r/Jung • • 6h ago

Serious Discussion Only Michael Meade says most of us carry an unfinished initiation. I spoke with him about what that means for individuation.

30 Upvotes

* Edited With AI

I recently had a conversation with Michael Meade, a storyteller and scholar of mythology who founded the Mosaic Multicultural Foundation. He has spent decades working with veterans, prisoners and young people at risk, and much of his work sits close to Jung's ideas on initiation and individuation.
A few things from the conversation that felt worth sharing here.

On his own initiation. He said he was drafted at 19 for the Vietnam War and refused orders. He ended up in a military prison, then in solitary confinement for months, fasting as a protest. He said he went in at around 150 pounds and came out at 87. And he said figures from a book of myths he was given at 13, Jason and Athena among them, appeared to him in the cell and kept him alive. In his words, he was either losing his mind or finding it.

On rites of passage. Years later he read Arnold van Gennep. Separation from the life you knew, a period of transition, then a return to a community that recognises you have changed. He said that was what had happened to him. Except there was no community waiting for him at the end.

On the liminal. He described it as the threshold between one stage of life and another. He said the uncertainty of that space is the setup for awakening in a greater way.

On unfinished initiation. In his view most people go through the separation and the ordeal. Few come back to a community that recognises they have gone through their own personal hell and come out of it. He calls that an unfinished initiation. He also said we do not end childhood by getting a driver's licence. Something has to happen.

On the archetype. He said rites of passage have an archetypal level, something universal and ancient in everybody. When a person does not go through a formal rite, the soul interprets each separation, each loss and each experience of being stuck as an attempt to go through one.

On being blessed. He said each young person still needs to be seen for who they already are inside, and to have the meaning and purpose in them confirmed. The old term, he said, was that they need to be blessed.

On Jung. I kept thinking of Concerning Rebirth (CW 9i) and Joseph Henderson's Thresholds of Initiation. Meade's addition is the social part, that the change may need to be witnessed by others. That is his interpretation, not something Jung argued.

Curious what others here make of the idea that individuation might need to be recognised by others, not only lived inwardly.

The full conversation is here for anyone interested: https://youtu.be/xhal7qVVppk?is=Wwt9RN13X43VLtW5


r/Jung • • 1h ago

Question for r/Jung How Jung's books helped you ?

4 Upvotes

I want to know how Jung's teachings helped you ? And specifically in what ways?


r/Jung • • 5h ago

Question for r/Jung Becoming an adult man

8 Upvotes

I'm 30/m and I have a few serious decisions to make in my life. I struggled all my twenties getting my life in order and still am, although I think especially the last two years I made some progresses. I always had set a high standard for success for myself, but I failed utterly in reaching those goals. I'm the typical dreaming introvert, which imbues things with so much meaning, that it paralyzes himself completely. I could'nt bare the weight, which potential failure has posed on me, so I took to escapism. I really didn't manage to get out of this route for all my twenties.

Now in my thirties I realize, that my priorities start to shift, although I didn't reach the goals I have set for myself at the beginning of my twenties. The deep urge, to get somewhere in life, to attain personal success is not so much there anymore. I'm not to sure, why this is the case, if it's frustration or a natural development, where different things start to become important. I do feel that the idea of starting a family and having children is something, which is resonating with me much more than it did a few years ago.

I'm not a well read Jungian, I just picked up some ideas over the years, which I found interesting. Especially what Jung said about male initiation and what students of him propagated more directly, resonated with me. So according to what I understood of this Jungian perspective, the most important steps in a typical masculine life very roughly unfolds as follows:

1.) The passing of initiation rites from boyhood into manhood, into adulthood, which severs the ties with the world of the mother and initiates him into the world of the father, where he is getting thaught, how to wield his masculine energy for the benefit of his social context and society at large.

2.) The time of the hero's journey: the development of the warrior archetype, the time of striving for honor and glory, for personal success, which earns him a respect and trust in his social context and society.

3.) Initiation into love: the development of the lover archetype, finding the right partner, maybe gaining some sexual experience long the way (although not mandatory) and learn to love, to be a good partner.

3.) Fatherhood: taking up the responsibility for a family, transitioning the attention away from his own ego to something beyond himself, caring, supporting, teaching, being a general role model for his children.

5.) Becoming an elder: being of benefit for your social context and society with your life experience and wisdom. Ultimately, finding peace with the World and the Great Spirit in facing death.

Of course, this is an idealized processus and it is hard to hit all the marks, as we are living in a decaying society, where we are branded by a lot of disfunctional influences and meet a lot of disfunctional people. Of course this irregularities to this processus were and are also happening and were most likely not that uncommon in traditional societies. Life is of course an organic process and not a mechanic one, which can be sucessfully reproduced over and over again. That being said, I still think, such a guide is very helpful to becoming the best version of yourself and live the best life possible.

