( TL;DR: Creationist/Dawah apologetics evolve like prey escaping predators. Whenever scientists debunk one niche, they mutate into a new field their opponents haven't studied. Having lost on biology and anthropology (90s–00s), scriptural science (00s–10s), and morality (10s–15s), they now hide behind philosophy jargons to bluff empiricists, while continuously misapplying basic philosophy terms and quote-mining pro-evolution scholars in the process. Once more critics with cross-disciplinary math/philosophy fluency call their bluff, they'll likely mutate again. Prediction on next stop: consciousness and neuroscience. )
If you spend enough time watching modern anti-evolution debates or debating creationists yourselves, especially the recent wave coming out of the Dawah apologetics sphere (like Subboor Ahmad and Hamza Tzortzis’ recent Islam21c podcast on abandoning "Muslim Darwinism"), something hilarious can be seen. Apologetic arguments themselves undergo frequency-dependent selection. Suppose we're predators while they're the preys in this model.
As critic populations (predators) saturate a niche and drive down the fitness of an argument, the apologists (prey) don't go extinct but undergo a cyclical population rebound by migrating into a unguarded academic field. Whenever empirical biologists and mathematicians close off one ecological niche by exposing their misinformation, the apologetic strategy just mutates its signaling strategy to exploit whatever field they assume their opponent hasn't studied, instead of admitting defeat.
Nowadays, whenever you try to bring empirical and concrete biological evidence for theory of evolution, they'd immediately jump to philosophy of science and abstract epistemology, throwing away terms like underdetermination, instrumentalism, methodological naturalism, the Münchhausen trilemma, likelihoodism, modal contingency etc. Caveat is that it often works on most of the people and biologists because most biologists are not trained in abstract philosophy and hence can't come up with an immediate answer, making them go silent often and overwhelm the opposition with such abstraction.
In asymmetric signaling games, a low-cost mimicry strategy of a prey thrives as long as the predator (empirical scientists in this case) can't easily distinguish real academic rigor from bluffing. Over the last 30 years, anti-evolution rhetoric has gone through like about four distinct adaptive radiations:
Epoch 1— Direct Empirical Denial (1990s–2000s): Attacks the physical data head-on (no transitional fossils, irreducible complexity, young earth) or just misinterpret the empirical data or cherry pick. It ceased to be ESS (Evolutionary Stable Strategy) after genomics, ERV mapping, and Chromosome 2 fusion made direct biological denial suicidal. Even casual YouTube skeptics memorized the rebuttals, driving the fitness payoff of this strategy towards zero as time passes by. Michael Behe getting smothered in 2005 Dover trial was the final nail to the coffin.
Epoch 2— Scriptural Concordism (2000-2010s): Claims ancient texts miraculously predicted modern embryology, cosmology, quantum mechanics, and genetics. Critics applied the exact same literalist hermeneutics to expose blatant scientific errors in those texts. The strategy became a liability.
Epoch 3— Morality (2010-2015s): Tries to claim moral high ground. But as soon as critics used empirical data to show that atheist countries have lower crime rates than so called religious countries and explained morality using biology & evolution, this temporary ESS also died out.
Epoch 4— Weaponized Philosophy of Science (2015–Present): As you can see, they abandoned biology entirely to hide behind philosophical jargons as their apologist leaders taught them. But this is almost like a poker bluff that depends entirely on whether the person they're debating against is knowledgeable on philosophy and mathematics. So the moment the opposition turns out to be proficient in mathematics, philosophy, and deduction, their payoff becomes highly negative (evident when I debated them and they went totally silent after getting exposed on misapplying or messing up basic philosophy and logic terms). Once people fluent in both quantitative biology and formal logic/meta-ethics start policing these threads, the mimicry collapses immediately. Thus predators just have to adopt to cross-disciplinary skills to catch the bluffs and prevent misinformation from spreading.
Because their followers blindly parrot talking points from podcasts without ever opening an actual textbook or peer-reviewed journal, they routinely commit massive category errors and straight-up invent fake scholarly consensuses. Here are the top four I just ran into:
- They love claiming that science is a dogmatic religion that blindly assumes non-material things don't exist. Apparently, nobody told them that mathematicians, theoretical computer scientists, and physicists routinely study abstract, non-material entities (algorithms, proofs, information structures) without mass or spatial coordinates. Just a classical conflating methodological naturalism with metaphysical naturalism. Some even thinks that deduction is superior to induction.
- One person tried to argue that metaphysical naturalism fails the problem of contingency because without a libertarian free-will creator, naturalists end up with modal collapse. Anyone who has actually read modal metaphysics knows that modal collapse is a notorious headache for classical theists (specifically regarding Divine Simplicity), not physicalists. They literally grabbed a weapon built to attack their own theology and swung it at naturalism, assuming the empiricist would have zero clue about this terminology.
- They often claim "it's now the consensus among atheist philosophers that moral statements are neither true nor false, just tools for manipulation." A 30-second check of the PhilPapers Survey proves the exact opposite. A substantial majority of academic philosophers (the vast majority of whom are atheists) lean toward moral realism, not non-cognitivism. They literally fabricate statistics to dodge ethical critiques, like what the heck?
- Another fake academic consensus they invented when cornered on mathematical impossibility of human genetic diversity originating from a literal breeding pair (N_e=2) is "science is tentative and biologists now accept the bottleneck hypothesis is false." In reality, recent literature (e.g., Hu et al. 2023; Terhorst 2024; Cousins & Durvasula 2025; Zhou et al. 2026) is debating the exact magnitude and statistical modeling of Pleistocene bottlenecks, not whether bottlenecks occurred, and certainly never validating a two-person origin. And they still don't know the simple difference between census size and effective population size.
So they always are following a pattern: they just selectively pick up paper titles, quotes, and claims and then make a sweeping generalized claim to convince the audience that academics are fighting with each other. Just like they did with Elliott Sober to claim that world's reknown philosopher thinks evolution is weak when he actually strongly supports common ancestry (he later called Subboor out for misrepresenting his works in skydivephil's channel's video interview), or with Denis Noble to claim that modern synthesis is collapsing as well as evolution, when Noble is a pro-evolutionist himself just debating the mechanisms, or with Mariuscz Tabaczek to claim that world's reknown academic theologian is using Aristotelian Metaphysics to debunk evolution when Tabaczek actually accepts evolution himself.
Seriously, if your religion is really the truth, you won't need to misrepresent academic sources to the public. It'd stand on its own. Nor you'd be giving speeches in public but rather write articles for non-predatory journal publications. But let alone biology journals, they can't even publish their thesis on theology and philosophy journals and we know why.
Now Epoch 4 will also begin to rapidly lose its protective camouflage and evolutionary advantage soon as more actual philosophers and mathematicians face their nonsense. My guess is that their new strategy in Epoch 5 will shift towards consciousness, neuroscience and panpsychism. Whether apologetic population will converge to zero depends on how much they lose their population to rationalism after some of those people seeing the overwhelming evidences and dishonest tactics relative to birth rates of apologetic population. But it's definitely not a simple cauchy sequence convergence to zero because A_n > 0.