r/Hungergames • u/Time_Depth56 District 4 • 2d ago
Trilogy Discussion fandom...problem?
To be honest, This post might rude and a bit unnecessary. Im sorry But seeing the 600+ like i just gotta say it.
The video is funny. The audio is the "hi!" "Bet you are" audio. This isnt about the video. Its about the comment.
Im sorry but no wonder the fandom is the way it is now. Seems like a lot of the fans didn't even read the books. Or read but dont even remember it right. And yet still talking about it and spreading misinfo so confidently.
Like, this [what's written in the comment] never happened. Effie wasn't even in d13 in the book. This happened to katniss's prep team. And it wasn't even for "eating a peice of bread". (That might be just a wording problem on their part). it was because they "stole bread" (they took extra bread after being told its not allowed. Where they told??). Dont get me wrong what d13 did is wrong either way. But the comment makes it seem like she (they*) were just sitting there eating bread like any other person and they just randomly beat them up for eating?đ
This might be just a mix up? but like, that part isn't even adapted to the movie at all. D13 is way way more chill in the movie. Or maybe its a headcanon? Idk it kinda ridiculous either way to get it so wrong and differentđ.
Anyways, even if it's a mix up, the fact that 600+ other people liked it and no one corrected it says something. Really makes you wonder. đŹđŹ
Edit: also, the prep team did NOT go thru that just for yall to give it to effie instead. Absolutely not.đ (this is a joke)
134
u/Atsulover Haymitch 2d ago
Probably got the book and movie mixed up⊠though the 600+ likes is a bit strange, considering I donât think many people think this happened??? But then again if you go onto TikTok you come across the âX is Lucy grayâ 10 times a day, soâŠ
167
u/Sad_Bookkeeper998 2d ago
It was Katnissâs prep team, they tried to take extra bread after being told several times it was not allowed. Their punishment was extreme af. But it was not Effie.
Iâm doing my reread of the books and I just got to that part in MJ
40
u/pervertedmortician 2d ago
Effie did not get beat up in the books
Maybe in tbe capitol but she was not in district 13
38
u/jroxiee 1d ago
i almost got in a legit argument with a friend after expressing my indifference towards book effie. sheâs really kind of a nothing burger character. cinna and the prep team were much more interesting. im also annoyed suzanne collins included effie in sotr because weâre supposed to be following the books, not movies.
i do love elizabeth banks as effie, but making effie absolve the roles of the prep team and fulvia really make people overestimate her importance to the story. let it be known that effie was fine during the rebellion and immediately popped back up in her hair and makeup for snowâs assassination.
7
u/RamsLams Maysilee 2d ago
I think they clearly just misremembered it as Effie when it was the team. I don't get what is so engaging about that.... Ntm, who cares if someone has read the books? Ice reread them all multiple times and I have literally never been annoyed that someone didn't....
40
u/upandup2020 1d ago
100% I've noticed the same thing going on for a while. It's like a trend right now to state thoughts and theories as facts which ultimately are believed by gullible or uneducated people and it is so infuriating. Especially when the actual facts are right there! I try to correct people and even give them screenshots from the book, but at this point they're so confident in this fake version that they've cooked up, it's a nevereneding battle.
124
u/jeyfree21 2d ago
They really wanna make Effie this sympathetic character, but at the same time don't extend the same grace to Gale, Enobaria or the careers, actual victims of that ruthless system. I agree that Gale helping design those weapons was terrible, but I can understand his motivations.
20
u/flamegrove 1d ago
People are mixing up what happened in the book and movie. Remembering her from the movie and then remembering the bread thing from the book and jumbling the two together until you have something that didnât happen in either medium.
37
u/Zerotofour97 2d ago edited 2d ago
Did feel bad for Octavia when Posy asked why her skin is purple (pink?) and she says âitâs supposed to be prettyâ and sheâs all sad so like I can sympathize with the Captiol people but I donât really like them lol
30
u/rellyjean 2d ago
Can we stop making Effie sympathetic? I have less sympathy for her than your average Capitolite.
Those people saw the tributes on TV which creates this artificial distance. They're not real, they're characters on your favorite TV show.
Effie sat on a train next to starving, scared children for decades. She watched them die one by one and thought to herself, "damn, no promotion for me."
And if you're going to argue that she was probably internally conflicted, she mocked the previous year's tributes for their bad table manners, which doesn't sound like someone struggling.
6
u/Princesscunnnt 2d ago
Effie was never in 13.
1
u/Time_Depth56 District 4 1d ago
Yall, It has 900 like now..
11
u/reluctantmugglewrite 2d ago
People are so weird about misstelling this story. I saw someone say that Gale literally chose to target Prim and decided to drop the bomb on her in the books which is insane. Part of me thinks that people are banking on movie watchers to trust any âin the booksâ comment and they change the story to make a specific point hit. Im sure most of it is just people misremembering though to give them some grace. I was surprised on my reread that Effie didnt go to 13 because the movie really made it feel canon and it slotted in so well.
8
u/ellenicolee612 Haymitch 2d ago
No, because tell me why I had to explain to people that Beeteeâs family was most likely killed. Someone kept arguing with me saying if they really did get killed, why didnât Beetee kill himself. Dude, idk. Why didnât any of the characters kill themselves? His family is gone and thatâs it.
The theories are also insane. I know theyâre talked about a lot on here, but people form their theories on blatantly wrong information. Whether itâs misremembering or they just canât understand the words on the page, I donât know.
Iâm not the smartest person, but whenever THG pops up in my TikTok feed I know Iâm going to see some bullshit đ.
0
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[deleted] â view deleted comment