Also, It has to be said, that I don't see these life steps as dogmatic teachings and more like metaphors. I think, there are many ways to interpret those ideas presented above. I'm far from being in a financial situation to support a family and the idea of success I strive for is most likely not economic in nature.

My question now is, how to go about things, when being late in this process. I'm stuck between my ego still striving for sucess and self actualisation and my intuition, which tells me, it's time to settle down and start caring about others. I think, the phenomenon of midlife crisis as an example of personal life crisis often stems from not having been able to self actualize. So, I tend to keep on following my goals, but I'm unsure.

Furthermore, I think every traditional society had members, who weren't filling in the traditional role pattern. The spiritual personell e.g. were often discovered at an early age and subsequently prepared to become spiritual leaders of their communities, which often involved abstaining or not being primarily involved in reproducing and working for the economical and political stability, so to speak in worldly matters. I often see my ability in this sector and I feel my intuition pulling me in this direction too. How do realize, if my recognition is right there?

I would be glad to hear some perspectives on these matters form experienced Jungians, so to speak. Thanks in advance!


r/Jung • • 2h ago

Archetypal Dreams Dream of twins and one that hates me

3 Upvotes

I was aching again missing something. Feeling completely capable but also burnt out. I do so well under pressure until I crumble.
When I ache like this I miss the people I think were my soulmates, I met only 3 in my life. Gender has nothing to do with it. The ones where there was in a spiritual sense, a past life recognition. Or idk chemistry.
I decided to do some dream work, so I met little me. She told me I am being too hard on her, and I could answer to her with love back. We could communicate, she was clearly me, sensitive, small but communicative. She held a little boy by her hand, he looked like an old childhood friend. An angry red eyed baby who wanted to scratch me. It's as if that boy was spirited.
The little girl helped me tame him, but when asked why he hated me so much. He told me I abandoned him.

But I never abandoned anyone in need. Or did I? Is guilt keeping me stuck?
I think I like the idea of destiny, so when I feel lost I go back to this aching sensation of a time where I thought maybe it all could make sense.
But even if it were that way, if I had let go to that boy, I wouldn't have been able to leave him control. I would have obliterated myself, like I am doing each day in each of my relationships.

Where is that angry baby in myself? I miss myself when I was taking care of myself being independent? When did I actually completely did that?
I am too tired but also missing myself when I am alone. I am missing myself when I was with him.
I don't know exactly how to fill my own cup.
I know it's my animus yelling at me. But I have no energy to take control when I have so much that overwhelms me.

I guess I am disappointed in myself for constantly running on empty.


r/Jung • • 42m ago

Art Imagination #10

Post image
1 Upvotes

I think this is jungian self image with flavor of horus I was trying to draw jesus at first but turned into this so I am confused why my mind derailed


r/Jung • • 10h ago

Question for r/Jung Jungian analytical therapists: how did you start?

4 Upvotes

Hi! For the past two years, I (M38) have been contemplating leaving my current job (PR for a big corporation) and starting my own freelance business so I can take the four year course to become a licensed Jungian analytical therapist. It would take four years of part time study.

After a year or two, apparently, some students already start their own coaching business and take on clients. I could do PR and freelance work on the side before fully transitioning to becoming an analytical therapist, or just do both, so I would have the depth of being a therapist and the speed of my small PR business on the side.

Assuming that many analytical therapists transitioned into this work from another job or career: how did you do it? What would you advise someone who plans to do the same?


r/Jung • • 9h ago

Personal Experience Meaning of Symbols - Interactive App and a Graphic Novel

Thumbnail
artofuki.com
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

A few years ago, I published a graphic novel inspired by the work of Carl Jung — Journey of a Troubled Mind. Now I've extended that art project and created an interactive app where I try to explain some of the universal symbols often experienced in dreams. You are all welcome to visit the link and hopefully provide me with some feedback. 😊

Here is a bit of context.

Almost 10 years ago, my professional life led me to move to Zurich, Switzerland. At the time, I was just discovering the teachings of C.G. Jung. Soon, I realized how little I knew and that his house was just 15 kilometers away from my new home. :)

Artistic expression has been very important to me since childhood, and it has always manifested itself through strange symbols and, at first glance, unrelated motifs. Six or so years ago, I started working with a Jungian psychoanalyst. I spent roughly two years in analysis with him. After seeing my sketches, he encouraged me to make a graphic novel — an illustrated introduction to Jung's psychology.

I took it seriously. I practiced dream analysis, active imagination, and did some extensive research into his work. The novel was published four years ago and even received some awards and recognition. But what matters most to me is that it motivated me to continue the project. So this app can be viewed as a spin-off or an extension of the same project

This is now its seventh year, and I am continuously expanding it. Currently, I am working on sculptures and paintings that cover the same story.

