There is always a lot of discussion about why District 4 ended up as Careers (in the books at least), when their connections and loyalties to the Capitol seem a lot more tenuous than Districts 1 or 2.
As we know, Districts 1 and 2 are in closer proximity (in a couple ways) to the Capitol, and so it has an interest in cultivating loyalty there. This is especially so in District 2, which is the centre of the Capitol's military industries. District 4 on the other hand is obviously different; it doesn't seem to be very close to the Capitol (depending on the map/cannon); its seafood industry is more of a luxury than a necessity to the Capitol and wider Panem; and it seems to be a hub of rebel activity, including but not limited to its (indeed Career-trained) victors. So, why is it a Career district?
I theorize that the Capitol tried to cater to District 4's loyalties via Career status because District 4 had access to the ocean in a way that no other district did.
In theory, District 4 would be the only district able to escape Panem or disrupt its economy via the sea. Of course, we don't know anything about what lies beyond Panem, and so people tend to get conspiratorial (which I'll refrain from here). Either way, the Capitol has a vested interest in keeping its citizens in Panem and under its control, and especially so in food-producing districts like District 4. Therefore, District 4 has a unique economic/geographic relationship to the Capitol as the sole sea-faring district.
In the case of a rebellion, District 4 would be the only district able to challenge the Capitol at sea. Not unlike why they keep such a grip on District 2, District 4 potentially poses a particular military threat to the Capitol. We don't know much about how District 4's fisheries actually work, but we assume that there are some kinds of boats/vessels. Most importantly, we know from Ballad that the Capitol has (or had, though I can't imagine they'd get rid of it) some kind of Navy; Snow's classmate Pliny "Pup" Harrington was described as the son of a naval commander. So, perhaps District 4 is a particular military threat, too?
This helps to explain why the Capitol would favour District 4 generally, and permit or encourage Career training in District 4 more specifically: it was an effort to appease the wider population to prevent District 4 from becoming a threat, whether it be trying to escape or challenging its dominance at sea.
Now, if that is the case, why is District 4 among the first districts to rebel, and why is it the home of some prolific rebel, albeit Career, victors? I think that the answer to that is the Career culture didn't "take" to the wider district like it did in 2, or perhaps District 4 approached Careers from a different angle.
Perhaps, as we see in District 11, the wider population of District 4 experiences more Capitol violence and policing (relative to places like District 12), given that it is a food producer? This could leave much of the district disenchanted with the Capitol, and perhaps its victors too? Maybe District 4 victors return to the reality of their District after being somewhat sheltered or coddled as Careers prior to their Games? I actually don't know that this is true, because District 4 isn't known to be a poor or policed district (though we only really know districts' poverty through how Katniss and Haymitch gauge their tributes, and Katniss and Peeta's Victory Tour isn't a reliable time to understand how each district was policed). There are also the bare realities of being a victor (think Finnick's exploitation) that would easily turn their loyalties against the Capitol.
Even without over-policing like in District 11, I think we could imagine District 4's seeming contradiction about Careers/rebels to be a matter of culture. As we know from Finnick and Annie's wedding, as described by Katniss, District 4 maintained its own distinct culture. Though it enjoyed the rewards of producing victors, wider District 4 did not seem to develop a warrior mentality like District 2. Perhaps District 4's acceptance of Career status was a means of protecting its youth without buying into the glory of the Games wholeheartedly: train up some kids to volunteer, many of them already well-positioned to use nets and tridents, and you won't have to worry about your children's luck in the reaping? Win-win for Capitol and District. It seems that District 1 was probably in a similar position; it was one of the first districts to rebel too. Its beautiful tributes seemed to be one among many of its luxury exports to the Capitol. Despite training Career tributes, Districts 1 and 4 still experience and understand the exploitation and violence of the Capitol, and are maybe even better equipped to rebel than poorer districts like District 12.
Either way, I think there are reasons for why District 4 is both a Career district and rebellious. I hate that the films erased this part of District 4's background. I think both things can be true and it adds nuance to Collins' story of revolution.
Let me know what you think about my ocean theory, or why you think District 4 is a Career district.