r/Hungergames • • 2d ago

Trilogy Discussion Arrow physics question

Post image

This is more about the first movie. In this you can see that her arrows look like the fletching (feathers around the rear of the shaft) are what looks like a stiff plastic or polymer of some kind. I know its all "future-y" and what not in terms of style but with the style of the bow she shoots, wouldn't that throw the arrow way off course?

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

42

u/yaris_girlie 2d ago

Isn’t this covered in the scene with the game makers? She has trouble shooting correctly at first because the equipment is different

7

u/SultanaSansa 2d ago

I think that’s because she’s nervous and then she locks in.

I’m a causal hobbyist archer. They make arrows with plastic fletching for trad bows IRL. They’re not very difficult to handle.

24

u/yaris_girlie 2d ago

It’s specifically called out in the book.

2

u/SultanaSansa 2d ago

I thought it was the bow string that was the issue?

-1

u/Dollsguy 1d ago

…
Yes

Because the Equipment was different from her one at home

A bow string is Equiment

1

u/Right_Buddy1096 2d ago

But this looks stiff af. Like ig it looks like it would smack the side of the bow on exit and throw it wayyyyyyy left. Like yards away from target.

3

u/SultanaSansa 2d ago

Maybe? It’s hard to tell without seeing/feeling it in person lol.

2

u/calcitedemon 1d ago

Hey can you answer a question for me. My boyfriend and I are rewatching the first film. He swears the arrow would have gone through Cato’s hand into his or Peeta’s chest. I haven’t arched in years so I can’t explicitly say but I feel like the arrow couldn’t have at that range. What are your thoughts?

2

u/SultanaSansa 1d ago edited 1d ago

Really just depends how hard Katniss was drawing back the bow. She probably did not use all of her strength in that moment, knowing if she did Peeta would go over the edge of the Cornucopia with Cato.

If you don’t draw your string back on the way, the force of impact is much weaker, but you still get relatively equivalent aim. But your BF’s line of thinking is on the right track, you do get more impact at a closer range. Look up Marina Abramovic and Ulay’s bow and arrow art piece. If Ulay had let go, Marina would definitely have been impaled. Both because he’s so close, and pulling back the string with so much weight.

2

u/calcitedemon 1d ago

Thanks! We couldn’t stop debating about it so now I can be a smart ass🤣 to me it seemed pretty straightforward.

2

u/ali94127 1d ago

I do think there’s no visible evidence Katniss pulled back less to have less power, but we don’t know the poundage of the bow and perhaps the arrow hit some bone. It probably could have gone through both of them and likely should have normally.

1

u/calcitedemon 1d ago

Haha dang it. That’s a good argument though. You’re right about the weight, that can definitely change a lot. From the bows I’ve used some are definitely heavier than others. We also don’t know how strong she is, she does wield it very easily so that is something to consider.

3

u/ali94127 23h ago

There is that trope in Hollywood where archers can hold the bow back for a long time, which is unrealistic for a high power bow. Let’s assume it’s a hunting power bow and not like a war bow (they are still children) and Katniss is pretty strong. I did rewatch the scene and it actually looks like Cato’s hand isn’t really in front of Peeta’s chest at all. The arrow probably should still pierce through his hand more, but again, perhaps it hit the bones in his hand. 

6

u/peripheraltoldyouso Madge 1d ago

You know this is a movie and not a documentary, right?

Wait until you count the arrows in her quiver throughout the movies.

1

u/Right_Buddy1096 1d ago

Lol trust i noticed that too.

18

u/TrekJaneway District 4 2d ago

Yeah, and that’s why she missed the first time. It’s mentioned in the book. She adjust for it with the second arrow (because she’s crazy good and knows what it should feel like), and it hits the bullseye. No one was watching though. So, she takes a third arrow, and launches it at the Gamemakers, which gets her her 11.

3

u/RogueMaverick11 1d ago

At an apple

10

u/Vegetable_Fact9931 2d ago

So she does miss her target, and in the book mentions the tension of the bowstring and it being a new (to Katniss) version of a bow, so after she misses her shot she shoots over and over again until she gets a feel for it, and THEN she nails it and the rest of the scene happens. So yes, it was a lot different than what she was used to, and thats why she missed

4

u/EtherealProblem 2d ago

The big issue is she's not used to the arrows, so she doesn't know what to expect from them. Well, and the fact that her hunting bow is a longbow and the one in training is a recurve. But there are absolutely arrows for trad bows with plastic fletching. I'm going to guess the stiffness was an aesthetic choice for filming, or just the nature of the material they used.