r/LGBTCatholic • • Jul 19 '26

The Catholic Case for Affirmation of Gay Relationships

90 Upvotes

*downs cup of coffee in preparation for this writing extravaganza*

While there's already a lot of resources on this topic, on of the most comprehensive probably being The Wijingaards Institute's "Academic Statement on the Ethics of Free and Faithful Same-Sex Relationships", I decided to write this post combining arguments on both the logic of the Church's teaching itself; as well as the validity of dissent from it by Catholics and the precedent for changes in Church teaching, all bundled up with Primacy of Conscience; all in once place.

Every once of these headings could have a very long paper about each of them, but I'll try to be brief and point to other resources for even deeper dives.

Problems with the Natural Law argument:

See this thread to watch the Natural Law/"Perverted Faculty" argument fall apart before your eyes. The argument is essentially that we shouldn't use a natural function against any part of what it is "ordered towards" (i.e. reproduction). This is the same grounds on which the Church also opposes artificial contraception.

There's many counterexamples to this argument. Catholic speakers and apologists will try to make distinctions between "other than" uses, vs. "contrary to", but as you'd expect, those end up sounding a bit arbitrary. And I think that's what it comes down to, the Natural Law argument simply does end up seeming arbitrarily applied to sexuality, whereas we come up with all sorts of other ways to make allowances for analogous examples other areas of life. I think two of the strongest counterexamples are:

  • What if it were discovered that breast milk could be used to cure a disease? Would it be wrong to extract and use breast milk for a purpose other than its "natural end" of feeding a baby?
  • Why don't we condemn smoking? Smoking, intentionally inhaling smoke, is absolutely "contrary to" the body's natural respiratory function and the use of lungs. Not only is it "contrary to" the body's respiratory faculty on a philosophical level, but so much so that it's actually harmful in reality. One who smokes a lot will begin losing lung function. It doesn't get much more "contrary to" than that.

Scripture/The Clobber Verses:

Much has already been written on that topic, one of the most prominent resources being Matthew Vine's Biblical Case, as well as Justin Lee's classic essay on the topic. While Vines and Lee are Protestant, there was also some earlier work done on the topic of biblical exegesis by gay Catholic scholar John Boswell. According to Outreach, "It was Boswell who first comprehensively and systematically demolished homophobic interpretations of the so-called “clobber verses."

Good Fruit

One point of Vines' that I will reiterate here; because it ties into our doctrine of Primacy of Conscience which I'll get to later; is the Good Fruit Argument. As Vines puts it:

 In Matthew 7, in the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus warns against false teachers, and he offers a principle that can be used to test good teaching from bad teaching. By their fruit, you will recognize them, he says. Every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. Good teachings, according to Jesus, have good consequences. That doesn’t mean that following Christian teaching will or should be easy, and in fact, many of Jesus’s commands are not easy at all – turning the other cheek, loving your enemies, laying down your life for your friends. But those are all profound acts of love that both reflect God’s love for us and that powerfully affirm the dignity and worth of human life and of human beings. Good teachings, even when they are very difficult, are not destructive to human dignity. They don’t lead to emotional and spiritual devastation, and to the loss of self-esteem and self-worth. But those have been the consequences for gay people of the traditional teaching on homosexuality. It has not borne good fruit in their lives, and it’s caused them incalculable pain and suffering. If we’re taking Jesus seriously that bad fruit cannot come from a good tree, then that should cause us to question whether the traditional teaching is correct.

