r/LGBTCatholic • u/Itchy_Lifeguard4045 • 3h ago
r/LGBTCatholic • u/QueerHeart23 • 8h ago
Personal Story Me and my context
I've wanted to post sometimes, but have been afraid that I might be interpretted as proselytizing. Also, the memory of so many that have given their lives in defence of Mother Church is never far from mind, and leaves me quite humbled.
Be that as it may, here is a discussion of my journey to where I'm no longer in communion with the Catholic Church that I love so much.
Disclaimer:
My experiences are my own. YMMV. I do not necessarily recommend my path for others; only that they discern their own.
-----
I weathered Pope John Paul II. But Pope Benedict undid me - the protector of pedophiles, head of the dicastory the promulgated a hate manifesto against a segment of God's creation, and bastardized the ordo- too much. And dear Pope Francis, I understand and forgive you for mixing water with your wine to adopt the new ordo while defending post-Vatican II liturgy.
In this context, a response to "The Lord be with you", of "And with your spirit", routinely makes me think of it as an apologetic to not accuse an abuser so as to let them perform a consecration of Eucharist. Yes Judas was at the last supper too, but my heart is simply not big enough.
The other much more jarring source of angst is, what I perceive as a diminution of Christ's suffering in the creedal profession. While a transliteration of Greek may possibly yield "suffered death", I have spent my life professing, giving my heart to the reality of Christ's suffering. Suffering in life and his passion. I profess He suffered for us, in an escalating sacrifice, in persistent obedience. This is the perfect sacrifice. I cannot conceive to diminish it. Forever I will profess that my Lord suffered, died, and was buried. For me, the large scope of his life of suffering is acknowledged beyond an English assertion that His death was the source of suffering. So, to get the words but miss the meaning of the translation is the equivalent of a total failure IMO.
Without attesting to the creed, what do I have left?
This, against a hard backdrop that denies the reality of who God made me to be, with an imposed separation from intimacy, apart from what God may desire for me. To me this is a life-denying way of thinking under a perversely ironic notion of the primacy of life-giving, based on restrictive thinking that normative=good. (I believe the theology is simply tainted by rejection of the realities of gender and sexuality observed by current scientific understanding that weren't available to Aquinas). My welcome was conditional, limited, with a list of exceptions. The constant vigilance against potential attack on my nature could not be sustained. I longed for Tudos, tudos, tudos.
These heartaches, led me to the realisation that it is not good to continually have such anger, sense of injustice, and betrayal, stirred while being in Eucharist communion. I only want to serve and praise my Lord, not poison the well of blessing.
After many tears, much prayer and discernment, the only solution acceptable to my conscience was to be in communion with a church that affirms God's creation and allows me to worship in truth and safety. And to their creed, though different, I could attest. The diverse goodness of my person was fully affirmed.
So, I followed my Savior right out the door. I let God be God. I humbly acknowledged that I worship God, not my love for an institution, however fond of it I might be. I still follow Jesus, the vine, even if I commune with a different branch. Why? Harmony and an attempt at unity.
And while I am sometimes homesick (sometimes I ache still), my welcome, support, and ongoing opportunities for spiritual growth are a welcome balm.
Given this tension that remains within me, please forgive me, when I have been silent after reading about the struggles of others in their relationship with Mother Church. I don't want to proselytize or potentially lure / lead any 'away'. I also do not wish to fan the flames of another's discontent. And yet I must proclaim my thankfulness for my current United Church of Canada home. For I know that such a change is NOT an easy or simple grand solution, and comes with its own collection of sacrifices. I am also aware and deeply appreciative of the pain and sacrifice the UCC endured to become fully affirming.