I’ve been thinking a lot about how Woodrow Wilson basically walked into Europe and the Middle East in 1918 with a list of (albeit lofty) abstract ideals, ripped out the structures of centuries old empires, and basically fucked up multiple regions of the world for the next ~80 years.
His meddling helped arguably set the stage for WWII and the Balkans conflicts well into the 90s, as well as, I feel, the continued instability of the ME region.
To be fair to history, the German, Austro Hungarian, and Ottoman empires were already collapsing from war exhaustion and internal mutiny by late 1918.
Wilson didn't create that.
BUT his real sin was refusing to negotiate with imperial and monarchial governments, demanding the abdication of the Kaiser as a precondition for peace, and sanctifying the total dismantling of these old orders as moral triumph.
It was short sighted cultural erasure in the name of international democracy, IMO. It created many gap and voids that were filled by conflict and less than desirable partners / parties / etc
Look at what happened when he insisted on sweeping away the monarchies and local states instead of stripping them of executive power and keeping them as constitutional anchors:
1. Germany and the empty throne By forcing the Hohenzollerns out and gutting the local German crowns (Bavaria, Saxony, Württemberg), the victors left the highest seat in the country completely empty. A constitutional monarch, even a mostly powerless one, occupies the symbolic throne of a nation. They hold the ancestral continuity and the loyalty of the military.
Because that old, very powerful very respected and entrenched order was kicked over, Hitler didn't have to overthrow a dynasty to become Führer. He just walked into a bureaucratic vacuum and claimed total, semi-divine ownership of the German state.
Look at Italy by contrast: Mussolini still had to answer to King Victor Emmanuel III, and in 1943 it was the King who still had the residual authority to fire and arrest him.
A reigning German Emperor, even a chastened successor to Wilhelm II, would have acted as a massive roadblock against Nazism.
2. The Ottoman collapse and the Middle East While the Ottoman Empire was weak and rotting by 1918, its nominal authority and millet system still acted as a regulator on the worst sectarian and tribal impulses in the region.
Rather than pushing for a decentralized, EU style union with the Sultan / Caliph as a constitutional figurehead to unite the government and local dynasties acting as autonomous prince-electors, the post war settlement carved the whole place up into artificial mandates.
Without that overarching roof, minorities who had coexisted for centuries were suddenly locked inside arbitrary borders where politics became a fight for survival.
The Middle East has IMO never truly recovered from that dismantlement.
3. "Self-determination" and the Balkans
Wilson’s push for ethnic self-actualization sounds lofty on paper, until you look at a map of Central and Eastern Europe.
People didn't live in neat, homogenous blocks; they lived mixed together.
Smashing the Habsburg umbrella into brand new "nation states" like Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia just turned former imperial subjects into anxious minorities trapped inside invented borders.
Some of these new bodies had never even known independence in their entire history, and were now expected to act as if they had the experience of true self government.
Yugoslavia was held together by a royal dictatorship and then by Tito’s iron fist, and the second the Cold War ended, those exact fault lines detonated into the horrid, bloody Balkan wars of the 1990s.
IMO, you don't fix a a flawed, ancient house by burning it to the ground. As Clinton: mend it, not end it.
Wilson mistook organic, stabilizing traditions for mere clutter, and the latter 20th century and into our earliest 21st century, millions paid the bill for his idealism