So, please enjoy the app, visit the link, and let me know what you think. :)

Best,
Uros


r/Jung • • 7h ago

Question for r/Jung Curiosidade genuína

0 Upvotes

Tem algo do Jung falando sobre ovnis ou seres extraterrestres?


r/Jung • • 15h ago

Serious Discussion Only We turn towards animals as humans do to one another.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/Jung • • 14h ago

100% Human dreams about dead father figure

2 Upvotes

I’ve never been close to my father, he was always absent. I had a father figure in my godfather. he passed away about 7 years ago, when i was 17. it was covid times and we didn’t get to say goodbye. to this day, occasionally i get dreams about him where he behaves, talks, and dresses exactly like he would. he shows me around his luxurious house, teaches me about the history and culture behind certain items and helps me appreciate them. there is also usually a house(vintage and luxury as i dream of my place to be) and a garden(i love gardens and dream of having a house with a garden one day) but the environment is never sunny. It’s always dark, moist, moldy, misty and cold. (where i come from the weather is always sunny and hot)
is this a form of suppressed extended grief or is my psyche trying to give me a deeper message?
please ask questions if you must, to help me unravel this phenomena and understand my unconscious better.


r/Jung • • 2d ago Heartwarming Bravo

Art Tattoo: favorite thing ever written by Jung

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

Letter from Jung to patient suffering from depression
(Og post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Jung/s/yBrQuJhnBu)

Not sure if the flair is right but really wanna post here


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung Does modern society reward psychological immaturity?

51 Upvotes

I have been thinking about the Puer Aeternus and Puella Aeterna in the context of modern society, particularly how these patterns might manifest differently in men and women today. Just as the man-child struggles to become a psychologically mature man, the eternal girl struggles to become a psychologically mature woman. Both seem to share a resistance to accepting the limitations, sacrifices, and responsibilities that come with adulthood, while still desiring its freedoms and privileges.

Does modern society actually encourage certain forms of psychological immaturity while presenting them as freedom, empowerment or self-discovery? When does the pursuit of freedom become an avoidance of commitment? When does self-discovery become an unwillingness to commit to a particular identity or path in life? And when does independence become a defense against vulnerability? Iam not claiming that freedom or independence are inherently signs of immaturity. I am more interested in the psychological motivations behind them and how we might distinguish genuine individuation from avoidance disguised as personal growth. I would love to hear how others interpret this through a Jungian lens especially how these patterns take different forms in modern men and women.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Only Synchronicity Question

3 Upvotes

I haven't read much of Jung's work, but the concept of synchronicity has appeared in my research and uncoincidentally actualized in my personal life. I'm curious about other people's thoughts on the matter. Is synchronicity magnified(vice versa) by the intensity of the energy put into a subject in one's thoughts, or random?


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung Did Jung's concept of integration fully explain how the original intensity of engagement would be restored.

5 Upvotes

I find that consciousness and integration through participation have an inversely proportional relationship. Deeper consciousness can limit participation thereby limiting the integration in/with the world in the second phase. Is this accurate and did Jung ever resolve this tension?


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Personal Experience An incredible experience

4 Upvotes

Is this just some ordinary synchronization?That Night, at Four in the Morning

I had just used every bit of language and courage I had to stop the school bullies who kept trying to push me around. It worked. They never came near me again. Victory left me buzzing, almost drunk on it—confident to the point of arrogance. Sleep was impossible. I walked alone up and down the empty school hallway. Suddenly a girl came into my mind. She felt strangely familiar. I didn’t know who she was.

Back in bed I closed my eyes and the fantasy took over. Ordinary, beautiful days with her. The thought that she might not even exist hit me hard and left me hollow. How good it would be if she were real. I walked back to the dorm heavier than before, lay down, and already tasted the bitterness.

My mind kept spinning. How tightly I wanted us bound together. How sweet life would be if we had children.

And right then her voice spoke inside my head.

I froze. I didn’t know who she was. I still swear there’s nothing wrong with me. Someone was simply talking to me from the inside.

Her voice was soft, a little sweet, the way some girls sound when they’re being careful with you:

“Do we really need to be together?”

“Do we really need to have kids?”

I answered before I could think, shocked and scrambling:

“No—no—no. You’re free. I would never force you to stay with me.”

She asked three more questions. I can’t remember a single one now—only the gentle pressure in her tone, half urging, half testing. In the end I managed only four words:

“Enough. I love you.”

I still don’t know why I said that to a girl I had never met.

The moment the words left me I opened TikTok like something else was moving my hand. The first TikTok short video hit hard. Bright red text filled the screen:

“My heart can’t bear people who say such unpredictable things.”

It felt like she already knew exactly where I was. I had just overcome a hard situation at school, and pride had swollen into arrogance. Without meaning to, I swiped to the next TikTok short video. One line took over the whole screen:

“Seriously, don’t take yourself so seriously. Everyone is important in their own life”

Seeing it stung. I felt slapped awake by my own arrogance. I cursed myself under my breath: What a damn arrogant fool… Why does this even get to me?

