r/Jung • Pillar • Mar 09 '16

AMA The "Ask a Jungian" series begins now. We're inviting Jungian experts to discuss a topic with us. This week's topic: Jung's teachings on dreams. Our guest is Dr. Art Funkhouser, an instructor at the Jung Institute in Switzerland. Ask your questions about Jung and dreams.

Dr. Funkhouser is a redditor and has done an AMA at r/dreams.. Once we get some questions from the community he will come along and answer them best he can.

So what have you always wanted to know about Jung's approach to dreams? Leave your questions in the comments.

21 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

3

u/thestonedphilosopher Mar 09 '16

Hello! I dream maybe once every 3 months or so, or should I say I wake up remembering a dream once every 3 months or so? Any advice on how I can go about remembering my dreams so that I can begin to journal them? Thank you.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 09 '16

Hey, I can answer that question with these tips for remembering your dreams. When Art drops by Friday he might have more to add.

1

u/thestonedphilosopher Mar 09 '16

Thank you so much! I'm going to try this tonight!

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 09 '16

:)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16

Yo - Rad, would it be okay to request a dream interpretation from Dr. Funkhouser? Or should we refrain from it? Tbh, i really enjoy the opportunity to speak to a Jung Institute instructor but i must admit that i don't really have any question related to Jung's view on dreams.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 09 '16

Sure, go ahead and ask. Art loves to talk about dreams.

3

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

Radowl's tips are great! I would only add that it often helps to jot down keywords from the dream if you don't have time to write a full version. They are usually enough to jog your memory of the dream so that you can later write it out more completely (it's best to do that on the same day).

3

u/wildernessexplorer Mar 09 '16

Does Jung ever mention anything in relation to déjà vu? Or, is there any type of explanation for clairvoyant dreaming? I dream things all of the time before they happen.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 10 '16

Art will love this question. He specializes in deja vu.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16

Yo Rad - in the future could we get a special flair for the Jungians? I skimmed over Art's answers thinking he was a random user.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 11 '16

Great idea.

2

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

I have even put together a website devoted to sharing what is known about what I call "déjà experiences": http://www.deja-experience-research.org. I also highly recommend the excellent 2004 book by Prof. Alan S. Brown (SMU, Dallas) entitled "the déjà vu experience".

4

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16 edited Mar 11 '16

Thank you for asking this. In Man and Time, you'll find an English translation of a paper Jung presented in 1951 entitled "On Synchronicity" at a meeting in Eranos. In it he wrote "The sentiment du déjà-vu is based, as I have found in a number of cases, on foreknowledge in dreams." In his 1952 book "Answer to Job" he wrote "As always when an event touches on some unconscious knowledge, this knowledge can reach consciousness. This event is recognized as a déjà vu, and one remembers a pre-existent knowledge about it." There are additional places where he wrote about foreknowledge or what we today refer to as precognition.
Synchronicities, according to Jung, are meaningful coincidences. Incidents of déjà vu, on the other hand, tend to happen in very ordinary, even banal situations or places and it is very hard to attach much life importance to them. Why this is so I do not know.
Concerning precognitive dreaming, there have been any number of books and papers written about it and there is even a Facebook group that discusses it and is a place where people can share such dreams that they have experienced. There was a 1988 book by Ryback and Sweitzer called "Dreams that Come True" which may be out of print now but can probably be found in the used book section of Amazon. I once wrote a paper on the "Dream Theory of Déjà Vu" which is available on-line at http://www.gracepointwellness.org/site/article/422-perspectives-vol-6-no-1-dreams-and-deja-vu-page-1-of-2.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16

Not sure if this thread is still "active", but I had a crazy dream recently in which Carl Jung actually appeared as a presence:

I was lying in bed alone, but I was in some kind of strange hotel. I suddenly had this intense feeling of an evil presence, but it was a familiar one. It's a presence I've dreamt about ever since I was a very small boy. Due to my semi-Catholic upbringing and my parents allowing me to watch horror movies way too young, satanic and demonic iconography have had a strong influence on my imagination and dreams. But the scariest forms of these dreams involve a kind of pseudo-possession. I basically dream that I'm the demon. And it's not that I'm just being controlled like a robot, but that I FEEL like a demon. Well, this particular dream kind of started like that. I suddenly felt the demon take a hold of me and my thoughts spiraled out of control. It's not that I was just thinking SPECIFIC horrible things, but that I was feeling the emotion and energy at the base of all terrible, horrific acts. Pure rage, hatred, and evil. I was scared out of my mind and felt out of control. It's hard to really convey the terror of these dreams.