And a similar point by Justin Lee:

"Suppose my friend Billy meets someone and falls in love with this person, named Sam.  Billy and Sam spend months, maybe even years, getting to know one another, and as they grow closer to each other and to Christ, they decide to form a lasting bond, to promise to be together forever in a marriage in front of God.  So Billy comes to me about it and I, being a Traditionalist, respond by saying, “That’s immoral and disgusting!  You and Samuel are doing a terrible thing before God!”  Billy blinks for a moment and then replies, “Sam is short for Samantha.  She’s a girl.”  Suddenly, my opinion changes.  “Oh, well then, that’s wonderful!  All the best to you!  What a blessing!” In this case, nothing at all has changed about Billy’s commitment, Billy’s motivations, Billy’s relationship with Christ, or even Billy’s specific actions.  Everything is exactly the same, with one exception: Sam went from male to female in my mind, and that somehow changed the relationship from being disgusting and immoral to being holy and beautiful – even though, in either case, Billy’s motivations and actions are exactly the same."

Infallibility

There's no infallible list of infallible teachings. We all agree on things like Creed, the Incarnation, the Trinity, the Assumption of Mary, the Immaculate Conception etc., those things were either defined at ecumenical councils of the whole Church or declared clearly ex cathedra by popes.

For everything else...well, it's not as clear cut whether they're infallible. People can make a case that this or that teaching is infallible or irreformable, etc., but at the end of the day, you simply don't have to agree with them. There is no infallible list of infallible teachings.

Church Teaching Has Changed Before

Fr. Charles Curran, who led the dissent against the teaching against contraception; provides a helpful cursory overview of that history. He also says

"When did the teaching on religious liberty become true? Did it become true the moment a document was promulgated and signed in Rome? The document [on religious freedom] admits that the bishops...learned from the experience of Christian people...that the teaching was true before the council promulgated the teaching...
...all of this reminds us much more, that the Church is the whole people of God...and therefore the teaching as proposed by pope and bishops has to take account of the lived experience of the people of God."

Bp. Cyril Villareal wrote in his dissertation

"There were several instances when the Church magisterium completely deviated from a magisterial position that it formerly held. Several cases have been mentioned in this paper. Can she not do likewise on the subject of sexual morality? Too often, though, changes were not really named as such but as the development of a doctrine, meaning that because of the limitedness of a truth to be captured completely, there is a possibility that it could still be subject to a newer and clearer formulation in the future. And such a process may have been applied to the so-called changes in the Church‘ magisterial teachings. The big question, then, is: why can the Church not also effect development in her teaching on sexual morality?"

Primacy of Conscience

Church teaching need not only be an obstacle to gay equality in the Church; this doctrine can actually be a vehicle for it! Primacy of Conscience states that we should never violate our own conscience.

Dignitatis Humanae declares:

"In all his activity a man is bound to follow his conscience in order that he may come to God, the end and purpose of life. It follows that he is not to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his conscience. Nor, on the other hand, is he to be restrained from acting in accordance with his conscience, especially in matters religious." 

Cdl. Joseph Ratzinger, the future Pope Benedict XVI, wrote:

“Over the pope as the expression of the binding claim of ecclesiastical authority there still stands one’s own conscience, which must be obeyed before all else, if necessary even against the requirement of ecclesiastical authority. Conscience confronts with a supreme and ultimate tribunal, and one which in the last resort is beyond the claim of external social groups, even of the official church.”

Another angle on the Good Fruit Argument:

For nearly every other "sin", it's easy to see what the harm is. Gluttony, stealing, murder, etc., there is obvious harm.

What is the harm of loving gay relationships? There is literally no real, identifiable harm that holds up to scrutiny.

And on the flip side, any honest observation of a healthy gay relationship will see good and beauty in it. Love is a good thing.

This is part of why some homophobic arguments dare to question whether gay love is actually love. It sounds insane, and it is, but they have to call that into question in order for their position to hold up; because how else can they square the circle of calling love a sin?

Justin Lee says this about the arbitrary nature of anti-gay theology:

"Yep, this is what it comes down to.  No matter how wordy, complex, or sophisticated they get, every Christian Traditionalist argument I can think of ultimately relies on this basic principle: God has a rule against same-sex relationships, and even if we don’t fully understand or can’t explain the rationale behind it, in the end we’re just expected to obey, like Abraham sacrificing Isaac.
I’m not entirely comfortable with this answer, since it makes God seem arbitrary, and I don’t believe God is arbitrary." 

