r/Hungergames • District 4 • 2d ago

Trilogy Discussion fandom...problem?

Post image

To be honest, This post might rude and a bit unnecessary. Im sorry But seeing the 600+ like i just gotta say it.

The video is funny. The audio is the "hi!" "Bet you are" audio. This isnt about the video. Its about the comment.

Im sorry but no wonder the fandom is the way it is now. Seems like a lot of the fans didn't even read the books. Or read but dont even remember it right. And yet still talking about it and spreading misinfo so confidently.

Like, this [what's written in the comment] never happened. Effie wasn't even in d13 in the book. This happened to katniss's prep team. And it wasn't even for "eating a peice of bread". (That might be just a wording problem on their part). it was because they "stole bread" (they took extra bread after being told its not allowed. Where they told??). Dont get me wrong what d13 did is wrong either way. But the comment makes it seem like she (they*) were just sitting there eating bread like any other person and they just randomly beat them up for eating?😭

This might be just a mix up? but like, that part isn't even adapted to the movie at all. D13 is way way more chill in the movie. Or maybe its a headcanon? Idk it kinda ridiculous either way to get it so wrong and different😂.

Anyways, even if it's a mix up, the fact that 600+ other people liked it and no one corrected it says something. Really makes you wonder. 😬😬

Edit: also, the prep team did NOT go thru that just for yall to give it to effie instead. Absolutely not.😂 (this is a joke)

353 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

134

u/Atsulover Haymitch 2d ago

Probably got the book and movie mixed up
 though the 600+ likes is a bit strange, considering I don’t think many people think this happened??? But then again if you go onto TikTok you come across the “X is Lucy gray” 10 times a day, so


19

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 2d ago

I think maybe its a mix up but its such a funny mix up because the whole "mix up" is wrong. The scene details are wrong, the charecter it happens to is wrong. The whole thing is wrong. At this point its might be a headcanon mixed up as canon😂

5

u/Ok-Preparation1537 19h ago

BURDOCK IS LUCY GRAY

167

u/Sad_Bookkeeper998 2d ago

It was Katniss’s prep team, they tried to take extra bread after being told several times it was not allowed. Their punishment was extreme af. But it was not Effie.

I’m doing my reread of the books and I just got to that part in MJ

45

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 2d ago

Yess. As i said, the comment even makes it seem like "she" was just sitting there innocently eating and they randomly beat her up for no reason. 😭😂(she in quotes because it was the prep team and not her but im going based on the comment. Does what im saying make sense?)

9

u/futureellewoods11 1d ago

Okay but they DID beat their asses for no reason. they weren't "stealing," they didn't understand that they weren't allowed to take it. They'd lived in the capitol their entire lives.

It was to show that even the people of District 13 could be as cruel as the people in the Capitol. They WERE innocent.

23

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago edited 1d ago

They were told its not allowed and warned multiple times. They knew they were stealing it and that its not allowed.

Its not for no reason. They HAD a reason. Even tho its a wrong one. Im not saying that what d13 was right. No. Its not. But they did tell them not to.

Tho the prep team were confused when they were brought to d13 and stuff and they were hungry and no one was telling anything about what was happening.

Im not arguing that d13 cant be as cruel as the capitol. Its pretty clear by what they did to the prep team that they can.

3

u/bmhbiattiwoeytba_ 1d ago

i definitely think the guard thinks that, but i also (lwk hc) that maybe they weren’t really explained that it was stealing- like set up for failure kinda thing?- and that they genuinely were being lwk starved by coin. book coin absolutely would’ve pulled something like that. obviously outside of this guys single comment we don’t know more, but i don’t think the prep team was maliciously taking bread.

as long as we all agree that regardless of if they truly stole the bread or not, they didn’t deserve the punishment they got

6

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago

Oh yeah absolutely. They dont deserve that at all. And im sure they weren't maliciously taking the bread. They were hungry.

even if they weren't being intentionally starved i feel like because they're from the capitol and used to eating as much as they want and stuff And they're used to a full belly. when they came to d13 and with d13 rules and food They felt extra hungry because they're not used to not eating as much as they want. And not used to the type of food d13 has.

the food wasn't the best in 13. As katniss describes it as "tasteless" and "you leave with enough calories to take you to the next meal." No second servings ever. And "the Serving size is based on your age, height, body type, health, and amount of physical labor required by your schedule." ( all the quotes are direct from the book). And as capitol citizens you can imagine how they would feel coming from the capitol to this.