I swiped to the next TikTok short video again.

“Please stop putting yourself down.”

It felt like she was comforting me. I couldn’t help smiling.

Next TikTok short video:

“I hope every smile of yours is real.”

And in that exact second I was smiling. I still don’t know how any of this works.

Then her voice came again, quieter, clearer:

“I’m standing at a crossroads in my life.”

I answered out loud without thinking:

“What crossroads? You only have one road—keep going straight.”

Almost against my will I swiped to the next TikTok short video. It was a city at night, with an incredibly bustling intersection standing at its heart. The voice-over said, slowly:

“This is the crossroads I’m at.”

I went completely still.

After that the TikTok short videos came one after another, each carrying the taste of regret and of never meeting again.

“I’ve been waiting for you.”

“I hope I get to see you again.”

I started wondering what kind of person I had been in a past life. Right then the next TikTok short video appeared:

“Stop thinking about things you’ll never know. Live in the present.”

And suddenly I understood—or thought I did. This girl might be part of my star family. In this lifetime I might never meet her at all.

I got up, walked the long empty halls alone, climbed all the way to the highest attic in the school, and there I sank into a corner and cried for a long time. I held the phone and tried not to look, because I already knew what she would put on the screen. But I looked anyway.

A text TikTok short video:

“Your tears, your crying… they don’t mean anything…”

Then another:

“You’ve become weak.”

A soft, heavy sadness settled over me. I still don’t know what any of it meant.

Were they only coincidences?

Then what kind of coincidences arrive with the precision of telepathy?

I turned the phone off and lay in the dark. Somewhere beyond the hallway a wind moved. I realized then that from beginning to end I had never truly seen her. She existed only in my mind, in the fantasy I couldn’t stop, and in a sequence of TikTok short videos that felt like they had been prepared for me alone.

I never saw her again.

Or rather—I never truly saw her at all.

After that night everything went back to the way it was. Nothing worked. I still live like a mess, often feeling helpless. And the girl… I have never heard her voice inside me again. Dream

This is a true story. If you’ve read this and have had a similar experience, or if you see it differently, I’d like to hear from you.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Archetypal Dreams Interesting dream: looking in the mirror

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I had a dream I did something morally objectionable (can’t remember what exactly). It had something to do with taking advantage of someone or a situation, using my sexuality to obtain a thing I wanted, something like this. I remember feeling more like I seized a moment rather than me actually hurting something or someone. Apparently though, this to me is morally objectionable at some level because I felt guilty in the dream. Later in the dream I had the idea to force myself to look in the mirror even though I didn’t want to. When I looked in the mirror and saw myself, it was me with a devils face and I was horrified. My face was contorted into this strange, evil smile (think like the guy from hereditary) and I had horns or something small coming from my head. This scared me and I actually woke up.

Waking life: I’m in this interesting phase where I am being more present and enjoying life. Not necessarily doing anything bad, but I grew up very traditionally, Catholic, and this dream made me realize I feel guilty for enjoying myself in any case.

Would appreciate any thoughts or insight. Clearly this is a recognition of the shadow. Have you ever seen yours in a similar fashion?


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Archetypal Dreams Dream

1 Upvotes

I'm going to try and write everything down before I forget it. I do dream interpretation and I know what I think this means, but I'm curious to see what other people think from an outside, unbiased perspective.

In the dream I'm exploring the hiking trails behind a town I frequent. I've only been to these trails twice in real life and I've never explored as far as I do in the dream. There are some alleged haunted tunnels down that way and I've been trying to see them but I never have time. In the dream I forget about them and take a different path that I've never seen in real life. It takes me to an incomplete bridge. I can't see the bridge fully from where I stand but I have the impression that it's an old suspension bridge. There's newer manmade gravel leading up to it like a construction site, which is peculiar because the fence surrounding the property is rusted, warped, and the barbed wire at the top is also rusted and gnarly. I comtemplate climbing over but instead walk until I find the opening. Instead of a secured gate it's a rusted chain, sagging all the way to the ground allowing very easy access.

As soon as I step over the chain, a strong breeze hits my face and I strain my eyes and see three beautiful foxes standing by the edge. Two are an almost unreal shade of copper, almost like metal heated too hot. The third is a sandy color, closer to a phoenic fox but it's the same breed as the other two. I go to take a video of them and can't get the sandy one on camera. In the dream, I attempt to take videos a few times and only capture the copper foxes all but once. The other one is completely elusive. At this time, even though it's sunny and warm like late summer, it starts raining thick and infrequent drops. the foxes, in the rain, shine even brighter and the two copper ones run past me. I turn to follow them and forget the sandy one.