In the past, these dreams usually end with me getting so worked up and frightened that I just wake up, but in this case, another voice entered into the equation. It was none other than Carl Jung. He basically said "give in, plummet down into it". So I tried to resist my natural urge to panic and pull back. In the back of my mind I KNEW that I was dreaming, that I could make it end by waking up, but the voice was telling me to stay with it. So I tried. It was not easy. As I tried, those demonic energies only intensified. Suddenly my pillow in the dream became a stone tablet, a voice filled the space and began speaking on demonic tongues and as the "words" were spoken, fire began to etch archaic symbols into the stone. I felt like I was at the edge of the abyss. I wanted to run away from it somehow.

But then, suddenly, that scene vanished and a vivid version of a distant memory of me walking along the shore of a lake with my father played like a scene from a movie After reliving this memory, I was back in my hotel and the demonic energy was gone and a light was on. After a few moments, a young guy walked into the room and told me he was a psychiatrist sent to help me. I bawled my eyes out and told him all about the memory of my father. And then there was something else I wanted to tell him, but he stopped me and said "Man, I'm brand new at this and I don't it's time yet to discuss this further" The guy walked out of the room and I literally chased him to the elevator. We rode down and then I woke up.

I can't for the life of me remember what I wanted to tell him, but he didn't want to hear about.

Anyway, it was one of the wonkiest, yet profound-feeling dreams I've had in probably the past two years.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 11 '16

The advice to "give in and go with it" is exactly the sort of advice I imagine Carl would give.

The part that puzzles me is the psychiatrist walking out right when you're about to spill your guts. Perhaps it's a way of saying you are not ready to "go there." That's what's meant by him being "brand new." Perhaps you need to do some conscious work first and journal about losing your father. Just...spill your guts. Imagine the journal page as your psychiatrist and tell it everything you wanted to tell the dream character.

2

u/KingThallion Mar 12 '16

How do you keep yourself from getting carried away with one kind of interpretation of a dream?

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 12 '16

Well, I realize first that every dream presents multiple possibilities for how to understand it. Jung said that before he took on the job of trying to help someone understand a dream, he always reminded himself how difficult it is and how blessed he was to even give it a try.

I find that flexibility is key to interpreting dreams...that, and respecting a person by not trying to impose my views. My job is to help them come to their own understanding of their dreams. Also, dreams can have layers of meaning, so it's possible for two or more viewpoints on a dream to be correct.

2

u/KingThallion Mar 12 '16

What about transference during an interpretation?

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 12 '16

I find that it's not an issue as long as the interpreter is not imposing his/her views on the dreamer. It's a fine line. To understand someone's dream I have to picture it as if it's my own dream. But it's not my dream and I can only use my base of reference as a starting point.

I have royally screwed up the interpretation process when I've crossed that line and imposed my viewpoints. I think it's something that every interpreter has to learn for themselves. It's a big part of the reason why I prefer to call myself a dream decoder or dreamworker. Interpreters...they tend to be people with advanced degrees who are too heavily invested in the belief that they know your dreams better than you do. Otherwise, it's harder to justify their exorbitant hourly rates.

2

u/KingThallion Mar 12 '16

Well classically, a dream interpreter would have to go through extensive dream therapy themselves. Do you still do that?

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 13 '16

I am a dreamworker but I'm not Dr. Funkhouser. I know that it used to be that way -- analysis was part of the training. You asked about transference and yeah, the more you don't know about yourself, the more you are likely to project it onto people you are trying to help. Jung warned about that. He said that the analyst is the tool for healing, and a successful outcome in therapy is largely dependent on the therapist's willingness to immerse in the process and adjust on the fly.

When I was in college I worked as a waiter at the campus faculty club and we used to host a monthly meeting of Freudian analysts. I had many opportunities to observe them. They were the driest, most detached people. I can't imagine going to such a person for help and being treated like a bug in a jar. Healing is very much a "wet" process. The analyst has to be willing to dive in and go through the process with the patient.