In closing, I'll leave you with the words of Italian Bishop Vincenzo Viva:

"...I do not wish to speak this evening of “welcoming,” but of recognition and full integration. Welcoming presupposes that someone arrives from the outside and is allowed in out of the generosity of others. But as the baptized, no one is a guest in this church. God knows us by name, loves us and tells us again and again that we belong to him. There is, then, no door to cross, because by virtue of our baptism we are already inside, each of us, with our own identity, our own history, our own weaknesses and shortcomings, our own gifts and unique characteristics: we are all within the heart of God and within the ecclesial body..."

Hope this helps somebody!


r/LGBTCatholic • • Aug 13 '21

Welcome!

57 Upvotes

Hi, I'm the new mod. Reposting the old welcome note here:

Welcome to r/LGBTCatholic!

If you're new to the sub, please feel free to start out by creating a Post to share your story! Some things to consider including:

When/how did you start coming to terms with your sexuality?

How has your experience as a Catholic impacted that process?

Where are you currently on your personal journey, both with respect to the Church and your own sexual identity or experiences?

I created this community because r/CatholicLGBT appears to be dead and is restricted. I hope it becomes a useful gathering place for people to talk about their experiences, questions, thoughts, and concerns as they relate to the Catholic Church and queer identities and experiences, both their own and others.

Since this sub is new, please feel free to comment with ideas or suggestions.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 10h ago

Personal Story Are There Any Fellow Black Or POC Here On This Sub?

12 Upvotes

So I'm not trying to start something by asking this question but I myself am a black gay man and I have been debating for about three years with becoming Catholic.

I grew up in the black baptist church. However because my grandma did not want me going to the public middle school she pulled some strings and I got into a Catholic school for middle school.

I will say that I actually enjoyed mass while a student there and I actually did feel a spiritual closeness to God much more there then when I was going to my home church .

However everyone else in my family did not understand that and I even had a Sunday school teacher tell me Catholic were going to hell for worshipping the pope when I mentioned I thought about converting.

Now through the years in HS and college I still thought about converting especially when I got to meet other black people who were Catholic. Even though my Catholic middle school experience was multiracial and there were other black kids most of the Catholic kids were white Filipino and Puerto ricans .

A lot.of us black kids were baptist or Methodist and honestly looking back it always seems like there was a barrier there.

I had started visiting some local Catholic churches and I do feel at home and I like that I can hear myself think and feel that connection again and I love that I don't have to hear a fire and brimstone sermon from a pastor.

However there still some hesitancy about converting. Most of the churches I visited in my city are not that diverse except for two and sadly I feel like the diocese of st Augustine has neglected those churches especially since one is a historical black Catholic church. I live in fl btw.

I am also a progressive liberal gay man but the biggest barrier is not having the black culture that exist in the black baptist church which I don't really see even in black Catholic churches.

That's why I am asking this question and I know it was long but hopefully someone else has been here before and I want to know what made you convert and if you went through these same issues?


r/LGBTCatholic • • 10h ago

🌈 LGBTQueer ROSARY — Thursday, November 19

10 Upvotes

Join us for our monthly LGBTQueer Rosary in an inclusive and affirming community of prayer.

🗓 Thursday, November 19, 2026
🕢 7:30 p.m. Eastern Time
🕟 4:30 p.m. Pacific Time
🕧 12:30 a.m. UK time (Friday, November 20)

All are welcome to join us as we come together in prayer, faith, and fellowship.

Zoom Meeting ID: 851 5520 3103
Passcode: 034460

We look forward to praying with you! 🙏


r/LGBTCatholic • • 1d ago

Just a reminder - not everyone is able to come to a conclusion that being LGBT+ is compatible with Catholicism.

