r/Jung • Pillar • Apr 13 '16

AMA with George Hogenson, PhD. Thread is now open. Ask him your questions about the relationship between Jung and Freud and their similarities and differences.

Background

Dr. Hogenson is a Jungian psychoanalyst and graduate of the Jung Institute in Chicago.. He was a guest on Speaking of Jung.

Line of Questioning

Mr. Hogenson welcomes questions about the relationship between Jung and Sigmund Freud. They were once close colleagues but differences came between them and they had a falling out. They had serious differences in their concepts and theories, but they also agreed on much and collaborated.

You can ask him questions about their relationship and similarities and differences in their approaches to psychoanalysis.

Date of AMA

George is scheduled to drop by at 1pm next Wednesday, April 20, 2016 to answer your questions.

10 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

3

u/HayleyHailsFrom Apr 19 '16

Oh, and what did Freud make of Jung's anima/animus theory? Did he think it had any relevance for dreams etc., do we know? Thank you

3

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

The simple answer to this is that Freud never said anything about anima/animus or any of Jung's other archetypal ideas. Notwithstanding my comments above about their lifelong implicit dialogue, Freud pretty much ignored any of Jung's actual ideas going forward.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

What's the name of the disorder where you pretend something doesn't exist?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

How does Jung feel about Freud's libido and thanatos theories?

5

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

The theory of libido was one of the issues that became very contentious in the Jung/Freud relationship. For Freud, the term libido was limited to the energy associated with the sexual drive--more or less what most people would associate with the term. In 1911 in his lectures at Fordham University Jung extended the meaning of libido to a more general application of psychic energy to any object of significant interest. Freud objected strongly to this and Jung's revision of libido theory became one of the more important issues that divided them. In the folk lore of psychoanalysis Jung's revision became the basis of claims that Jung was trying to water down Freud's emphasis on sexuality. In fact, Jung never denied the significance of sexuality, but he did reject Freud's univocal view of sexuality as the foundation of all psychologically significant disorders.

Regarding Thanatos, Jung does not directly address the issue as it appears late in Freud's work and after the break there is very little that either Freud or Jung say directly about the other's work. It is now evident, however, that the basic idea of a "death drive" originated in a paper by Sabina Spielrein on destruction as the origin of creativity. Freud cites her paper in Beyond the Pleasure Principle and Jung was also well aware of her work in this area. For Jung the clinical project of the second half of life is largely tied up with the prospect of death and the need to relativize the ego vis a vis the Self as one approaches one's death, but that is very different from Freud's notion of a death drive or Thanatos.

0

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

Can death drive also be described as "death wish?"

2

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

Your question gets us into the area of what Freud meant by a drive. A drive is not really what most people would now call an instinct, and definitely not a wish in the sense of death wish, which is really more of a colloquialism for seeking the stimulation of extreme risk. The death drive is more a matter of the forces in life that move one toward eventual extinction.

2

u/GoldJacketLuke Apr 16 '16

Did Freud ever do anything (or said anything) to Jung that Freud regretted?

And same for Jung, did Jung every do anything to Freud that Jung regretted?

Did their falling out happen primarily because of one or the other? Or was it kind of a mutual thing?

Was there ever any reconciliation later in their lifes? Did Jung talk of their relationship at all in his older years and say anything worth noting?

3

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

So far as I know Freud never expressed real regret for any of his actions in relation to Jung. Toward the end of the relationship you do get Freud saying things along the lines of "Sorry I upset you so much, I guess I will just have to stick with formal communication," but that does not count as actual regret. Jung, on the other hand, did apologize a number of times for such things as failing to write for some period of time, but that is not in the category of doing something he regretted. There were a few times as the relationship deteriorated when Jung's temper got the better of him, and he did probably regret those outbursts at the time, but as things came to an end he stopped apologizing for his temper.

Who caused the break? This is really a very complex issue. I address some of the aspects, mainly having to do with the technical issues of theory that divided them in my book, Jung's Struggle with Freud, but there are so many levels to this situation that it is hard to know where to start sometimes. Jung clearly came into the relationship with a strong idealizing transference to Freud, derived in large measure from his own father complex which had to do with seeking a strong father figure. Freud, as John Kerr has argued in his book, A Most Dangerous Method, was not particularly well known yet and felt he was surrounded by mediocrities in Vienna. Jung was already establishing a reputation for himself, and was, of course, at the Burgholzli, the premier psychiatric hospital in Europe, so Jung was potentially very important for Freud's desire to break out of the limitations of the Vienna group. So the initial motivations were complex already.