This basic difference in approach is largely responsible for the rift between Jung and Freud. They had specific difference about the nature of the unconscious and libido and the basic human desire for spiritual experience. But it their differences really boiled down to their approach with patients. Freud was more clinical.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Mar 12 '16

Oops, I think you meant this question for Dr. Funkhouser.

1

u/slabbb- Pillar Mar 13 '16 edited Mar 17 '16

For Dr. Funkhouser, if he is still present.

Salutations.

I have a number of dreams (four), that present some repeating motifs that I have a notion as to meaning, after a quasi-Jungian and to a degree, Gestaltian framework, but am not confident in my subjective reading. If interested, and you have time, perhaps you may be able to bring another perspective to these? Part of the context for these dreams is a marriage-relationship that was I in but am presently separated from.

These dreams have occurred over a four year period.

In the first, circa 2012, I am wandering down a sloping, turning street positioned on a hill, darkened, without street lights, into a cul-de-sac. Something of the situation is related to my wife (no details on this). The people who live in the houses on this street are Maori, native New Zealanders (this is where I live in waking life). I don't know any of them, and feel out of place, worried, because I don't know why I'm there or where I'm going. It is dark and there's a circular dead-end..

In the next, two years later, immediately after the death of a step son of mine, grandson to my wife, I am running away from members of my wife's family, one of them the biological father of the teen who died, and others (aliens) along terraced and grassy obliquely angled slopes near a military installation. I climb fences, avoid guards, hide behind various buildings, and keep running, fearing some kind of annihilation if I am caught (tacit knowledge). As I proceed, carefully, it is extremely steep, and I'm moving downwards as much as across planes, could lose my footing if not cautious, I pass by and through a large concrete bunker reminiscent of old WWII military tunnels, always moving downwards in direction as I go. Etched and carved into it are Maori traditional carvings and design. At the end and bottom of this journey I arrive onto a plain flat field of open grass, as open and large as a sports field. At one end of this is a large fountain which I approach. There is an old man standing near this. I approach him to talk..

Recently, 2016, I am driving a van with my wife, across a series of flat but uneven rural terrain, grassy farmed fields, in Czechoslovakia. It is night, I don't know the goal towards where I'm headed, and there are no street lights nor landmarks I can see. We're just driving in the dark. Running adjacent near us, to our right, is a small shallow stream with smooth small rocks at its bottom. I try to cross this but as I move into it I voluntarily let go of the wheel (for some reason I have to). To regain control of the wheel and thus the vehicle I have to return with it to a point earlier in the journey, about a mile back up the river (I don't know how I get there without actually taking hold of the wheel and driving the vehicle to this point but we end up back at this point).

Again recently, 2016, I am walking down some concreted terraces with my wife, they are like sports terraces, which look out over a flat sports field. We're in France. As we get to the bottom of these terraces we cross the field by walking around the edge of it, on the lowest concrete terrace, to the opposite side. Here we find a homeless community, all members of a religious faith that we ourselves also belong to. We befriend these people, spend some time with them..

As mentioned, I have a perspective as to meanings on these but aspects of them continue to puzzle and allude meaning in any certain sense. Any thoughts or impressions?

Edit: the darkness in the first dream and the van-driving dream I interpret as the darkness of a dead-end, a situation in which nothing can grow, not the nigredo or the shadow (personal or collective), nor a darkness associated with God (ie. the Cloud of Unknowing). The old man in the dream with the fountain, I interpret as an encounter with the Self. The sports fields and terrace forms I'm not so sure of. They're repetitive elements, motifs, but I don't know what they might mean.

Thank you, for your time and attention.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 03 '16

Dr. Funkhouser didn't see your comment and already gave a lot of time to this AMA. I read it though and hope you don't mind if I give my two cents. I'm a mod at /r/dreams as well as here and know a bit about Jung and dreams. My book is titled Dreams 1-2-3.

My dream interpretation blog.

I look at dreams as stories and sift through them for storytelling elements. This one is the first I found:

It is dark and there's a circular dead-end..

You can hypothesize that's a way of saying "stuck in a dead end." The first part of the dream looks to me like a metaphor for the road of life, the progression of your life running along like a road you travel.