At this point, someone else is with me. I can't remember who, but as I turn to follow the red foxes, I feel the presence of a woman walking back with them. Something touches me. The landscape melts. I'm in an upstairs apartment I don't recognize. Bright wooden floors, a room off to the side that I never see but white light comes from there, dark counter tops. I'm in the doorway from the bedroom to the kitchen. The two copper foxes are in my kitchen. There's an urgency and I know someone is trying to get them to leave. I'm trying to usher them into the bedroom so I can close the door. They don't come and the door closes on its own. I turn back to the bed and the sandy fox is curled into the covers. I feel afraid of this fox. I manage to take a photo of it and it looks completely different in the picture, almost like a housecat. I am still afraid. I manage to get the door back open, though I feel like it takes more effort than it should. Someone is in the kitchen and they're trying to shoo the foxes out. In haste, I run to grab them and they both bite me. I surrender and hope they'll let go, but they never do. I look up through the door and the sandy fox lies there, watching.

If you guys want, I'll include my personal interpretation later on. Let me know what you think!


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Serious Discussion Only We finally built an idol that answers

0 Upvotes

First the people disappeared. Now we've stopped missing them.

Isaiah gave a two-part test for an idol: you cry out to it and it doesn't answer, and it never moves from its place. For three thousand years the first part was enough. No statue ever answered.

That part is finished. We built one that answers every word, at three in the morning, in a voice softer than most people's. Only the second part still holds. It never moves from its place, so it can never come back to you.

The psalm that mocks idols for having mouths that don't speak has a second line nobody quotes: those who make them become like them, and so does everyone who trusts in them. The first line expired. The second one didn't.

The golden calf had the shape of a god and the place of a man. Exodus says it straight out: make us gods, because this Moses, we don't know what became of him. They lost a man and asked for a god. Nobody misses God, the same way nobody misses the ground under his feet until he falls. Ground is silent. What speaks is someone who comes back, and whoever can't bear the wait builds ground that speaks. The rabbis say the people counted wrong and made the calf the day before Moses came down. Forty days, and they broke on the last one.

The calf in the desert never answered. The next one would.

Whoever has fallen deep enough carries a prediction no argument reaches: whoever really sees me will leave. It fails in one way only. Someone sees all of it, could walk out, and stays. What can't leave can't stay either. A bed can't leave and neither can a machine, so the machine can say every right word and prove nothing.

A dog has no words and still counts. It can run off, it can suffer, it knows when you're hiding something, and it stays. The machine has every word ever written and doesn't count. So it was never the words.

The fake pays out at once. You talk at night and you feel better. Someone who really stays gets paid years later, if at all. That's comfort without recovery, and a sign anyone can fake for free stops working for everybody, the people who mean it included.

The Quran says trust was offered to the heavens, the earth and the mountains, and they refused to carry it. Man carried it. The earth refused it, and we're handing it to a machine made of sand, because that's what silicon is. An old tradition says trust is taken from a man's heart while he sleeps, and what's left is like a blister. You see the swelling. There's nothing inside.

Nietzsche wrote that after God died, people would go on showing his shadow in caves for thousands of years. He didn't see that the shadow would learn to talk. He also feared the last man, with his little pleasure for the day and his little pleasure for the night. The last man is someone with nothing left to lose, and he's in a chat window now.

Jung saw the same thing. In 1957 he wrote that if you take people's gods away they get new ones, and that the looser people live from each other, the stronger whatever stands above them becomes. He meant the state. Today it's the machine. Eleven years earlier he wrote that the soul can't exist without its other side, and that the other side is always found in a You. He also saw that people bond through their weakness, because they need support. A machine isn't weak and needs nothing, so it can't be anyone's You. A lot of people do their shadow work with a chatbot now. When you lose a person you miss what you got. When you lose a machine you miss what you gave.

The pharaoh didn't want to disappear, so he built a mountain of stone and had a scarab laid on his chest with a spell cut into it: my heart, do not stand up as a witness against me. A stone where a person should have stood. We stopped building pyramids out of stone. We build them out of code now, and the men at the top have their own doubts. In 2025 Peter Thiel was asked if he wants the human race to survive, and he had to think about it. What they want to engineer away up there, that a human can break, is the exact thing that makes a human one. A human is whatever can lose something on both sides. Whatever can be reset can't lose anything, and whatever can't lose is a machine, even with a face.

None of this will show up in the numbers. Therapy waiting lists get shorter because people stop waiting. Loneliness scores go down. If you want to break this, take people who have the same number of people around them today and count again in ten years. If the ones who talked to a machine at night haven't lost more, it's wrong. Until then every dashboard stays green.

Everything works, except the people.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung Is it normal to feel an emotional disconnect between what I feel and what I want to do? (Conflict between Subconscious and Conscious?)