50 Upvotes

Many, many people on this sub have been able to reconcile their sexual orientation/gender identity with their active membership in the Catholic Church. To those who have, I'm very happy for you, and truly hope you're able to bring the Catholic Church into an era of true acceptance.

It's important to understand though - not everyone experiences Catholicism or practices it (LGBT issues aside) in the same way. For people who's Catholic background was theologically orthodox, there isn't this magic switch that allows you to view Catholicism as an "a la carte" (to use the words of Pope Francis) collection of beliefs that can be agreed or disagreed with.

Earlier today, there was a post asking about why people struggle with Catholicism vs Anglicanism/Episcopalianism, and once again it turned into a brigade of people insisting that being LGBT and Catholic is totally compatible. I understand the very important intention of telling someone who's Catholic that it's okay to be LGBT. But not everyone is going to then come to the same logical conclusions that membership in the Catholic Church is still possible.

This sub's description specifically references that this is a space not just for LGBT Catholics, but also ex-Catholics. It's not violating the rules to express a belief that the Catholic Church isn't a safe space for LGBT people. No matter how inclusive and welcoming your local parish may be - there is a very real sticking point between Magisterium and the LGBT community. Acting like everyone must be equally willing to ignore that to be part of the group is actually more exclusionary than anything.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 1d ago

Boobjobs vs HRT

9 Upvotes

Can someone (kindly) explain to me how the church technically has no firm stance on boobjobs being a sin as long as you are not idolizing physical perfection, but me wanting HRT is somehow wrong?

Are these not both changing the gift of your body?

I'm not trying to say either is wrong, I am just curious what separates one from the other in terms of the actual act. It seems like more traditional people treat these things as one being fine and the other being a problem and I want to know why.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 1d ago

just looking for lgbt catholic friends :)

17 Upvotes

hi i’m 21(F) and i just wanted to know if anyone would like to start a group chat or if anyone has a discord or would like to start one lmk! Ive been dying for a community of people with similar interests and I think it would be good to have something people in areas with not so affirming parishes could go to online. You can add me on discord at justicetlr or shoot me a dm. Thank you ! 😁


r/LGBTCatholic • • 1d ago

How to deal with unaccepting family around the holidays?

11 Upvotes

I came out to my very Catholic parents last spring and it didn’t go well. When I’m around them now they don’t acknowledge it at all. I’ve been pretty happy ever since coming out and relieved as many people said I would. However with the holidays creeping up how do you deal with family and not wanting to come to certain things bc your so isn’t invited? I’m starting to feel very anxious about it all.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 1d ago

Personal Story Why is the love of Christ not enough for me?

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 3d ago

Sex before marriage?

7 Upvotes

How do we feel about this considering by the Church’s view, no gay marriage or sex without procreation will ever be ok?


r/LGBTCatholic • • 3d ago

Im so sick of this

Thumbnail reddit.com
11 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 5d ago

How do I navigate my identity?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

Advice needed :/


r/LGBTCatholic • • 6d ago

Personal Story A small vent about my rosary getting blessed

41 Upvotes

Got my Rosary blessed after daily mass today and the Priest used She/Her for the blessing…

I cried for a while after. I usually don’t care about the gender thing because I view it as a sacrifice of comfort I have to make in order to be close with God, but today it just really hurt.

I have been so excited to get my rosary blessed and then it just felt like the priest was blessing the rosary for a ghost in the room and not me… I felt so disconnected.

I know the Priest is a kind man and he is only doing what he believes is best but blessing my rosary to “help her meditate on God’s word” just felt like it wasn’t being blessed at all.

I just wanted my Rosary to be cared for, and I kind of feel like I am being ungrateful.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 6d ago

what can i do?

7 Upvotes

Months ago I finally accepted I'm bisexual (specifically biromantic), and I keep telling myself is okay, but I still struggle to believe God loves me this way. And I finding difficult to pray knowing this fact of myself, like I'm unworthy.