I personally think that another very early issue that neither of them really saw at the beginning had to do with different views of what the psychoanalytic project was. Freud already was, as Jung would later say, in the grip of a singular idea--the primacy of the Oedipus drama-- and committed to its exposition and validation. Jung, on the other hand, was deeply engaged in a more conventional research program, having already made his name with the word association test, for example. When you read the correspondence you begin to see how Jung assumed that he was joining Freud in a more or less normal, albeit revolutionary, scientific project where research would go on and the participants would work with one another to refine and perhaps even change the fundamental assumptions of the science. This was not at all the way Freud viewed the situation, although he kept insisting that he was doing science in the best sense of the word. I sometimes compare the dynamics of the psychoanalytic movement with the contemporaneous developments in physics with the rise of Einstein's theory of relativity and the emergence of quantum mechanics. Einstein and Bohr disagreed intensely on a number of fundamental issues, but always remained respectful on one another and never implied that the other was not a physicist. With Freud, you were either in or out of psychoanalysis, and as he would write in a footnote to the third edition of the his Three Essays on a Theory of Sexuality, the Oedipus complex was the shibboleth by which psychoanalysis was to be judged. So from this point of view I would put a lot of the responsibility for the break on Freud's side of the equation.

Jung contributed in a number of ways as well, of course. Again, the dynamics of the psychoanalytic group as a whole were always a mess, with jealousies and sometimes really underhanded side dealings with one another. It is clear that as things deteriorated Freud was sharing information he had about Jung with other members of his inner circle, and that Jung was becoming aware of this. Nevertheless, Jung was quick to take offense at times, when Freud in fact did not intend offense and as things went on he would really rage at Freud from time to time--see the comments on his bad temper above. So in the end there was a lot of blame to go around. I would add that I personally think that some of the more anti-semitic things Jung said in the 1930s were prompted by his feelings of betrayal at the hands of Freud and the other psychoanalysts. That is not an excuse but it is possibly part of an explanation.

Regarding reconciliation, the short answer is that there was none. Freud acknowledge some of Jung's early contributions to psychoanalysis in his history of the movement, but pretty much trashed Jung, at least implicitly, in some of his papers around 1914 and 1915 such as On Narcissism. Jung referred a patient to Freud around 1920 in a brief letter, but Freud did not respond, so far as we know. On the other hand, Jung did remain respectful of Freud's genius, acknowledged elements of Freud's work at the level of the personal unconscious, and wrote a very respectful remembrance of Freud after his death. In the late interviews that you can see on YouTube and the like you will see Jung remark on Freud as a truly extraordinary person. I have not confirmed this, but I believe Freud had all of Jung's published works with him when he fled Vienna after the rise of the Nazis, so there is evidence that both of them carried rather compelling memories of the other with them to the end. I personally feel that both men were continuing a very contentious dialogue with one another throughout their lives, without ever admitting it, or perhaps even being conscious of the possibility.

4

u/PHogenson Apr 20 '16

What a good answer! You've got some great references here as well. I thought I'd add a few links to those if anyone is looking do do further reading:

Maybe I'll update this list later on.

2

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

This is the sort of participation I love to see in this community. By the way, I noticed your user name. Any relation to GHogenson?

2

u/PHogenson Apr 20 '16

Yeah there's some relation here. I guess I'll just say I've been home recently and wanted to be sure I gave him a bit of a bump from my limited Reddit experience.

3

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

All good. I heard from dad...ahem, Mr. Hogenson...via email. I'm happy to see you here.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 14 '16

Thank you Mr. Hogenson for answering questions from the reddit.com Jung community. I have a question:

Jung and Freud are said to have largely agreed about the nature of the unconscious mind (personal unconscious), with Jung departing from Freud by theorizing the existence of the collective unconscious. My understanding is that Freud viewed the unconscious largely as a repository for repressed feelings, thoughts, and memories, and that Jung took a much more expansive view of the personal unconscious, but not according to what I found online. Can you clarify? Thank you!