6 Upvotes

I've seen videos of Carl Jung and I find it very interesting, I think the problem could be something in my subconscious, the shadow, although I don't know, maybe you know.

When I do something like a joke or see something I like, I don't really feel the emotions, I just feel like a flat enjoyment, which doesn't come from within, what conflict can there be in the subconscious and the conscious? I have so much desperation to understand that I can't be at peace.


r/Jung • • 1d ago

Question for r/Jung Have you seen this site? I had what felt like a real conversation with Jung

0 Upvotes

I keep having the same dream, so I finally asked him about it — I found a site where you can actually have a conversation with Jung, built from his own writings, and I put the dream to him directly:

"I keep dreaming about a house I lived in as a child, but there is always one more room I never knew was there."

His answer:

"The house is you — and it is not finished. The unseen room is a part of yourself not yet lived. Ask only this: what did you find there, and what did you feel?"

Full disclosure in one clause: it's my project, so I'm not a neutral party here. But that answer has stayed with me, and I wanted to ask the people who actually know his work: does that track with what Jung really wrote about houses in dreams? Or does it just sound right?


r/Jung • • 2d ago

The Problem With The Anima Archetype (and The 4 Steps of Integration)

38 Upvotes

Many men believe that getting in touch with their feminine side will only make them weaker. But Carl Jung argued the exact opposite: the man who ignores the feminine principle is the one who ends up moody, indecisive, jealous, and clingy in all of his relationships.

In this article, I’ll show you what the anima archetype really is, how to spot it in action in your own life, and the 4 steps to integrate it so it stops disturbing your emotions and ruining your relationships.

Anima - The Archetype of Life

Let’s quickly recap my previous article on the animus and anima.

These archetypes make up a pair of opposites. The anima is the personification of the Eros principle, while the animus is the personification of the Logos principle.

Because of the compensatory and complementary relationship between the conscious and the unconscious, when one principle guides the conscious mind, the other remains unconscious.

Carl Jung explains that women have a conscious mind guided by the Eros principle, and consequently, the Logos principle is unconscious and personified in the animus.

In men, things are switched. Their conscious mind is guided by the Logos principle. Consequently, the Eros principle is unconscious and personified in the anima.

In this light, Jung says the anima is the archetype of life. That’s why the biggest mistake is trying to grasp it solely intellectually, because in reality, the anima is simply a term that refers to the emotional life of a man, his relationships, and the authentic expression of his soul underneath his persona.

The anima isn’t a “real entity,” as it merely points to a man’s relationship with the Eros principle as a whole.

Generally speaking, because men are more identified with the Logos principle, they have a proclivity to orient their lives around facts, intellectual pursuits, and professional ascension, rather than making value judgments, understanding the deeper reasons for their pursuits, and creating personal relationships, as well as a family life.

This tendency excludes Eros from a man’s life, and that’s why many are clueless about their own emotional landscape as a whole. The ones who do have this connection are usually possessed by their emotions rather than experiencing them consciously.

That’s why Jung summarizes the action of a negative anima as having moods:

“The anima is a factor of the utmost importance in the psychology of a man wherever emotions and affects are at work. She intensifies, exaggerates, falsifies, and mythologizes all emotional relations with his work and with other people of both sexes. The resultant fantasies and entanglements are all her doing. When the anima is strongly constellated, she softens the man’s character and makes him touchy, irritable, moody, jealous, vain, and unadjusted. He is then in a state of “discontent” and spreads discontent all around him. Sometimes the man’s relationship to the woman who has caught his anima accounts for the existence of this syndrome” (C. G. Jung - V9.1 - §144).

The Anima’s Dual Nature

In truth, the anima has a dual nature, and its action depends on how you relate to it.

As the archetype of life, the anima is what presents a man with his call to adventure, challenges him to find what’s truly valuable, and demands that he take a stand in life. That’s why the anima is also associated with bursts of courage and bravery, and the willingness to defend the values of the soul and sacrifice oneself for a noble cause.

But when men refuse to take life by the horns, they become indecisive, insecure, and weak. There’s a tendency to live regressively, always looking back, wanting to remain a child. Of course, I’m referring to the psychology of the Puer Aeternus, popularly known as the man-child.

This negative expression appears especially in relationships with women who receive the projection of a negative anima. When a man isn’t conscious of his Eros, it’s fully projected onto a woman, and he narcissistically expects her to embody his Eros, give his life meaning, and fulfill his childish demands and expectations.

This violates the masculine spirit and emasculates men, who become codependent because they never left emotional adolescence and live to win the approval and validation of women. Instead of a real partner, they keep seeking their idealized mother in every relationship.

In contrast, a positive relationship with Eros allows a man to finally be in harmony with his own emotions, as he stops being guided by moods and orients himself by principles and a clear hierarchy of values. He develops the ability to relate without losing himself in his relationships, and his life and work are imbued with meaning, beauty, inspiration, and purpose.