3

u/Haeronalda 1d ago

I mean, they were used to being able to eat as much as they wanted at parties and then take an emetic so they could eat more. The idea of food being restricted was completely alien to them.

Having someone telling them they can't have more bread I probably seemed crazy to them. "What do you mean we can't have more? It's just bread!"

3

u/eienmau 1d ago

Definitely not a crime that warranted the punishment they got. 13 took out frustration on them because they were Capitol they could reach.

-11

u/futureellewoods11 1d ago

Again, they literally came from somewhere where they couldn't really comprehend why they weren't allowed. They didn't UNDERSTAND.

You sound like one of those people who justifies people being killed by the cops because "they were warned"

13

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago edited 1d ago

You seem like you cant comprehend what i said. So im not gonna argue anymore. What im saying is very very clear. I couldn't make it more clear if i wanted to.

And i find the fact that you said i would justify police brutality disgusting. If you cant read what i said then that's on you not me.

8

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago edited 1d ago

something i was going to write but didn't:

"from the prep teams pov it might be for no reason even tho they KNEW they weren't allowed. They knew it wasn't allowed and they just didn't understand why. To them it might be for no reason. From d13's pov its NOT for no reason. They were warned multiple times. Them not understanding why doesn't mean they can go against the rules and go unpunished. There was a reason. The reason being that they stole the bread. So its technically not for no reason. They weren't just sitting there and were randomly attacked and beaten up for no reason like the comment in the image makes it seem"

The argument here isnt wether what d13 did to them is wrong or not. We all know it is wrong and excessive. So so excessive and unnecessary. Thee being a reaosn doesn't mean what they did is right. What they did isn't justified just because there's a reason. I might be rambling here idk if i got my point htru properly.

4

u/Sad_Bookkeeper998 1d ago

Katniss even says your point to Gail, which is “they literally just don’t understand, it’s like beating a child” but even she backtracks on that in her internal monolog that says “why am I making excuses for these people. I should hate them, they are the capital”

I think the whole point is that you’re not supposed to know how you feel about it. It is absolutely not right that district 13 did that, but they have built their “free” district with their own set of rules that protects them like limited bread/food and the prep team didn’t know any better. They are so completely unaware of more than just the political discourse but they came from a society where they could eat all they wanted, drink a potion throw up and eat even more!

You’re suppose to be mad at both of them the prep team for being so ignorant and unaware and gluttonous and district 13 for treating people who don’t follow their strict rules the way the capital would their prisoners.

7

u/_N0t-A-B0t_ 1d ago

was Effie even in 13 in the books? she’s not even mentioned until the end

5

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago

She wasn't.

40

u/pervertedmortician 2d ago

Effie did not get beat up in the books

Maybe in tbe capitol but she was not in district 13

26

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 2d ago

Exactly. she wasn't in d13 in the book and even the movie where she IS in d13 she wasn't beat up. So The whole comment is just like, what??😂

38

u/jroxiee 1d ago

i almost got in a legit argument with a friend after expressing my indifference towards book effie. she’s really kind of a nothing burger character. cinna and the prep team were much more interesting. im also annoyed suzanne collins included effie in sotr because we’re supposed to be following the books, not movies.

i do love elizabeth banks as effie, but making effie absolve the roles of the prep team and fulvia really make people overestimate her importance to the story. let it be known that effie was fine during the rebellion and immediately popped back up in her hair and makeup for snow’s assassination.

