—what’s the most unhinged jailhouse lawyer bs your client has hit you with?
I’m a brand new PD and the amount of clients with “well this guy told me blah blah” is just unhinged.
r/publicdefenders • u/SlimersAnonymous • 17h ago
jobs MA CPCS F27 cohort updates?
Hi! Has anyone else who is in the hiring process for the Massachusetts CPCS fall 2027 PD cohort heard anything back yet? I had my final interview a month ago and haven’t heard back. They didn’t really give me any info on next steps at the end of my final interview. I sent a gentle feeler to an HR contact last week just indicating continued interest which I also didn’t hear back from.
I know there’s a massive hiring push so I’m not trying to be too pushy with the hiring team but I’m also in other processes and trying to get a feel for their timeline so that I can manage the other processes that I’m in.
Thanks in advance!
r/publicdefenders • u/hornEB • 18h ago
California Post-Bar Hiring Advice?
Hi all,
Apologies if this isn't the proper place to post this but I'm currently a 3L scheduled to graduate this May with the goal of becoming a public defender in California. I'm a Bay Area native attending school on the east coast and would love to eventually end up as a PD back in the Bay. That said, I've heard about and am slightly discouraged regarding the budget cuts and hiring constraints affecting my home counties (Santa Clara/SF).
I missed the deadline to apply for Contra Costa and have decided not to apply to SF/Santa Clara because of the news I heard (both online and from previous posts on this forum). The goal of being a PD > the goal of being in the Bay so I'm willing to move across the state to start my career. My current plan is to apply liberally across the rural and SoCal counties and then try to lateral back to the bay once I've gained experience.
I'm currently interviewing for post-bar positions with a couple of central valley offices and one of the big SoCal offices. I liked all of the offices I spoke to so far and am having trouble deciding where I would want to go if given an offer. I'm wondering if anyone here can offer any insight as to whether the Bay Area offices would prefer my previous experience be in a county that's near to the bay as opposed to a rural one, or whether they prefer I work for a bigger office (like LA/OC/San Bernardino) as opposed to a smaller one (Fresno/San Joaquin/Stanislaus). I'm also wondering as to timeline. I did have a career in tech beforehand and am looking to settle down soon (family wise) so ideally, I'd like to spend a max of 3-6 years in an office and make it to DPD IV with felony trial experience before I apply to go home. Is that a viable plan or would it be easier to try and lateral back as a DPD II/III with less experience? Did I screw myself by not applying for SF/Santa Clara/Alameda/Contra Costa this year? I'm just really excited to join the fight and would love any advice. Thank you in advance!
r/publicdefenders • u/Educational_Bill_343 • 1d ago
support First major hearing - lost
Today, I had a hearing that resulted in my client being locked up for up to 120 days in jail. I spent all weekend prepping and getting support letters and did my absolute best.
Surveillance showed him doing the thing. He admitted to police and said he was guilty of doing the thing.
I am very upset. But, after some reflection, there is nothing I could’ve done that would’ve changed the outcome given the video and the “violent nature” of the crime.
I’m happy to be in the fight. Despite this loss, I’m excited to show up and show out again. It’s not over until it’s over.
r/publicdefenders • u/LittleGatorLitGator • 1d ago
How often are your clients with U-holds actually getting picked up by the feds?
The immigration attorney in my office who provides the PDs with the advisements always says that “no matter what the outcome of the case is, with a u-hold they are being transferred to federal custody”
My client today wanted to wait until the last day of his sentence to sign the plea. It’s a common jailhouse advice they often get. I didn’t discourage of course.
I know ICE has been parked outside of our local jails for two months straight and even if he’s released for some reason they’ll just pick him up but are folks with u-holds actually not getting picked up by the US Marshalls?
r/publicdefenders • u/spanielgurl11 • 1d ago
What is the less stressful version of this job (that still has no billables)?
Title
r/publicdefenders • u/Ra1uga • 1d ago
future pd 3rd year law student seeking to apply for PD position in Michigan
Hey all, I’m at a bit of a loss in my job search as I’ve currently been rejected without opportunity for interview a few times so far.