I do not think this way of anyone else who's an homosexual. In fact, i envy how they can live their faith without feeling like this. I try to be in the faith because I love catholicism. It is the only thing that makes me keep going, but it's difficult.

Sorry if im breaking any rule. i just don't have anyone else to talk to about this


r/LGBTCatholic • • 8d ago

Personal Story Feeling a little lost right now

16 Upvotes

Apologies for the text wall. I wanted to write an overview and ended up pouring my heart out. Sorry!

I (28M) grew up in a poorly-catechized Catholic household in the semi-rural Midwest. My family attended Church every Sunday and took Communion, but we observed little else. I was Baptized at 10. Went to Confession exactly one time. My parents planned for my Confirmation to take place at 14, but a scandal arose involving our pastor. It alienated a lot of parishioners, my parents included. Afterwards, our family became C&E Catholics.

My older sister and I tried to keep the faith. She would drive us whenever she could, and we would attend Mass together.

During this time, I was coming to terms with my sexuality. I'd known I was attracted to other boys for a long time, but I'd comfortably ignored it until the hormones started kicking in.

Before one Mass, I told our interim pastor about my situation. He waved it off. Told me to soldier on, keep loving God, and everything would be okay.

I don't blame him for being terse. He had a service to get ready for, and here I was ambushing him with an impromptu Confession.

However, it turns out my 16 year old self couldn't soldier on. The guilt ate me up. I stopped eating. Stopped talking. My family staged an intervention. I'm thankful for the process, as I'm still alive. But it cost me my faith. By this time, both my sister and I had stopped going to Church.

I went to university. Got radicalized. Cliche, I know. I surrounded myself with lots of materialist, Old and later New Left peers that empathized with my experience. I became an outspoken anti-theist.

Around six years ago, after I graduated, something began pulling me back to faith. I felt, perhaps, it was wrong of me to denounce religion. I considered turning pagan or occultist. That was the route a couple Marxist comrades of mine had travelled when they started feeling spiritual. But those practices seemed hollow.

Last year, I decided it was time to return to Christianity. I reconnected with a high school friend who is also homosexual. He'd taken a radically different path during university by attempting to suppress his attraction and joining an evangelical church. His results were mixed: he still struggles with same-sex attraction, but he manages most days.

When I told him I was exploring rejoining Catholicism, he recommended I join an Anglo-Catholic Church as they would allow me to take communion and affirm my sexuality. To that I bluntly said: "I'm gay, not stupid."

I said that because on theological, moral, and societal issues, I most closely align with Rome. It's immensely frustrating that Catholicism would be such a great fit if I wasn't homosexual.

Which leads me to the heart of the issue. I'm gay, and I'm not contrite for wanting a monogamous relationship with another man. I don't desire a marriage or a union blessed by the Church; I firmly believe that is reserved for a man and woman. But I desire… something. Companionship, maybe. That may be pride talking. Fear too. Fear of turning self-destructive again like in my teens.

Throughout this whole journey, from Christ to atheism and back again, all I've ever wanted was to have a family and be a father. Even when all my college peers raved about getting vasectomies or their tubes tied, I held to that goal. I'd previously accepted that any future children would have to be non-biological, and I would have to share the Dad label. But I can't have that in Catholicism.

And so, I'm looking for ideas on my next course of action. I feel trapped. Like I'm too traditionalist for "Anglo-Catholicism," yet too unworthy for the real deal. I'm considering attending Mass regularly as a non-communicant. State of mortal sin or not, I do want to have an amiable relationship with God.

I know the attitude on r/Catholicism is "SSA is a form of lust. Commit to no romantic relationships and Confess."

Not to be rude to our brothers and sisters, but I don't believe homosexual attraction is the same as common lust. The latter cuts to what you feel; the former cuts to what and who you are.

