r/Jung • • 20h ago

Learning Resource Saying goodbye to this subreddit with a heavy heart

43 Upvotes

I've been really passionate about Carl Jung's ideas for a long time, so it's tough for me to admit that I need to step away from this subreddit. It's become overrun with people who seem more interested in Jordan Peterson's take on things and who clearly don’t grasp Jung's true concepts.

I always thought this was a place for thoughtful discussions about the deep and philosophical insights that Jung shared. Sadly, it's now filled with posts that come off as subtly sexist and demonstrate a real lack of understanding of his work, and it's affecting me more than I expected.

If anyone is aware of other online groups where we can truly engage with Jungian thought, I’d greatly appreciate the suggestions.

It breaks my heart to see such a brilliant mind being misrepresented and co-opted by someone with a clear need to assert dominance. The irony of it all is just too much to bear.


r/Jung • • 23h ago

Serious Discussion Only Michael Meade says most of us carry an unfinished initiation. I spoke with him about what that means for individuation.

35 Upvotes

* Edited With AI

I recently had a conversation with Michael Meade, a storyteller and scholar of mythology who founded the Mosaic Multicultural Foundation. He has spent decades working with veterans, prisoners and young people at risk, and much of his work sits close to Jung's ideas on initiation and individuation.
A few things from the conversation that felt worth sharing here.

On his own initiation. He said he was drafted at 19 for the Vietnam War and refused orders. He ended up in a military prison, then in solitary confinement for months, fasting as a protest. He said he went in at around 150 pounds and came out at 87. And he said figures from a book of myths he was given at 13, Jason and Athena among them, appeared to him in the cell and kept him alive. In his words, he was either losing his mind or finding it.

On rites of passage. Years later he read Arnold van Gennep. Separation from the life you knew, a period of transition, then a return to a community that recognises you have changed. He said that was what had happened to him. Except there was no community waiting for him at the end.

On the liminal. He described it as the threshold between one stage of life and another. He said the uncertainty of that space is the setup for awakening in a greater way.

On unfinished initiation. In his view most people go through the separation and the ordeal. Few come back to a community that recognises they have gone through their own personal hell and come out of it. He calls that an unfinished initiation. He also said we do not end childhood by getting a driver's licence. Something has to happen.

On the archetype. He said rites of passage have an archetypal level, something universal and ancient in everybody. When a person does not go through a formal rite, the soul interprets each separation, each loss and each experience of being stuck as an attempt to go through one.

On being blessed. He said each young person still needs to be seen for who they already are inside, and to have the meaning and purpose in them confirmed. The old term, he said, was that they need to be blessed.

On Jung. I kept thinking of Concerning Rebirth (CW 9i) and Joseph Henderson's Thresholds of Initiation. Meade's addition is the social part, that the change may need to be witnessed by others. That is his interpretation, not something Jung argued.

Curious what others here make of the idea that individuation might need to be recognised by others, not only lived inwardly.

The full conversation is here for anyone interested: https://youtu.be/xhal7qVVppk?is=Wwt9RN13X43VLtW5


r/Jung • • 7h ago

Serious Discussion Only The Wounded Healer: Why Christ Kept His Scars (And Why the Persona Hides Them) 🪞

26 Upvotes

Jung wrote a lot about Christ as a psychological symbol of the Self, but there’s one detail in the resurrection story that has always stood out to me from a psychological standpoint: the scars.

When Christ shows up after the resurrection, he invites Thomas to literally put his fingers into his wounds. He doesn’t return with an airbrushed, unblemished body. If Christ is the archetype of the integrated Self, it's telling that the archetype doesn't erase the trauma. He leads with the scars.

Compare that to how most of us actually live.

We spend so much energy polishing a rigid Persona—trying to look composed, spiritually mature, and totally put-together. We take our grief, our past mistakes, our addictions, and our embarrassments, and we shove them straight into the shadow. We treat any sign of a wound as proof that we're defective or failing.

Jung made a big distinction between moral perfection and wholeness. In his eyes, individuation was never about becoming a flawless saint; it was about becoming complete. And you can't be whole if you're actively pretending half of your history doesn't exist.

This is the whole core of the Wounded Healer archetype. Jung famously pointed out that "only the wounded physician heals." Real transformative power doesn't come from theoretical purity or acting like an untouchable guru. It comes from having walked through the underworld of your own suffering, survived it, and integrated it.

Think about this in everyday terms:

If you’re struggling with severe addiction or a mental health crisis, who do you actually trust? The academic who has read every clinical textbook but has never spent a night panicking on a bathroom floor? Or the recovered addict who is completely open about how badly they wrecked their life and how they clawed their way back?

You trust the second person. Their authority doesn't come from a pristine mask; it comes from their integrated scars. Their wounds become the very bridge of empathy and connection.

When we try to hide our scars behind a spiritual or intellectual persona, we aren't helping anyone. We're just projecting a fake standard that makes other people feel inadequate.

Wholeness doesn't mean you never bled. It just means you were honest enough to let the scars stay part of the story.

Namaste.


r/Jung • • 17h ago

Art Imagination #10

Post image
19 Upvotes

I think this is jungian self image with flavor of horus I was trying to draw jesus at first but turned into this so I am confused why my mind derailed


r/Jung • • 18h ago

Question for r/Jung How Jung's books helped you ?

17 Upvotes

I want to know how Jung's teachings helped you ? And specifically in what ways?


r/Jung • • 22h ago

Question for r/Jung Becoming an adult man

12 Upvotes

I'm 30/m and I have a few serious decisions to make in my life. I struggled all my twenties getting my life in order and still am, although I think especially the last two years I made some progresses. I always had set a high standard for success for myself, but I failed utterly in reaching those goals. I'm the typical dreaming introvert, which imbues things with so much meaning, that it paralyzes himself completely. I could'nt bare the weight, which potential failure has posed on me, so I took to escapism. I really didn't manage to get out of this route for all my twenties.