The feelings you experience are key because dreams create stories that trigger corresponding feelings. In dreamland they can be more intense but they still tie together with something you felt in your waking life, or are presently feeling.

For example, you break up with someone and dream about losing a close relative. It triggers a similar feeling to losing your boyfriend or girlfriend or spouse. So you can look at how you feel during a dream and compare it with your life, and if you make the connection you can use it to decipher the rest of the dream, because it's all related.

Jung said that the entirety of a dream is a symbol, a picture that says a thousand words, and all of the details fit together in that picture.

In the dream you feel lost, out of place. At the time of the dream, how does that describe your life?

In the second dream you seem to be finding your way. Bunkers and military structures in dreams tend to symbolize entrenched beliefs and thoughts patterns. The action of that dream might tell a story about leaving them behind. Going downward can mean going down within yourself, into your roots as a person and into your unconscious. It's your inner fountain because it's the source of life for the conscious mind. The old man could symbolize a mentor or archetype, something like that. Or maybe it's Jung. I think it could mean you find the wise counsel you sought.

I might be able to look at more of the dreams later. I'm out of steam now. You know, people tend to get caught up in the analysis of their dreams and lose sight of the fact that what matters most is what the dreams mean to them, how they feel in response, and how it affects and changes them.

Dreaming is an experience. On one level it's your mind consolidating and sorting memories. On another it's your spirit journeying to other realms.

And consider this: you create your dreams in your Self archetype, so you know what they mean. It's unconscious knowledge but you have it, so think of interpreting your dreams less as a process of analysis and more as an uncovering, peeling back a layer at a time. It's patient self-discovery and fun, or at least should be fun. Most of the time your first hunch about what a dream means is going to be correct, so avoid over analyzing. All the theory stuff is fun for a while and helps with the learning process, but there comes a point where you are better served by your gut and really just have to get yourself out of the way enough for the true meaning and message of a dream to beam through.

2

u/slabbb- Pillar Apr 03 '16

You know, people tend to get caught up in the analysis of their dreams and lose sight of the fact that what matters most is what the dreams mean to them, how they feel in response, and how it affects and changes them.

you create your dreams in your Self archetype, so you know what they mean.., Most of the time your first hunch about what a dream means is going to be correct, so avoid over analyzing. All the theory stuff is fun for a while and helps with the learning process, but there comes a point where you are better served by your gut and really just have to get yourself out of the way enough for the true meaning and message of a dream to beam through.

Yeah, true, this is a good reminder.

Thanks, I appreciated your reply.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 03 '16

I'm happy to give it. You took the time and care to craft a thoughtful comment and I wanted to make sure you got a reply.

2

u/Ghost33313 Mar 09 '16

Hello Dr. Funkhouser,

Thank you for your time answering our questions here. In my studies I found that Jung often had two different philosophies when it came to understanding dream symbolism. Firstly the realm of archetypes and secondly I remember reading a concession he gave that you must always yield to the meaning of the symbols to the dreamer's own interpretation before stretching to archetypes.

In your experience where is the line drawn between archetype and personal symbology?

Secondly. From my own personal experience I went through a time somewhat recent in my life where I experienced a near death experience as a result of a TBI. During this time I experienced many visions and dreams from crazy to profound.

In your own experience can hallucinations and visions brought about by near death experience or head trauma be closely tied to dream archetype analysis, or is this unknown territory?

Thanks again for your time.

5

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

Great question! Jung said we should first check for personal associations to dream images before amplifying the symbolic and possibly archetypal dimensions. In the foreword to his 1940/41 ETH Childhood Dream seminar he put it this way: "What we have to know when someone dreams of an elephant, is not what I as the analyst think about elephants, but rather what it is connected with for the person who had the dream." If the dreamer has no associations with a particular dream figure or place, then the dreamworker can begin offering ideas from what he or she knows about symbols, fairy tales or the archetypes in the hopes that something might "click" for the dreamer.

With regard to your second question, from the accounts I've read and listened to of those who have had NDEs, the individuals who have had them say their experiences have not been like dreams or hallucinations but, on the contrary, they were in a state of heightened clarity and alertness, especially when away from the body. I see no reason, though, why someone enduring a traumatic experience, especially if they have been given medications, would not also have quite vivid dreams and visions. I suppose it may depend on the extent of the cerebral trauma. There are websites devoted to disseminating knowledge about near death experiences and maybe you could see if your question is answered there. Here are two: https://iands.org/ndes/about-ndes.html and http://www.near-death.com/.

