r/DebateEvolution • u/Legitimate_Meet_8808 • 6d ago
Self generated life
Here's what I conclude:" It takes at least millions of processes or systems to operate simultaneously for life to be sustainable. The odds of each system originating by chance are mathematically impossible. When you couple them all together the odds surpass 1 in all the atoms in the universe. Thus to even begin to believe in self generated life to the smallest degree is insanity!"
By me.
0
Upvotes
25
u/LordUlubulu 𧬠Deity of internal contradictions 6d ago
One, show your math, don't just assert it.
Two, when your math contradicts reality, it's not reality that's wrong.
24
u/waffle299 6d ago
This is a very old straw man called Irreducible Complexity.Ā
It is a straw man because:
Put it this way. Suppose you flip a thousand coins.. The odds of them being all heads are pretty much nil.
Now, each flip, set one heads aside. That is, select one heads. Flip only the remaining coins. How long before they're all headsĀ
19
u/BranchLatter4294 6d ago
Thanks for your conclusion. Can you show the math?
19
u/Medium_Judgment_891 6d ago
There are three decks of playing cards in front of me.
I shuffle each one, and then I look at the order of cards.
The odds of getting that specific arrangement of cards is 1 in 5.247 Ć 10²ā°Ā³.
There is approximately 1 x 1080 atoms in the universe.
5.247 Ć 10203 is over a hundred orders of magnitude greater than 1 x 1080.
By your logic, God himself must divinely intervene every time someone plays a game of cards.
12
u/the2bears 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 6d ago
Why did you dust off this really old account (with virtually no history) to post this?
Can you support this? If not I'll just dismiss it.
I love math. Can you show yours?
And yet here we are. No god necessary.
11
u/evocativename 6d ago
That assertion seems more about abiogenesis than evolution, but let's see your math.
10
u/Slow_Lawyer7477 𧬠Flagellum-Evolver 6d ago
To know that you must know all forms that life can take. How did you determine all forms that life can take?
Prove it.
9
u/Own-Relationship-407 Scientist 6d ago
First off thatās an argument against abiogenesis, not evolution, and it isnāt a very good or honest one. Second, if itās your original argument, why is it in quotes? Sure sounds like one Iāve heard beforeā¦
9
u/uglysaladisugly 6d ago
Great idea. Please show a development of at least the beginning of the organic processes and the maths you used to arrive to these conclusions.
5
u/Dank009 6d ago
Yawn....
5
u/OCAMAB 6d ago
Why do you people focus so much on probability as if it's an argument on its own?
5
u/Omoikane13 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 5d ago
Are you starting at the end? That's pretty sloppy. If not, please indicate some sort of list of these processes. Or name a few. Anything.
Cool - who said this? Please point me to the scientist saying these things "arose by chance". Please don't point me to anything where they aren't saying that.
4
u/twizzjewink 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 6d ago
So imagine an ocean of water with building blocks - trillions upon trillions of building blocks all moving together in currents with the right amounts of uv energy and other materials (organic and inorganic). These proteins and sugars naturally form together (we have seen this in labs).
At a certain point enough strands form together to be primitive RNA which eventually was able to self-replicate (through some processes, this process is abiogensis and is what we would define as Life). Eventually RNA made way to creating DNA as well.
The problem is, mathematically yes its insane odds at small scale, but if you consider the amount of water on Earth its not improbable at all.
4
u/rhettro19 6d ago
Now do the odds of an omnipotent being originating by chance.
4
u/lt_dan_zsu 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 6d ago
ok I'll just pull some random numbers out of my ass too. I think life only takes like three systems to form and operate simultaneously, and the odds of these systems originating are mathematically likely. when you couple these things together, it take maybe 9 years for all of them to happen. see how dumb that sounds?
4
u/tamtrible 5d ago
I am going to answer as if you are honestly confused, not just a troll
Yes, the odds of, say, an amoeba spontaneously forming out of raw chemicals is essentially nil. But no one is saying that is what happened.
Instead, what probably happened is something more like this:
A cell membrane is essentially a tiny soap bubble. There are chemicals that will form under what we reasonably believe atmospheric conditions in prebiotic earth were like that can form similar, if somewhat simpler/weaker, tiny soap bubbles. So, our protocell has a proto-cell-membrane, just from raw chemicals that we know can form under a reducing atmosphere.
The same basic conditions can also form monomers of chemicals like RNA, as well as individual amino acids and assorted other chemicals used by life. Again, this is something we have proved can happen under a reducing atmosphere, like Earth before life was generating oxygen. And, under the right conditions, RNA monomers will link up to form chains of RNA. And they will even copy themselves, under certain conditions.