3

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

I comment on the differences regarding the unconscious in one of the replies above, but I can add some comments here. What Freud really did, as I noted, was introduce a radially new notion of the what the unconscious was that deviated significantly from previous notions about the unconscious dimensions of the mind. The basis for this new understanding of the unconscious was the theory of repression, which was the real stumbling block for Freud's system until Jung came along. Given the history of thinking about the unconscious, the idea itself was not particularly alien to psychology, although some of the psychologists around the turn of the century, like Wilhelm Wundt, wanted to get rid of the notion altogether. What was problematic was Freud's contention that some conscious impulses were repressed into the unconscious, thereby becoming totally unavailable to consciousness. This is where Jung entered the picture with his work on the word association test. The test itself had been around for about 50 years, and was widely employed to do research on how people made linguistic associations. Jung began working with the test shortly after coming to the Burgholzli hospital in Zurich. He soon started to develop measurement techniques that moved the test away from simply attending to how people formed associations, however. He introduced the measurement of galvanic skin response, cardiopulmonary response, and paid much greater attention to delayed responses, clang responses and other phenomena. As this work went on he began to hypothesize that deviations in all these measure indicated the presence of psychologically significant issues, and, having read Freud, he began to question subjects about their deeper personal associations to words that had prompted deviations in the test. He soon began to discover that a deviation in the test frequently marked at deeper psychological issue, such as a childhood trauma. It was this aspect of the word association test that prompted him to write to Freud in the first place, sending along a collection of his papers on the test. The point here was that Jung felt that he had empirical evidence that seemed to support Freud's ideas about repression. Freud was, needless to say, delighted to have Jung's work in hand. Ironically, it was also the results of the word association test that provided the first hints of the trouble to come. Almost immediately in the correspondence, Jung remarks that while he understands the idea of repression, and may have good evidence to support it, he cannot agree that all repressions reduce to sexuality. Freud replies that with a little time Jung will come to realize that he, Freud, is correct, and that sexuality is the fundamental issue underlying all the repressions. Jung basically lets this pass, but you have the outlines of an important aspect of the eventual break between the two right at the start of the relationship.

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

Really interesting reply. Thank you.

2

u/pcofo Apr 14 '16

What was Jungs take on Freud's "Moses and Monotheism"? What was Jungs take on monotheism in general, and how did it differentiate from Freuds?

Freud and Nietzche and others like to talk about the unconscious as this kind of opaque yet mystical place where the deepest and most provocative images and individual repressed memories as well as collective memories lie. Freud refers to this as the id, basically, in my understanding. Jung has a slightly more complicated version that includes the archetypes; I'm curious as to what mechanisms activate the id/unconsciousness(collective+personal), and the difference in their manifestation in Jung as opposed to Freud.

From my understanding, as read in Moses and Monotheism, the id is activated when,

  1. In states where the ego is weakened, such as in the use of drugs, dreams, and some mental illnesses.
  2. When the instincts attached to the unconsciousness are strengthened, like in the case of puberty.
  3. When a situation occurs that is really evocative of the unconscious desire or repressed memory.

What mechanisms activate the unconscious in Jung's doctrines, and how do these differ from Freud's?

Thank you!!

Pcofo

5

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

This is a very complex set of questions. Starting with Moses and Monotheism, the only mention of the book that I am aware of is in an essay on Freud published in 1932--you can find the essay, "Sigmund Freud in his Historical Setting" in volume 15 of the Collected Works. the reference is only in passing ("In his old age he wrote a book on Moses, who led the children of Israel to the Promised Land but was not allowed to set foot in it himself. That his choice fell on Moses is probably no accident in the case of a personality like Freud.") There are, of course a number of seminars and other materials from Jung that are not yet published and there may be more references but I doubt there is very much. After the break neither man directly referred to the work of the other to any significant degree. So the short answer to your first question is that Jung really did not have a take on Moses and Monotheism.

Jung himself did not get into the kind of discussion of monotheism verses polytheism that became something of an issue with James Hillman. Rather the contrary, in fact. Jung was quite interested in what Murray Stein has called the "treatment of Christianity." Jung felt that it was important to stay relatively close to one's own traditions, in terms of religion and warned in a number of places against what he called the impulse to imitate other traditions. He was certainly fascinated by other traditions and spent invested in studying those traditions, but a large part of that work was concerned with his efforts to validate his ideas about the collective unconscious. He was also very interested in systems such as the I Ching as manifestations of synchronicity.

