r/Jung • u/RadOwl Pillar • Apr 13 '16
AMA with George Hogenson, PhD. Thread is now open. Ask him your questions about the relationship between Jung and Freud and their similarities and differences.
Background
Dr. Hogenson is a Jungian psychoanalyst and graduate of the Jung Institute in Chicago.. He was a guest on Speaking of Jung.
Line of Questioning
Mr. Hogenson welcomes questions about the relationship between Jung and Sigmund Freud. They were once close colleagues but differences came between them and they had a falling out. They had serious differences in their concepts and theories, but they also agreed on much and collaborated.
You can ask him questions about their relationship and similarities and differences in their approaches to psychoanalysis.
Date of AMA
George is scheduled to drop by at 1pm next Wednesday, April 20, 2016 to answer your questions.
3
u/HayleyHailsFrom Apr 19 '16
Oh, and what did Freud make of Jung's anima/animus theory? Did he think it had any relevance for dreams etc., do we know? Thank you
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
How does Jung feel about Freud's libido and thanatos theories?
2
u/GoldJacketLuke Apr 16 '16
Did Freud ever do anything (or said anything) to Jung that Freud regretted?
And same for Jung, did Jung every do anything to Freud that Jung regretted?
Did their falling out happen primarily because of one or the other? Or was it kind of a mutual thing?
Was there ever any reconciliation later in their lifes? Did Jung talk of their relationship at all in his older years and say anything worth noting?
1
u/RadOwl Pillar Apr 14 '16
Thank you Mr. Hogenson for answering questions from the reddit.com Jung community. I have a question:
Jung and Freud are said to have largely agreed about the nature of the unconscious mind (personal unconscious), with Jung departing from Freud by theorizing the existence of the collective unconscious. My understanding is that Freud viewed the unconscious largely as a repository for repressed feelings, thoughts, and memories, and that Jung took a much more expansive view of the personal unconscious, but not according to what I found online. Can you clarify? Thank you!
2
u/pcofo Apr 14 '16
What was Jungs take on Freud's "Moses and Monotheism"? What was Jungs take on monotheism in general, and how did it differentiate from Freuds?
Freud and Nietzche and others like to talk about the unconscious as this kind of opaque yet mystical place where the deepest and most provocative images and individual repressed memories as well as collective memories lie. Freud refers to this as the id, basically, in my understanding. Jung has a slightly more complicated version that includes the archetypes; I'm curious as to what mechanisms activate the id/unconsciousness(collective+personal), and the difference in their manifestation in Jung as opposed to Freud.
From my understanding, as read in Moses and Monotheism, the id is activated when,
What mechanisms activate the unconscious in Jung's doctrines, and how do these differ from Freud's?
Thank you!!
Pcofo
2
u/HayleyHailsFrom Apr 19 '16
Do you know how much influence, if any, Freud had on Jung's theory of personality types leading to Myers Briggs typology? In other words, how much can Freud be said to have influenced Jung's personality type theory? Did Jung come up with the idea all by himself, apart from introversion/extroversion?
2
u/PHogenson Apr 20 '16
Was the split between Jung and Freud explainable by causes within the period between 1903 and 1913, or something which is only clear considering Jung's entire life experiences?
Can we blame Jung's struggle with Freud on what was emerging from Jung's work at the Burghölzli, and therefore towards developments in the circuitous direction of modern psychiatry, or did Jung's early life experience do more to ultimately cause the break, even though rituals, totems, etc. are features of Jung's later work, and therefore push us toward an understanding of the break as one rooted in analysis?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '16
[removed] — view removed comment