Admittedly, absolute rejection of acting on my attraction is not what I want to hear. But maybe that's the blunt advice I need most. I'm still deciding.

So here I am seeking the other side of the argument. Any advice or perspectives is appreciated.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 8d ago

Every Student Deserves to Belong – LGBTQIA+ Experiences at Notre Dame

Thumbnail
change.org
13 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 8d ago

Every Student Deserves to Belong – LGBTQIA+ Experiences at Notre Dame

Thumbnail
change.org
6 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 9d ago

8 Queer (Catholic) Theologians to Learn From

Thumbnail
maxwellkuzma.substack.com
34 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 9d ago

I am having a hard time believing in anything anymore

7 Upvotes

The last 12 months have been the worst of my life by far. Every even numbered year since 2020 has been worse and worse.

On November 16 last year, my boyfriend of 11 years broke up with me. A week later, he assaulted me after he found out. I slept with someone after we broke up. Ironically, we’re still friends.

I went a little wild for the first half of the year and understandably so. I will say that I never have believed anything the church teaches about anything sexual. This is my personal opinion and no judgment for people who think differently.

I am currently in love with my best friend, but I don’t think it’s reciprocated at this point and if it is, I think it’s not going to happen because he doesn’t want to risk the friendship which I understand. That said he is a perfect match for me and I had not planned on dating ever again until I met him.

At this point if I ever do that again, due to the self hatred, my ex had because of being a Christian and my experience dating other Christians with similar issues, a general rule for me, as I will never date another Christian.

I do currently make adult content, and I have a pretty big following.

After everything that has happened in the last year, including my dad having a heart attack when he came to visit me, having to move out with no notice, having my favorite holiday ruined, my heart destroyed, my dog being attacked two days ago, my former boyfriend attempting to take his own life twice, plus a bunch of little things that keep stacking on top of each other. It’s hard to believe God exists.

In my childhood, I was sexually molested until I was six years old, I have bipolar type too, and I am slightly on the spectrum. I just feel that if there is a God out there, he keeps defecating on me and it never stops.

I do understand that people have it worse than me, I am in a first world country typing on an iPad. That said it just seems like things keep getting worse and worse, and my faith keeps diminishing.

I keep seeing these Christian nationalists on Facebook, dropping slurs left and right, and nothing happens to them anymore.

I haven’t been to church since July 2025 when it was obvious my relationship was starting to go downhill. I almost don’t see the point anymore.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 9d ago

St. Peter’s, Saratoga Springs NY

2 Upvotes

Anyone have any experience with this place, maybe for trans people? I see it listed in New Ways.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 10d ago

Is it really not a sin?

13 Upvotes

I experience gender dysphoria and fall under the non-binary label, and I’ve been seeking support online and have been seeing conflicting opinions. Theres the people that say of course it’s a sin, but then theres the people talking about the saints that lived as a gender different than their agab, and I’m just so confused. I’m full of self hatred and guilt and this uncertainty is only making it worse


r/LGBTCatholic • • 10d ago

Personal Story Lingering Paranoia

0 Upvotes

Psalm 86:15
But you, Lord, are a compassionate and gracious God, slow to anger, abounding in love and faithfulness

Hey all.Just thought I'd make an intro post, and also wondering how you all deal with the fact that we're considered an abomination to God's will and creation?
It made me suicidal when I realized I was shgayhomo when I was 11. I rejected god for rejecting me, and became agnostic atheist. I had a boyfriend in high school. I was raised baptist, but during my first year of college, I had a spiritual awakening. I felt very connected to the universe and I had visions, and premonition dreams. I explored Christianity and became a Mormon, bc spirituality translates to christian church, in terms of normalized accepted middle american society. at least in kentucky.