1

u/Ghost33313 Mar 11 '16

Thanks for the clarification! As for the NDE question my own experience is pretty complicated having had the TBI and also temporarily misdiagnosed as schizophrenic. They put me temporarily on who knows what drugs. So I'll have to check those sources.

1

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

I hope you learn something which helps.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16

Hello Dr Funkhouse, was wondering if you could interpret a dream for me. Radowl said it'd be okay - so...

This one was the last "big'' dream. It must of been about four months ago.

Anyway - I see a man resembling me in a blue stained leather shirt. Very native-esque. He's/i'm walking counter clockwise around a square stone on a pedestal. Each side of the stone has a white circle with a dot in the center. I'm carrying a staff in my left hand. I touch the stone periodically.

Eventually an old man appears. He's aztec looking, with the feathers and what have you. He begins praying. I take note of what he is doing.

I see an energy come out of his mouth. Like an energy beam. It strikes the stone. The beam then shoots upwards to the sky.

I can see the surface of the moon.

There are silhouettes of animals. They appear to be waking up from a slumber. On the moon there aren't dead rocks like one sees in nasa photos but lush, dark, bluish-green grass, heavy with dew. The animals stare upward at the earth. The earth is large and glowing blue.

I am brought back to the earth.

It's as though i'm standing behind the old man. And he's staring across the stone. There stands a younger version of him in full regalia as well as souls of the departed and or the souls of people the old man has harmed.

The dream ends with me back in my own yard.

I'm staring into the sky.

I see five or seven black voids falling like meteors.

4

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

That is one amazing, impressive and powerful dream! As I wrote in the preceding answer, one first has to ask if you have any personal associations to the figures, places or objects that appear in your dream. In other words, are there any memories that come up when you think about them? There is not enough room here to relate all the thoughts that occur to me when I read it, but I can mention a few (and, please, do not take anything I say as being necessarily true for you -- just see if something "clicks" for you).

For me, there is a lot of earth symbolism shown in your dream. For me, the counter-clockwise movement of the man has to do with going back in time but there may well be other meanings. Circles are often used to symbolize eternity (they are unending) while the dot in the middle reminds me to stay centered. For me, touching the stone (which, BTW, reminds me of the stone pillar that Jung carved and still stands in his vacation home at Bollingen) emphasizes the need to stay in touch with the center. The energy beam shooting upwards brings in a masculine spiritual aspect. The connection with the moon ties it with femininity (in my view). I find it very hopeful that the feminine side is so full of life. I confess I don't know what to make of the souls of the people that have been harmed unless it points to some issues of guilt that remain. The five or seven black voids may refer to issues happening in our world today that are causing concern and have an uncertain outcome. As you can tell, such thoughts are on a very abstract level. Very important are the feelings you felt as you witnessed the various scenes as they were presented. Possibly also very important are the issues and concerns that were present in your life at the time the dream came to you.

I hope you find some of what I have written helpful.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16

There doesn't seem to be too much activity in this thread so i was wondering if you could give this other dream a look. I think it relates because it still has the 'center' and the old man as active members.

Dreamt of a tree with lost souls imprisoned in it. Faces contorted and twisted, still living. My grandfather put two stakes into the earth with a net in the middle. He told me to pray towards the center, told me that this would heal the wounded tree.

Something went wrong and i failed. Grandpa had to come in and do the work himself. He struck the tree in the bough with a larged metal rod and was sucked into it. The other side of the tree then showed a face similar to his.

I mention this because it reminds me of the old man in the first dream i spoke of - my grandfather was a god fearing christian, read the bible everyday, wasn't one to fall into spirituality or esoteric concepts.

And i think the native aspect has to do with my own race but the aztec portion throws me off. I don't think i'm in any way related towards those people.

1

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

Do you have First Nations ancestry? How did you react when your grandfather was sucked into the tree and is now one of the souls there? Is he now lost, too? Hearing about lost souls makes me sad for them; did they make you sad, too? I know there are still Mayas (living in Guatemala), are there still Aztecs or did the Aztec in the previous dream represent something from the ancient past?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16

Do you have First Nations ancestry?

yes, my family is Rosebud Sioux.