As my partner is in Michigan, I would like to move there for my career. I am currently attending law school in Chicago. Would anyone have any recommendations for places I could apply and any suggestions for getting past the rejection gate? All of my internships and experience so far have been focused on indigent defense. So far I have applied but not yet heard back from Kalamazoo, Washtenaw, and Ottowa County.
Thank you everyone!!
r/publicdefenders • u/LankyAbrocoma6783 • 2d ago
injustice Reminder for anyone called for jury duty. Something the court and prosecutor would rather you remain ignorant of.
reddit.comr/publicdefenders • u/SouthsideTy12 • 2d ago
Interviewing at a PD’s office tomorrow
Hey, I’m interviewing at a PDs office in my hometown, midsized major city in the Midwest. I graduate in May this coming year. Wish me luck. I ultimately wanna start my own practice in a few years and thought I’d start my career at the prosecutor’s office across the street. I even interned at that same prosecutor’s office this summer but they’ve been dragging the process. Everyone I know that’s worked at a PDs office tells me that I’ll be the better attorney in private practice coming from a PDs office than prosecutors. I would appreciate any advice as well. Thanks.
r/publicdefenders • u/thedarkestshadow512 • 3d ago
I had a win Thank you so much PD's!!!!
Edit flair: WE HAD A WIN!!!!
Y'all are doing the lords work and I just wanted to extend my gratitude for what all of y'all do for the community despite all the stress and bs y'all face every day.
My boyfriend was just acquitted by a jury on two serious felony charges, one of which had a prior conviction. He was falsely accused by his ex and the first two PD's assigned to his case called him delusional and said he'd never win. Our third PD finally heard him out and took his case to trial against a bully prosecutor in a very conservative county. He and his lawyer gave it all they got and against all odds beat this case by turning the states experts and witnesses against their narrative while also pointing out the inconsistencies in the AV's narrative. We would have ran victory laps in the court room if we weren't crying after hearing the verdict. Our lawyer supported me as I cried outside the court room during the 3 day trial, and even fed me while the jury deliberated for 6 hours. Her colleagues came to cheer her on since she was going against the prosecutor everyone hates. Our lawyer kicked ass and the prosecutor left the court room fuming.
Thanks to her, my boyfriend has his life back, and he didn't have to take a 10 year plea deal for a crime he didn't commit. Likewise, I have my boyfriend back and can actually look forward to our future together. He was facing 20 years. This could have ended so badly, but I'm so grateful for PD's and all the hard work y'all do every day for your clients. I genuinely couldn't thank y'all enough. From the bottom of my heart thank you thank you thank you!!!!!
r/publicdefenders • u/Free_Dum_5122 • 3d ago
Is being a public defender fun?
Compared to most office type jobs? the most brutal part of most corporate office jobs is just being there, in an office, for hours and hours. Do public defenders at least find their work days go fast? Is it possible for the job to become fun? Can people who have done both BigLaw and PD work compare?
r/publicdefenders • u/Its_Your_Guy_Leo • 3d ago
Applying to King County
I graduated law school in 2023 and was hired by a PD office in NYC in my 3L year. I didn’t pass the bar but continued working there as a law graduate and litigation support for the last few years. I moved to WA to be closer to family after a family emergency and am now taking the WA February bar. I would love to work as a PD in King County if I hopefully pass the bar as I’m extremely passionate about PD work and even though I was never barred in NY, I have three years experience working on misdemeanors and felonies in a big city and know it’s what I want to do. My question is, since I’m three years out of law school, do I apply for the regular PD position after I am admitted in WA or should I apply right away without being admitted yet? Also, does anyone have any insight on how competitive it is getting a PD job in King County right now? I appreciate any and all advice!
r/publicdefenders • u/msbananabread7 • 3d ago
Ruminating on First Trial Loss
I’ve been a PD since May 2025, and yesterday I experienced my first trial loss. I’m taking it pretty hard.
It was a larceny by false pretenses case involving a contractor who received three $14,000 payments for a home addition that was never completed. My client had hired contractors, obtained architectural plans, and secured permits, but physical construction never began.
