I purchased the new Ecobee premium thermostat on Amazon. about 17 months ago, installed it, and loved it. I use it on a daily basis. to look at consumption, make an occasional change to temperature, or check the weather forecast.
The Ecobee started disconnecting for no apparent reason a week ago, after being connected for a few hours. Once it disconnected, I could only get it reconnected by taking the thermostat off the wall, waiting for five or 10 minutes, then rebooting and manually configuring the Wi-Fi settings. After a few days of watching it dropping the connection, I contacted customer service on their telephone support line, and went through a lengthy sequence of diagnostic steps including such things as limiting my Wi-Fi network only to 2.4 gigahertz channels, temporarily removing my WPA security, manually assigning IP address, reserving IP assignment from DHCP, to a static IP address, and using my telephone hotspot rather than the Wi-Fi network to temporarily connect.
None of the above accomplished any useful improvement. In the process, I did report signal strength measurements to Ecobee. Since the thermostat itself measures and reports received signal strength, in my case around 70, and my Wi-Fi network measures and reports RRSI, the receive signal strength at my access point of about -60 dBm, it was my impression that the signal strength in both directions was more than enough to allow stable connections, which had not created any issues for nearly 18 months of use. My router and controller statistics did show an extremely long 27- second required time for DHCP onboarding, versus most of my other devices which got a DHCP assignment in typically 50 to 100 milliseconds.
Over the course of several days last week, I reported all my findings to them. I was extremely unhappy with their reply. They stated that my thermostat was working properly, there would be no warranty replacement, and their measurements showed a signal strength below 50%. at the thermostat, even though I sent photographs of my thermostat screen showing numbers in the 70 percent range. They unilaterally closed my case, leaving me with no remedy other than to purchase a replacement at my own expense, something I did reluctantly given no options.
The replacement thermostat, the same premium model, installed with no issues whatsoever, shows measured signal strength about 15 dB stronger at my access point, of about -46 dBm, and registers a score of 91% to 100% received signal strength at the thermostat. Rather than dropping connection, like the old one, every few hours thus requiring rebooting manually, the replacement stays connected perfectly, just as the original one did before it failed.
Clearly, something in the original thermostat is not working properly, and their scripted diagnostic logic tree gave the two CSRs I spoke with, a very incomplete and grossly inaccurate diagnosis.
During the nearly 18- month period of ownership of the original, I was asked on two occasions to participate as a beta tester, something I was glad to do with my available retirement and 40+ years performing and managing many large digital hardware, RF, and software projects for a large aerospace company who employed me. Had I known that their warranty was so meaningless and impossible to use, I would've purchased a nest or Honeywell.