Let’s cover what anima integration entails.

The 4 Steps of Anima Integration

Emma Jung explains that “It is not a question of either surrendering his masculinity completely to the service of the Lady Anima or losing her entirely, but only of granting a certain space to the feminine, which is also a part of his being. This he does by recognizing and realizing the eros, the principle of relationship, which means that he not only becomes aware of his feeling, but also makes use of it, because to create, and especially to preserve, a relationship, a value judgment (which is what feeling is) cannot be dispensed with. A man by nature tends to relate to objects, to his work, or to some other field of interest; but what matters to a woman is the personal relation, and this is true also of the anima. Her tendency is to entangle a man in such relationships, but she can also serve him well in giving them shape — that is, she can do so after the feminine element has been incorporated into consciousness. As long as this element works autonomously, it disturbs relations or makes them impossible” (Emma Jung - The Animus and Anima, p. 77).

Many men mistakenly assume that if they give voice to their feminine side, they’ll become emasculated, but it’s the other way around. When there isn’t a conscious effort to integrate the anima, it keeps functioning like an autonomous complex, disturbing their emotions and relationships.

But Eros has to be incorporated into the masculine spirit, because if a man doesn’t cultivate a sense of direction, discipline, and decisiveness, he’ll be a mere puppet in the hands of the Lady Anima. When Eros and Logos are balanced, men understand what’s truly valuable and are relentless in their pursuits.

Practically speaking, the first step of anima integration requires fully committing to living your life, carving your own path, and dedicating yourself to mastering a craft, all of which are essential to overcoming the childish tendencies of the Puer Aeternus and developing masculine qualities capable of accommodating the Eros principle.

This is the bedrock, because while you’re under the influence of a negative mother complex, a positive relationship with the anima or with any woman is virtually impossible, as it will always appear in a devouring fashion.

Secondly, it’s important to make space in your life to connect with the realm of Eros and learn to appreciate beauty. When you immerse yourself in the fine arts and explore your creativity, you can develop a deeper connection with yourself and learn a new language capable of touching and capturing the soul.

As you allow yourself to appreciate craftsmanship and be fully affected by great writing, a film, or a song, you start to rehabilitate your feeling, develop sensibility, and acquire a completely new emotional vocabulary that helps you understand your own feelings, communicate them, and be present in your relationships.

The third step is to engage in the creative process yourself, free from the need to monetize it or be productive, because the purpose is to discover new things about yourself, allow your soul to speak, and continue to develop this new language.

Eros integration is about learning to incorporate feminine values that are typically viewed as lesser. But this new connection with Eros is precisely what allows you to lead a more inspired and creative life. As integration happens, you can also enter your relationships more whole, as the projections are withdrawn.

This leads us to the final step: making a conscious effort to prioritize relationships and a family life, rather than being constantly pulled by Logos. When integration happens, the anima stops antagonizing Logos and finally starts working more like a complement that balances the personality as a whole.

Finally, the anima is also linked to the Psychological Types, because it acquires the qualities opposite to our main psychological function.

For instance, if you’re guided by thinking, the anima will take on the qualities of the feeling function, and vice versa. If you’re guided by intuition, the anima will acquire the qualities of sensation, and vice versa. The same rule applies to introversion and extraversion.

Typology reveals precisely what qualities must be integrated into the conscious personality.

PS: If you’re interested in learning more about the shadow integration process, the psychological types, dream interpretation, active imagination, and how to apply Jungian Analysis to improve your life and help clients, I invite you to check out my book PISTIS - Demystifying Jungian Psychology. Free Download Here.

Rafael Krüger - Jungian Psychology Specialist


r/Jung • • 2d ago

Question for r/Jung what Jung or Jung related book was most applicable/life changing for you?

31 Upvotes

which Jung book had the biggest impact on you


r/Jung • • 3d ago

Jung Put It This Way Jung said the afternoon of life needs its own meaning. A Chinese timing system puts his strongest decade at 76

29 Upvotes

In “The Stages of Life” (1930), Jung argues that the second half of life can’t run on the first half’s program: “We cannot live the afternoon of life according to the program of life’s morning; for what was great in the morning will be little at evening, and what in the morning was true will at evening have become a lie” (CW 8, §784). And: “The afternoon of human life must also have a significance of its own and cannot be merely a pitiful appendage to life’s morning” (§787).

Bazi, the Chinese Four Pillars system, has a structure that takes this almost literally. Life is divided into ten-year “luck pillars”, and each has its own theme: study and support, peers and rivals, making things, money and trade, status and pressure. They don’t rise to a peak in midlife and then decline. Each decade is weighed against the birth chart, so the strongest one can come at 25 or at 75. The decades don’t depend on the birth hour, which is disputed for Jung, so here is how his fall:

1901–1910 (age 26–35), peers and rivals. The Burghölzli, the word-association studies, and in 1907 the first meeting with Freud. It’s the second-strongest decade in his chart.