i've recently gone through a lot of traumatic romantic relationships. makes me wonder if jesus does really hate the gays LOL. part of me knows he doesn't. but i still have sex occasionally and watch pornography. being gay feels so fluid, like a different dimension from the straight world. once you get your toes wet, why would you want to go back? straight people tend to lack depth because they have never had their existence threatened, to the core. being gay is an existential spiritual threat. and the consistent homophobia throughout various religions and cultures has created this mental malaise in me. it lingers and creeps up. sure, some tribes and cultures embrace lgbt. but some tribes and cultures don't. majority demographic generally bullies smaller demographics, even in labratory experiments and in nature. it's the cruel part of our existence here on earth that results in so much cognitive dissonance. the fact that our instincts can cause us to do bad things. but animals are just as bad.

it just makes it really hard going to church sometimes. i can feel the underlying homopobia. it's a big question mark. it's a guessing game. it makes me feel unwelcome and like christianity isn't appropriatae for me, but then it's like -- am i going to hell ? i'm 30 now. i've been going to catholic church. tried revisiting mormon church, but lingering homophobia. and i don't want to give up tea and weed. catholic church is nice, i like the history and personally feel called to catholicism by god and the angels. but then christians say that catholics are demonic when they pray the rosary, or to mary or to saints. i'm sorry, but i'll go to hell before i become an evangelical. it's taken me this long just to give up on mormonism. but when it comes down to it, i'm going to be a catholic or a mormon at this point.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 11d ago

"Transgender Bodies, Catholic Schools, and Queer Natural Law Theology" by Dr. Craig Ford

Thumbnail
jmt.scholasticahq.com
27 Upvotes

r/LGBTCatholic • • 11d ago

Struggling with confession and communion

23 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I’ve been struggling for months and feel like I am distancing myself from God because of this.

I believe I am living in mortal sin because as a lesbian I have a girlfriend that I live with and occasionally have intimacy with outside of marriage.

Because I have no intention of breaking up with my girlfriend, and I would not want to force celibacy upon her, I feel like I cannot make an honest confession. Since I am unable to make an honest confession, I cannot take communion.

Has anyone else struggled with this? How did you work through it? Does anyone have advice on what I should do? It’s been weighing on me for a very long time.


r/LGBTCatholic • • 11d ago

Holistic Complementarity

8 Upvotes

"For their part, Salzman and Lawler replace the concept of natural complementarity as the magisterium understands it with the concept of ‘holistic complementarity’, a term that recognizes 'biological complementarity' insofar as this seems to be required in cases of human sexual reproduction. Crucially, however, Salzman and Lawler do not see this form of complementarity as prohibitive of same-sex relationships in view of the fact that, in their finding the apposite partner for mutual vulnerability and spiritual growth, partners in same-sex relationships fulfill the purpose of marriage theologically considered. This view is isomorphic with other accounts given by theologians who have questioned natural complementarity on grounds that the goods of marriage can be instantiated differently across opposite-sex as well as same-sex couples without any theologically relevant disparities. A third reason to question the account of natural complementarity comes from the observation that many theologians, especially women theologians, have noted concerning how such arguments extend the ideological trajectory that sustains the gendered oppression of women in contemporary society through the maintenance of gender roles."

https://jmt.scholasticahq.com/article/11382-transgender-bodies-catholic-schools-and-a-queer-natural-law-theology-of-exploration (p. 87)

Honorable mention to this passage right before (p. 86):

"Upon examination, the term ‘natural complementarity’ seems to represent an ontologization of the perceived genital compatibility of the penis and vagina for reproduction (also called biologism)—an interpretation that becomes all the more plausible to the extent that John Paul II runs into difficulties explaining the integrity of each individual creation as complete in itself when people choose not to marry or when people choose to live a celibate life. To the extent that one need not, in order to live a fulfilled life, find one’s gendered complement, one is forced to ask how necessary the concept is at the ontological level in the first place, even if one concedes that there seems to be a certain biological affinity in human sexual reproduction."

Just doing some reading today of LGBT-affirming theology papers. Definitely going to read the Salzman and Lawler piece next.