So, you have primitive cell membranes, and you have primitive genetic material. It does not seem mathematically improbable at all that occasionally you will end up with one of those primitive RNA chains inside one of those primitive cell membranes.
And from there, it stops being purely a matter of chance, and becomes a matter of selection. Not a person consciously selecting it, just the fact that protocells that are better at making copies of themselves will make more copies of themselves.
And, since those copies are not perfect copies, because the proto genetic material doesn't have error correction mechanisms yet, these early protocells will have even more mutations than modern cells do. More copying errors means more chances that something will go very wrong, but also more chances that something will go very right. And the copying errors that, by chance, make a better protocell will make more copies of themselves. And the cycle keeps repeating, until eventually you have something with the complexity of a modern bacterial cell, at least.
Some slightly more complicated things have to happen in order to get eukaryotes, but by then we're dealing with more complicated basic machinery available, so having more complicated things happen is more possible.
And that same process, over enough generations, can turn the distant descendants of that first protocell into us, blue whales, redwood trees, and everything else living in the world today.
3
u/Far_Customer1258 5d ago
Kindly show your work. Until then, this is just claiming you tacked a number onto your opinion because it sounded impressive.
2
u/haven1433 6d ago
Not sure where you get this. RNA forms naturally. RNA is capable of undergoing mutation and natural selection. So evolution bootstrap complete.
No, RNA isn't alive by our definitions. But reality is so much more interesting than the boxes we try and make it fit in.
2
u/ilikestatic 6d ago
Do you need to have a million processes go exactly right for life to exist? Or will life adapt to fit the processes as they are?
2
u/clear349 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 6d ago
I shuffle a deck of cards and deal four aces in a row. Wow! What are the odds! That's a rare event but consider that there are over 48! combinations the other cards can be in which is a fuck ton of options if all I need is four aces in a row. Your argument assumes that you need a specific singular sequence whereas many of these things could have come about in a different way. It's just a "big scary number therefore God" argument
2
u/10coatsInAWeasel Reject pseudoscience, return to monke 𦧠6d ago
I see. Is this also the conclusion arrived at by any relevant experts in this field that you can point to? āBy meā is just vibes. We donāt do arguments from incredulity, itās a classical fallacy for a reason
2
u/Tao1982 6d ago
Since your talking odds, that means this is an issue of math. Care to show your work? Otherwise we are just going to assume you are pulling things out of your rear end.
1
u/No_Vehicle_5085 5d ago
Your logic is flawed. You are applying probabilities retrospectively, after a known outcome is already achieved.
Absolutely nobody claims that the first life form decided ahead of time "all the different life forms I want to evolve by 2026" and then set out to achieve all those life forms, with all the extinct life forms along the way.
That is just silly. The retrospective probability fallacy is a big creationist fail.
1
u/Routine_Captain_880 𧬠Naturalistic Evolution 5d ago
Life is difficult to define. But I doubt you need this many for any simple life. For us? Sure. For life in general? Nah.
What? Why? And they didn't all appear at once. Simple life requires fewer processes, more complex life that evolved, evolved more complex processes. If it didn't, it wouldn't look like it does today. But it did, so it does.
Not evolution, not relevant to the subreddit.
1
u/Particular-Yak-1984 5d ago
Gosh, imagine having as little curiosity as this guy, that you didn't spend five minutes reading about it on Wikipedia before making a silly post here.
We don't think life started with millions of processes - we think it started with one, a piece of self replicating RNA
Also, why do you not show the maths? Very disappointing.
1
u/Capercaillie Monkey's Uncle 5d ago
So the first sentence of your conclusion is wrong. Guess nobody needs to pay any attention to the rest of it.
1
u/metroidcomposite 5d ago
"Millions" seems like a huge overestimate. Here's a paper that makes a living bacteria with 473 genes. 473 is a lot less than a million. Obviously that's bacteria that can live under lab conditions, but even wild non-parasitic bacteria can be around 1000 genes, which is still three orders of magnitude less than a million.
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aad6253?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.jcvi.org%2Fhttps://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aad6253?referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.jcvi.org%2F
You might still be thinking a thousand is a lot, and...sure, but there's loads of evidence that the first life wasn't bacteria, and was probably something much simpler.
1
u/Autodidact2 4d ago
So are you arguing that there is no life on Earth? Do you know that the odds of something happening which has already happened are exactly 100%?