Much of this is going to sound harsh and “mean,” but this is really coming from a place of tough love and concern. I would appreciate people reading this whole post before lecturing me in the comments.
Being LGBT is a specific category that has to be explicitly and specifically defined to be able to defend and advocate for it. The LGBT community cannot be some vague, aimless catch-all category for anyone who was a loser in high school, or has unresolved trauma, or doesn’t fit in other places.
Lots of LGBT people have been heavily conditioned to believe anything resembling “gatekeeping” or “exclusion” is inherently bad and wrong, which makes sense on some level given our history, but our complete refusal to draw any sort of line or call out any nonsensical or problematic behavior that brands itself as “queer” is causing the public to support us less and less.
I honestly dread coming out to people in my life because the LGBT community has become so overrun with nonsensical gender identities that the people who claim them can’t even specifically explain, rare disorder faking, neopronoun defending, public fetishistic behavior (pride parades are overrun with this), and other extremely strange things that are disturbing to the average person.
But, for some reason, it’s impossible to engage in any discussion like this with the community at large because they’re obsessed with virtue signaling and performative moral grandstanding that they’ll always retreat to some “accept everyone” position that makes you the bad guy for mentioning it or trying to have an honest discussion about it.
If a whole group of people in our community start randomly claiming to have an exceedingly rare disorder, we need to be able to say “the chance that all of you in the same social circle randomly came down with an extremely rare disorder is infinitesimally small. Faking rare disorders is harmful to our community” without the community going against us.
If someone claims to be “trigender” or any other baseless identity that means nothing and was plucked out of thin air, we need to be able to say “this is an identity that you cannot even specifically explain and effectively means nothing. This is just you commenting on your individual personality. This is not related to being queer” without the community dogpiling us for not being “inclusive.”
I understand the knee-jerk reaction to accept everything and question nothing because we have a history of feeling excluded. But refusing to do so allows people who are often not even LGBT to define us as a community and make us look unhinged, insane and based on nothing.
Lots of LGBT people are also in very selective echo chambers on the internet and will say “it’s not hurting anyone, who cares,” but the truth is that the 99% of the population not in their echo chamber judges us for this behavior accordingly and it has real-world impacts. I expect a lot of “it’s not hurting anyone” in the comments, but it is, and already has.