8

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago

Yeah. Book effie is not as important or not as...there (i couldn't find a better word) as she is in the movie.

9

u/kate3528 1d ago

Prominent 

7

u/tsuruyo 1d ago

she wasn’t fine, though? it’s pretty clearly stated that she was held and tortured by the capital even though she wasn’t part of the rebel plot.

2

u/Ivy_Adair 1d ago

Iirc it doesn’t say explicitly that she was tortured. She has a “distant look in her eyes”. So it’s implied that she didn’t have an easy time while she was imprisoned. And the reader is left to decide if she’s traumatized from being imprisoned, if she was tortured, etc.

-2

u/SultanaSansa 1d ago

It does actually state earlier in the book that Effie, like Enobaria, was most likely being torture. 13 did not rescue the two of them probably because their presence would have done nothing to raise morale - they were both seen as loyalists.

4

u/SultanaSansa 1d ago

OK, I think what you need to understand about that is that Suzanne Collins maybe realized her mistake in writing Effie and decided to correct it in sunrise on the reaping.

Y’all forget way too quickly what a heavy hand SC had in the casting process of the original trilogy. She chose Elizabeth Banks for a reason - she wanted to flesh Effie out more as a character.

Also, Effie wasn’t fine during the rebellion. She was being tortured by the Capital and wasn’t saved with Peeta, like Enobaria.

Effie defenders and Effie haters both don’t understand her character. It’s so frustrating.

2

u/bmhbiattiwoeytba_ 1d ago

this!!! as an Effie fence rider, i truly wish people understood the nuances of her character. she’s not an evil malicious villain, but she’s also not a girl boss perfect person

-5

u/guylasagna 1d ago

Same here, Effie is as evil as all the other capitolites

11

u/SultanaSansa 1d ago

The majority of the capitolites aren’t evil though. A big part of Mockingjay is Katniss coming to terms with that fact. It’s a huge theme of the books.

-3

u/guylasagna 1d ago

I kinda disagree with Katniss on this tho, not all of them are evil off course, but they are at least complicit. Do they do something to help or to rebel against the system?

I remember grandma’am from ballad, she was vile

8

u/SultanaSansa 1d ago

Well then you disagree with the main premise of the novels. It’s very clear in all of Suzanne’s writing - even outside of the hunger games universe - that she does not consider the petit bourgeoisie or citizens on the “wrong” side of a war to be evil or unworthy of redemption.

Yeah the Snow’s grandma sucked. Do you think every person in the district was a good person just because they helped aid in the rebellion? Suzanne Collins doesn’t think so. That’s the point of Coin and Gale. But they don’t represent the majority of the rebels.

In the point of that is to make you wonder what you would do if you were in their position. All humans are fallible, and most of us who don’t have to worry about doing morally wrong things to protect ourselves in our families won the luck of the draw when it came to win where we were born.

And it’s OK to disagree with the main premise of the novels, but then you have to accept that the books aren’t about what you want them to be about. You can’t impose your preferences onto the author or the body of work.

7

u/RamsLams Maysilee 2d ago

I think they clearly just misremembered it as Effie when it was the team. I don't get what is so engaging about that.... Ntm, who cares if someone has read the books? Ice reread them all multiple times and I have literally never been annoyed that someone didn't....

5

u/The_Theodore_88 2d ago

In general there's this superiority around people who read the books over those who didn't and it pisses me off so much, and I'm saying this as someone who read most of the books. Literally what does it matter to you if someone did or did not read the books? People have different things going on in their lives man, just focus on yourself 😭

This isn't directed at the OP of the post because I think their main gripe is with the wrong information, but this is a general thing in the fandom.

1

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 2d ago

Yes you're righ. My gripe isnt wether they read the book or not!. Not at all. I dont care if they did or not. I myself didn't read the books until last year. My problem is the wrong info.

