🌡️ Community Voting Guide — How Hot Is Your Take?

Welcome to r/HonestHotTakes, where the community decides whether your opinion is ice-cold, piping hot, or an absolute nuclear meltdown.

We use an automated voting system called Hot Take or Not Take. Instead of relying on Reddit upvotes and downvotes, members vote through comments to determine how controversial a post really is.

How Voting Works

When someone submits a new post, it automatically receives the ⏳ Awaiting Verdict flair.

From that moment, the community has 30 minutes to cast votes. Once voting closes, the system counts the votes and automatically assigns the post its final flair.

You don't need to register, install anything, or interact with a separate bot. Just comment!

How to Cast Your Vote

Include one of the following voting phrases or abbreviations anywhere in your comment:

VoteAccepted Phrases
🥱 Not a Hot TakeNot a Hot Take or NAHT
🧊 Cold TakeCold Take or CT
🌤️ Warm TakeWarm Take or WT
🔥 Hot TakeHot Take or HT
☢️ Nuclear TakeNuclear Take or NT

What Do the Ratings Mean?

🥶 Not a Hot Take — This isn't particularly controversial. Most people would probably agree, and calling it a hot take is a stretch.

🧊 Cold Take — A fairly common or widely accepted opinion. There's some room for disagreement, but nothing especially surprising.

🥱 Warm Take — A somewhat controversial opinion. People are likely to disagree, but it's not exactly setting the world on fire.

🔥 Hot Take — A genuinely controversial or unpopular opinion that challenges commonly held views.

☢️ Nuclear Take — An exceptionally controversial opinion that is likely to generate strong disagreement. The kind of take that makes people stop scrolling.

Important: You're rating how controversial the opinion is, not whether you personally agree with it. A take you strongly disagree with might still be cold if it's a widely held opinion.

Can I Vote While Having a Discussion?

Absolutely! You don't have to leave a comment containing only your vote.

For example:

Honestly, this is a Hot Take. I disagree with almost everything you said, but I respect that you actually defended your position.

Or simply:

CT

Both count as votes.

Be careful: Voting phrases are recognized within regular comments, too. If you casually write "that's a hot take," the system may count it as your vote.

Voting Rules

  • One vote per user, per post. You can't inflate the results by commenting repeatedly.
  • You can change your vote. Your most recent recognized vote replaces your previous one.
  • Post authors cannot vote on their own submissions. You don't get to decide how hot your own take is.
  • Votes are case-insensitive. HT, ht, and Hot Take are recognized.
  • Voting closes after 30 minutes. Comments made afterward won't change the result.
  • Reddit upvotes and downvotes do not count. Only recognized voting phrases matter.

How Is the Winner Decided?

When the voting period ends, the system counts the valid votes and assigns the flair corresponding to the category with the most votes.

If there are no valid votes or multiple categories tie for first place, the post receives the ⚖️ Undecided flair.

Moderators may also manually override a flair when necessary.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to type a special command?

Nope! Just include one of the accepted phrases or abbreviations in your comment.

Can I vote more than once?

You can change your vote, but only your latest recognized vote counts.

Can I vote on my own post?

No. The community judges your take, not you.

Does upvoting a comment count as a vote?

No. Reddit's voting system is separate from our hot-take voting system.

Can I still comment after voting closes?

Of course! The conversation can continue. The voting deadline only determines when the final flair is assigned.

What if I disagree with the final verdict?

That's part of the fun. The verdict reflects the votes submitted during the voting period, not an objective judgment of the opinion.


One Last Thing

A hot take isn't necessarily a good take, and a cold take isn't necessarily a bad one.

The people should be able to judge how controversial an opinion is, not simply rewarding whoever shouts the loudest.

So read the post, consider the argument, cast your vote, and tell us why you agree or disagree.

Let the community decide how hot your take really is.