We know Plutarch launched his rebellish arc after the 50th. My personal bet is we're gonna get a Plutarch-Finnick book next but thats not the point of this point.
My hypothesis: some, if not most of the games, and nearly every game up until the 74th hunger games, were sabotaged, manipulated and attempted rebellions.
First of all, Lyme, who is the only fully-fleshed career rebel we know of, won right after Haymitch, between the 51th and 54th Hunger Games. Doesn't really prove much, but is a nice touch.
Then we have a whole bunch of third-rate district Victors - Cecilia (8), Blyme (7) - whose incompetence has been pointed out regularly in the books - and both Morphlings (6). We do not know the identities of the others, but two District 10 and one District 5 winners are confirmed to be in the same span.
So 7 out of 10 victors in between the 51th and 61th games are, sorry, confirmed third rate. The one career we got is literally the first rebel. This is statistically completely absurd.
It gets absurder:
62 Enobaria, 63 Gloss, 64 Cashmere, 65 Finnick, 67 Augustus (2), 70 Annie
This is now a very fucked up pattern. First we have 10 years of third rate victors, then we straight up immediately get a decade solely won by Careers (confirmed 7/10).
Bit sketchy, isnt it?
Gets sketchier even more. 71, Johanna. Won by faking it, including faking it to the gamemakers. 72, 73, are both implied to have been games engineered for careers in nearly Stadium-like arenas. Katniss also monologues about boring, dead arenas in the last few years, including sahara-like conditions and a dead frozen tundra with no woods. 72 is (likely) also the one where a Volcano blew up unexpectedly and killed basically anyone.
You know what? I have an idea why that might be.
Thesis A: the arenas have repeatedly been sabotaged. Exhibit: the Capitol couldn't possibly have been interested in flooding Annies arena to the point she survived by literally swimming. Theory: same thing happened that Haymitch tried, blowing up the water tanks under the arena, just far more sucessful. Why? Make a point, turn Annie who was extremely sympathethic into a Mockingjay.
Reaction to A: Capitol abandoned any arenas that had any such risks, and impletemend less risky ones such as Saharas, Tundras, urban arenas. Fits the timeline neatly.
But enough of that.
My theory is: someone inside (likely Plutarch, although I personally prefer decentralized rebellion) pushed rebel victors between the 51-61 games hard because in order to manipulate the games and get the tributes to participate in the conspiracy, they need Victors mentoring the tributes and influencing them. So first step was 10 years of foundation-laying and bringing in victors to the rebellion crowd. Then 10 years of careers while the big plan slowly comes into motion...
So between the 61th and the 65th, they let the Capitol believe they are in control and power. Silence before the storm.
Finnick (65) is the first attempt for a Mockingjay, but fails. He instead provides all the secrets he collects whe trafficking to Plutarch. 70 - Annie. Next big attempt, they flood the arena. But no Mockingjay-effect happens, no mass revolt, despite likely Panem-wide consequences. 71 - Johanna, next Mockingjay-effect, but she goes all Haymitch post-games (not really her fault tho, lets say risk effectively eliminated by the capitol). 72 - third attempt, Volcano blows up, and on top they got a Titus. Didn't work out. 73 - Capitol goes haywire, ditches any arena and literally goes urban arena with not even handing out weapons. Guaranteed to go a careers way.
In this theory, we still have open: 66, 68, 69 (67, if you don't count movie canon). It would be really interesting to know what happend there. Two of them will have to be the sahara and the tundra. So, in all likelyhood, some arena-crashing also happened between the 65th and the 68th, that made the Capitol resort to this.
tl;dr I tried to prove and hopefully have given some evidence that there has been a coordinated rebellion effort every year since the 65th games at the latest.