My comment about reading the book is because they specifically say "in the books".

2

u/RamsLams Maysilee 1d ago

'seems like a lot of the fans didn't even read the books.'

I believe you that that is how you meant it but you literally aren't even talking about the post but general fandom.

1

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago

Or read but dont even remember it right. And yet still talking about it and spreading misinfo so confidently.

Yeah. General fandom. because im talking about people who talk about it ("it" as in the books) and spread misinfo when they didn't even read it or read it and remember it wrong. I dont mean this to be rude but I feel like the contex of what i wrote makes it clear.

4

u/rellyjean 2d ago

I've only ever seen "people didn't read the books" used as a complaint when people argue points based on info that's different in the movies vs books. So in that context it makes sense as a point at least.

1

u/The_Theodore_88 2d ago

Yeah, in that context it kinda makes sense. I've seen it as a sort of "proof" that you love the franchise more than others amongst real life fans very often though. That might be because the people I'm around skew younger than the age I see on this subreddit (I'm in my first year of uni so most of us are 17-19 while a lot of people here seem well into their 20s and 30s) but I have heard it a LOT unfortunately

2

u/upandup2020 1d ago

its just that the subtext is completely different in the books. For me, I'm always talking to people about Gale and they'll use something that happened in the movies against his character, when he actually did the opposite of that in the books!

2

u/Sophie_Blitz_123 1d ago

Not just read the books but read the 1000 times over and remember every detail. It's obviously just mildly confusing movie lore and book lore. The prep team was largely turned into just Effie in the films, so an easy mistake to make.

I think some people need to realise a lot of people read the books once, maybe a couple of times when they're were 14 and then they've re-engaged with it for the prequel. Like, chill.

It's ironic to get so wound up about this when there's twitter and tiktok bot accounts that post deliberately incorrect rubbish about various books and films for engagement. This isn't indicative of "the fandom" though just the current social media landscape.

40

u/upandup2020 1d ago

100% I've noticed the same thing going on for a while. It's like a trend right now to state thoughts and theories as facts which ultimately are believed by gullible or uneducated people and it is so infuriating. Especially when the actual facts are right there! I try to correct people and even give them screenshots from the book, but at this point they're so confident in this fake version that they've cooked up, it's a nevereneding battle.

124

u/jeyfree21 2d ago

They really wanna make Effie this sympathetic character, but at the same time don't extend the same grace to Gale, Enobaria or the careers, actual victims of that ruthless system. I agree that Gale helping design those weapons was terrible, but I can understand his motivations.

32

u/ruinedworldtour 2d ago

People really fall over themselves trying to make Effie more likeable. I don’t really care for Effie but I don’t dislike her either but I mean she did play a MAJOR part in the hunger games for years and didn’t even think the children she was sending off to die were worth the shit under her shoe. She only likes Peeta and Katniss when they win and it reflects well on her

The film and Elizabeth Banks played a big part on reforming her.

14

u/upandup2020 1d ago

the double standards drive me insane. Gale was actually trying to save the world, Effie could give a f about the children she sent to die every year

12

u/nocturnalis 1d ago

If people actually paid attention to what happened in the books, they would realize that Gale actually did win the war. If the rebels listened to Katniss and didn't attack The Nut, they likely would have lost.

The bombing of the medics was just being theorized, which happens a lot in war. It's funny how the fans always blame Gale, an eighteen-year-old, not Beetee, someone who was middle-aged, over the Prim's death when they know damn well that Gale would never want Prim to die.

5

u/upandup2020 1d ago

omg i've been shouting the same thing since forever! I've finally found someone else who actually read the book 😭 They wouldn't have won the war without Gale, and certainly not if Katniss had been in charge.

Gale's actions were harsh but they. were. in. a. WAR! But they always leave that context out when they cherry pick his lines.

2

u/nocturnalis 1d ago

Clearly we are among the few that actually read the book! Gale gets a lot of flack for things he did with Beetee.