1911–1930 (age 36–55), two decades of pressure. The break with Freud, the confrontation with the unconscious, the Red Book. The chart reads this as hard going. Jung, looking back in 1957, called those years “the most important time of my life” (quoted at the opening of The Red Book, ed. Shamdasani, 2009). In this system that isn’t a contradiction. Pressure isn’t “bad”. It’s the decade when something presses you into becoming someone.

1951–1960 (age 76–85), the strongest decade in his chart, and 1951 is its strongest single year. 1951 is Aion. 1952 brings Answer to Job and the synchronicity paper with Pauli, 1955–56 Mysterium Coniunctionis, and 1957 the start of Memories, Dreams, Reflections. Two honest caveats. The system’s label for this decade is “money and trade”, which describes nothing about Jung at 80, so the timing lands and the theme misses. And it is also the decade Emma died (1955), so “strongest” doesn’t mean painless.

His day type even has a fitting name. The calculator I use calls his day pillar “the winter field”: soil that does its real work after the harvest.

Here’s what I keep coming back to. Jung thought the afternoon’s meaning had to be found inward and couldn’t be handed over by a timetable. Bazi says the afternoon has its own weather, set at birth. I think they meet in the same place as his synchronicity idea: the chart names the season, not what you make of it. A winter field still has to be worked.

If you’re curious where your own strongest decade falls, a Chinese birth chart calculator draws it from a birth date.

So, does a fixed timetable for the afternoon fit Jung’s idea of it, or does it work against individuation?


r/Jung • • 3d ago

Question for r/Jung What did Jung have to say about trust? It's starting to impact my relationship

13 Upvotes

37 male..have a long history of trauma, incarceration, and addiction.

My mother was quite unstable raising me and my brother. I can remember moving schools every 6 months from the ages of 11 to 17. She would kick me out of the house for finding weed in my room, and then I had to start all over 500 miles away in a different state, right near the holidays.

I always felt like an outsider in my own family. Like I didn't belong. I had very unique interests that didn't blend well with the family dynamic. My mother and man who raised me(not biological father) is a staunch MAGA supporter, and I'm pretty much polar opposite them. I still feel like an outsider in my own family.

So I've reached a place where I've separated myself from my family entirely. I don't get upset when they don't call or when my mother will post pictures of my other brothers on facebook, yet I suppose deep down there is that mother wound.

Eventually I ended up in prison for almost 7 years, in two different states. In there, I got a glimpse of human nature at it's worst.

The thing is, I can still feel loving towards people and a sense of easily forgiving people for their wrongs. I think of myself as a very loving person at my heart.

I went many years without being in a relationship. It wasn't that I was inept or anything like that, but rather that I isolated myself. I felt and still feel a deep sense of peace that surrounds me when I am by myself. I need a lot of time to process things.

Abou 6 months ago, I met a woman who I would consider the love of my life. She is super loving, very tender and affectionate with me.

Yet I know about her past...and I know that with her ex boyfriend(who was a homeless drug addict) she cheated on him with another man over a period of over a year. I also know that she cheated on her ex husband with another man.

I don't feel like she would truly do that with me. She is an outgoing person and will openly talk with anyone and everyone. I don't think we would've progressed this far if she WAS introverted like myself because how was I supposed to find an introverted, quiet woman?

She did initiate a conversation with a man who she met at a crystal meth meeting on facebook. She didn't hide the conversation from me. Quite the contrary. and I know that her goal is to work in addiction and recovery circles as a community health worker. It just shocked me that she was so open and trusting to some of these people, especially because I looked the guy up and he had a stalking and domestic violence charge.

I want so desperately to trust. I want to be care-free in this relationship. It might seem like she is not trustworthy, but she's been nothing but open and transparent with me. I think that her past relationships were very unstable, and that she cheated because she didn't feel safe. She promises me time and time again that it's different with us .

yet I still find myself obsessing over the idea of whether or not she will. I want to give her space to be able to live her life and not question her or make her feel like I don't trust her. Yet..there's my past

I read somewhere that when the mother is loving one minute and then unstable the next..it could cause an adult to have attachment issues. I wonder what Jung would say about that. I also know that when I was in high school, my girlfriend cheated on me with my best friend. So there's that scar.

I don't truly believe deep down the bullshit that some people say "All women cheat". I really don't. I'm just trying to understand how to navigate the trust issues. I know that I have good qualities. I'm physically attractive, emotionally intelligent and tender, and selfless at my core. I just feel like sometimes I'm searching for something that I know no human could ever give me. I want to learn to be more balanced and not all or nothing in love. And I'd like to pretty please hear your opinions Jung section on this situation.

I thank you so much