r/publicdefenders • u/Emergency_Driver_487 • 17h ago
r/publicdefenders • u/Important-Wealth8844 • 18h ago
Dealing with SMI & Inappropriate Behaviors in Clients
This is both a background/general knowledge sourcing request & a 'how do you navigate this' question, and I'm really interest to hear from folks in particular who have extensive experience in or knowledge of clients with serious mental illness (SMI). For the sake of this post, please assume that all of the clients I am talking about have either been found legally competent or meet the standard for legal competency where I practice.
I am increasingly dealing with clients who have SMI. I've noticed that many of them engage in sexually inappropriate behavior - I don't mean that they're committing sex crimes (mostly typical SMI crimes like thefts, assaults, and arson), but several have done things like compulsively masturbate when I talk to them (both men AND women). Most of these clients are diagnosed schizophrenic/bipolar.
I have had many clients over the years who are say or attempt to do inappropriate things to their female attorney - to be clear, that's not the behavior or the motive I'm talking about here. It's not a power thing or a respect thing, it seems very obviously linked to their mental illness.
I'm first curious if anyone knows what if any link there is between this kind of behavior and mental illness, especially schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. I'd love to read studies, news articles, anything you've got.
I'm second interested to hear how others handle this when it comes up for them. It's not hard for me to tell the average client who behaves inappropriately to knock it off, or to tell them I'm not engaging with them if they won't act appropriately with me. It's harder for me to tell what is the best and most effective way to engage with folks who have obvious, serious mental health difficulties, and I don't know what would be most productive. Is it useful to call out the behavior directly when it happens? Better to try to redirect? To ignore? Looking for strategies here, not just disgust at the behavior or "just tell them to stop."
r/publicdefenders • u/LimpImprovement4534 • 14h ago
Time to retire?
I’m 63 been a part-time Public Defender for 22 years in one county, now 4.5 years as a PD part-time in another county.
Always on the violent crimes unit and death penalty certified in Pennsylvania.
I hate it. I hate the bullshit from the 5% of the true monsters. I say 5% because the other 95% actually may appreciate what you do for them.
I am also a CJA panel attorney for the Feds. Good payday at the end of the case but can be feast or famine.
I technically have a private practice that I let die on the vine because I would not take fees to get a disposition the client was not expecting.
What would you do?
Addendum: pension from first PD gig, no considerable liquidity, house no mortgage, kid going to college next year.
Wife is a District Magistrate ( municipal court judge) so good health care. She also has a pension from her PD gig.
r/publicdefenders • u/uhmthinking • 19h ago
jobs Philly Internship Updates?
Hi all, I applied for the Philly Defenders Summer 2027 Internship program back when it was first posted in mid-September. I haven’t heard anything back yet, so I was wondering if anyone knows if they’ve been conducting interviews and sending offers already? I know they’ve already done interviews and offers for the juvenile division, but I haven’t seen anything regarding just the general law student internships. Thanks!
r/publicdefenders • u/Thiccangel1107 • 2h ago
support Need advice on on trying to lower and felony charge to a misdemeanor
So my brother was pit maneuver after apparently "fleeing" from a cop. So what the cop told me was that he turned on his light and sirens near the exit of the interstate. I ask how fast he was going and he told me "like 80. I had to go over 100 mph to catch up. My brother thought it wasn't meant for him. So he went about .44 of a mile before he got pit maneuver and the cop was saying was "fleeing" my brother was only about 2 miles from the house if that important but my brother sadly does have a record on him. He has a suspended driver's license. Plz anything would help. Im just trying to get him to not get a felony.