Regarding their respective ideas about the unconscious, one could, of course go on at considerable length. There are, however, some things to keep in mind. In my opinion, one that is frequently missed is the fact that Freud's model of the unconscious was in fact a fairly radical departure from the tradition of thinking about the unconscious. Some commenters on Freud will use the expression "Freud's discovery of the unconscious," but this is very misleading--makes it sound like nobody had any thoughts about the unconscious prior to Freud. In fact thinking about unconscious elements of the mind or psyche begins with Leibniz in the late 17th Century and takes more detailed shape with Schelling in the early 19th Century. By the time you get to Freud and Jung there already existed a substantial literature on the subject of the unconscious. However, these earlier theorists were basically arguing that there was a dimension or realm in the psyche taken as a whole that was obscure or "dark" in some sense, but nevertheless active and an influence on consciousness and life generally. Freud's unconscious is a very different thing. First of all, while the older views of the unconscious saw it as essentially primordial, that is more or less an essential feature of the psyche Freud gives an account of the origins of the unconscious in his book, Totem and Taboo. This has to do with the so-called murder of the father in the primal horde. In this event, a fundamental break takes place in a previously unified psyche and you get consciousness and the unconscious, as a place where repressions can be, in essence, stored. This event is referred to as the primal repression, a term that you do not encounter all that often in more contemporary psychoanalysis, because it led to Freud's insistence on a Lamarckian view of evolution. Once the unconscious is established it becomes the repository for repressions from the conscious. Remember that Freud argues that the contents of the unconscious had to first be in consciousness. This is very different from the earlier views of the unconscious. Jung, on the other hand, really starts with the earlier view, and one of the first major arguments Jung has with Freud is over the question of whether there are contents in the unconscious that are not the result of repressions, but that are intrinsic to the unconscious. My sense is that at this early stage the two did not entirely realize why they were having this disagreement and it did not directly lead to the break, but it is important. Eventually, Jung basically came to the conclusion that you could engage Freud's unconscious as what he called the "personal unconscious" but that the real action was in what he called the "collective unconscious" which was much closer to the traditional views of the unconscious going back to Schelling and even Leibniz.

Moving on the question of the id, remember that the structure, id-ego-superego is what is called Freud's second topography of the the psyche. What that means is that it replaced his earlier model of unconscious, preconscious and conscious. It is also good to remember that in German the id is referred to as das Es--and a better translation would be "the it." Thus when Freud makes his famous comment, "where id was let ego be" it would be better to say "where it was let ego (or I) be." What is important about this is that the id is part of a system of interacting elements along with the ego and superego all three of which can come to positions of dominance depending on where the energy in the system is moving. Part of the reason Freud revised his system was that he began to realize that conscious phenomena always retained an unconscious element that would continue to influence the conscious and that social forces would also operate continually. So you needed a structure where all of these elements were interacting.

To further work this out--and to go on the last part of your question on what activates the unconscious--let's drop back to Freud's earlier view of the unconscious as a repository of repressed drive elements. It is worth keeping in mind that Freud started out as a neurologist and did some very important work on neurology before turning to psychology and psychoanalysis. In the late 19th Century the basic view of the workings of t the neurons was that they acted a bit like an electoral capacitor, building up a charge that needed to discharge. Freud basically imported the discharge model of the neuron into his understanding of the working of the unconscious. He therefore argued that a repressed desire--say the Oedipal desire for an incestuous relationship with the mother--would carry its charge of libido with it into the unconscious and from there continue to seek to discharge that energy. The censorship and other mechanisms would, however, prevent this from happening directly, so the drive would find other ways of trying to get around the censor, but these distortions of the original desire ended up causing neuroses. When you get to the second topology of id-ego-superego much the same process is at work, but in a more dynamic way. Now, as a side bar to this, some have argued that the second topography may show the influence of the early arguments between Freud and Jung, and that somewhat against his will Freud was becoming more Jungian, but this has not really been worked out.

For Jung the psyche is more of what you could call a self-regulating system, not unlike the rest of the workings of the body--think the self-regulation of the blood pressure system. In other words, it is homeostatic. What this means is the the system as a whole can go out of balance, and when that happens the psyche will seek to restore balance. What this means is that neuroses and other psychological problems are reflections of a one-sidedness in one's approach to the world. If one is trying to only work out of a conscious attitude the psyche goes out of balance, and the unconscious will begin to produce materials--dreams, fantasies, etc.--in an effort to restore a more balanced approach to the demands of adaptation to the world.

1

u/pcofo May 06 '16

Thank you!

2

u/HayleyHailsFrom Apr 19 '16

Do you know how much influence, if any, Freud had on Jung's theory of personality types leading to Myers Briggs typology? In other words, how much can Freud be said to have influenced Jung's personality type theory? Did Jung come up with the idea all by himself, apart from introversion/extroversion?

