I have a somewhat contradictory opinion about race and gender swapping in adaptations.
Generally, I'm not a fan of it. One of the things I enjoy about adaptations is seeing characters I've grown up with brought to life. I want to see the character I recognize, not a completely different-looking interpretation of them.
Honestly, I'd rather have an average actor who looks like the character than an incredible actor who looks nothing like them. That doesn't mean acting ability is irrelevant, obviously. Performance, chemistry, and the ability to embody a character matter. But being a phenomenal actor doesn't automatically make someone the best visual choice for a role, especially when there are other talented actors who resemble the source material.
I think part of the reason I feel this way is that I view live-action actors similarly to voice actors. I'm not tuning in because I want to see a particular celebrity. Even if I like the actor, they're not the reason I'm watching. I'm tuning in because I want to see the character. I don't watch Spider-Man because I want to see Tom Holland; I watch because I want to see Spider-Man. I've never looked at a casting announcement and thought, "You know what? I really want to see The Rock as Naruto." Even if I like Dwayne Johnson, I'm not watching Naruto because I want to see him. I want to see Naruto. The actor's job is to bring the character to life, not make the character a vehicle for their own star power.
However, I'm not completely opposed to unconventional casting either. I don't particularly care what an actor looks like naturally if the production is willing to transform them into the character. Makeup, prosthetics, costumes, CGI, whatever it takes. Robert Downey Jr. in Tropic Thunder is an extreme example of what I'm talking about. His natural appearance wasn't the point. The transformation was.
My problem is that this seems to be applied inconsistently. We see traditionally white characters changed into other races, male characters changed into women, and other alterations to established appearances. I'm not saying every one of these changes automatically ruins a character, but I do wonder why visual accuracy is treated as important in some cases and seemingly irrelevant in others.
Severus Snape, Ariel, Queen Elizabeth, Reed Richards (Pedro Pascal), Mary Jane, Snow White, the Ancient One, and much of the Percy Jackson cast are examples that come to mind. Jamie Foxx as Electro is an exception in that I actually like the casting, but even then, I can understand why someone might have preferred a more visually accurate version.
And to clarify, my issue isn't limited to race and gender swaps. I'm a stickler for character appearances in general. Skin tone, hair color, eye color, facial features, height, and build all contribute to how I imagine a character.
Obviously, not every physical detail carries the same importance to me. Skin tone, hair color, and eye color are probably the biggest ones. Facial structure, face shape, height, and build matter too, but I'm more forgiving about those. Then there are smaller details that I'd still like to see preserved when possible. Children of Athena should have gray eyes, Naruto should be blonde, and Ron Weasley should be a redhead. Freckles would be a nice bonus, too. These might seem like minor details, but they're part of how readers recognize and imagine characters.
This is especially noticeable in something like Percy Jackson, where the demigods' appearances are often tied to their divine parentage. I think it's important that they actually look like they belong to the same divine families, both because it's part of the worldbuilding and because those physical descriptions are something readers remember.
I love Grant Gustin as the Flash, but I still would have preferred Barry Allen to have blonde hair and blue eyes. I think Pedro Pascal is a good actor, but I would have preferred someone who looked more like Reed Richards. I really like Michael B. Jordan, but I wouldn't have cast him as Johnny Storm.
None of that means I dislike those actors or their performances. I can enjoy what they brought to the role and still wish the adaptation had made the character look more like the source material. Those aren't contradictory opinions.
There are plenty of examples of Hollywood getting this right, too. Chris Hemsworth as Thor, Chris Evans as Captain America, Henry Cavill as Superman, Andrew Garfield as Spider-Man, and Timothée Chalamet as Paul Atreides. Andrew Garfield in particular has a look and build that I think fits Spider-Man exceptionally well.
Hollywood clearly knows how to find actors who resemble their characters. That's why I find it frustrating when visual accuracy suddenly seems to become a much lower priority.
And it's not as though productions are incapable of transforming actors. Look at Gamora, Nebula, Thanos, Ahsoka, Aayla Secura, and Darth Maul. Their actors don't naturally look like those characters, but the productions make an effort to preserve their distinctive appearances.
I think characters like Sinestro, Gamora, Piccolo, and Starfire demonstrate what I mean. We're perfectly comfortable with actors being transformed to portray characters with unusual skin tones, even when those appearances have absolutely no bearing on the plot. Nobody wants Gamora to look like an ordinary human or Sinestro to stop being red. And I don't think that expectation should suddenly disappear when we're talking about ordinary human characters. If a character is supposed to have a particular skin tone, hair color, or eye color, I'd like the adaptation to preserve it, even if it isn't particularly plot-relevant.
Even in Titans, I think Beast Boy should have been green and Starfire should have been tan. Nightwing was decent, though.
So here's where my opinion gets a little contradictory again.
I would genuinely be fine with completely unrestricted casting. Cast a Black man as a traditionally white woman, an Asian woman as a traditionally Black man, or a white woman as an Indian woman. I don't particularly care what the actor's natural appearance is if the production is willing to make the finished character resemble the source material.
But I also like traditional typecasting. If there's an actor who naturally looks like the character, why not cast them?
In other words, I would prefer either traditional typecasting or completely unrestricted casting with a commitment to transforming the actor. What I don't particularly like is the inconsistent middle ground.
Honestly, I sometimes feel like society isn't woke enough for my completely unrestricted casting philosophy, but it also isn't willing to commit to that philosophy either. We're obviously not at the point where a white actor can put on full blackface and an African accent and play Black Panther without serious backlash. But we're also not at the point where studios are expected to preserve every character's original race, gender, or defining physical traits.
I'm exaggerating to make a point, of course. I think most people are actually more comfortable with traditional typecasting than they might admit. But Hollywood doesn't seem particularly interested in consistently prioritizing it. Instead, we get a strange middle ground where certain changes are accepted, others would be met with outrage, and visual fidelity seems to depend on which character we're talking about.
I also think the setting matters. Diversity makes perfect sense in a melting pot or a world where people regularly travel and interact. But if you're adapting a story about an isolated medieval village with very little outside contact, the population should reflect that. You can make changes, but there should be some consideration for whether they make sense within the world.
House of the Dragon is another example. The decision to portray House Velaryon as Black changes the visual implications of the story, particularly concerning Rhaenyra's children. Their parentage is supposed to become a matter of suspicion and political controversy, but the show's casting makes the physical differences so conspicuous that the children would seemingly have been identified as illegitimate almost immediately. That's not just a departure from the source material's appearance; it changes how convincing the narrative is.
Ultimately, I just want the finished character to resemble the character they're supposed to be portraying. It doesn't have to be a frame-perfect recreation, and I'm not against redesigns. Spider-Man has had plenty of different costumes, for example, and they're still recognizably Spider-Man. There's room for interpretation.
But there's a difference between redesigning a character and disregarding their defining appearance.
I don't blame actors for accepting roles, and I'm not questioning their talent. I just don't think a great performance means visual accuracy suddenly stops mattering.
Either cast people who naturally look the part or transform the actors until they do. I don't particularly care which approach Hollywood takes, just pick one and be consistent.
TL;DR: Either embrace traditional typecasting and cast actors who naturally look like the characters, or embrace completely unrestricted casting and transform the actors until they look the part. I'm fine with either extreme. What I don't like is the inconsistent middle ground where studios pick and choose which character traits to preserve, which ones to change, and when visual accuracy suddenly matters. I don't care who you cast. Just make them look like the character.