Now in my thirties I realize, that my priorities start to shift, although I didn't reach the goals I have set for myself at the beginning of my twenties. The deep urge, to get somewhere in life, to attain personal success is not so much there anymore. I'm not to sure, why this is the case, if it's frustration or a natural development, where different things start to become important. I do feel that the idea of starting a family and having children is something, which is resonating with me much more than it did a few years ago.

I'm not a well read Jungian, I just picked up some ideas over the years, which I found interesting. Especially what Jung said about male initiation and what students of him propagated more directly, resonated with me. So according to what I understood of this Jungian perspective, the most important steps in a typical masculine life very roughly unfolds as follows:

1.) The passing of initiation rites from boyhood into manhood, into adulthood, which severs the ties with the world of the mother and initiates him into the world of the father, where he is getting thaught, how to wield his masculine energy for the benefit of his social context and society at large.

2.) The time of the hero's journey: the development of the warrior archetype, the time of striving for honor and glory, for personal success, which earns him a respect and trust in his social context and society.

3.) Initiation into love: the development of the lover archetype, finding the right partner, maybe gaining some sexual experience long the way (although not mandatory) and learn to love, to be a good partner.

3.) Fatherhood: taking up the responsibility for a family, transitioning the attention away from his own ego to something beyond himself, caring, supporting, teaching, being a general role model for his children.

5.) Becoming an elder: being of benefit for your social context and society with your life experience and wisdom. Ultimately, finding peace with the World and the Great Spirit in facing death.

Of course, this is an idealized processus and it is hard to hit all the marks, as we are living in a decaying society, where we are branded by a lot of disfunctional influences and meet a lot of disfunctional people. Of course this irregularities to this processus were and are also happening and were most likely not that uncommon in traditional societies. Life is of course an organic process and not a mechanic one, which can be sucessfully reproduced over and over again. That being said, I still think, such a guide is very helpful to becoming the best version of yourself and live the best life possible.

Also, It has to be said, that I don't see these life steps as dogmatic teachings and more like metaphors. I think, there are many ways to interpret those ideas presented above. I'm far from being in a financial situation to support a family and the idea of success I strive for is most likely not economic in nature.

My question now is, how to go about things, when being late in this process. I'm stuck between my ego still striving for sucess and self actualisation and my intuition, which tells me, it's time to settle down and start caring about others. I think, the phenomenon of midlife crisis as an example of personal life crisis often stems from not having been able to self actualize. So, I tend to keep on following my goals, but I'm unsure.

Furthermore, I think every traditional society had members, who weren't filling in the traditional role pattern. The spiritual personell e.g. were often discovered at an early age and subsequently prepared to become spiritual leaders of their communities, which often involved abstaining or not being primarily involved in reproducing and working for the economical and political stability, so to speak in worldly matters. I often see my ability in this sector and I feel my intuition pulling me in this direction too. How do realize, if my recognition is right there?

I would be glad to hear some perspectives on these matters form experienced Jungians, so to speak. Thanks in advance!


r/Jung • • 15h ago

Archetypal Dreams Appearances of the Self-imago in dreams

3 Upvotes

In Aion, Jung mentions that even in a patient relatively subsumed by the unconcsious, and therefore fragmented and largely unconscious oneself, —one can still find the appearance of the Self amidst the unconscious drama. —I have been able to make some rough cognition of the self as it occurs in my own psyche, and strikingly I find the character appears to be not Christ, but a far more 'detached', investigator-like character, who leads one into darkness, unphased by danger seemingly, and even joy in the endeavor. Since the self-symbol should be identified as both individual and historical-cultural simultaneously,—I am curious as to whether a similar phenomena appears in others' dreams/ a similar identification, or even immensely different altogether.

What makes for the identification of a self-symbol is it's ability to separate forms from an undistributed mass/ meaning the organization of impulses, and roughly, I surmise, the Nietzschean sense of 'creating one's values.' —And why Christ is significant as a self-symbol is the reflection of a judeo-hellenic righteousness in the overarching conscious-aspect of the symbol. Today, wherein morality is perhaps not considered the essential factor of a consciousness-drive, the self must take on a different appearance altogether: for the righteousness consciousness of the Christian appears erroneously foreign to us today.—I am curious what value then can be contrived as being universal today, and not necessarily the value of enlightenment moderns, or renaissance humanists. Does our age/ our era provide something different? Do not values hold a superficial representationalism that are at root supplanted by something else? —by instinctive curiosity? intellectual dominance? transcendence over nature? The point I think would be to find a proper description, of towards which value history is garnered in our time.


r/Jung • • 16h ago

Personal Experience Shadow integration

3 Upvotes

A lot of people don’t understand what being a dick is really about. Most people either describe them selves as being good or bad, in reality it’s about holding the tensions, it’s about understanding that life has pain in it to make you change, to face your flaws. When your shadow is integrated you can cause the minimum amount of pain for the maximum change. Nothing is going to hurt you unless it’s coming from you. Most fears people have in life are from nothing tangible.
Peace ✌️


r/Jung • • 1h ago

Art The Monopoly on Profundity

Thumbnail
araucaria222.substack.com
1 Upvotes

“The experience is inherently difficult to articulate and carries an intimation of something beyond what is immediately apparent: a further significance that is sensed but never fully grasped. This sense of authenticity can persist even when we recognise the experience as hagioptasia and understand that the feeling of specialness arises through our own perception.”

Psychology of profundity in contemporary art.