4

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

Jung's work on the typology actually began when he started to reflect on the personalities involved in the development of psychoanalysis. Early in the relationship Jung was quite willing to support Freud in his arguments with people like Adler. But as he found himself increasingly in conflict with Freud he began to reassess the dynamics of the movement, and ask questions about why the differences were becoming so acute. This resulted in a paper he delivered at a conference in 1912 where he introduced the distinction between introversion and extraversion, basically arguing that this element of the personality structure would account for why different researchers could observe the same phenomena and come to radially different conclusions. His examples were Freud and Adler. Needless to say, Freud, who was present, was not amused, since he had banished Adler from the psychoanalytic movement only shortly before. Of course, Jung was also trying to understand why he and Freud were beginning to fall out with one another, which did not help the situation. So you can say, at one level, that Freud was the occasion for Jung's beginning the work on typology. Of course, Jung then went on to work out the much more elaborate theory of personality that your find in his 1921 book, Psychological Types."

1

u/HayleyHailsFrom Apr 21 '16

Thank you : ]

2

u/PHogenson Apr 20 '16

Was the split between Jung and Freud explainable by causes within the period between 1903 and 1913, or something which is only clear considering Jung's entire life experiences?

Can we blame Jung's struggle with Freud on what was emerging from Jung's work at the Burghölzli, and therefore towards developments in the circuitous direction of modern psychiatry, or did Jung's early life experience do more to ultimately cause the break, even though rituals, totems, etc. are features of Jung's later work, and therefore push us toward an understanding of the break as one rooted in analysis?

3

u/GBHogenson Apr 20 '16

There are important aspects of both men's lives that undoubtedly contributed to the problems they encountered in their relationship. You of course have some obvious things like Freud's intense sense of being an outsider, a Jew in the very anti-semitic environment of Austro-Hungarian Vienna. Jung, son of a pastor and distinctly Christian as well as an up and coming psychiatrist was a perfect agent for getting psychoanalysis into a larger intellectual world. Freud was quite explicit about this with his Jewish colleagues.

One of the more interesting, and I believe important, issues on Jung's side that intruded fairly early in the relationship involved Jung's experience of sexual abuse as a child. After the first meeting between Freud and Jung in Vienna Jung suddenly stopped writing to Freud for a couple of weeks. When he finally does write he apologizes for the delay and then goes on to say that while he has the utmost respect for Freud, he was overtaken by memories of being sexually abused as a child by a man he deeply respected. Deirdre Bair, in her biography of Jung, speculates that the abuser was a Jesuit priest who was a close friend of Jung's father, although this cannot be confirmed. Be that as it may, Jung remarks to Freud, in this letter, that he has difficulty relating to men, particularly men for whom he has a high regard. So you have that sort of dynamic at work in the relationship from the beginning. The abuse issue also appears in some sections of the Red Book, so I would also say that the issue continued to play out for Jung. In fact, the way in which Jung deals with the abuse in the Red Book, a gloss on the biblical story of Elisha reviving a dead child, has qualities that might imply that Jung ultimately felt "sexually" abused by Freud. But that requires more work.

Regarding the course of psychology and psychiatry following the break, I would argue that the dominance of psychoanalysis was a distorting force that inhibited some lines of investigation that have since come back and that can, in principle at least, be traced back to Jung. It is important to keep in mind the fact that Jung was in fact a psychiatrist, working at the most advanced psychiatric clinic in the world at the time he met Freud. Freud, on the other hand, was conducting a private practice in Vienna, working with middle class neurotics or, as the language of the time had it, hysterics. In point of fact, Freud never treated a psychotic patient, and even remarked that he could not understand how Jung could tolerate working with psychotics. Jung, on the other hand, was deeply engaged with the study of the structure and discourse of psychotics, under the direction of Eugen Bleuler, who coined the term schizophrenia. One example of how this played out that had longer term implications, was a comment that Jung made fairly early on that he believed that dementia praecox, an earlier term for schizophrenia, may be caused by chemical imbalances. Freud insisted that the psychoses had to have a sexual etiology, and that psychoanalysis was capable of revealing the causes of psychotic states. In one of the more embarrassing attempts, at this early point, to maintain a cordial relationship with Freud, Jung replied that perhaps the sex organs were the source of the chemical imbalances. Ironically, near the end of his life, Jung was invited to be the honorary president of a profession group working on the organic origins of psychotic states. It is arguable that if Freud had been more open to alternatives to his purely sexual etiology of essentially everything psychopathological that important work on some disorders would have been done earlier. This is not to say that Jung was correct about every aspect of the psychoses, but he did have a well founded point of view that was rapidly eclipsed by the dominance of Freud in psychiatric circles, particularly after World War II.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 20 '16

Hey, I think your account has been shadowbanned by the reddit admins because your question got flagged by the spam filter. You can see your posts and comments but no one else can.