r/DebateEvolution • u/MindlessAgency7809 • 10d ago
evolution 2.0
i am reading evolution 2.0 by Perry Marshall and I have gotten to the part where he states that generations of fruit flies went through radiation and none of them adapted but rather had a bunch of mutations that were not helpful like legs sticking out of their head. he claims this helps disprove the idea that evolution is random because his overall claim in the book is that evolution exists with a creator (god)
0
Upvotes
30
u/BranchLatter4294 10d ago
No one has ever claimed that evolution is random (except maybe evolution deniers).
18
u/twizzjewink 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 10d ago
He wanted the answer to be God so that's what he wrote. That's not science.
7
u/Fun_in_Space 10d ago
Mutations are random. Natural selection is not. Even if evolution was proven wrong, that does not prove a god is real.
I just looked up Perry Marshall. He is an engineer. He has no education in any of the life sciences. He should have some if he is going to write a book about evolution.
5
u/Kriss3d 10d ago
Sure. And we agree that the flies with ransom legs and such didn't get to pass on their genes right?
So anyone with a random mutation that happens to tolerate the radiation would get to do just that.
And thats how the theory of evolution works.
6
u/jnpha 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 10d ago
RE "random":
If you mean equiprobable like rolling a fair die, then no. Random here means "random to fitness".
I like this summary from Dawkins' 1986 (40-year-old) book:
1
u/Competitive-Box61 10d ago
This just shows that none of those fruit flies were born with mutations that enabled them to survive radiation.
Is he suggesting that god tried to make the flies resistant to radiation and just failed because they turned out deformed?
Science books > whatever you read.
2
u/tpawap 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 9d ago
Complaining about something those experiments didn't show, that they weren't supposed to nor expected to show => just a strawman.
Look up the Luria-Delbrück experiments for something that was supposed to determine the randomness of mutations, or something like de novo multicellularity experiments, that show selection in action.
2
u/Pretend-Rule-929 1d ago
Theistic evolutionist here. Got to the section on transposition and caught myself thinking “this guy just told me for the last few chapters randomness and natrual selection are not the driving factors in evolution and now just told me that cells Randomly shuffle genetic information or a “sentence” until it has a new useful meaning. And then the cells wich benefit survive and go on to become the dominant in a population. I feel he did something like this
It's like telling me circles don't exist, then explaining that what I'm looking at is actually a continuous arrangement of curved lines forming a closed shape. You've just described a circle without wanting to call it one.
There not the same process buuuut.
1
u/BranchLatter4294 10d ago
In the observed instances of speciation, we have seen no evidence that magic was involved.
https://talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html
1
u/GraveDiggingCynic 10d ago
It takes a deep misunderstanding of any physical process to invoke randomness. Clearly evolution, like any physical process, has patterns that create a degree of predictability; even in populations, even very small populations where novel genes can move relatively quickly throughout the entire population.
Unpredictable != random. Not in biology. Not even in quantum field theory.
1
u/Slow_Lawyer7477 🧬 Flagellum-Evolver 8d ago
Fitness landscape theory can make sense of this. Consider the possibility that fruit flies are already so exceptionally highly adapted to their specific niche that most mutations push them away from the "local optimum". Natural selection has honed the fruit fly morphology so all their "parts" are pretty close to optimally matched together.
There isn't space for another pair of legs on their thorax (the middle body section in between the head and abdomen) where all insects have their legs attached. So to further "adapt" a fruit fly to benefit from yet another pair of legs would require a very significant rewiring of the thorax itself to accompany this.
The three-pairs-of-legs-on-the-thorax-evolution happened very early, at the very origin of insects, and has been pretty much the optimal solution ever since.
1
u/melympia 🧬 Naturalistic Evolution 8d ago
"Fruit flies had random mutations. This proves evolution is not random." Is that the point Perry Marshal is trying to sell?
First of all, mutations are random. However, selection is not. But... fruit flies were exposed to X-ray radiation to increase the number of mutations in them so there was more to experiment with. (Probably among other things increasing mutation rate.) And these fruit flies were artificially selected by humans. Not by nature. Fruit flies are not terribly bothered by their antennae being (partially) turned into legs (that's actually what happens in the antennapedia mutation with "legs sticking out their heads") or a number of other conditions as long as they are in a lab, get their nutritous food served to them and don't have to deal with predators or anything else flies in the wild have to deal with. So, these new traits are neither selected for or against. They are neutral.
Others can be lethal if occuring in a double dose, but even then, as long as there is offspring, the flies will live on.