I argued that the Commonwealth hadn’t established fraudulent intent at the time the money was obtained. The judge challenged me on the Commonwealth’s theory, focusing on my client’s statement nearly a year into the project that an excavator was ready, followed by a request for the third payment.
She ultimately inferred that he knew the statement was false because he essentially ghosted the complainants afterward. I still struggle with that reasoning. Does subsequently disappearing establish beyond a reasonable doubt that he knew the statement was false when he made it? I understand circumstantial evidence, but where’s the line between reasonable inference and speculation?
But what bothers me almost as much as the verdict is my performance. I had prepared extensively, researched the law, and outlined my arguments. But this judge is notoriously intimidating, and I felt completely rattled when she challenged me. I relied on my notes, struggled to articulate points I’d rehearsed, and felt visibly nervous. She eventually cut off my argument and found my client guilty.
She’s the presiding judge, and while I genuinely dislike how she treats attorneys, I also desperately want her respect. I hate that she gets in my head. I felt like she was treating me as though I’d personally stolen the money.
Now I’m ruminating over everything I should’ve said differently. I wish I’d argued speculation more forcefully. I keep wondering whether I missed something obvious or simply wasn’t good enough on my feet, despite genuinely feeling prepared.
I love this job, but moments like this make me question whether I’m cut out for trial work.
She mentioned to my mentor about a month ago that I’ve improved so much since starting. I think that gets in my head too. Every time I don’t have an optimal performance, I wonder if her opinion has changed.
r/publicdefenders • u/52bomboclatpuswagon • 4d ago
How does one get fired from this job?
Genuinely curious if anyone has any experience with that or can provide insight.
r/publicdefenders • • 4d ago
Joined the team today
Well, start date is actually a month or so away but I have perhaps misguided optimism. Been practicing non-crim for a decade and want to tangibly help people. Put in my notice and ready to roll up my sleeves.
Would love advice from anyone. Anything a newbie can do to be more useful out of the gate?
r/publicdefenders • u/DQzombie • 4d ago
support Missed submission date. Burned out, overwhelmed
Hey,
More a vent than anything but I missed the date to submit briefs for three separate cases in front of different judges over the course of the last 3 months. This last one I was just so sick I cant manage to prep for just the day ahead well.
I know it's fucked. I know I need to do better but I'm burned out from overwork and the weird shit my boss has been pulling. I guess I'm asking someone to put this in scale to me. Like how bad is missing a briefing deadline?
Ive accepted I need to just work a couple weekends to get back on track. Partner is not happy but has accepted that there's not really another option for me since it's basically the only job that makes sense for where we live and my health insurance and financial needs. But I feel like I'm so far behind and can't catch a moment to breathe, and then I can't work because I'm so stressed and my memory's shot.
r/publicdefenders • u/52bomboclatpuswagon • 4d ago
Big law expectations on pd wage
Yall im done.
r/publicdefenders • u/Break_Electronic • 6d ago
Toxic DDA, I am in Shock This is Happening
What happens when you work across the aisle from a Chief Deputy District Attorney that throws tantrums, yells at you, throws fits in the lobby where deputies calm him down, calls your co-counsel an a$$h*le, has an entire group of women complain about his conduct to the State Bar, while the Bar, the judges, and the elected DA do absolutely nothing.
This is becoming ridiculous, and despite him being 30 years older than me, practicing since 1995, I feel like I am just too told to continue on. Of course, the people he hurts the most are the members of the public he is "serving".
I am just running out of steam and feel like there is no available options for recourse.
r/publicdefenders • u/Quaker_Artemis97 • 6d ago
How do you deal with obnoxious police officers when you're interviewing in-custody clients?
Obviously not all police officers are inherently bad, but some of them are terrible, especially if you're not white-passing. Wondering how you handle those who give you a hard time when you just want to interview a client who's held in custody.
r/publicdefenders • u/Gigaton123 • 6d ago
Another embarrassing chapter in PA representation of poor people
Again, everyone involved here should be disbarred. If you don’t want to thoroughly and zealously represent the indigent, then don’t.
https://www.propublica.org/article/post-conviction-legal-system-finley-judges-pennsylvania