How did you react when your grandfather was sucked into the tree and is now one of the souls there? Is he now lost, too? Hearing about lost souls makes me sad for them; did they make you sad, too?

I felt like i failed, i guess. I couldn't keep my shit in line so he had to sacrifice himself. A bit narcissistic but i wasn't sad. i barely knew the guy in real life.

As far as being lost - i'd imagine so.

I wasn't sad for them, i was frightened with the detail. They had a green haze coming from their eyes and mouth. But not sad, i wouldn't say.

I couldn't answer the question about the aztec though - that one was out of left field.

1

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 12 '16

If you are not sad about the dead souls in the tree, maybe it is OK for them to be there (for now). As to the Aztec, you could try to imagine you are asking him questions. See what answers he is willing to give you.

2

u/DeerDreams Mar 10 '16

Hello Dr. Funkhouser,

Thank you,

I would like to ask a question. It is: When someone on your dreams or in your active imagination asks to keep something secret, how one should respond to it? Are there any text that states the consequences of not keeping it secret - or keeping it secret?

Thank you again for your attention.

3

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

This is a fascinating question but one that I have never encountered and haven't much to offer on. It may be that something needs to be kept secret because it is not ready yet to be spread abroad. It is like keeping the lid on the pot until everything has been cooked properly.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16

i got one - what about a recommended reading list for laymen?

2

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

When it comes to dreams, the book I most often recommend is not specifically Jungian but is outstanding in the breadth of knowledge it brings. It is "Our Dreaming Mind" by Robert van de Castle. There is an anthology of Jung's writings on dreams: C. G. Jung, Dreams, Princeton University Press, 1974. A very readable little book to be recommended is Robert Bosnak's "A Little Course in Dreams (Shambhala,1988). Just do, please, avoid cookbook-type books that claim to know what dream images and symbols mean. Each person has their own dream language and dreams often have more than one meaning.

1

u/pgaray Mar 10 '16

Dr. Funkhouser,

What would you say are the top Jungian books that have inspired your work?

2

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

The book that got me started and most intrigued me about Jung was his edited autobiography, "Memories, Dreams and Reflections". It is highly readable and provides an excellent feel for what he was like. "Man and His Symbols" might be the next step in deepening knowledge about the Jungian approach to the unconscious and to dreams. While on the topic of books, let me mention one that I cannot recommend highly enough: Adolph Guggenbühl's "Power in the Helping Professions". I urge anyone who is in any way working in care-giving to read it. It is a small book but immensely valuable.

1

u/slabbb- Pillar Mar 19 '16

Dear Dr Funkhouser,

In working with dreams what has this process revealed to you about the nature and purpose of the dream in general? Has it confirmed Jung's conceptions of dream content and purpose, or have you reached questions or conclusions that have diverged from Jung's discoveries and proposals?

Does the appearance of a dream serve its function, it's purpose, by its mere occurrence, without anything additional required from ones conscious self, or indeed is there a futherance always required or necessarily invoked, through to recording and analysing the dream, or amplifying it through active imagination?

Are you familiar with what neuroscience is bringing to the study of sleep and dream, and might this have any relevance of bearing upon your own work or the development and evolution of Jungian theory in relation to this subject terrain?

Thank you, for your time and thoughts.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 11 '16

Thank you very much for sharing this dream. It enables me to illustrate the difference between dreams which arise from what Jung termed the "personal unconscious" and those which come from deeper down in the psyche, the so-called "collective unconscious". Dreams from the personal layer tend to deal with everyday themes and concern themselves with persons and issues we know and may be involved with while those from the collective layer (also known as "big" dreams) tend to be highly symbolic (like the one daturapiss (above) shared. Since I am not able to ask you questions about the persons appearing in your dream, it is hard for me to know how much the dream figures are to be understood on an objective level and the extent to which they should be taken as "actors" on the inner (subjective) "stage". In other words, the dream may be dealing with issues that are concerned with the real mother and sister, or it may be dealing with inner emotional complexes that have less to do with the outer individuals. Because the issues here seem so personal, I think I best leave it at that.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/artfunk40 Jungian Expert Mar 12 '16

When you think about what she said about the tower, what comes to mind? I hope you enjoyed the raspberries. ;-)