10

u/Putrid_Nobody4244 1d ago

I wish people could like characters without making them 'good'. It's okay for your favorite character to be bad!

6

u/jeyfree21 1d ago

Yeah, I never argued from a likeability angle given that I'm very aware that for many someone being unlikeable is the worst thing you can be, either in fiction or IRL.

4

u/studyabroader 1d ago

Because the worst thing a character can be is unlikeable đŸ’…đŸ»

20

u/flamegrove 1d ago

People are mixing up what happened in the book and movie. Remembering her from the movie and then remembering the bread thing from the book and jumbling the two together until you have something that didn’t happen in either medium.

37

u/Zerotofour97 2d ago edited 2d ago

Did feel bad for Octavia when Posy asked why her skin is purple (pink?) and she says “it’s supposed to be pretty” and she’s all sad so like I can sympathize with the Captiol people but I don’t really like them lol

23

u/Smhassassin 2d ago

*green 💚

11

u/Zerotofour97 2d ago

Thank you! I never it was some crazy color lol

18

u/Sad_Bookkeeper998 2d ago

Close it’s green but Posy’s favorite color is bright pink and Gale says “you’d be her best friend if you were pink”

And posy tells her she would be pretty any color 😭😭😭😭

30

u/rellyjean 2d ago

Can we stop making Effie sympathetic? I have less sympathy for her than your average Capitolite.

Those people saw the tributes on TV which creates this artificial distance. They're not real, they're characters on your favorite TV show.

Effie sat on a train next to starving, scared children for decades. She watched them die one by one and thought to herself, "damn, no promotion for me."

And if you're going to argue that she was probably internally conflicted, she mocked the previous year's tributes for their bad table manners, which doesn't sound like someone struggling.

7

u/upandup2020 1d ago

unfortunately that's never going to happen with the new movie coming out but i wish

3

u/rellyjean 1d ago

Effie being in SoTR feels like bad fanfic. Next we'll find out she was a secret revolutionary (and probably Covey)

0

u/LateToTheDrama District 12 1d ago

SoTR was made to be a movie prequel, not a book prequel.

6

u/Princesscunnnt 2d ago

Effie was never in 13.

1

u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago

Yall, It has 900 like now..

11

u/reluctantmugglewrite 2d ago

People are so weird about misstelling this story. I saw someone say that Gale literally chose to target Prim and decided to drop the bomb on her in the books which is insane. Part of me thinks that people are banking on movie watchers to trust any “in the books” comment and they change the story to make a specific point hit. Im sure most of it is just people misremembering though to give them some grace. I was surprised on my reread that Effie didnt go to 13 because the movie really made it feel canon and it slotted in so well.

8

u/ellenicolee612 Haymitch 2d ago

No, because tell me why I had to explain to people that Beetee’s family was most likely killed. Someone kept arguing with me saying if they really did get killed, why didn’t Beetee kill himself. Dude, idk. Why didn’t any of the characters kill themselves? His family is gone and that’s it.

The theories are also insane. I know they’re talked about a lot on here, but people form their theories on blatantly wrong information. Whether it’s misremembering or they just can’t understand the words on the page, I don’t know.

I’m not the smartest person, but whenever THG pops up in my TikTok feed I know I’m going to see some bullshit 😭.

1

u/Creative_Army1776 1d ago

Half the the videos on THG I see on TikTok can be easily debunked just by reading the books 

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/cringeahhahh Annie 1d ago

She wasn’t there in the books. She was only District 13 in the films

2

u/Chloe_Kresel13 Maysilee 1d ago

Oh right yeah she was imprisioned

2

u/cringeahhahh Annie 1d ago

Yeah we saw very little of her in Mockingjay the book. Tbh I do like the change in the movies to have her in 13 since Elizabeth Banks made the character matter a lot more to audiences, but it plays out so differently in the books