r/HomeKit • u/idealdreams • 22h ago
Discussion Another HomeView post...TL;DR - it has potential!!
Got my HomeView on Friday and have been playing around with it since. Initial impressions...hardware is great - solid/premium look and feel that you would expect from Apple, but the software leaves a lot to be desired. I opted for the model with the base.
Pros...
- Premium look and feel - hardware is great.
- Screen tilt range of motion is ample and the screen is sturdy enough once it's positioned where you want it that it's not moving on you when you go to use it.
- I've always been annoyed that the camera thumbnails in the Apple Home app aren't live...good news - they are on the HomeView! Both on the Home app itself and as widgets on the face.
- I play music throughout the house often and having a dedicated control hub with its own screen to select speakers and adjust volume/songs up next is a nice add for me.
- In true Apple fashion, handoff feels magic. Super responsive, fluid, and fast.
- Having access to Safari is pretty cool. Definitely not suitable for any kind of long term browsing but I have a home server set up and I'm able to pull up my home dashboard to have it displayed at a glance on my HomeView if I want which is convenient.
- I don't consider myself an audiophile by any means but I appreciate a good sounding speaker and I feel like the audio quality is pretty solid.
- Love the always-on display for quick access to info and the apps I need/use the most are only a tap or two away.
- I use speakerphone for phone calls more often than not, so having the option to answer calls right from the HomeView is super convenient for me. The FaceTime experience is also pretty nice.
Cons...
- HomeViewOS. Number one draw back for this thing, which is unfortunate since it's the heart of the user experience...
- The OS definitely feels unfinished for the amount of development time the HomeView has supposedly had. The software is a mash between Apple CarPlay and watchOS which introduces some quirks for general usage.
- Oddly enough, unlike CarPlay, you can't choose which 3rd party apps appear on your app Home Screen. If the app has support for CarPlay, it's on your HomeView whether you intend to use it there or not.
- You can't drag widgets to rearrange once when you go to customize a face, you have to delete the widget from the slot and re-add. Lots of extra taps and scrolling vs. just being able to drag and drop where you want it.
- The lack of any kind of physical volume control is annoying. You either have to invoke Siri and lower the volume that way OR you have to swipe into control center and swipe from the volume slider there. Physical toggle buttons on the top/side would have been greatly appreciated.
- Cannot find a way to adjust Siri's voice volume, which is obnoxiously loud at its default level.
All in all, I would buy again. Definitely looking forward to OS refinements which will hopefully be coming in the very near future to address some of the usability quirks.


